Lost Mafia - Who won? - The viewing audience of course

[Deleted member]

It would only make sense that if you're not a survivor, then you're scum.

 

[Deleted member]

So yes, I'm pretty positive that being a survivor = town.

 

[Evil Eye]

Heh, in the morning I thought you were claiming a survivorcop. As in, you can see if someone is an Independent Survivor (which is a thing) or not. No sleep and hours of studying will do that. I soon realized my error but decided to roll with it to see if you got flustered.

So, detail why you investigated Gorf and why you investigated Joey/Dooms. And why you didn't provide this information on D2.

And no, Joey, we didn't out the cop. If Ausu is indeed the cop, he outed himself with a poor attempt to be subtle.

 

[Evil Eye]

Sawyer being cop is pretty damn weird though. Paraphrase your flavor.

 

[#HBC | Ryker]

Sawyer was the ****, right?

And you say you checked Gorf on N1?

 

[Deleted member]

I only motive in investigating Gorf is that I really didn't like his way of posting from day 1. Seemed a bit off to me. Joey on the other hand I just don't ever trust in a mafia game, and with the results I got, I still don't trust/know what to think of his role in this.

Sawyer was a con man in lost, but the argument here is that a good criminal can make a great cop. Thus why Sawyer is the chosen cop character.

 

[Evil Eye]

Sawyer was also a cop in the alternate universe. Accepted.

 

[Evil Eye]

I buy the targets, moreso Gorf, too. Gorf was all over Auspher on D1 and cops under pressure, in the hands of emotional players, tend to investigate their aggressors.

 

[Deleted member]

I highly doubt I'm going to live through night 3, but I suggest we go for who we know is mafia, then put heavy pressure on Dooms either now or day 4. I don't like that I was unable to get any information from investigating him. He could be the leader of the mafia.

 

[Evil Eye]

Gonna reread before I make up my mind but Gorf looks like the play. I ignore my gut too much. Not today.

Ausu you will live if mafia has a RB.

 

[#HBC | Ryker]

I see no conceivable reason to lie about that, especially now with Gorf being a popular night choice. If Gorf flips scum, we can guess mafia has a tracker or role cop to figure out Gheb or he wouldn't have claimed. It may or may not have BEEN Gorf though.

Vote Gorf

FF should die in the night.

 

[#HBC | Ryker]

*popular town choice

Jesus, what am I smoking.

 

[Evil Eye]

Ausu paraphrase your no result ... result. As closely as possible to what was said.

 

[Evil Eye]

@Ryker: seven gram rocks

 

[Dooms]

I highly doubt I'm going to live through night 3, but I suggest we go for who we know is mafia, then put heavy pressure on Dooms either now or day 4. I don't like that I was unable to get any information from investigating him. He could be the leader of the mafia.

Vote: Gorf

 

[Deleted member]

Ausu paraphrase your no result ... result. As closely as possible to what was said.

I chose to investigate Dooms.

I got a message back saying that I get no information.

 

[Evil Eye]

So how are we gonna take Gorf's turning my frozen case onto G Life (and "moreso J")? Surely he was up to something there. I think he put himself out there a little too much to have just been outright faking his scumhunting. It was him connecting things to J "if frozen flips scum", and people were hated on some serious Jerkus before J came in. Seems sexier as a mafia thing to do with a dead frozenscum on the horizon, doesn't it?

Could all just be a red herring though since he was piggybacking me on the lynch in the first place. Frozie can still totes die in the night tho

 

[#HBC | Ryker]

Means you were probably roleblocked.

 

[Evil Eye]

>roleblocking Auspher
>dead rajam
>dead mentos

what the **** IS THISSS GAAAAAAME

 

[#HBC | Ryker]

So how are we gonna take Gorf's turning my frozen case onto G Life (and "moreso J")? Surely he was up to something there. I think he put himself out there a little too much to have just been outright faking his scumhunting. It was him connecting things to J "if frozen flips scum", and people were hated on some serious Jerkus before J came in. Seems sexier as a mafia thing to do with a dead frozenscum on the horizon, doesn't it?

Could all just be a red herring though since he was piggybacking me on the lynch in the first place. Frozie can still totes die in the night tho

Look at who he treated how on Day 1. I thought he was pretty big on that J wagon then.

