Majoras Mask Mafia! DGames' Longest Game Ends - Who Won?!?!?!?

[#HBC | J]

I've got a few possible-scum on my list, but I am not going to place a vote just yet.

Why aren't you going to place a vote?

I think T-block is being abnormally abrasive, to the same extent that Xastrn is being cuddly. Granted, I haven't played with T-block in a while. Talk to me about T-block.

If you think this is abrasive, you should try attacking him head-on. It gets pretty abrasive in that sense. But yeah, I find his style to not be that changing nor indicative of anything. It's what he is posting that I like thus far.

What's your opinon on TB/Xastrn since you asked me about them?

It's not hypocritical... I didn't question your post because you didn't provide reasoning. It was because you didn't give a clear stance, saying things like "he always looks scummy, but i don't like him".

In 105, I saw heavy deflection onto spell, more pre-emptive justification for future inactivity, and defenses that consist of nothing more than "how the hell did you come to that conclusion?". I'll probably bring up a more formal case against Panta later in the Day, so you can wait for that

The bolded quote is a stance haha. xP Look I said I don't like him this game which impliiiiiies? But yeah, I will be waiting on you for that "more formal case."

J, where are you? You should be here 24/7 to respond to me immediately.

I'm terribly sorry, I've been slacking off in my absence. But I'm always here for you Nabe when you need me the most.

I like this post a lot.

Why may I ask? =P

Overall thoughts: J and Raz are good, Nabe leaning good but need more, would like more from Overswarm and Circus before forming an opinion, Xastrn uneasy, John needs to deliver more content, don't like Panta, Frio completely null, RR leaning town, gambit was good idea but him pulling off does nothing so I don't like that, will be waiting for Spells to replace out before I can get a real read.

ooooh I forgot T-Block. He looks priy good so far.

For both these quotes, I have nothing but this....

Total agreement. I mean it's kind of what I want to say as for reads and it's like mind-transfer jutsu. :3 However I do wanna change one thing, possibly on Circus and John. Though I'd rather keep those opinions to myself for now.

That was @Circus of course.
J can be a good friend, and intelligent, and often you want him on your side. But sometimes he'll take that trust and smack you in the face with it. Case and point, Circus has had a run-in with betrayer!Jscum before.

Hahahaha I just have to comment and I really hate to admit but this is so true. I do get a thrill of smacking people in the face when they trust me sometimes. It's just fun when the opportunity arises. Idc if they deducts points from me but I do have to admit I can be shady when I need to be. Circus and I have a very odd past. One were I betrayed him and another where he made a slip-up BECAUSE I betrayed him. Bwahaha xD Still makes me laugh that happened.

Btw, who is Theon?

He was very suave in RE4. I'd like to get along with him.

I haven't seen any post of his in this game that I've liked.

Can you be more specific to this? What exactly don't you like about Raz thus far?

No clue. I'm not expecting to need a proper read on OS until later in the game, and by then a read will have naturally developed after getting used to his persona in this game. For now I'm treating him as assumed town and playing around him.

^^^^^This x100.

 

[Raziek]

I'd like to avoid talking about the ongoing game any futher, since it's... still ongoing. As for the rest of the content of your posts, I don't really see anything worth addressing at this point. We're still fairly short on actual time passed for the "not addressing" people to mean much, and only a few people have actually laid out reads.

That, and I want to see what others think of it, and if there are any notable changes in behavior based on the graphs.

For example, I could be paranoid and reference Werekill, but I quite frankly don't care that he exists at this point in time. We'll see who cares about their perception in due time.

 

[¯\_S.(ツ).L.I.D._/¯]

I find it hard to believe that only 9 people have been called scummy this game, OS. May I ask what post that data goes up to from 117? Also interested to know if your vote on me is your interpretation of the data you presented or something else. If so, what part of that data led to your interpretation?

@J: Theon is a character from A Game of Thrones. He's a friend to Robb (one of the good guys/kind of a major character) and treats him like a brother, but takes over his castle when he's off fighting.

 

[#HBC | J]

Wooooow OS, way to put in a lot of work. @_@ *though I don't know how much of is substantial and also indicitive to anything besides what you are thinking but it's nice to see the amount of work.*

Are you voting Solid for the excel thing about who he calls town and who he has referenced? If so, wouldn't Circus be in a similar boat? I'd like to know a bit more about your Solid vote because I actually don't mind him at the current time.

 

[Raziek]

Protect Circus, Kill Solid, Investigate Nabe.

Interesting answer, no? ;P

Are you voting Solid for the excel thing about who he calls town and who he has referenced? If so, wouldn't Circus be in a similar boat? I'd like to know a bit more about your Solid vote because I actually don't mind him at the current time.

What changed, J?

 

[#HBC | J]

I find it hard to believe that only 9 people have been called scummy this game, OS. May I ask what post that data goes up to from 117? Also interested to know if your vote on me is your interpretation of the data you presented or something else. If so, what part of that data led to your interpretation?

