Monster Island Mafia- Game over! Town wins!

[#HBC | Mac]

unrawr rawrity: Chaco

yes not me!

 

[Blue Yoshi]

Not wanting to just lynch a random person, I checked Chaco's past posts to see if he looked suspiscious. The result was only 4 or so posts this entire thread, with this one sticking out:

Rawr: Chibo

It's a large game, we can spare a sacrifice.

50%in' he's scum.

He's willing to 'sacrifice' people since it's a large game, and he's not contributing much to help the town... doesn't sound like he is pro-town at all. I'll join with the Chaco lynch. Of everyone, he's the one I would most likely consider to be scum.

Rawr: Chaco

 

[smashman90]

"When mankind falls into conflict with nature, monsters are born. Vote/Rawr Count:

Chibo: Chaco, Xonar (2)

Kirbyoshi: (1)

Scumfever: Mentos (1)

Mentos: Cacti (1)

Xiivi: Kirbyoshi (1)

Chaco Blue Yoshi, Macman, Marshy, Xiivi (4)

Macman: Chibo, Scumfever (2)

Not voting/rawring: Circus, TigerWoods, Gheb, frozenflame (4)

With 15 people, it takes 8 to lynch. Please correct me if any votes are incorrect. Any prods will be sent shortly.

 

[Chaco]

Why lynch an experienced player on a quick lynch compared to a newb who will make mistakes?

Your wagons aren't pressure anymore, they're stupid.

Also, Blue Yoshi went against his own thing and all he said about me was generic bull ****.

Chibo and Blue Yoshi so far.

 

[Chaco]

He's willing to 'sacrifice' people since it's a large game, and he's not contributing much to help the town... doesn't sound like he is pro-town at all. I'll join with the Chaco lynch. Of everyone, he's the one I would most likely consider to be scum.

Rawr: Chaco

Your basis is poor. You are grasping at strwas. You're leaving an ambiguous middle. You're going against your own wagoning policy, and yes what you are doing is wagoning.

You reek of newbie scum.

 

[Blue Yoshi]

I'm not going to join another wagon unless there is a purpose to it. "applying pressure" doesn't seem to be working.


...


If you think he's scum, state reasons why and I'll join the wagon. If you just want to have 'just another wagon', then, as I've already explained, I don't see the purpose.

Not wanting to just lynch a random person, I checked Chaco's past posts to see if he looked suspiscious. The result was only 4 or so posts this entire thread, with this one sticking out:

Rawr: Chibo

It's a large game, we can spare a sacrifice.

50%in' he's scum.

He's willing to 'sacrifice' people since it's a large game, and he's not contributing much to help the town... doesn't sound like he is pro-town at all. I'll join with the Chaco lynch. Of everyone, he's the one I would most likely consider to be scum.

Rawr: Chaco

So... where do I go against what I said? I basically said that if it's just a wagon to pressure people (like basically all the ones we've had so far), then I won't join it because they aren't working, but if there is a purpose to the wagon (e.g. we think they are scum), then I'll join. In your case, I do see reason to believe you are scum... including what I quoted from you. I never go against what I said.

I do find it very strange how your one major defense is that I went against what I said, which I didn't, as explained in the last paragraph. Also, whether a player is experienced or not does not change the fact that if they are scum, they are scum. No amount of experience can alter that. (this applies to everyone playing this game).

So that said, either I mis-understood your posts (the one I quoted and your two defense posts), or my belief that you are scum is legitimate (not saying it's necessarily true, just saying I have good reason to believe it is).

 

[Chaco]

You're fenceriding me hard. All the more reason I think you're newbie scum.

And yes, experience has a lot to do with how you perform as a mafiat. You attempt more things when you've successfully branched out. I'm not saying you're scum because you are new, that's just dumb. I am saying you are scum because you are acting how new scum acts.

UnR; Rawr: Blue Yoshi

 

[Circus]

If I wasn't quite down for a Chaco wagon before, I am now.

Rawr: Chaco

Of all the people you would consider acceptable to "sacrifice," Chibo and Blue are really at the top of your list?

 

[Chaco]

Sacrifice was a joke. Tunnel, much?

Chibo and Blue Yoshi can die at anytime.

 

[TigerWoods]

Hey guys i should be back for good.

To defend myself from Gheb, quite honestly... I haven't been here. I shall try to contribute more into the discussions though.

Anyway, I don't think Chaco is scum... I just think he hasn't really been here. His "sacrifice" post came from earlier in the game and didn't seem too threatening.

Though chaco... how does new scum "act" ?

 

[DtJ Jungle]

he has a santa snoopy avatar

how can you vote that?

seriously though, Yoshi it looks like you were just finding a reason to vote chaco, but no matter how ****ty the reason, you were going to vote him anyway.

 

[Blue Yoshi]

I'm not going to join another wagon unless there is a purpose to it. "applying pressure" doesn't seem to be working.

If I am currently Rawring someone...

