I am a new player to smash, not to FGC. I am about to sound super scrubby and whiny because boy am I feeling like both of those things, lol.
I am getting rofl-stomped in our group of scrubs. The big thing: I have absolutely no idea how to punish rolls properly and I have not found a easy answer to this browsing around. The slightly lesser big thing: I have no idea how to punish people using the basic "hold forward" get up option off a ledge, which I seem to die from all the time and no one else does in our group.
Everyone in our group rolls constantly to the point that I know pretty much the exact situations/times that a roll is coming, and I can't do a damn thing about it most of the time. I'm playing Falco/Shulk/Meta Knight.
Shulk I have the easiest time with, I usually just try to sh.fair or run grab. MK dash attack/dash grab is fine, sometimes side B if I'm really feeling it. But all of those miss if they spot dodge, which one of our less scrubby players does occasionally, and both roll and spot dodge seem to have like no lag whatsoever. And it makes my brain bleed because I don't understand the rock/paper/scissor here. Those defensive options literately beat everything, specifically:
With Falco, it's the worst, and this is the main reason I decided to post here- I knew my opponent was going to roll, I ran to where they would be after the roll, and I did a run up-smash as they rolled into it. They were apparently still invincible even though they had stopped rolling/were no longer flashing during the first swing of the upsmash, then they were able to block the second hit of the upsmash. Like, I'm standing in the exact same spot as them, I read the god damn book on them and it didn't matter.
It's really frustrating for me because all of these guys are button mashers in like every single other fighting game. It's intuitive for me to punish step in Tekken or anti-air DP on reaction in a 2D game, but I literately have no idea how to stop basic scrub stuff in smash. I've watched hours of Zero playing and even sometimes he's just like "this guy rolls a lot" and doesn't actually punish any of the rolls. This can't really be how it is, is it? This really isn't that dominant and I'm just missing something, I hope...