Compared to other fighting game communities, you guys are "on time".
That's... ****ing scary.
Also, on the topic of friendlies: they're pretty important for the community. Taking away our practice time... You'd better have a pretty good reason. Just sayin'.
i don't get the whole "coaching should be banned" aspect of this thread. coaching definitely seems like it's more support than actual coaching since in game adjustments are only made by the player. people are acting like it's a broken tactic.
on a positive note, i think it shows how the smash community is willing to help out and support a friend during crucial play. i don't think coaching breaks the game, especially if both players are allowed a coach.
...Did you see Melee grand finals? Armada was pounding Hungrybox, and then Seibrik started coaching. All of a sudden, Hungrybox turns it around and wins three in a row to take the first set. Excuse me, but I really don't think that's a coincidence, especially when Hbox even mentioned to the commentators that Seibrik was "magic". Coaching is a big ****ing deal. You no longer have to deal with playing and reading; you can rely on your coach to point out opposing habits to you, to an extent. This is incredibly valuable in smash, a game where making reads is ridiculously necessary.
Yes, the FGC does the same thing... but not to the DEGREE that the Smash community did it. The other problem is the Smash community did it with THEIR OWN GAMES. "This isn't Brawl, **** Melee!"
Yeah, we get that a lot. The problem is, Brawl and Melee are very, very different games. If you look at who placed well at both events, or hell, who
entered both events, you'll notice that there was like,
one person who did well in both: Mew2King. That's... pretty much it. Brawl and Melee are like Brawl and Street Fighter: Yeah, on the surface similar, but the communities are completely different with very, very small overlap. I've never even met about half of the German smash community because I never go to melee tournaments, and about 80% of those guys never go to brawl tournaments. Of course, such interaction is not really
encouraged, especially when you have crap like this constant "Melee is better, Brawl players are little kids" bull**** being spouted. I have nothing against the melee community, but when crap like this slips by without anyone calling it...
Lastly, PLEASE DO NOT LUMP MELEE PLAYERS WITH BRAWL! A good number brawl players (thankfully not all) are part of a cesspool of filth. Not only do they literally smell filthy, but go to the Apex results thread and watch almost every brawl not shout out their homeys but instead talk about money, the metaknight ban, etc. Why is the first thing that comes to your mind not the homeys you hung out with?
...Are you ****ing serious?
Are you ****ing serious?! You really want to go down this route? I really hope this was a bad joke that I didn't get, but somehow I doubt that that's the case. I don't want beef with the Melee community, but I will say that if ever was time for someone to make an example, this would be it. There is no excuse for spouting inflammatory crap like this.
It's the same problem as with the FGC: why do we want to interact with people who really want to degrade us like that? If one community is hating on your favorite competitive title and
you for playing that title, are you enticed to join that community? Of course the Smash community is isolated; we're also ostracized, and it doesn't seem to be getting much better. The infighting certainly doesn't help. I have no beef with melee, and I have no beef with melee players who aren't total ****s. Unfortunately, those who actually open their mouth on the subject most often are the ones with the opinion that's going to piss me off, rather than those who just passively support both communities.
To be honest, when I saw traditional fighters on the stream, I wasn't that bothered – sure, there was supposed to be another stream, but whatever. What really pissed me off was all the bragging about how MvC3 had more viewers than melee and brawl, and how Smash was a party game... Learning that we missed
every set with Mr R. in it so that these guys could get their time on the stream was not a positive influence on my mood either. I'm sorry, but when it comes to the largest, most hyped brawl tournament in the history of brawl, where almost every single person in the bracket (and at the very least every single person who wins round one and many of the losers as well) is an absolute
monster of a player, there is no excuse for only streaming top 8. Same with Melee. After seeing how this went down, I really wouldn't mind if the FGC just stayed home at APEX 2013. I mean, there's probably some financial or practical application I'm missing, but all else being equal, Smash and traditional fighters just don't mix well.
...Speaking of no excuse: Melee Grand Finals. God, and I thought
brawl was slow. We need a rule that if Hbox and Armada meet in bracket, the set is a Bo1. It'll last about as long as the typical Bo5.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/1c4fb/1c4fb4a004ac374ae735c210f8560be0dce354ac" alt="Awesome :awesome: :awesome:"
I swear, grand finals lasted longer than USA vs. The World.