Newbie Mafia 3 | Jungle Republic | Ovah. Who won?

[Ronike]

Ok look, WIFOM is not something to be instantly dismissed. This is a big problem in mafia games at the moment. The truth is a WIFOM argument can be a valid argument: it just requires one to put a bit of thought into it to realize whether it is a BS argument or a valid one. But they should not be instantly dismissed. In FFVII mafia, I had an entire case against FF (who was a mafia member) that was about half based on WIFOM which at least 2 other people dismissed because he called it WIFOM. Town ended up losing. Keep it in mind.

As for role claiming, I'm pretty sure we can, we just can't quote a mod pm. Just paraphrase it. Again tho, there is a problem in that any one can lie about a role, so any role claim we receive we have to take with a grain of salt.

AS for being nervous, don't be. We're all really nice. As long as you aren't scum.

 

[Mayling]

@ronike

sometimes they only use wifom in their arguments. for forum mafia, there needs to be more substance than just wifom arguments.

imo anyways.

 

[Ronike]

Well yes, arguments can't just be based off of wifom, but a myth going around DGs is that all wifom is pointless and should immediately be dismissed. This is not true.

 

[DtJ Jungle]

It's the chaco syndrome

 

[Tom]

It's the chaco syndrome

BAM

the callout

 

[Chaco]

Oh, and guys, if your wondering why I dismissed it as WIFOM was not because of laziness. It was because it was easily dismissed as WIFOM and on my scum partner. If it's easily dismissed then it's what I'm going to do. So, in all honesty, that callout had validity behind it, but with a purpose. :]

 

[Mister Eric]

Put this newb down if there's still room open.

 

[soaring-raptor-blast]

oooooh, nice

Im In!

(whizontree BTW)

 

[DtJ Hilt]

Mister Eric is the one Mayling was talking about, switch VaMP with him.

 

[Delvro]

I'm here and ready to play!

 

[#HBC | marshy]

player list updated. i'll send out roles when the mystery men confirm

 

[Cello_Marl]

Confirmation

Mystery Man A confirming. Ooh...first post on this forum for me!

Nice to see you for those that know me,
Nice to meet you for those that don't.

(P.S. I'm Cirno)

 

[DtJ Jungle]

I secondary you in UNL

 

[Tandora]

Hi! Thanks for inviting me on this forum. I'm looking forward to see how forum play is different from AIM play.

I'm Mayling and Cello's sister. My aim is tandoravonsydow. I don't play Smash but I've enjoyed meeting all you Smash players! Good luck and have fun!

 

[Mayling]

Wii would like to paly.

 

[Tom]

who are we missing? :o

 

[Mayling]

No one, right? =O

 

[KevinM]

GL Everyone!

 

[Clownbot]

Newb here.

Since the spots are full, I guess I'll go ahead and sign up as a replacement.

 

[#HBC | marshy]

Role Pms are out. It is now Day 1.

With 12 alive, it takes 7 votes for a lynch

A deadline has been set for the last second of Saturday, November 28, EST

 

[Xiivi]

vote: mayling

she's a big bad werewolf

 

[Ronike]

vote xiivi[\b]

he has too many posts to be telling the truth, and I believe in lynch all liars. Let's go

 

[Tom]

vote xiivi because he voted mayling and also for the sake of a wonderful wonderful bandwagon

 

[DtJ S2n]

How did Xiivi get that many posts? That's absurd.
And also, just to let you guys know, Me and a lot of the other KY guys are going to be at a tourney tomorrow. I don't think we're going to be posting from the venue.

 

[Tom]

thats cool just remember loose lips sink ships

 

[Xiivi]

Hello, new players, welcome to the RVS. Please drop a vote for whatever random reason you please. Make sure you pay attention to the number of votes a player has and the number needed to lynch though! I won't forgive anyone for dropping a vote at L-1 (The number of votes required for a lynch [7] minus one [6]) and claiming they didn't realize it! Unless it's Mayling who we lynch. Feel free to drop some votes on her because she's a big bad werewolf.

