That is very much what I was hoping to see, thank you J.
I agree with so much of that. To be honest, I
REALLY want to lynch John toDay. Originally I planed to make some BS case and ask him what he thought of it as a gambit of sorts to get a read. So I re-read a bit, and tried to look for a case I could make up. Then I saw Nabe's strange attitude towards the lynch targets D1 and started reading into him more and actually found a legit case to be made. The result was me making an actual case and getting less of a read on John.
The point still stands: His play has been so opportunistic. At times I feel like giving up and saying "ugh it's just noobtown", but then he comes in saying something like "have you decided a FB lynch" or "I'm trying to answer your questions", or even "Vote: Solid because lulul opportunistic".
Depending on flip, we can look into others (namely Nabe, Inferno, and Raz for me. Maybe WK as well). Raz made a valid point: John is playing very scummy and is likely scum. On the chance that he is not, he is still a detriment to town and his play could ruin as in an endgame scenario. Look at what happened with felipe in Awkard Moments. All it takes is one easy to manipulate player in LyLo and scum wins.
D1 we lynched scum. This gives us an advantage, already. Let's not lose that by lynching people like Solid (I don't even know why he's at L-1 right now, someone feel free to remind me) who are more likely to be helpful if they are town in the endgame.