Hi, this is GhostStorm, from over on GameFaqs and YouTube. I've been reading through the post, seen a few people I already recognize. You know I'm a Tails supporter all the way. I'll go ahead and just throw my two cents into the topic instead of just waiting. I don't just hope he is in, I'm almost certain that he will be, there's a lot more good evidence for him than against him and to be quite frank we might be getting both Tails and Shadow. I've noticed ever since they brought Shadow back he's been kind of portrayed as the fourth wheel of the Sonic gang, look at some of the advertisements over the past year and you might see what I'm talking about.....
The reason why I believe this is the most optimal situation is that......Tails, I don't care what anyone says is going to get a spot. He's been a more relevant, more prominent, and frankly more consistent character than Shadow and is a pioneer of the franchise. Tails has been wanted since Melee, He's been mentioned by two major publications, is one of the most iconic and memorable video game characters of all time and Sakurai isn't ignorant he knows this. Just like how he went and put Proto Man and Bass with MegaMan, because he knows they're a trio I'm sure he knows about Tails and Knuckles being Sonic's companions. Not to mention the Sonic 2 re-release? Sonic Mania re-release (Tagline "Ultimate Celebration of past and future") ? Team Sonic Racing (Team Sonic: Sonic, Tails and Knuckles)? A new Sonic series based around the Mania crews work? The fact that Shadow's assist trophy was replaced with Knuckles and not Tails or an item representing the character (Ie: The moon with Skull Kid or the bus with Isabelle)?The Mii costume???? Sonic 2 just had its 25th anniversary last year come on now.....Shadow however IS a very popular character and honestly, while I do believe Knuckles does DESERVE it more, I'd not only rather have Shadow, but I think it keeps the balance better. Sonic, Tails and Shadow have a very similar parallel to Fox, Falco and Wolf or Pit, Palutena and Dark Pit....etc....it feels right. It wouldn't surprise me if Sakurai thought this way at all. Tails and Shadow I feel in this instance are also more unique as characters, Tails defining trait is flight, Shadow's is stopping time.........Knuckles defining trait is punching ****....which a lot of characters on the roster already do. I think Tails is a lock in my opinion, Sakurai is a smart guy, I don't feel he would **** Tails over like that especially considering the weight and history that character holds. I'd be utterly shocked if he didn't make it in with classics like Ken.