Monster Island Mafia- Game over! Town wins!

[Xiivi]

unrawr:

Much better than "let's 50% chance on Chibo!" as a way to come into the game.

I'd love Marshtown, Chibtown, and Mentown in endgame. :D

 

[Circus]

What three players would you choose to be in an endgame with you? On your team. (Town)

A cleared Marshy, Frozen and Mentos would be super fly. Not that it matters what I want; what matters is who's scum. And that would be youuuuuu.

Marshy, Xiivi, what the hell do you think you're doing? Obvious scum is still obvious.

 

[CT Chia]

I like Chaco's analysis on everyone on his wagon, though I really don't like how he boasts about not going to roleclaim since it's D1 and all that jazz, yet he openly says hes a PR (practically saying Town PR) which is practically close enough to roleclaiming. It's still going to give you a big giant X on you're name for the mafia - and I know that someone like Chaco would know better than to say that as a townie, especially when he's not even at L-1 yet.

Though for the sake of answering questions... Xiivtown Circutown and Townfever sounds like a fun entourage

 

[Xiivi]

no Chaco's making better posts for now, we can kill him later if need be

we need to get more from mentos/ff now

circus if chaco was already dead, who would be the play?

 

[Chaco]

Chibo, you honestly are making me want to kill you to save the trouble in the later game. You obviously don't know as much as your going on about. You do not know how I play, really, to be honest. You're little Chaco would know better is a stupid argument. Pretty much shows that you'll fall for anything. Put more thought into things.

I could easily be a bomb wanting a kill on myself, ever think of that. Stop weighing only one option and weigh the majority.

 

[#HBC | Mac]

chacos post reeks of AtE

 

[Xiivi]

Chaco's bomb comment was ********.

Want Circus' answer.

 

[CT Chia]

Chaco, you can't just cover up anything I say about you by saying things like I don't know what's going on and my arguments are stupid and that you want to kill me to save you trouble later.

The aggressive play isn't gonna scare me away.

Try again. umad?

 

[Circus]

circus if chaco was already dead, who would be the play?

Would depend on Chaco's flip. If he's scum, well...Scum. If town, I wouldn't have a play for you. But I'd look more Frozen for possibly trying to encourage a pointless TvT argument?

 

[Chaco]

chacos post reeks of AtE

Not at all. If anything it would be a differing type of appeal.

The bomb comment holds truth. You just are tunneling so hard right now that you can't realize it. It's jut an example, a d honestly I dont worry about getting night killed. (shrug)

 

[CT Chia]

Since when was tunneling scum a bad thing?

Not to mention the wagon on you has been for like, what, 3 pages or so out of this 22 page game? I hardly call that tunneling, stop spewing nonsense.

 

[mentosman8]

Ok, so I didn't realize I had neglected this game so much I've been keeping up on all my other games excellently, but for whatever reason I kept forgetting to post in this one(prolly because it's a large game on D1 honestly).

Chaco wagon: I'm not sure I agree with it initially, although Chaco's response has not been my favorite. He talks about Blue responding to votes by attacking, when that's pretty much exactly what he's done. While this wouldn't entirely surprise me coming from townie chaco, especially as I think a lot of the wagon built up without good enough reasoning to really defend against(I mean, Blue's vote on him was for saying he was willing to sacrifice someone on D1 in a big game like this, if I got voted for a comment like that I'm not sure I would have a way to defend myself from that).

In terms of Blue: Kind of agree with what's been said. As much as it's rehashing, he is doing things reminiscent of noob scum, although noob town sometimes does the same. His responses were pretty much the same thing over and over for a while, and I feel it was a bad explanation as well. The sacrifice thing was REALLY enough to make you think he was scum?

Also, smashman, it looks like you put the votes on Chaco in alphabetical order instead of the order the votes were placed on him. Either that or they're in the exact opposite order that they were placed(odd that it could be either wayXD), could you fix that so that we can tell voting patterns? Should have been Xiivi, Marshy, Mac, Blue instead of the other way round.

Finally, to Chaco's question: I refuse to answer because nothing is accomplished by answering it. Pretty much it just tells scum who everyone would like to be alive lately, and that is information they could easily manipulate. Not sure how it helps in scumhunting either. If you can give me a legitimate reason that it's at all helpful to town, I'll answer, but right now it looks like a worthless question trying to make yourself look better.

 

[Chaco]

Tunneling is tunneling, no matter the length.

 

[mentosman8]

A cleared Marshy, Frozen and Mentos would be super fly. Not that it matters what I want; what matters is who's scum. And that would be youuuuuu.

Marshy, Xiivi, what the hell do you think you're doing? Obvious scum is still obvious.

