Here are my reads thus far, because I was way too impatient to sleep on it.
Tonberry
Right now I feel like the Tonberry wagon only has one piece of evidence pointing to him being scum, which is a lot less than ToasterBrains for me. I'm waiting for him to give his reads and whatnot tomorrow.
- Hoove of Suspicion, for now.
I agree with Benji that his reads appear well thought out and genuine. I disagree that this makes him more townie, however. Tonberry is clearly an experienced, smart player. He should have known better than to make a wagon L-2 with such little evidence. Still not getting a lot of action out of him. He continues to bear my hoof of suspicion. He's the guy I wanna look at next, it's just hard cuz he posts so little. - Scummy
Badwolf
His early game smelled really suspicious to me (it still does, but it's easily explained away by the "herp derp RVS doesn't matter" mentality lots of players have). Ironically, the strongest townpoint he has is his case against me, which indicates that he's scumhunting. His case was extremely weak, but I guess it's fair to assume I'm the only person who thought so at the time. There were obviously questions raised that I needed to answer so that we'd all be on the same page.
- I'm inclined to lean town
This hasn't really changed. He seems to be done with me, but he hasn't moved onto anyone else yet. Don't see him as being terribly scummy so I have no interest in looking at him now. - continued Town lean
Soup
Soup is on my radar for sure. I must have missed Vinyl's case on him the first time through (probably because I was busy defending myself from Badwolf). Not about to sleep on him just cuz he's the IC. His "hands off approach to being an IC" this game is a really convenient excuse to vote however he wants with no justification, and then challenge
us to figure out why. When Vinyl called him on it, he still opted to not give reasons for his actions. Since I had previously stated that I thought I knew what his motives were, he knew he could just kick back and allow me to clear his name. If you look at his list of "reads", you'll notice that they are more or less identical to Badwolf's, right down to the fact that I was "a conundrum". Are they really that like minded? Or is Soup just letting us do all the work for him?
- Pretty scummy. I've got my eye on you
Soup kinda changed my mind on this one. I still don't know that I trust him, but his behavior probably wasn't scummy, just him being a bad IC in my eyes. - Null
BSP
I'm not so sure about him. He plays way too dumb, then suddenly he seems to be a borderline mastermind. The fact that everyone keeps telling him that he's noobtown, and then he argues with them about it, doesn't clear it up for me. He thinks and talks in terms of WIFOM way too much for me to trust anything he says. (Wine In Front Of Me. This is a concept from the Princess Bride often used in Mafia. It refers to the infinite loop of thought that your enemy might put poison in your wine, but he might also know you'll suspect that, and instead put the poison in his own wine.)
- I'm only inclined to lean town by process of elimination. Otherwise he would be hella Null read
This one is pretty much the same too. He's getting more active all the time, and he's starting to hunt for scum a bit more. I'm slightly more inclined to call him town than I was before. - lean town
Vinyl
Vinyl appears to be hunting scum. I think we share a similar read on Soup at this point, and since he brought it up before anyone else, I know he's thinking for himself. I'd like to see more in the next few days so I can try to solidify this read more.
- Town lean
Vinyl's also still in the same boat. The more he posts, the more I like this read. - Townie
Toaster
I've already made my case on him, but it boils down to his obvious bandwagon votes on BSP, and his constant lurking while contributing nothing. His responses when pressured about leave much to be desired.
- Hella scummy
Since the time that I posted this, he has only done more things to prove that he is scum. This one definitely stands. - SCUM
Sold2
Obv scum
Nah he hasn't posted enough for me to know.
- By default, this makes him a null read, for now
Still waiting for him to post more. He keeps saying he will. - Null
Tyranitar
Flying way under the radar so far. Hasn't been totally inactive, but hasn't posted much of anything useful. Get some reads out there please!
- Null read
Still flying low. Want to see you post more - Null
Benjy
- Refer to Tyranitar read
Not sure what to make of that exchange we just had. It's enough to make me want to look at him next if Tonberry doesn't go anywhere, but that's not really saying much. Maybe he just plays weird, like Ori said. If he keeps up the activity, he may change my mind, since it's still early. Gun to my head, I'd say he's more scummy than town, but it's only ever so slightly so. Not something to get worked up over just yet. - Mostly Null
Loli/Ori
- Refer to Tyranitar read
Still not a ton to go on, but I'm confident with Ori_bro at the helm of this slot, we'll be getting more activity, and more readable data. - Null
Joker
I'm with you guys on this dude. I don't know WHAT to make of him. He is a mystery wrapped in a riddle.
- Swag read
Like I said before, I dunno why everyone is still so "Null" on me at this point. I guess I'm just not a priority target. - Swag
(<----- this is what insulting you looks like)