 

[#HBC | Ryker]

>roleblocking Auspher
>dead rajam
>dead mentos

what the **** IS THISSS GAAAAAAME

To be fair, didn't Auspher say something along the lines of

"Lynch me and town is screwed."

He's been sitting on my PR list since (yeah, I think I know the ID of some of the PRs).

THEN scum had a night to role cop, track, etc him.

If he's lying, we murder him and all we did was lose Gorf.

 

[Evil Eye]

ah yeah, I forgot that post. Never mind.

@other post: That could go either way but yeah I'll take a peek.

I was also wondering what you think this means for frozen. I'm leaning toward him makin' plans with a scumbuddy about to die. Possible J mislynch afterward to make up for lost mafiatness?

 

[Evil Eye]

Hm come to think of it.... brb

 

[#HBC | Ryker]

Would a Lost game be likely to have a bus driver or a role that specifically tampers with the cop? I find it hard to believe a possible tailor exists and they happened to hit Gorf.

 

[Evil Eye]

I totally feel Gheb's frustration with the setup. Being a solo indy with an investigative role designed just to find you is pretty balls. Def. too hard for him if he is TRULY a solo indy. Let's not pretend it's impossible for SK's to be linked to another indy in larger games (it's happened before, way back in SP Mafia II).

Keeping him around to use as a vig is a somewhat attractive option, and a well directed BP SK certainly poses a greater threat to the scum than the mafia in the short term. Have to get rid of him eventually though.

Also, this does not in any way clear Gord IMO. He could easily be a scum stalker or something of the like and figured out Gheb's role by other, not so townie means.

@ Gheb, were you responsible for either of the disappearances last night? If so, why did you target not flip? If not, who did you target?

Heh .

 

[Evil Eye]

If we have a game with no flips from night phase, a stalker for mafia, and a framer, I am seriously butthurt.

 

[Evil Eye]

Miller is possible I guess but that's why I wanna reread.

 

[Asdioh]

I always hope EE is town because otherwise I might actually have to read one of his big posts one of these days.

lol. i'm attempting to skim earlygame (mainly to get a read on Frog) but god damn i don't have the attention span for this.

 

[Asdioh]

EE who is the quote in 1265? I remember someone mentioning the possibility of a stalker but forgot who.

 

[Evil Eye]

Heh. It was frozenflame.

That's why I find it pretty god damn interesting.

 

[#HBC | Ryker]

FF, I'd assume.

 

[Evil Eye]

So yeah. Ryker. Gorf and FF, on a scale of one to scumbuddies...?

 

[#HBC | Ryker]

I think it's probably right. Gorf trying to set up lynches on the back end of an FF scum flip. I would've NEVER pinned Gorf without a bingo though.

 

[Asdioh]

reminds me of that one time Adumbrodeus mentioned the possibility of Red Ruy knowing there was a gunsmith in B&H mafia and I was like "How could you know he knew that?" but then he played it off pretty well and I let him off the hook, shame on me.

so yeah put Frog or FF to L-1 and I'll fakehammer them.

 

[#HBC | Laundry]

Evil Eye. Rage more, it's a fun read.

I'm Sawyer, the town cop. I made this quite obvious day 1 when I said that I wouldn't be able to provide anything useful until after the first night phase. Admittedly, I was inactive for day 2, but it was during night one that my investigation yielded that Gorf is not a survivor. I investigated Dooms on night 2 and I got no results.

unvote vote: Gorf

 

[#HBC | Laundry]

@Ryker: seven gram rocks

that's how i roll

winning

 

[#HBC | Laundry]

>roleblocking Auspher
>dead rajam
>dead mentos

what the **** IS THISSS GAAAAAAME

one hell of a ****ing scumsided one.

gorf did you pass the blunt to the rest of your buddies

 

[Evil Eye]

I want the real hammer guys. I think I deserve it.

 

[#HBC | Laundry]

Hammer's yours, my man. I got the honor of slaying the Gheb.

But jegus **** how scum-sided could this game get. Indy SK, scum multi-shot Jan, scum Stalker, town lovers.

The fuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuck.

FF needs to die in the night.

 

[#HBC | Laundry]

hey gorf i see you lurkin' whachu got to say