Btw, I just wanted to point out I find this worth some lulz. If Chaco's question was about cleared townies, it wouldn't matter who was there in endgame because town would be clearedXD

/joking post time

 

[~ Gheb ~]

According to gheb there's about 8 blatent scumbags.

elaborate. whom did i call a 'blatant scumbag' and where did i do it? show me quotes because i cant think of those 8 players youre talking about. if you dont do it or fail to do so then youre a liar (since you already are a blatant scumbag anyway).

scumfever's a good choice too. it's like will the vacuous posts ever stop?

haha quit dreaming

Unrawr Rawr Scumfever

You're acting like newbie scum by:

-Contradicting yourself (No wagoning)
-Joined a 5 vote wagon right after saying that?
-Shirking defense by pointing fingers

i asked you before but why are you so certain that its newbie scum and not just newbie in general? newbie townies can make that mistake too. make sure to answer this question in detail because i feel like you just try to look for a comfortable lynch without looking scummy later.

And I agree that Gheb has pointed out half the game as scum right now.

false. i have pointed out half the game as village idiot which so far holds truth. i have only pointed out two players as scumbags: you and scumfever. parroting your scumbuddy isnt a smart thing to do.

What three players would you choose to be in an endgame with you? On your team. (Town)

i cant think of one town alligned reason to ask a question like that. and you earnestly complain about being wagoned for your play? in a 15 player game? qq less plz.

FoS Chaco

I could easily be a bomb wanting a kill on myself, ever think of that. Stop weighing only one option and weigh the majority.

i dont know how serious you are about this but nothing youve done or said so far even remotely resembles the play of a bomb and you didnt do anything a bomb would do. in fact you play quite the opposite of a bomb.

I dont worry about getting night killed. (shrug)

noted

Finally, to Chaco's question: I refuse to answer because nothing is accomplished by answering it. Pretty much it just tells scum who everyone would like to be alive lately, and that is information they could easily manipulate. Not sure how it helps in scumhunting either. If you can give me a legitimate reason that it's at all helpful to town, I'll answer, but right now it looks like a worthless question trying to make yourself look better.

listen to this kids and stop answering chacos attempts to get info for him and his scumbuddies. if you openly say whom you trust you just paint a target on their backs so please stop it unless you want the people you trust to die.

 

[#HBC | Mac]

Tunneling is tunneling, no matter the length.

what exactly is your point here?

 

[Circus]

The bomb comment holds truth. You just are tunneling so hard right now that you can't realize it. It's jut an example, a d honestly I dont worry about getting night killed. (shrug)

But since you are clearly not a bomb who wants to get lynched, all you basically just said was "yeah, I'm acting scummy, but don't lynch me because that might be exactly what I want you to do!" Rather than denying scummy behavior, you have conceded it and are trying to rationalize a reason for us not to lynch you instead of a reason for us to think you're town. This bomb thing, not-so-ironically, has blown up in your face.

Also, you've been caught with your pants down on the Blue Yoshi issue. You say he reeks of newbie scum, not just general newbie-ness, and then when asked to clarify what newbie scum tells are, you say that it depends on who their vet scum partner is. You then list a couple of reaching reasons for why Blue looks scummy. So, Chaco, by this logic, since you are so certain Blue Yoshi is scum and can name specific traits that prove as much, you should also be able to determine who his scum coach is. Care to share? I feel like that would be helpful information for the town to know.

If you dismiss this post with "loltunneling," I'm gonna go ape****.

@Xiivi, Frozen, Xonar: (Mildly detailed) thoughts on Chaco and Scumfever, please.

 

[Kirbyoshi]

I came back looking to push for more Xiivi votes, only to find he's not the scummiest anymore.

Vote: Chaco

The bomb statement was complete crap, and the only thing you saying you're weren't worried about getting NK'ed proved was that you're either scum, or a NK-immune Miller Vig. Don't think we have one in this game.

 

[Chaco]

Blue Yoshi is scum, and yes Circus, you are tunneling and cannot pick up when to drop ****.

Kirby....NO THE HELL IT DOESN'T. ARE YOU THAT ****ING DENSE? ARE YOU? Go look at a list of roles, and tell me around 5 things wrong with your statement. Good god.

 

[DtJ Jungle]

Kirbyoshi that's a pretty strong assumption you make, saying if he's not worried about being NK'd he must be scum. we have seen roles here that have been 1 shot bulletproof and things of the like.

Chaco, your bomb statement is a really pathetic attempt to scare us into not voting you instead of reasoning with us why we shouldn't. Take a breath bro.

 

[Chaco]

I'm like so close to ranting about how terrible SWF towns are. I know I'm not helping right now, but your about a few seconds away from lynching the cop on a useless bandwagon I tried to differ by making you realize things. Which didn't work. I CANNOT DEFEND A BANDWAGON. LEARN THAT NOW.

I'm taking a break from this game. V/LA

Smash, if you don't like that, I'm sorry. Replace me if you want.

 

[#HBC | marshy]

I'm like so close to ranting about how terrible SWF towns are.

cop

 

[DtJ Jungle]

wait you just claimed cop and left the game?

wtf?

 

[Cacti]

I really don't see the case against Chaco. Is there even one? It seemed like people just bandwagoned him for "pressure", which I think doesn't work if you outright say that it's for pressure, and it went too far. Does he even have anything to defend against?

However, he really needs to clarify what "newbie scum" mistakes Blueyoshi is supposedly making.