Ronike mentioned Lynch All Liars. This is a good policy to enforce! However, Ronike actually lied in that post he made there. In FFVII mafia, he lied about his role! He knew he was lying! Yet he didn't vote himself. Thus it's plainly obvious he does not believe in LAL and was lying in that post as well. Feel free to drop your votes on him for this.

Finally we have Tom. Tom's vote is a good example of OMGUS. Once he saw that I had found out his werewolf partner Mayling and voted for her, he immediately took to the offense and voted me in return. Another great lynch candidate!

Here is a Glossary of mafia terms and abbreviations.

Don't be afraid to ask questions.

 

[Mayling]

Xiivi, out of all the people in the RVS you could have picked, why me first?

 

[Xiivi]

'cause you had a Pit avatar

 

[Mayling]

Makes sense. Pit said you're not ready yet, and you got offended, ehhh!

Also, quick question. No editing of past posts, right? Double post is preferred?

 

[Mayling]

Nevermind I found in the rules where it said that. <.> Doh.

 

[Tandora]

I notice you haven't defended yourself yet. That seems suspicious to me. >.>

 

[Mayling]

Me?

There's nothing to defend against. :O

 

[#HBC | FrozeηFlame]

Vote: Xiivi

Too helpful. It's a FARCE!

 

[Tandora]

Quick forum noob question. Does the mod post the vote count? How can we keep track of who has what votes?

 

[#HBC | FrozeηFlame]

Yeah the mod will periodically post vote counts to help us keep track of who's voting for who.

****, now I'm being too helpful. Obvscum right har

 

[Ronike]

Indeed FF.

Unvote Xivii, Vote Frozenscum

 

[DtJ Hilt]

Yeah the mod will periodically post vote counts to help us keep track of who's voting for who.

Vote Frozen for using who instead of whom.

 

[Cello_Marl]

vote: mayling

she's a big bad werewolf

By the way, was there any particular reason you said werewolf specifically
and not some kind of bad guy in general?
I think a person trying to vote under the guise of the RVS might subconsciously
think in terms of his or her own scum type.

Please drop a vote for whatever random reason you please.

I've seen many players on mafiascum.net who were able to change the RVS into
an actual fact gathering session. Encouraging otherwise seems unproductive.
Unless you were going to ask people why they randomly voted the way they did?

I won't forgive anyone for dropping a vote at L-1 and claiming they didn't realize it!

Is that because scum would never vote hammer and it would likely be a quick lynch
due to an overeager inexperienced townie player? (Eyes Tandora)
Don't get me wrong, I'm all for being careful when we get so close to lynch. But since I know some people here are fairly new, such as Tandora and raptor, it's important to explain that such a quick vote would cast suspicion on people who are otherwise more likely innocent than not can only be harmful to us all.

Unless it's Mayling who we lynch. Feel free to drop some votes on her because she's a big bad werewolf.

Indeed...

In FFVII mafia...

Do you have a link to this game? I'd like to read it in order to see how people in this game
played in it. Also, was everyone's alias the same (that participated) or are there any names I should know?

Finally we have Tom. Tom's vote is a good example of OMGUS.

That's not OMGUS. That's bandwagoning, and he stated as such himself.
This sounds more like you trying to use an easily exploitable and memorable term
to garner favor for your opinion. I've only played once with Tom, and it was in AIM, not
forum, but I don't think he'd try an obviously scummy bus early on.
Have you played with him before? Can you point me to a game that suggests otherwise?

...his werewolf partner Mayling...

Right...

 

[Cello_Marl]

Finally we have Tom. Tom's vote is a good example of OMGUS.

This was supposed to be a quote. Sorry about that.

 

[DtJ S2n]

Vote Hilt for being a grammar nazi and for beating me yesterday.