JohnKNight, I'm not going to read your walls of text, so when you respond to me...keep it small.
I cannot believe I slept in this late. That's what I get for staying till 4 watching crappy ninties movies.
What am I to respond to=???
What crappy Nintendo movies did you watch=??? I sadly have seen the entire Legend of Zelda TV series. What has been seen cannot be unseen.
As for Chrono's statement, what he is saying is the Bowser Jr. fanbase in the pre-Brawl days faded over time, and Chrono sees it happening again. Whether that happens or not I think depends on Bowser Jr.'s continued role in the canon Mario universe, and how strongly people want Bowser Jr. Clearly there were many folks like myself who were somewhat for Bowser Jr., but not many hardcore for him like Geno, Mega Man, or God Forbid Sonic (Sonic was a religion).
I think Toad's pre-Brawl fan base was pretty small all things considered. There were probably about 20-30 fan bases bigger for characters that weren't in Brawl for him. However, it got bigger as the game's release date got bigger and bigger while most fan bases diminished on smashboards and other such sites. With Toad's recent growth, I think Chrono is alluding that Toad's role in Mario will only get bigger. On top of that, Toad is seen as retro and a staple of Mario, and us oldies want more of Toadie since there are less "retro" characters to choose from that we really want. That is kind of why I've slowly become more and more of a pro-Toad person.
Name retro characters that are main characters in 1st/2nd party Nintendo games. There aren't many left. Takamaru, Little Mac, Mach Rider, the Balloon Fighter, The Urban Champion, Bubbles, Lip, and Sukapon. That's all I can think of, other than the Duck Hunt Dog. Honestly, over time that list is only going to decrease. By the time we have 3 more smash bros. games, at least 2-6 of them will be gone. Trust me when I say this: that only helps Toad's chances.
Coming from a huge Paper Mario supporter, I can't take that for an answer.
Before saying that I do these things, I don't say things like favorite. I only say popular but... That's it
I agree though that we can get 2 mario reps. It sounds impossible but it's not. It just seems unlikely to people. Only me, Iblis and Omega realized this.
Let me re-phrase that: I think by the time the game is revealed with a trailer (assuming Paper Mario isn't in it), Paper Mario will have overwhelming support. He will have many supporters, and few haters, much like King Dedede in Brawl. Well aside from the "he's just a paper version of Mario, how is he special?" crowd.
I expect similar things with Dixie Kong, too.