So guys, I had a thought, and I’m probably crazy, I’m probably wrong, but hear me out. I’ll start with my thesis statement.
What if Geno is, and always was, number 5, and Hero was never going to come with Geno?
I recognize that this goes against a lot of the speculation and insider information we’ve gotten, but for the sake of conversation let’s say that’s all wrong. Like PapaGenos always says, maybe people are getting info out of order.
So if Hero was never supposed to come with Geno, why does he have no returning costumes? Simple! He was supposed to come with the missing sword fighters. Either Lloyd and Gil or the two Monster Hunter ones. Boom, the mystery of those missing costumes solved (where they ended up I’ll get back to in a minute).
Fast forward to character 5. We’re still missing some Mega Men, blue shooty boys, and oh look Geno is also a blue shooty boi. So character 5 is and always was Geno, a character synonymous with Smash character requests.
So now what about those other costumes? Simple, two of them were supposed to come with Hero and two were supposed to come with Banjo... and they were cut to come with Lloyd and Dante.
Bam. Pass 1 ends with Geno. And pass 2 starts with either Lloyd Irving or Dante from the Devil May Cry series.
Like I said I’m probably wrong, but that all made sense to me.