Unrawr

Yes. Everyone wagon Macman to Lynch-1, and if he still avoids reading Gheb's posts, we lynch him! :D

If you think he's scum, state reasons why and I'll join the wagon. If you just want to have 'just another wagon', then, as I've already explained, I don't see the purpose.

Not wanting to just lynch a random person, I checked Chaco's past posts to see if he looked suspiscious. The result was only 4 or so posts this entire thread, with this one sticking out:

Rawr: Chibo

It's a large game, we can spare a sacrifice.

50%in' he's scum.

He's willing to 'sacrifice' people since it's a large game, and he's not contributing much to help the town... doesn't sound like he is pro-town at all. I'll join with the Chaco lynch. Of everyone, he's the one I would most likely consider to be scum.

Rawr: Chaco

I did not join the Macman wagon because I did not see any reason to lynch him. As I said for the Chaco wagon, if there was no reason to vote for him in my opinion, then I would not vote for him. However, some of his actions seemed suspiscious to me, so I did see reason to vote for him.

I asked him to correct my reasoning if I had mis-understood his posts (first post of this page), but he just continues accusing me. It's not like I'm lynching him no matter what, I'm asking him to clear up where I may be mis-understanding. He hasn't done that in two posts, and instead votes for me.

So that said, at the current moment, I do see reason to vote for Chaco.

 

[Chaco]

That depends really, depends on who is scum coach is, Tiger.

Anyways, yeah Yoshi you were just looking for an excuse to hop on a wagon. It's pretty evident.

 

[Xiivi]

Still down for Chacotacos. :D

 

[Chaco]

Back your **** up then.

 

[TigerWoods]

rawr blue yoshi

In the same way blue, you haven't defended yourself either. You're using arbitrary proof that you are not scum just because you didn't join the wagon on macman.

 

[Blue Yoshi]

No, I wasn't looking for an excuse to jump on a wagon. I didn't jump on the Macman wagon because I saw no reason to. I saw reason for yours, and joined it, then (on the post at the top of the page), asked for you to clarify where I may have mis-understood. You still have not done that, so I still see reason to vote you.

As for your "Blue Yoshi is acting like noob scum" statements, you're now saying that the way noob scums play depends, meaning there is no exact way noob scum play. So how can I play like noob scum, when the way noob scums play depends on who his scum coach is (I assume that's what you meant to type).

You're contradicting yourself trying to change the vote to me.

 

[DtJ Jungle]

WHile there is no EXACT formula as to how newb scum plays, there are certain mistakes/things newb scum tend to do.

 

[Xiivi]

Ew scum you already had your chance to get blue yoshi quicklynched. Too late now. Sorry!

3 more votes :D

 

[Blue Yoshi]

At the time I was posting my last post, Chaco's post # 293 was the last post.

As for defending myself (by not defending myself lol):

All the posts I made were reasons for why I joined the chaco wagon, and not to defend myself from getting voted for. I never defended myself, I simply provided reasons for my voting decision.

 

[Chaco]

Xiivi, back up your vote or I'll tear it apart. The wagon is doing nothing, lol. I can grill the hell out of it.

Blue yoshi, I am nit contradicting myself not will I ever te you what tells those make then you become heightened to them. Im not stupid.

 

[Blue Yoshi]

Not to be mean, but can you rewrite that last paragraph? I don't understand it.

 

[CT Chia]

I really don't like how aggressive Chaco is acting with this wagon on him saying how he's going to tear ppls votes apart or grill the hell out of the wagon. Sounds like hes trying to act like a big tough guy to scare us off of the wagon. Not workin on me, I'ma hold on tight

 

[Xiivi]

Chibo you aren't on the wagon, join it!

 

[CT Chia]

Oh whoops, thought I was

Unrawr Rawr Chaco

 

[#HBC | FrozeηFlame]

Cool beans, now we got Chaco up in this **** ready to bash some skulls.

Yo Xiivi step up to it. I wanna see some C v. X action up in here.

 

[#HBC | ZoZo]

Sht just got real, not joining wagon myself, this should prove to be pressure enough

 

[#HBC | marshy]

huh? more votes. he's more dumbhunting than he is scumhunting

 

[~ Gheb ~]

This isn't a reason not to kill you.

were not looking at players and search reasons for why we *not* kill them. we look to find scum. youd be ok with xiivi, marshy, macman, blue yoshi, chibo, kirbyoshi, tiger woods and yourself dead by your own logic unless you can tell me good reasons why we should not 'kill' any of these guys. they can all die but they cant all be scum.

Your basis is poor. You are grasping at strwas. You're leaving an ambiguous middle. You're going against your own wagoning policy, and yes what you are doing is wagoning.

You reek of newbie scum.

You're fenceriding me hard. All the more reason I think you're newbie scum.

And yes, experience has a lot to do with how you perform as a mafiat. You attempt more things when you've successfully branched out. I'm not saying you're scum because you are new, that's just dumb. I am saying you are scum because you are acting how new scum acts.

