-
Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!
You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!
Monster Island Mafia- Game over! Town wins!
- Thread starter smashman90
- Start date
haha yea i was thinkin that.
i tracked circus last night. Would have had another clear. Town ***** this game, it was a lil too easy, I don't feel very accomplished.
i tracked circus last night. Would have had another clear. Town ***** this game, it was a lil too easy, I don't feel very accomplished.
Right I was voteblocker. My restriction was faked, sorry Tiger 
Glad that scumfever lynch happened D1 thanks to Circus' anonymous DV. I would've been pissed because I had obvscum pagged D1 and nobody seemed to care. -_-
Xiivi was Roleblocker? Did he seriously Roleblock Chaco N1?
Glad that scumfever lynch happened D1 thanks to Circus' anonymous DV. I would've been pissed because I had obvscum pagged D1 and nobody seemed to care. -_-
Xiivi was Roleblocker? Did he seriously Roleblock Chaco N1?
#HBC | ZoZo
Shocodoro Blagshidect
lol@unoobs, chaco wasnt being roleblocked >: (
we dont even have a roleblocker D:
we dont even have a roleblocker D:
balli n. scumlist was chibo/cacti going into n2. kirby was a good neighbor and frozen is a bamf
yu guys were masoned/neighbored right?
aye neighbors
CT Chia
Smash Obsessed
TigerWoods
Smash Champion
YOU... were the CAUSE... of my TORMENT!!??
CT Chia
Smash Obsessed
Yea unfortunately Xiivi flipped town :/ But in a large game like this especially with some of the activity problems D1 had I wasn't going to pass up the chance at killing someone, and for some reason Xiivi just didn't sit well with me.
My night 2 shot though was a lot easier. Mafia wasn't in too good of a situation really to bus someone, so I conviniently only had to choose between Me, Blue Yoshi, Cacti, and Circus. Blue Yoshi wasn't rawring anyone which wouldn't make sense at all. Another scum would definitely be voting someone to try and lead a lynch on them to get activity off of Xonar. I obviously wouldn't kill myself either lol. So that left me with a toss up between Cacti and Circus, and I found Cacti to be the scummier player. Couldn't have done it without the rest of town lynching Xonar though D2, great job guys.
Does anyone think 3 scum in a 16 person game is a little tough for the mafia though, even with a Janitor and Godfather?
Kind of interesting to compare this to tourney sleepover since they both recently finished and were both 16 players. This had only 3 mafia with one non-killing independant while tourney sleepover had 4 mafia and a killing independant. town had a much easier time in this game.
dunno. scum maybe couldve used a roleblocker. chaco was outed d1 and scum had to nk him to stop him from investigating...eh
as for the comparison to tourney sleepover im not sure how much it works considering that town was completely ****ing awful and inactive while there was just more interest and effort here. that was also 18 players while this was 15. i think the quick win def had more to do with the players than the setup
as for the comparison to tourney sleepover im not sure how much it works considering that town was completely ****ing awful and inactive while there was just more interest and effort here. that was also 18 players while this was 15. i think the quick win def had more to do with the players than the setup
Agreed with Marshy. If we hadn't gotten lucky with the Scumfever lynch D1, this game coulda turned out a whole lot different, and for whatever reason D2 everyone seemed to be fully intent on carrying things on. 15 players/3 scum ain't a bad ratio, I think town just got some luck and did good enough to make it seem easy.
Hard to tell if this game was balanced or not. Town ***** scum within two days and the only PR we needed was a Vig which isn't out of the ordinary at all so it doesn't really matter *shrugs*
Kind of sorry that this game never had the time to really unfold - this town was just to good.
@Chibo
Targeting Xiivi was the right desicion. Before you deal with a village idiot for 3 days straight you just rid us of him. I also targeted him for my voteblock but him and myself both died the same night.
Kind of sorry that this game never had the time to really unfold - this town was just to good.
@Chibo
Targeting Xiivi was the right desicion. Before you deal with a village idiot for 3 days straight you just rid us of him. I also targeted him for my voteblock but him and myself both died the same night.
#HBC | ZoZo
Shocodoro Blagshidect
Kinda want to see FFs role.
breadcrumbed specifically neighbor after i saw that you/frozen read my claim out of worrying that you guys would assume i meant mason and thus kirby was town. did you catch that?
CT Chia
Smash Obsessed
What do you mean by village idiot there?Targeting Xiivi was the right desicion. Before you deal with a village idiot for 3 days straight you just rid us of him.
edit:
Mod: Would you mind posting all of the PMs and all the night actions each night?
Blue Yoshi
Smash Master
also, while posting night actions etc., could you also look over my possible win again? Minilla died at the very end, and my win condition states I have to live longer than him. So, technically, did I win at the very end of the game?
you didnt do this
#HBC | ZoZo
Shocodoro Blagshidect
Lynch... nah.
Jim Morrison
Smash Authority
Rawr: Xonar
I was definitely blocked N1...
Game was one sided and only one indy in a 16 man? Needed a Serial Killer, imho.
Godzilla would've been hella broken.
Scum was weak, even with a Hitman and Janitor. In a game like this a strongman or a mafia JoaT would've fit better.
Godzilla would've been hella broken.
Scum was weak, even with a Hitman and Janitor. In a game like this a strongman or a mafia JoaT would've fit better.
TigerWoods
Smash Champion
Hmm...
Pretend you guys lynched me D1... that would've led to a much longer game, no?
I think we just got pretty lucky.
Pretend you guys lynched me D1... that would've led to a much longer game, no?
I think we just got pretty lucky.
Blue Yoshi
Smash Master
TigerWoods
Smash Champion
Well... yeah.... Hahaha.
Go us
Go us
Kirbyoshi
Smash Apprentice
I wasn't as convinced about Fever, but Xonar was SOOOO freaking scummy, and Cacti didn't sit well with me at all for most of the game. Way too quiet.
Tiger, if someone had caught you in falsely playing the n00b card, my guess is you WOULD have been lynched.
Tiger, if someone had caught you in falsely playing the n00b card, my guess is you WOULD have been lynched.
TigerWoods
Smash Champion
I've never played mafia on THIS forum though... so I don't think anyone could have found out haha.
My role was a little bit overpowered just because there was only one non-town kill, so if I kept myself seeming town I could only die by being shot consecutive nights. I think an SK would have both completely balanced my role and made the setup much different for town. On the other hand, town WAS very good this game, so I don't think it woulda changed the outcome much.
yu said not confirmed and i assumed you were saying i was wrong about my guess
i wud have shot the **** out of xiivi n1 too.
yes, he did visit chaco n1 too. for w/e reason
I was the doctor. I could protect one person per night as per normal, OR I could protect myself, but if I did that, I lost my powers. Protected Chaco N1 and Myself N2 because I thought for sure I was gonna bite the bullet after nailing Xonar D2.
Yeah, Marsh def. did a great job with the role breadcrumbing. Only took one re-read for me to figure you and Kirby out. Good ****.
Town *****. Fun game but I agree the mafia probably could have used some more power in a game of this size.
Yeah, Marsh def. did a great job with the role breadcrumbing. Only took one re-read for me to figure you and Kirby out. Good ****.
Town *****. Fun game but I agree the mafia probably could have used some more power in a game of this size.
Cacti
Smash Journeyman
I wasn't just the janitor when i ate people i got their powers. For example if i had eaten frozen i would have becom mafia doc bit i don't think it balances the game.
#HBC | ZoZo
Shocodoro Blagshidect
We don't learn of the players role before killing them, so we have to do it immediatly. It's a guessing game