Lord of the Rings mafia: Game Over

[#HBC | Mac]

kirbyoshi is SOOOO not the lynch

 

[#HBC | Mac]

so im losing interest in this game

since it seems like only 3 of us are playing

 

[adumbrodeus]

@Xonar: You're active now, please answer my question.


@Macman: *sigh* I agree, town's playing bad cause nobody's here, so many good lynch choices atm. Who's your top choice atm?



@everyone: 53 hours till deadline, top lynch 3 choices ASAP! No lynch d1 would just be stupid with so many anti-town players



@tom and summoner: Where the **** are you guys? Who do you think is scum?

I need you to explain basically everything in this post. How was it an 'easy' bandwagon, and why was my reason 'bad'. I don't think there were more useful people to pressure since, I wanted Kirbyoshi to post. I didn't want him lynched but I might now.

The bandwagon was easy because it was on routine inactive created by a player with a substantial reputation.


It was bad reasoning because you really HAD no real reasoning, if you wanted to pressure him, why didn't you ask a question? And why pressure somebody who's on V/LA before they're back? It was a bad pressure wagon, so opportunistic lynch wagon seems like the most likely conclusion.


Scumtell or stupid town play, not sure which yet.


Convince me it was a brainfart to do it in a scummy manner if you're town by applying some good pressure to people who need it.

 

[SummonerAU]

How could a lynch have EVER happened on someone who was V/LA? That point is basically irrelevant, since I think everyone (including me) knows that that bandwagon had VERY little chance of ending in a lynch and that lynch would not have happened at LEAST until Kirb posted.

I dunno maaan a bandwagon on someone 3 days before deadline will probably lead to a a lynch of that person. If there was 3 votes on Kirbyoshi and 1 day left, would you push his lynch?

@Summoner: Nah, it's just that inactivity makes for boring games.

Why did you have to ask the mod about it? Couldn't you have just gone "blah blah let's lynch summoner for inactivity"? I think even if you were aiming for a replacement over a modkill, you were still risking an early day modkill(in the off chance the mod HAD overlooked the number of prods I had).

OS, why did you specifically point out Tom's activity?

Tom, if OS and Kirbyo were pots and if Riddle and Xonar were pans, which would you want messed up first?

Riddle, Kirbyo and OS are all cool lynches. I think that OS and Kirbyo are of different alignments. Not really liking Xonar's 'lol doing in later' but I don't think it's THAT scummy right now with these other people around. Xonar, if you could look back at those posts you said you would, I would be happy :]

 

[#HBC | Mac]

Summoner, what do you think about tom?

 

[SummonerAU]

Nothings stands out for me on Tom but I'm okay with him.

 

[#HBC | Mac]

THe fact that he isn't posting at all after posting alot initially doesn't bother yu.

also, we were mafia together once, so i'll be able to tell if yur mafia now. Are you frightened?

 

[SummonerAU]

I don't like 'he was posting and then he stopped' since he could have just been hit by life (you know, like I was). If I were scum, I would be

 

[#HBC | Mac]

but he's posted in other games(atleast one other at the very least). Do you not think inactivity should be a reason to vote/lynch someone?

do you think i'm scum? Why or why not?

 

[SummonerAU]

Macman, looking through both games (I'm in both), Tom's posts here and his posts in the other games match up (roughly), his most recent post in that game is straight after he's been prodded. I'd say he's been inactive/forgotten to post when he's been on. I definitely would be against a lynch on the grounds of inactivity against Tom.

I have no idea Macman. When you were scum with me, you hardly posted at all. If I meta'd you from that, you would be town. I suspect that you probably change it up a little though ;P
Going from just what you've posted though, you haven't really bothered with explaining much so I would go with ballsy scum or town. I'd need some more stuff to get more of a 'read' on you.

 

[#HBC | Mac]

so lol sorry for interviewing you, but i'm bored and you're on and you were one of my lynch options so i have to grill you now while you're online.

Expand on your reasoning for thinking riddle is scum. You weren't very clear previously.
Why do you think OS and KirbYo are opposite alignments. You don't consider their confrontation to be TvT? Why not?
You said you weren't ok with lynching Tom for inactivity, would you be ok to lynch anyone else for inactivity.
Do you know much about LOTR? Should we name claim?

(remember, be honest. =D)

 

[SummonerAU]

lol so'k Macman, I always have trouble putting things I'm thinking down without answering some sort of question.

Riddle is basically for reasons already brought up + he didn't try to say I was wrong when I said I was cop with a guilty but he then says I was being silly using a tone I thought was 'mad'. This makes me think he was either 'not there' for the time between when I said it to when I said it was a joke OR he decided to do the same thing as he did in Barhouse when I had a guilty on him and not say anything.

I think OS and Kirbyo are opposite alignments just because of their little 'spats' with each other. I find both of them kinda scummy because of it (at worst, they are both town and both insist on being silly but I don't think that's the case).

I'm almost always against inactive lynches.

I know about lotr, but nameclaiming could just as easily get as mislynches as lynches. We could have Sam/Frodo, Boromir/other, Legola/Gimli, hell there's a heap of combinations that Nich could have used. I could just be overthinking it and nameclaiming could get us an easy two lynches lol.

 

[#HBC | ZoZo]

Summoner I've already done what I wanted to, I'm just waiting for Tom to be lynched.
Macman what do you think about Tom+OS?
Summoner why did you categorize me with Riddle?
Adum, how would Overswarm communicate with his scumbuddies in thread?
Overswarm, after he answered, tell him if he was wrong yes or no. Just that.
Why do the people who said they don't like me don't like me?
Adum where is your question?