UnR; Rawr: Blue Yoshi

horrible posts. the second quote is 75% omgus including the vote. you also fail to explain why he looks like newbie *scum*. why are you so sure that he cant just be newbie town? you say he hes leaving an ambiguous middle but at the same time youre extremely vague and dont point out where and why anything you say is the case. you are reaching hard to find a reason to vote him but in the end its still an omgus vote.
in fact you do exactly what id do myself if i was scum (and also what scumfever has been doing): attacking inexperienced players with the lame excuse of trying to get rid of weaker players in a 15 player game. thats a very easy stance to take and perfectly the angle scumd go for because you dont have to deal with actualy scumhunting and you dont upset more experienced players because you generallly leave them alone. if it wasnt for the anonymous doublevote id vote you now but it seems like youre at l-2 already.

seriously though, Yoshi it looks like you were just finding a reason to vote chaco, but no matter how ****ty the reason, you were going to vote him anyway.

how is that any different from chaco himself? curious hhow youre quick to point that out in blue yoshis case but you leave chaco alone with that? even though a new player is more likely to make that mistake as a townie than chaco is? either youre a blatant scumbag or a huge pussy.

Cool beans, now we got Chaco up in this **** ready to bash some skulls.

Yo Xiivi step up to it. I wanna see some C v. X action up in here.

youre the one who has to step it up. you have made zero posts of substance so far. all you did was justifying your own inactifity. start scumhunting and dont coast like you did in ffvii

 

[DtJ Jungle]

According to gheb there's about 8 blatent scumbags.

 

[#HBC | ZoZo]

were not looking at players and search reasons for why we *not* kill them. we look to find scum. youd be ok with xiivi, marshy, macman, blue yoshi, chibo, kirbyoshi, tiger woods and yourself dead by your own logic unless you can tell me good reasons why we should not 'kill' any of these guys. they can all die but they cant all be scum.

I'd be ok with them dead if we found no scum and they aren't helping town. But no RAWRs atm

 

[Cacti]

Both Chaco and Blueyoshi are not justifying their votes against each other very well.

@Chaco, could you point out exactly what "newbie scum" mistakes Blueyoshi has been making? Also, could someone tell me what fenceriding means?

I have a feeling that Blueyoshi is dumb not scum, but that doesn't get him in the green. He could still be dumb scum.

 

[DtJ Jungle]

thank you cacti for saying what the last 14 people have said.

 

[CT Chia]

There's still 10 votes not on Chaco. Why?

 

[Circus]

Scumfever, you're doing a piss poor job of distancing yourself from your scumbuddy, Chaco. You guys wanna just tell us who your third (and fourth?) partner is and get this over with? Is it Tiger?

 

[#HBC | marshy]

scumfever's a good choice too. it's like will the vacuous posts ever stop?

 

[Xiivi]

we just need like 2 more votes for a quicklynch! scumfever can go tomorrow :D

 

[Chaco]

This is why we don't listen to Marshy. I'm not claiming my PR on ****ing D1. I can live through the game anyways, I'm not worried about that. Your wagons are dumb, and hold no merit. Play the ****ing game to win and not just to be a douche.

I'll let you lynch me before I claim on D1. That'll prove my point enough.

Marshy, you're a glad player, but you mask that with your **** posy and play style. I know you have a good gut, so use it. Wagoning on D1 is okay if you're somewhat accurate and aren't ****ing town over by tunneling.

Xiivi, I know you're a better player than this.

Blue, I'm not gonna hold back in a game like this because your new. Let to many things slide by newbie mistakes. You're acting like newbie scum by:

-Contradicting yourself (No wagoning)
-Joined a 5 vote wagon right after saying that?
-Shirking defense by pointing fingers

Circus, and you're doing a piss poor job of scumhunting. Get your **** in gear and stop talking out your ***.

Cacti's golden right now to me because he's not being dumb.

And I agree that Gheb has pointed out half the game as scum right now.

I honestly don't care for Xiivi one bit right now, he's just being anti-town.

Chibo is pressuring a useless wagon meant for pressure but is really only making me hate playing as town.

Xonar's pretty much just here.

Question time:

What three players would you choose to be in an endgame with you? On your team. (Town)

 

[#HBC | marshy]

unrawr chaco

 

[#HBC | marshy]

This is why we don't listen to Marshy. I'm not claiming my PR on ****ing D1. I can live through the game anyways, I'm not worried about that. Your wagons are dumb, and hold no merit. Play the ****ing game to win and not just to be a douche.

I'll let you lynch me before I claim on D1. That'll prove my point enough.

Marshy, you're a glad player, but you mask that with your **** posy and play style. I know you have a good gut, so use it. Wagoning on D1 is okay if you're somewhat accurate and aren't ****ing town over by tunneling.

bawww you got wagoned d1 of an 18-man game