 

[Cacti]

Oh... Wait a second. I didn't see that cop comment.

 

[Circus]

Jesus Christ, Chaco. You're developing a nasty habit of claiming a PR on D1 when it's not ****ing necessary.

Unvote

I'm gonna be gone for most of the evening. When I get back, I'll try to work out what I think this claim means for us.

 

[#HBC | marshy]

rawr macman

 

[Cacti]

Also, nevermind about the thing about asking Chaco to explain the newbie scum things again... Didn't see that he did.

 

[#HBC | Mac]

rawr macman

n o

 

[DtJ Jungle]

mac what do you think of chaco now?

you havent said anything in two days

 

[#HBC | Mac]

hahahahha before i only read marshy's post and now i see where chaco claimed cop. What are you doing chaco. very foolish of you. stop being sore and play the game

don't think the real cop shud cc if there is one tho i believe chacoo

voteircus

mentos can die too

 

[Blue Yoshi]

a d honestly I dont worry about getting night killed. (shrug)

I'm like so close to ranting about how terrible SWF towns are. I know I'm not helping right now, but your about a few seconds away from lynching the cop on a useless bandwagon I tried to differ by making you realize things. Which didn't work. I CANNOT DEFEND A BANDWAGON. LEARN THAT NOW.

I'm taking a break from this game. V/LA

Smash, if you don't like that, I'm sorry. Replace me if you want.

You're not worried about getting night killed, yet you're now claiming you are the cop? Not to blatantly accuse you, but most of your posts contradict eachother in some way.

I know I'm a new player (only played like 5 in-person mafia games before this), but one thing I noticed is that the last resort most commonly used by people is claiming they are cop, even if they are not. Obviously town doesn't want to kill the cop, so no one will attack them. I'm not saying this proves you're not the cop, I'm just saying that claiming cop does not necessarily clear you as the cop

 

[Blue Yoshi]

Oops, forgot to Unrawr, but I'm still not convinced you're not scum... but for what it's worth, might as well leave it for now.

 

[Cacti]

Not liking the people making fluff posts.

Unrawr, Rawr: Scumfever

Kirbyoshi's being really dumb right now, maybe even scum. What kind of reasoning was that when you voted Chaco? Also want to look into the other people that had bad reasons for joining the Chaco wagon later on.

Macman, what is this "voting"? Is it a custom you participate in your hometown? Does it have anything to do with our "rawring"? I see you have it bolded like our "rawr".

 

[#HBC | Mac]

Macman, what is this "voting"? Is it a custom you participate in your hometown? Does it have anything to do with our "rawring"? I see you have it bolded like our "rawr".

don't speak to me in that tone, mister

 

[Cacti]

I see that you also have a phobia of unrawring (unvoting, if that term is unfamiliar with you).

 

[Xiivi]

Would depend on Chaco's flip. If he's scum, well...Scum. If town, I wouldn't have a play for you. But I'd look more Frozen for possibly trying to encourage a pointless TvT argument?

rawr: Frieza FrozenFlame

 

[~ Gheb ~]

you're either scum, or a NK-immune Miller Vig. Don't think we have one in this game.

so you dont think theres a nk immune miller vig in this game? thats a fair assumption. good job.

Blue Yoshi is scum

youve been asked more than once to explain why he is scum but you failed to do so. no amount of whining and complaining will make up for that fact. i asked you to explain how and why blue yoshi is newbie scum and how you think youre able to tell the difference between newbie scum and newbie town. you didnt do it. you just qq about the town when you suck *** so far in this game yourself.

I'm like so close to ranting about how terrible SWF towns are.

you are a huge part of it.

I know I'm not helping right now, but your about a few seconds away from lynching the cop on a useless bandwagon I tried to differ by making you realize things. Which didn't work. I CANNOT DEFEND A BANDWAGON. LEARN THAT NOW.

no. i have brought up legitimate questions and discussion but you simply chose to ignore it and parrot a stupid remark of scumfever about me. you keep on insisting that blue yoshi is newbie scum when you were asked to specifically point out why he cant just be newbie town. you didnt do it but just keep on tunneling (which you ironically accused other players of) against him. you couldve just tried to answer questions and debate like somebody intelligent but you intentionally refused to do so.

i do not believe your cop claim. if you are a cop then this town has lost this game already. you keep blaming the others but you have to take part of the responsibility yourself. you did not try to argue, you did not answer questions, you did not play smart. if you are a cop then you are a absolutely horrible one. real cop dont cc please.

I really don't see the case against Chaco. Is there even one? It seemed like people just bandwagoned him for "pressure", which I think doesn't work if you outright say that it's for pressure, and it went too far. Does he even have anything to defend against?

he has been asked questions but he ignored them several times. stupidest way ever to get wagoned.

rawr macman

the hell are you doing? hop scumfever already

mentos can die too

thoughts on frozen? id rather see him dead than mentos tbh

 

[#HBC | marshy]

vig if you're out there guns better be going off like crazy

 

[Xiivi]

CC NK-immune miller vig




no, but really it'd be cool

is TigerWoods V/LA or coasting or something?