Geno is kind of an odd duck because he technically did "die" before. Just look at his Smash 4 thread
over here
“I serve… a higher authority…” This will be the main topic for discussion the character potential of Geno, one of the main characters from the game "Mario RPG" for the Super Nintendo. I'll update as I think up more information or people post something good. For those interested, his...
smashboards.com
His thread didn't even crack 100 pages. Compare that to the absolute kings that were Ridley and K. Rool during that period. Or well, compare it to Geno's thread for this game, at least the first one from before December 2020.
Geno had a lot of fortunate circumstances that brought him and his fandom back into the limelight after seemingly petering out after Brawl. The character was directly acknowledged by Smash and Sakurai for the first time with the Mii outfit released alongside Cloud, and Sakurai then said in an interview released shortly afterward
that he actually wanted to make Geno playable. Of course, Ultimate then gets announced a few years later and begins to start fufilling a whole slew of long standing character requests like Ridley, K. Rool and Banjo & Kazooie, which gave hope to Geno (and Isaac) fans that they were next in line.
But now Ultimate and come and gone, despite it again fufilling tons of dream requests like
and yet the most Geno could get was just the return of his Mii outfit with barely any changes. With the Smash series heading towards an unknown future after Ultimate, one has to wonder how much Geno is actually going to stand to the test of time. After everything that happened during Ultimate it kinda made sense to support him again, but I dunno. Are people still gonna be clinging onto a several year old interview that amounted to basically absolutely nothing the very next game?