Mafia and Werewolves Gamethread

[osieorb18]

wam

I'm ready when you are.

 

[osieorb18]

S Scarlet Rage Wiisp Come vote Wam!

 

[ExLight]

also, this is majority lynch so we gotta hurry and make a lynch happen

Sign-ups says Majority+Plurality, so it doesn't have to hammer to happen.
The fact the host said it's randomized in case of tie kinda proves that further.

 

[ExLight]

Vote: Wam

I can do Wam

 

[#HBC | Gorf]

I'm ready when you are.

ehhhh i still want exlight. ill be on for a fat minute, ill pivot if exlights not happening

Sign-ups says Majority+Plurality, so it doesn't have to hammer to happen.
The fact the host said it's randomized in case of tie kinda proves that further.

swag

 

[gellnick]

its a shame this wasnt answered

It was. Post #1098.

 

[gellnick]

I'm perfectly happy to vote Wam tbh, I'd prefer Swiss but here we go.
Vote: Wam

 

[Swiss]

Gellnick do you have any opinions other than Swiss bad

 

[#HBC | Gorf]

Uh, ok
Wiisp: Claimed cop. I'm still wary because I've been in games where powerful PR's have been claimed (notably, one game where scum claimed Acop and then proceeded to use it to waste 2 of Town's days thanks to a pardoner ability) and it's gone really well for scum. Post #93 makes me almost certain they're not traitor, even if their claim is false. Townread for now.
Osieorb: Replaced 3DSNinja. Some random stuff for the first few posts (Gorf, why is all your text green?) Other than that, pretty solid reasoning for everything, I'd say Townread.
Swiss: I really don't like their early attack on Rhand. Looking back on their posts, I really don't like Post #234 - It seems like they know something the rest of us don't? I could totally be misreading that though. I do like his constant read lists though, he's slowly been getting less scummier as the game goes on. Post #639 seems somewhat odd to me, either sarcasm from town or pseudo-sarcasm from scum. Either way, no one take his advice on this until there's a reason to do so. Scumread.
Have to go now, I'll do Exlight and Utopian later.

i really did skip your post lmfao my b

sadly only partially answered

 

[Chop Chop]

Vote Count

utopian (3) - wam, eido, mao
Wam (3) - rhand, osie, gellnick
exlight (2) - swiss, Gorf
swiss (1) - whysper
Not Voting (5) - scarlet, wiisp, utopian, exlight, frozen

With 14 alive it takes 8 to execute. Day 1 ends Sunday 8:00 pm PT.

 

[#HBC | Gorf]

so its wam or poyzin hmmmm

why wam > poyzin osieorb18

 

[ExLight]

ehhhh i still want exlight. ill be on for a fat minute, ill pivot if exlights not happening

istg if you mislynch me in another phase I'll be legit sad because I have never been mislynched as town outside of D1 and it's one of the small things in my life I'm proud of ùmú

 

[gellnick]

Gellnick do you have any opinions other than Swiss bad

Yes. Wam bad, Rhand good, Wiisp good, Osie good, Exlight null, Utopian bad.

 

[Wam]

I'm tired and deadline is at 4 am for me so probably last post.

Might just be me but tbh I'm struggling to see why I'm being run up but oh well.

Might as well claim.

I'm town redirector. Pick two targets there night actions are switched.

Have fun maybe see you in the morning.

 

[#HBC | Gorf]

oof first impression is i dont like the claim

 

[ExLight]

I'm not a fan either, I have never seen a redirector like this and it sounds like scum utility

their actions as in what they do is swapped or in their targets is swapped?

 

[osieorb18]

so its wam or poyzin hmmmm

why wam > poyzin osieorb18

I didn't like the wagon composition for poyzin, and there was some talk of giving poyzin a chance until they blew it. I'd still potentially be down, I suppose. But the town redirector claim doesn't help wam's case.

 

[osieorb18]

It sounds like some form of semi bus driver.

 

[ExLight]

It sounds like some form of semi bus driver.

yea but instead of being a double deflector it's a double redirector

 

[osieorb18]

As weird as the host's naming system is, I can't imagine them calling that role a redirector.

