ChronoBound
Smash Hero
- Joined
- Sep 20, 2006
- Messages
- 8,998
I am speaking at least for what went on in this thread, and what goes on among those who ask for character requests for Smash 4.I'm not saying your observations are necessarily incorrect, just the way you present your observations. You present them in such an absolute way, without acknowledging you can't speak for everyone. Also I would argue that the Sonic series is one of the biggest of all time,.
As for Sonic being among the biggest franchises of all time. That does not matter one bit, because its a third-party franchise. Metal Gear Solid is a similarly popular franchise (though it has more accolades than sales, whereas with the Sonic series its the inverse), yet there is not this mentality that an additional character is necessary that I have seen among several Sonic fans in this thread.
Secondly, I don't think that little stat box means much. Shadow supporters tried to bring that up before, but the fact is that he is probably the most divisive Sonic character of them all (he is the Sonic character with the most hate votes). Even among long-time Sonic fans who would actually like to see an additional Sonic there are plenty who hate the character.
Keep in mind the Sonic fanbase is an extremely divided one in general. There are many that love the 2D Genesis series yet consider the 3D ones trash. Those who think the first 3D game was good, but SA2 was where it became crap, those who think SA2 was the last good one but the later ones were crap, etc. These factions extend to characters as well (those hating all the characters introduced with the 3D games, those who hate characters introduced after SA1, those who hate characters introduced after SA2, etc.).
This is ultimately politics and craziness that should not be indulged in. The fact that additional Sonic characters in general look to be a very unpopular idea, and that the Smash Bros. fanbase is very conservative in regards to additional third-party characters (even Pac-Man struggles to get within the Top 10 most wanted characters), makes this road an easy one to not walk down.