One thing people need to recognize, in a general sense, is that different insiders know different things, and they are beholden to their sources, who may or may not have/give them accurate info but may themselves only know about certain things and be playing a game of telephone with their sources, who could have spotty info about stuff.
You won’t find a lot of people who will say Verge is a fraud, for example, but it’s very clear that while he knew almost everything about Ultimate base game (including a DQ rep which we found out later was almost included in the base game), but didn’t know about PPlant, didn’t know about Joker, and basically didn’t know anything about any of the DLC besides Hero. Their non-Ultimate info has also been hit-or-miss, but it’s clear they did know stuff at one point.
Point being, insiders can’t know everything, and if their sources have wrong info or deliberately lie to them, they aren’t always going to know everything. But that doesn’t mean that they’re fake or not credible just because they didn’t get things 100% correct, when it can be demonstrated that they have correctly predicted things and clearly do have legitimate sources, just ones that are more ‘localized’ to certain things and not all-knowing.