Everyone bashing Sonic '06:
Yes, the game is terrible. But when you come down to it Sonic '06 is SA1 minus nostalgia.
That is all.
Except Sonic goes slower than his counterpart 10 years before and the story was less stupid
The difference between SA1 and 06 is that 06 was made on the current gen of consoles, which are like 20 times more powerful than the old Dreamcast. There isn't any excuse why a Sonic game of now plays a lot worse than a game that came out 10 years before.
Although I will admit the game gets a lot of undeserved hate in some areas, like Silver and the visuals. I always liked Silver and wished they'd include him in more games and I never understood why people said the visuals looked outdated by years when it came out it was early in the next gen's lifespan and they still look fine to me
EDIT: and now that I read the previous page, I can say this
I like the story with Mephiles. I wish SEGA would bring Mephiles back in a game. Out of all the characters Sonic has ever faced, Mephiles has got to be the most dangerous he's ever seen. I mean he is a cold, hard calculating an ruthless enemy who, mind you, has actually managed to kill Sonic. No other enemy ever has actually accomplished that. Not Perfect Chaos, not FinalHazard, not Dr. Eggman, not Time Eater, etc., and he's not even a quarter of the size of them either, bar Eggman. He is one of my favorite villains in the series given how awesome he is. I seriously wish Mephiles would come back, because he was just that amazing.
Also, I will admit this and say the story between Sonic and Elise never bothered me when I was like say 12 or so. I always thought it was pretty sweet that Sonic and Elise liked each other and I wondered where the romance would lead off to had I actually finished Sonic's story back in the day. I blame the fact that I find it weird nowadays to the Internet and just learning in general that bestiality is a bad thing in society. If it wasn't for that I'd view it with the same Disney innocence I used to see it with.
I don't like Shadow in this game. I'm sorry but I don't. He just seemed TOO dark for me in this game already. I understand that he has issues considering half the world hates him and that he wasnt even sure he was the real deal at one point, but it's a Sonic game. When I play Sonic I want bright and cheery characters (more or less), not a black hedgehog who can't stop complaining about everything. It's why I like Generations better for him. He seemed more happy and it looks like he finally got over all his issues here, even if he got only like 3 lines of dialog in this game