@shortiecanbrawl: I understand that requirements clearly. I was not asking why the rule exist, I was questioning OmegaXVII why he said that originating from video game did not matter under certain circumstances.
@Arcadenik: I'm curious, why do you think that we're going to see three Kid Icarus rep if we get any at all? I also don't understand the relation between Palutena and Peach. Peach is a princess, Palutena is an all-powerful goddess. You should also explain why we can't have one without the other as a playable character.
Thino said:
Is it a requirement set by Sakurai that characters must originate from videogames? if yes , any sources?
Yes it is. People have already said it many times and Sakurai did say it himself.]
Arcadenik said:
And the only reason more people are supporting Medusa than Palutena is because Medusa is a twofer token minority (female AND villain). This is the same reason why some people support Captain Syrup despite her not being THE villain of the Wario Land series.
I'm also supporting Medusa for these reasons:
- For being a prominent Kid Icarus character.
- Unlike Palutena, she is not Pit's Final Smash. There's a chance that they'll change Pit's move set to make Palutena playable, but I can't really see that happening.
So I'll make a deal with you. If one of {Palutena, Toad} gets in SSB4, I will never again use the move set argument again.. You don't have to give up anything if you end up being wrong, thought.
Arcadenik said:
So? Roy is not in Smash Bros. anymore. Forget him.
I will agree with this, thought. Even thought I preferred Roy over Marth in Melee, he was clearly a clone and as such, should be forgotten.
PsychoIncarnate said:
I don't see a point in 3DS exclusives. Maybe the 3DS isn't powerful enough to have all the characters, but the Wii-U is powerful enough to have them. If they Wii-U version CAN have the characters, it should
I would prefer for the 3DS version to be a slim down roster with the Wii-U version having all the characters in. Therefore, at least we stand a good chance of having a solid roster. Keeping the 3DS and Wii-U's roster the same would be stupid not only critically, but financially.
I would also be okay with the character rosters having lots of exclusives on both platforms while still having 25-35 3DS characters and 44 or more Wii-U characters with potentially the combined total going over 50 character (Not including transformations) AND being able to transfer characters to the Wii-U version.
PsychoIncarnate said:
Oh no, return of the Ashley fans
I'd be quited disappointed if she was playable. There's no need for a second WarioWare character in the game, even if I think Kat & Ana has move set potentials.
WhatIsRaizen said:
Does anyone support a Diddy + Dixie combo much like ice climbers?
I would love to see that. While not very probable, it would be really cool and if Dixie is involved as a playable character and if King K. Rool is in the game, I think Dixie will tag up with Diddy Kong. We'll have to see on this.