@J: Theon is a character from A Game of Thrones. He's a friend to Robb (one of the good guys/kind of a major character) and treats him like a brother, but takes over his castle when he's off fighting.

See! He keeps on ninja'ing me with my thoughts in an almost similar way so how can I not think he is town! (I know I know but it's just so "....spooky" that he keeps doing it."

Aaaah thanks for the reference get cuz I was getting confused with that.

I do have to say though, I'm not surpised only 9 people have been called scummy this game so far. This game is kind of lacking in people going after one another which is odd for a D1 in my books.

 

[#HBC | J]

What changed, J?

Hmmm? Nothing did for you to reference that specifically because at the time, I did think that. However, after getting more posts from both of them (and Nabe) I have formed better opinions on those slots.

If I had a do-over, I'd switch Solid and Circus around. I think my opinion on why I like Solid more has been shown in my last 2-3 posts. =P

 

[Raziek]

Cool. We're on the same page then.

Raz/J/T-Block Town team go go?

 

[#HBC | J]

Sounds lovely to me but aren't you one to hate buddying? ;P

However, not too too sure on TB atm, I like him but I don't know enough yet to join a team with him. I'd probably have like Nabe moreso imo.

 

[Raziek]

But Nabe hates me. D:

My opinion on it changes. I've found being paranoid and not trusting anyone as Town to have worked out poorly, so I've decided to give it another try. The key is recognizing when those you trust might be out to get you.

 

[#HBC | J]

I agree haha but alright fine.

The pleasure is mine to hold your hand.

 

[#HBC | J]

Raz, I'm voting Dastrn, should my vote be elsewhere oooor could I possibly tempt you to join me for a bit?

I do have someone else in mind if you choose secret option C, but that's up to you.

 

[Raziek]

Let's hear option C. I'm fairly comfortable with Dastrn, as much of what I've disliked from him stems largely from ideological differences. Not opposed to revisiting him at a later time, however.

 

[#HBC | J]

Option is a very punny vote.

Unvote
Vote: Circus

Meet option C, Option Circus. ;D

 

[Raziek]

I like this vote. I was hoping that was who you had in mind.

vote: Circus

 

[#HBC | J]

Circus, tell me why you think I have this suspicion.

 

[#HBC | J]

Raz, tell me why you joined me on Circus. As in, why do you dislike him apparantly as much as I (and Nabe*?*) do?

TB, you seem to agree with Raz on alot, do you agree with him on this.

Solid, is OS's thing on you more scummy at the moment ooooor do you have another opinion. Can you tell me what you think of Circus/Xastrn?

 

[Overswarm]

I'd go for Solid over circus imo.

 

[#HBC | J]

I'd go for Solid over circus imo.

I'll need you to tell me why mon ami.

 

[T-block]

J is trying to steal my Raziek >=(

I think it would have been more effective to show this a bit later, but I love this.

Maybe you're all right, OS.

 

[¯\_S.(ツ).L.I.D._/¯]

Solid, is OS's thing on you more scummy at the moment ooooor do you have another opinion. Can you tell me what you think of Circus/Xastrn?

What do you mean? I don't think OS' thing is scummy, I just want to know his reasoning.

Xastrn hasn't posted in a while, but he's okay. I said I was uneasy on him earlier and I think that still holds true as he hasn't lately as I said. I suppose I don't have a full read on him at this time.

I suppose Circus fits in with OS' info dump and his ideas of how scum may stick out while attempting to fit in, but I'm not convinced on him.

 

[Raziek]

Well, my primary issue is because Circus has been quietly buddying most of the more vocal Town players. (in this case, Nabe, You, and Myself) That's largely why I was glad you wanted to move that direction. It's also one of the things I took note of from OS's charts. Circus has called you and only you Town.

I like this post a lot.

It might be a minute, because I'm going to eat before getting any further.

Do like Raziek and J against Xastrn. Do like T-block's suspicion of OS' ideas.

/thoughtvomit

Be back soon.

This post in particular. If this is thoughtvomit, why make it so obvious that he's trying to slide under our radar?

And we've seen how well that has worked out before.

Because OS gambitting in that way right after Ryu did is not good. I'm unsure if OS was strictly joking around or if he legitimately wanted to try to fake a daycop claim, but it wouldn't have been a totally bad plan for OScum to try. Thanks to Ryu's gambit, OS knew he wouldn't get CC'd if he claimed dayvig, and claiming a clear on me was a decent way to try to buddy me.

Now, I don't think OS is actually dumb enough to try to get away with that, normally, but I think he might think that this town is dumb enough to fall for it. And even if he was kidding, what's the benefit of keeping the joke going? Especially coming from OS specifically, who has previously declared quite clearly that...

My hypothetical questions came out of my doubts about OS, is what I'm saying.

You can be worried about the red if you want to be. I'm just being honest.