 

[ExLight]

does that role even make sense considering we have a ton of vanillas
like does it fail or does it still happen

 

[osieorb18]

does that role even make sense considering we have a ton of vanillas
like does it fail or does it still happen

It might do some sort of odd roleblock?

 

[ExLight]

It might do some sort of odd roleblock?

hmm
if I were by that logic
if it swaps who performs the actions it's used for framing and if it swaps the targets it acts as some sort of roleblocking

 

[ExLight]

well sounds like I'm parroting I should've put the swaps who performs later so it sounded like it was a proper conclusion

 

[osieorb18]

hmm
if I were by that logic
if it swaps who performs the actions it's used for framing and if it swaps the targets it acts as some sort of roleblocking

It might actually just he a bus driver and Wam just bungled a fake claim.

 

[ExLight]

It might actually just he a bus driver and Wam just bungled a fake claim.

why not just claim bus driver then
it's usually a town role right

 

[Wam]

Actual title is town operator. Figured that wouldnt mean anything to anyone as it didnt to me.

I checked and if one role is vt the other doesn't target anyone.

 

[ExLight]

in any case this confirms I wouldn't mind seeing this slot get yeeted
this claim is super weird and I don't see how this role can be high utility for town unless it gets lucky enough and it has potential to mess our investigative/protective actions if anything

 

[osieorb18]

why not just claim bus driver then
it's usually a town role right

No, usually scum. Redirection in general is slightly more likely to be scum in a vacuum. For this game it could be a bit more up in the air, but meh.

 

[osieorb18]

in any case this confirms I wouldn't mind seeing this slot get yeeted
this claim is super weird and I don't see how this role can be high utility for town unless it gets lucky enough and it has potential to mess our investigative/protective actions if anything

Unfortunately I could see it being town in this game, but I agree that eliminating with fire is not the worst idea.

 

[Wam]

Difference to bus driver is bus driver is aimed at the targets I have to hit the power roles.

in any case this confirms I wouldn't mind seeing this slot get yeeted
this claim is super weird and I don't see how this role can be high utility for town unless it gets lucky enough and it has potential to mess our investigative/protective actions if anything

Yeah given I can make scum shoot themselves its probably pretty high utility.

 

[Wam]

For an example look at the just finished things I like game.

 

[ExLight]

No, usually scum. Redirection in general is slightly more likely to be scum in a vacuum. For this game it could be a bit more up in the air, but meh.

Huh, on bulba it's a lot more common as Town. I think I've seen it as scum once or twice maybe.
Nothing related but once there was this Bus Driver Unjester and that was a pretty cool role.

Yeah given I can make scum shoot themselves its probably pretty high utility.

You'd have to know who the shooting scum is, and you'd have to be lucky enough to target another scum with it.
If you're good enough to spot 2 scum like this I feel like you should be vomitting your readslists here instead of hoping your role will pull a miracle trick.

 

[ExLight]

And if you end up targetting a town investigative role? or protective role? you could also clear a scum or help scum get a kill through

 

[Wam]

Yes day 1 very unlikely. Lylo, mylo could be game changing.

 

[ExLight]

Yes day 1 very unlikely. Lylo, mylo could be game changing.

if not Day 1 it's likely that the traitor will give them enough items to coordinate around

actually, does the traitor know which scums are the power roles and which ones are the goons?

 

[Wam]

And if you end up targetting a town investigative role? or protective role? you could also clear a scum or help scum get a kill through

Given 2/3 town investigative roles have claimed I would have to be rather unlucky to manage that.

Protective role, its possible but i think with all the investigative roles plus mine a town doc is unlikely.

 

[ExLight]

erh, *Night 1 *have given

 

[Wam]

if not Day 1 it's likely that the traitor will give them enough items to coordinate around

actually, does the traitor know which scums are the power roles and which ones are the goons?

Where does it say the traitor can communicate with the teams?

 

[ExLight]

Where does it say the traitor can communicate with the teams?

who said anything about communicating?
they're inventors, they give out items