Mini Mafia: Bowser Jr. Mafia [Ovah swam]

[#HBC | ѕoup]

Gheb's idea isn't bad, and I support it. However, I already sent my track.

 

[#HBC | Joker]

Uh-huh. I can turn my emotions off like a ****ing light switch.

maybe not, but instead of just explaining yourself over and over, I'd prefer you prove your towniness by acting like a townie. Stop trying to justify yourself to me and find scum. I'd be happy to change my read on you to town, but all I hear is excuses.

 

[#HBC | Joker]

Potentially getting the chance to clear townies doesn't affect you?

Yeah, you don't understand how mafia is played.

It doesn't affect me because I cannot participate. Durr

 

[#HBC | ѕoup]

I think RR is bull****. I like Swords. I'm cautious of No Hetero. I'm not sure on you. I think Gheb is town.

 

[#HBC | ѕoup]

Orbo? He could be scum too. In fact, it's completely plausible.

 

[#HBC | Joker]

Feel free to move forward with your plan, Gheb. Don't let me stop you. You're just really limited on who you can work with on this, cuz you can only work amongst the trackers.

 

[#HBC | Joker]

I didn't even realize Orbo was in this thing until I saw Kantrip get lynched, and saw Orbo in the votecount.

 

[~ Gheb ~]

Ryu, I'd like to track you. Would you mind not using your tracking ability toNight?

 

[~ Gheb ~]

Also, I think you're all taking this game too serious. It's just a mad little mini-mafia game to have a fun time with.

 

[#HBC | Joker]

Also, I think you're all taking this game too serious. It's just a mad little mini-mafia game to have a fun time with.

nah **** that

play2win

 

[#HBC | Dancer]

But I have fun BY WINNING Gheb.

 

[Orboknown]

catching up in another game, then commenting here if i have itme before work. I'll be V/la over the weekend though

 

[#HBC | Red Ryu]

Wow Gheb talking tough after leading a fail Mislynch.

Soup defiantly scum.

Idgaf about what Gheb does I'm tracking Soup.

 

[#HBC | Red Ryu]

2.) It's ryu, therefore it's not justified

Hahahahahahahaha.

This is rich, I called Gheb out on this in Skies and people agreed he was full of it. And I will continue to do so as long as you try to belittle my ability to try and scum hunt.

 

[#HBC | Joker]

Gheb's just trying to seize thread control by criticizing everyone else's play in the hopes that they will defer to his "wisdom."

You're right about him having just led a mislynch though. I certainly didn't just lynch a townie.

 

[#HBC | Red Ryu]

Terrible read so far.


Neither.

Unvote Vote Kantrip

Nice Quick lynch bro.

FoS Gheb

 

[#HBC | Dancer]

Actually I don't really feel like playing this game too much right now.

I'm gonna just say that I think RR is town and so is PJB.

There's probably a scum between Soup and Gheb. I agree with PJB's 215. The last scum is between Orb and No Hetro.

/obvious statements

 

[#HBC | Dancer]

Orboknown when you get here can you please explain your thoughts on Gheb and Soup?

 

[#HBC | Dancer]

soup's insistence that his emotional instability is justification for his behavior grants him no sympathy from me.

 

[Kantrip]

Gheb is scum. His biggest scumtell is when he goes with a lynch for the sake of it and doesn't actually buy it. Lynching me is one he loves because he thinks it's an "easy" lynch. Let me put this in perspective: He justified lynching me with
"this is your town meta but I don't care I'll lynch you on principle to teach you a lesson haha take that!"
He led a quicklynch after acknowledging that he knew I was town.
Also @Gheb: All my reads this game WERE MY REAL READS. I did not fake a single thing in this game and you're ****ing bad at mafia.
soup, I'm sorry that things are getting to you in real life but that doesn't excuse the fact that your responses to RR's early innocent play were scummy. If you're town you need to learn what NOT to interfere with. You gained NOTHING by calling RR out on his "bull****" because it wasn't scummy bull****.

You were wrong about your read on me, and you're wrong about your read on Red Ryu. Ruy is town, I was town, and you might be town too but you need to calm the hell down.

Gheb though. Please track him toNight. Don't let him get away with his "Hey RR, dont Track toNight because I want to Track you." That's BULL ****. Why would he tell his target not to do anything? Gheb is ****ing scum as hell.