This feels pretty fake to me. It was pretty clear that OS wasn't gambitting, so I don't like that he's expressing false suspicion on him. On top of that, he's brushing off my suspicion at that point instead of giving a decent explanation.

Why? You nervous?


Nabe, do you know when the last (and only) time I saw you do this was?

I don't know if I'd put it in those terms. But I like J so far.

Right.

You're scum.

My hair is perfect. No one's in it.

He's scum.

His focus on John is also unsettling. I don't particularly care for John, but I wouldn't go as far as to say "He's the play." Same goes for Frio, though that's less of an issue at this point.

 

[#HBC | J]

As iiiin, what is your opinion on OS right now? ^^ What type of vibes you getting from the duder?

Did you know, that's not the reason I am really voting for Circus?

 

[#HBC | J]

Pretty good reasoning Raz-duder. I will have to steal that post possibly to expound upon what I am seeing because you pretty much touched upon all the major points but I want to make it a home-run post. Basically you got near 2nd/3rd base but you haven't gotten there yet.

 

[Raziek]

Actually, almost ALL of Circus' suspicions have either been directed towards those who have posted less. (Frio, John, Spellcasters) Only OS sticks out from that pile, too.

Take it home, J.

 

[#HBC | J]

Oh nonono not yet. You can't rush these things haha. Let's see what Circus has to say first.

Plus I have to get to sleep, busy day tomorrow. I'll try and get a post up in the morning.

 

[Raziek]

Fair enough, I can agree with that.

T-Block, talk to me. How do you feel about Circus and OS? Are you willing to work with J and I?

 

[T-block]

TB, you seem to agree with Raz on alot, do you agree with him on this.

Rereading Circus' posts... I can certainly see where the push comes from. His attack on Frio seemed opportunistic, and he hasn't done much in the way of scumhunting in that there's little follow-up or logical prelude to his pushes. The accusation on John is giving me pause though - being the first to really be against him made him look better, although his follow-up to that was garbage.

So yes, at the moment I'd vote with you guys.

 

[¯\_S.(ツ).L.I.D._/¯]

As iiiin, what is your opinion on OS right now? ^^ What type of vibes you getting from the duder?

Oh, I gotcha. Seeming town, but then again other than his images and his infodump with the vote on me he really hasn't posted, and hasn't really displayed his opinion at all. So yeah, can't be sure at the moment.

Did you know, that's not the reason I am really voting for Circus?

I figured. Raz's reasoning (which it seems is essentially yours as well) makes more sense and is more conclusive.

 

[T-block]

Fair enough, I can agree with that.

T-Block, talk to me. How do you feel about Circus and OS? Are you willing to work with J and I?

Hella conflicted about OS. I really really dislike the way he presented that fallback lynch proposal and his dodging of the questions about it. However, I don't think scum would go through the trouble of presenting the tables that he did - it's difficult to falsify that data without being called out on it, so if we can trust that, it will be a valuable tool later on for finding scum. Why would scum give it to us?

Overall though, still leaning scum. It's OS, so I could see him doing that as scum.

 

[#HBC | Nabe]

Skimming, posting tomorrow.

Well, my primary issue is because Circus has been quietly buddying most of the more vocal Town players. (in this case, Nabe, You, and Myself)

 

[Raziek]

Overswarm, did you gain any information worth sharing from people's opinions on the Fallback lynch idea? Is there a specific reason you've ceased pushing the idea?

There's been no mention of the subject since the beginning. I want to know what you garnered from it.

@Nabe: If that's a joke, it's lost on me. Otherwise, I use Town as a term to refer to all players, Town-aligned or scum. We're all still members of the Town as a whole.

 

[#HBC | Nabe]

How redundant. But yeah, I'm going to go study now.

My Circus vote is stale, but know that I endorse what's going on here.
Vote: Circus

 

[¯\_S.(ツ).L.I.D._/¯]

I'm out for the night, will post in the morning after the inevitable late night goings on.

 

[Frio]

I didn't even realize that circus was attacking me >_>
Vote: Circus
I'm voting for him for pretty much what T-block said.

 

[Raziek]

Frio, just as an aside for meta reasons, am I correct in guessing you know T-Block IRL?

 

[Raziek]

T-Block can answer that as well, of course.

 

[Frio]

Yeah we know each other IRL

 

[Dastrn]

I took the last few hours away from the keyboard to meet with a developer friend...details don't matter.

I like the general flow of today's actions.

OS, i like your spreadsheet. I wish you were in the broom so you could understand how much I like spreadsheets in mafia games. it's become a meme back there.

I need to reread the last 3 pages or so to get a better feel on this sudden circus wagon. I still don't want to unvote my joke vote because I still want John2k to do SOMETHING.

Also, Frio. There, I said his name. The last player i haven't interacted with.

 

[Raziek]

Cool. I ask because you jumped on the wagon without saying much. I want to know your current reads on the following players, with a short explanation for each.

Overswarm
J
Nabe
Raziek
T-Block