Hmm. There's a lot of games to pick from. Most games I play in are one-sided.
There was one I ended replacing into the cop slot and ended up with a world that was me an Swiss pushing to lynch scum Zen and Xonar. Ended really close. Don't remember the flavor.
Skies of Arcadia and Batmanfia 2 are my next choices, but the latter is really old.
Aren't u confusing two games? I think the one u replaced into cop was one of Ghebs games but I died to a randomly ******** Ruy there.
As for me, I think I played Swag Halloween mafia almost as well if not better than Fire & Lightning, though that might just be me preferring good town play to good scum play.
If you want to show the best of dGames, look for Kuz's best game (town), Ryker's best game, Swiss's best game (scum), EE's best game (town), my best game, Overwatch's best game, and probably like Zen's best game (scum)? Personally those were the players that always impressed (and inspired) me the most, even though I disagree with a lot of them on playstyle, a good mafia game is something you can't not appreciate.
Another impressive performance was Sephiroths in Paper Mario. Had one of the hardest scumslip catches I've EVER seen in mafia on Adumbrodeus and overall just an uncontested performance. He died pri early on though (N2) but a good read imo.