Am I the only one who really doesn't like Bowser Jr.?
I mean, I've yet to play Super Mario Sunshine(will get it soon), but the whole shadow Mario thing was sorta lame if you ask me.
Nintendo keeps using the whole dark side thing (Dark Link, Dark Samus, Blood Falcon).
I see moveset potential with the paintbrush, and I don't think he's undeserving, I just really don't like him.
Well the Shadow Mario move set from Brawl thing seems over. Bowser Jr. only became Shadow Mario in Super Mario Sunshine. Since then, he's been in Super Mario Galaxy 1 and 2, and New Super Mario Bros. and New Super Mario Bros. Wii without it.
He could be a great fit as an original character with a few (but not many) similarities to Bowser, kinda like how Lucario was in a few ways similar to Mewtwo, but aside from that, he would be completely different.
Sukapon is actually a pretty good choice. He would be a "WTF?!?" character, as ROB and Mr Game and Watch were. He was the main character in Nintendo's first fighting game, Joy Mech Fight. I'm actually a big supporter of him.
But, personally, I'd also like to see Isaac over Matthew.
I agree that Sukapon could make a great playable character, but Sukpaon just doesn't seem that likely to me IMO.
And Issac over Matthew anyday. I haven't played the newest Golden Sun game, but I've seen some of Matthew in it, and he seems annoying. (like when they made the sequel to Tales of Symphonia, and made that annoying new character after Lloyd was awesome!) Issac is the bomb, as is Felix. Now Issac would be an epic character!
Also, every character needs their own theme. The Link theme suggestion would be awesome. That'd be epic to the max! I always watch that when I start up a Link to the Past! Toon Link should also totally have some version of the main theme of the Wind Waker, Zelda could have Zelda's Lullaby, Ganondorf could have his theme, and Sheik could have the regular Legend of Zelda theme.
Ness should have the EarthBound theme from SSB64/Melee (I loved the Melee one), and Lucas could either have the Brawl Mother 1 theme or the Mother 3 Love theme of some variation. Let's continue this discussion folks!