 

[#HBC | Mac]

word summoner.

Tom is scum, OS is town...

xonar, what do you think of the game. Why are you hiding behind asking questions. You still haven't given any of your own input at all.

 

[#HBC | ZoZo]

Tom is scum, McCloud is town, OS/Riddle I don't like.

 

[#HBC | Mac]

whyd yu ask me specifically about tom and os

 

[#HBC | ZoZo]

Wait...
Mhm let me reread

 

[#HBC | ZoZo]

@Macman
I'll explain later

 

[#HBC | ZoZo]

No I'm actually fine with what I said before.

 

[#HBC | Mac]

you'll explain later? Why not now?

 

[#HBC | ZoZo]

Because .

 

[#HBC | Mac]

lol

smh

 

[#HBC | ZoZo]

Let's say Tom flips scum.

Who will his most likely be, Mac?

 

[#HBC | ZoZo]

his partner* lolol

 

[#HBC | Mac]

tom/riddle is my current scum pairing and has been for a while.

you can't expect me to answer your questions willingly if you refuse to answer mine xonar.

 

[#HBC | ZoZo]

Are you implying that you're answering my questions against your will?

 

[#HBC | Mac]

what

idfk

i dun wanna answer yur questions if yur not gonna be cooperative with me

 

[#HBC | ZoZo]

But you did ~_~

 

[#HBC | Mac]

yep becuz i know how to get over my annoyance

yu done yet?

willing to explain?

 

[#HBC | ZoZo]

What you think changed from when I refused lol.

 

[#HBC | Mac]

i have no idea

but i don't think yu have any reason in asking these questions and i'm tryna get you to tell me if you do so that i can keep the opinion that tom/riddle is the scumteam

 

[#HBC | ZoZo]

Nah your opinion is fine.

 

[#HBC | Mac]

but if you keep asking questions just to give off the impression that you're being helpful or trying to attain information than i'm going to question whether you are scum and one of tom or riddle isn't which wud stop me from going hard on em

and you know how i love to tunnel =/

 

[#HBC | ZoZo]

Nah TBH a lot of our convo was just curiousity.

 

[Overswarm]

nuke: Xonar and Macman

>:[

That was confusing.

OS, why did you specifically point out Tom's activity?

Because people were talking about him being inactive and really he wasn't being specifically inactive in this game.

I think that OS and Kirbyo are of different alignments.

That's dumb as ****, considering there's no possible way you could no that in any way shape or form at this point in the game. The only thing this statement could possibly do is set up for a back-to-back lynch of two townies if you were scum, since you'd know we were both town and would consider it "proof" that since I/KirbyYoshi flipped town the other must be scum.

Because we all know town never disagree with each other and mafia get into loud confrontations, right?

FoS: Summoner

 

[#HBC | Mac]

overswarm is right about that. It's the fallacy of TvS arguments.

i however don't think scummoner is scummy because of that. Though it's possible. I kind of shrugged it off as a newbish thing that he saw other ppl do in other games and thot it was a legit way to think.

 

[adumbrodeus]

OS, atm I think you're giving summoner WAY too much credit as far as intelligence goes.

.
Why do the people who said they don't like me don't like me?

Blatant lack of scumhunting drive, in activity.

Adum where is your question?

It was more of a statement actually, but you fulfilled it. I wanted you to start having an opinion.

 

[#HBC | Mac]

@nick moar voatcounts and deadline plox

 

[Riddle]

lol so'k Macman, I always have trouble putting things I'm thinking down without answering some sort of question.

Riddle is basically for reasons already brought up + he didn't try to say I was wrong when I said I was cop with a guilty but he then says I was being silly using a tone I thought was 'mad'. This makes me think he was either 'not there' for the time between when I said it to when I said it was a joke OR he decided to do the same thing as he did in Barhouse when I had a guilty on him and not say anything.

I think OS and Kirbyo are opposite alignments just because of their little 'spats' with each other. I find both of them kinda scummy because of it (at worst, they are both town and both insist on being silly but I don't think that's the case).

I'm almost always against inactive lynches.

I know about lotr, but nameclaiming could just as easily get as mislynches as lynches. We could have Sam/Frodo, Boromir/other, Legola/Gimli, hell there's a heap of combinations that Nich could have used. I could just be overthinking it and nameclaiming could get us an easy two lynches lol.

I didn't say you were wrong with the cop result because i wasn't on in the 1 hour and 4 minutes between your claim and when you said you were joking. I didn't not say anything in Barhouse, but its irrelevant anyway, because i repeat there were 64 minutes in the early morning (my time) in which it was thought that you actually had a guilty.

Why are you against inactive lynches? Especially on Day 1, inactive lynches seem to be a great alternative if there is no one sufficiently scummy around.

You're Town v Scum thing, as already stated, is kind of silly. Why couldnt they be bussing scum, or fighting town?

 

[Nicholas1024]

@Macman
Can I help it that you guys make 3 pages of posts while I'm still asleep?

Vote Count:
overswarm(2): kirbyoshi, Tom
xonar():
kirbyoshi(2): Overswarm, Riddle
riddle(2): Summoner, adumbrodeus
adumbrodeus():
mccloud():
tom(2): Macman, Xonar
macman():
summonerau():
Not voting: Mccloud

Deadline is noon EST on June 24th.


I'm getting a bit impatient with Tom. If he doesn't post by deadline, I'm going to replace him and give a deadline extension.