Pit does have an excellent recovery. If you are so sure of yourself, why not challenge a top Pit like Koolaid and prove it. Personally I am almost never gimped. Pit can just glide over or under the stage, or use WOI, or just jump to safety. Pit has a very large amount of options and a strong Pit is rarely gimped.
I could go on and on about your post, but just go read Gheb's.
EDIT: 500th post
Okay, Pit's recovery is not *excellent*, it's great, but it has exploitable flaws. As far as i know, even Pit mains agree with me on this. If you are never gimped as Pit, *ever*, then you must be playing A: People who suck, B: Chars that have no offstage game, or gimping capabilities, or C: Ganons... Telling me to challenge Koolaid is an invalid statement also, for the love of all that is sacred, *of course* anyone would have issues gimping the best Pit out there, there's reasons why people are "the best", but having one amazing player doesn't put a character in the top tier... If that were true Ray Kalm would've put Ganon in at least the B tier.
"Pit has a large amount of options".... For recovery? If you consider 3 a large amount... As far as I know he has WOI (risky), three jumps, and a great glide. True, that's more than what some... A few... Characters have, but it's not S-tier
Also, I'm sorry, but Gheb's post is just... No... Pit's Fsmash *is not* that amazing
It fails against any character who can DI... FFS, it can be p. shielded out of... *not* amazing, lol. His UTilt is good, I'll give him that, but it's not particularly amazing
Having the ability to rack up damage quickly is something that nearly every character above low tier has. Having one particularly good attack for said activity is something pretty much every character has.
While Pit's projectile is good, it's not something that's going to put him at the top tier. Having one arrow that does 5-11% when fresh is not something that's going to move Pit up to the S tier. IMHO, TL's Projectile game is far better than Pits, and we don't see people clamoring for his immediate induction into the top tiers. His Uair isn't even *that* great, it'll only poke shields if it's under a platform, and the person's shielding it, and getting all the hits to connect is easier said than done. Dealing 12%... Max... not 15%+
So really, what you're saying is since Pit has good tools for dealing damage, and can't easily be juggled, that should put him in the A tier? Erm... no
I will agree with you that Pit shares a few traits with the top chars, but ffs, so does Jigglypuff and she's at 34
EDIT: Dualseeker, I think we've determined that indeed, Pit's UpB is better than Falco's UpB
This calls for Falco and Pit to immediately switch spots on the tier list! Sarcasm... But you do see my point, one better attack says absolutely nothing. Jigglypuff's Fair is better than MK's Fair... Does this mean that Jigglypuff is better than MK? (they've actually got like a 45:55 MU... but that's beside the point
)