I'm gonna have to disagree with you on that. Mewtwo isn't like Shiek and ZSS. Sure he dishes out higher damage per hit, has a pretty good projectile, and a decent amount of combos, but he's incredibly tall, floaty, light,and doesn't have the frame data to make him an effective glass cannon like Shiek and ZSS. Any smash attack can kill him below 80-90%, and him being tall floaty super light character with slow attack speed,doesn't work with the top, unless he has some meat shield+range like rosalina. He will never make it to serious tournaments in the top 3, and still has unfavorable match ups against all the top and upper mid. I personally don't care that he isn't top tier, but something his missing, and I'm not satisfied with how Sakurai handled Mewtwo.
If he had all of his good attributes from melee(same weight value of 85, down throw comboing instead of being useless, shadowball hitboxcharging, same grab hitbox)+the current buffs from 1.1.3, along with up tilt being reliable, he's be pretty darn good. Mid tier at least without a doubt. Whats wrong with asking for that?
So many characters have gotten buffs in without noticable nerfs transitioning from melee/brawl to smash 5, and no one says a thing, but praises them. but suddenly people just settle when he gets buffed with half of the buffs he should have gotten in the first place on launch day.Mario, Luigi, Yoshi, DK, Link, Lucario, and Roy, for example were improved massively. Faster, heavier, stronger, faster attacks+combos They didn't get significant buffs only to be countered by nerfs. Yet Sakurai nerfed Mewtwo in a number of ways in which he was better off without(lower weight, losing combo with d throw, shadowball not having a hitbox while charging, and shorter grab range+unreliable against shorter characters), didn't fix half of his fundamental issues he had since melee(hitbox) and tried buffing him in other ways(slighty higher ko power) at launch, and must have thought he was better or didn't really care d called it a day until 8 months later when people complained.
I don't think his weight nerf (as well as grab, wonkey hitboxes, losing down throw as a a combo)justifies his slight increase in KO power and speed from day 1 through the 1.1.3 patch A What's wrong with asking for a character is that is actually tournament viable against upper mids? Why not have the best of both worlds(everything good from melee and smash 4)? I'm not even asking for anything that unreasonable. I'm not even asking for the Roy treatment. But its sad to see characters like Mewtwo and Dr Mario got shafted when they were released, when
There's no way he wouldn't benefit from getting his melee weight, grab hitbox, down throw having a combo, and fixing up tilt at least. To think that people will settle with Mewtwo now and call it quits, when we potentially one last balance patch, is incredibly disappointing. Nintendo has listened to us. People asked for a faster speed and fixing the wonkey hitboxes, and they mostly delievered on that. But doesn't complete him and completely justify the nerfs he got imo.