 

[#HBC | Dancer]

@1st

Soup - town; Ryu - null; PJB - town:

@2nd

Him not explaining his reads while pretending to know stuff he doesn't. Pretends to have stuff on soup that he doesn't elaborate on. His push on PJB. All fake. Glad he's dead.

@3rd

I can see where you're coming from but think you're overthinking things a bit re: soup. If it's really staged then he'll prolly crumbe sooner or later. That man is a nervewreck.

@4th

I will operate under the assumption that the two of us are clear. Whether you believe it or not is your business, not mine. I'm here to find scum, not to convince you I'm town.

I disagree completely with your 4th point. It IS my business and should be everyone's. If you can clear two people then why wouldn't you? Convincing everyone that you and another player are town would be a huge leg up for us if you're right.

Also I'll like to know why you're town reading Soup. Even if you believe that the accusations against him are unfair, what has he done that's in itself townie?

 

[#HBC | Dancer]

Gheb is scum. His biggest scumtell is when he goes with a lynch for the sake of it and doesn't actually buy it. Lynching me is one he loves because he thinks it's an "easy" lynch. Let me put this in perspective: He justified lynching me with
"this is your town meta but I don't care I'll lynch you on principle to teach you a lesson haha take that!"
He led a quicklynch after acknowledging that he knew I was town.
Also @Gheb: All my reads this game WERE MY REAL READS. I did not fake a single thing in this game and you're ****ing bad at mafia.
soup, I'm sorry that things are getting to you in real life but that doesn't excuse the fact that your responses to RR's early innocent play were scummy. If you're town you need to learn what NOT to interfere with. You gained NOTHING by calling RR out on his "bull****" because it wasn't scummy bull****.

You were wrong about your read on me, and you're wrong about your read on Red Ryu. Ruy is town, I was town, and you might be town too but you need to calm the hell down.

Gheb though. Please track him toNight. Don't let him get away with his "Hey RR, dont Track toNight because I want to Track you." That's BULL ****. Why would he tell his target not to do anything? Gheb is ****ing scum as hell.

Um, I think you died and thus aren't supposed to be talking right now . . .

 

[#HBC | Joker]

Kantrip, you are dead. DEAD! You can't be posting stuff like that.

 

[Kantrip]

No rule against it

 

[#HBC | Dancer]

Actually Kantrip's totally right. If it's not posted, it's not a rule.

 

[Kantrip]

Geez guys.

So yeah don't follow Gheb's plan. Someone should Track him.

 

[#HBC | Joker]

Wow, no rule against dead people talking... get me.

 

[#HBC | Dancer]

Gheb is scum. His biggest scumtell is when he goes with a lynch for the sake of it and doesn't actually buy it. Lynching me is one he loves because he thinks it's an "easy" lynch. Let me put this in perspective: He justified lynching me with
"this is your town meta but I don't care I'll lynch you on principle to teach you a lesson haha take that!"
He led a quicklynch after acknowledging that he knew I was town.
Also @Gheb: All my reads this game WERE MY REAL READS. I did not fake a single thing in this game and you're ****ing bad at mafia.
soup, I'm sorry that things are getting to you in real life but that doesn't excuse the fact that your responses to RR's early innocent play were scummy. If you're town you need to learn what NOT to interfere with. You gained NOTHING by calling RR out on his "bull****" because it wasn't scummy bull****.

You were wrong about your read on me, and you're wrong about your read on Red Ryu. Ruy is town, I was town, and you might be town too but you need to calm the hell down.

Gheb though. Please track him toNight. Don't let him get away with his "Hey RR, dont Track toNight because I want to Track you." That's BULL ****. Why would he tell his target not to do anything? Gheb is ****ing scum as hell.

Actually I agree with your conclusion but not really for these reasons. Would like to say that I think Gheb's truly suspicious not because he admitted Kantrip was playing to his town meta (don't think he ever actually did that) but because of posts like his 162. It's a very unnecessary post to make that doesn't really help in finding scum. Soup said that it was a constructive post but I really don't think so. Why make just a long winded post criticizing players that (save from Kantrip) he either has town or null reads on? How did that really help find scum? Seems like he's being discount for the sake of being discount . . .

Also some of his wording bothers me.

"This game isn't about you, it's about town finding the scumbags and get them."

"I'm here to find scum, not convince you that I'm town."

This just doesn't seem like natural word choice to me. Who talks like this? He sounds like he's reading the script for movie.

Also that Soup read bothers me. Wrt Soup it seems like he's cockblocking his suspicion for the sake of being "individualistic." Again even if he didn't like Soup suspicion he hasn't actually explained why it's wrong but rather simply reduced it to "a clash of personalities" and "Soup has no scum intent" (paraphasing his 162) which I think is misrepresenting what others have been saying about Soup. It really does seem like posturing to me.

 

[#HBC | Joker]

So D2 we're gonna lynch Gheb then? Good, maybe we'll get something useful done instead of lynching Kantrip.

 

[Xivii]

Wow, no rule against dead people talking... get me.

There is.

 

[#HBC | Dancer]

Gheb or Orb/No Hetro imo.

PJB are you willing to put Soup on the back burner and if so why?

 

[Xivii]

Guess I just speak a different English from the rest of ya. Once you're removed from the game, no talking

 

[#HBC | Joker]

2. You may not discuss the game outside of the game thread until the game is over unless otherwise stated in your role PM. This includes talking with people that are not in the game AND after being removed from the game.

I guess instead of seeing someone say "it's not in the rules" and me just taking their word for it, I should go double check the rules first.

 

[#HBC | Joker]

Gheb or Orb/No Hetro imo.

PJB are you willing to put Soup on the back burner and if so why?

I'd be willing to drop soup for now. He's calmed down and might start contributing. If we get to Day3 and soup's still not doing anything, he'll still be there for me to vote again.

 

[No Hetero]

soupy:

I really think people misread what I'm trying to do. Just because I swear and I push something, doesn't mean I'm angry about it. I didn't like Red Ryu's gambit. I thought it was absolutely pointless and I wanted him to stop. There's literally that's all there is to it. I don't know why I'm being scrutinized for this. I'm being grilled over something so inane that It boggles my damn mind. What does it mind you that I didn't like RR's gambit, and I proceeded to push him on it? I want information. Pushing people is a means of doing that. I can get people to give me what I want. Is this clear?

Mm, hon, I'm not quite sure what this has to do with me asking why you started off the game the way you did. While I don't care too much for an answer to my original question, I am left unstimulated by how you changed the subject solely to highlight your alleged forthrightness with regards to Ruy and your scumhunting process.

Also, what is there to be cautious about with me? I like it rough.



Dancer: Please walk me through how you have transitioned from preferring soupy to Ghebbycakes. You point to Ghebaby's 162 in his criticism of other players and call it unnecessary, but weren't you harping on soupy earlier for somewhat similarly unnecessary posting (albeit his "staged" reactions you were talking about)?

Now if you girls'll excuse us, me and my other half will be spending the rest of the nightphase how we usually do.

 

[#HBC | Dancer]

@No Hetro: It mainly stems from the fact that I think Gheb's town read on Soup is uncalled for. As of his 185 he was town reading Soup, but nothing he has said before then or since justifies it. Rather he's simply been attacking PJB's and Kantrip's reasoning for scum reading Soup, but he has actually stated why Soup's town. IIRC, the closet he's really came to this is stating that he believes Soup really is a nervous whack, but even that should only lead to a null.

 

[#HBC | Dancer]

I'd be willing to drop soup for now. He's calmed down and might start contributing. If we get to Day3 and soup's still not doing anything, he'll still be there for me to vote again.

Where exactly did he calm down though? What does contributing have to do with keeping him alive?

 

[#HBC | Dancer]

@No Hetro: It mainly stems from the fact that I think Gheb's town read on Soup is uncalled for. As of his 185 he was town reading Soup, but nothing he has said before then or since justifies it. Rather he's simply been attacking PJB's and Kantrip's reasoning for scum reading Soup, but he has actually stated why Soup's town. IIRC, the closet he's really came to this is stating that he believes Soup really is a nervous whack, but even that should only lead to a null.

To clarify even more, what I'm saying is is that it looks like Gheb might know something we don't, and so it further adds into the whole "posturing" accusation that I'm making with regard to him.

 

[#HBC | Joker]

Where exactly did he calm down though? What does contributing have to do with keeping him alive?

his 204 and 205 are him laying out his stances.

Whether or not that means he'll begin scumhunting remains to be seen, but it's been awhile since he posted so I can wait to see what he does. See if his reads are going anywhere, or if he's just making **** up.

those posts do look a bit like he's just trying to appease me, though.

 

[#HBC | Red Ryu]

Swords Gheb or Soup?