critique the playstyle above you

[DtJ Jungle]

Rockin, it's like really obvious to tell when you're scum and when you're town. Your overall logic makes so much more sense and your posts are much more coherent when you're town as opposed to when you're scum. When you're scum you're all over the place.

 

[Rockin]

Rockin, it's like really obvious to tell when you're scum and when you're town. Your overall logic makes so much more sense and your posts are much more coherent when you're town as opposed to when you're scum. When you're scum you're all over the place.

can you explain this a bit further?

 

[DtJ Jungle]

i'd have to talk about ongoing games to show you otherwise i would

 

[Omni]

He's right tho.

Like there are a few games in the past that I've played you and I'm like... wow, ok Rockin is acting weird. Then you flip scum because your partners bus you for you playing so scummy or w/e. Then there are other games where you're like solid and your thoughts connect naturally and I'm like... wow ok, Rockin is obv town.

Also, thanks for the tips @ everyone else. I totally agree. Like Marshy said I get bored easily so when I do I usually act like a **** to draw out w/e possible.

 

[Rockin]

He's right tho.

Like there are a few games in the past that I've played you and I'm like... wow, ok Rockin is acting weird. Then you flip scum because your partners bus you for you playing so scummy or w/e. Then there are other games where you're like solid and your thoughts connect naturally and I'm like... wow ok, Rockin is obv town.

Also, thanks for the tips @ everyone else. I totally agree. Like Marshy said I get bored easily so when I do I usually act like a **** to draw out w/e possible.

That's weird.

I was told before by Marshy and Macman before that I'm laid back as townie, but get more 'serious business' when I'm scum. Hm.

I can't help but feel Ronike is right about me (we talked on AIM), to which I don't have a playstyle. Everytime I play, I feel like I never really have a playstyle at all...>>;;

In anycase, I guess it's something to work with.

 

[Evil Eye]

I completely disagree.

Rockin was town and I scum in Megamafia and , wait hold on.

*pops da col', KevinM style*

There we go.

--and I pretty much fed him his own **** in the debates because he was so meandering and spastic. In his arguments he created a multitude of inconsistencies I was able to exploit. Yet he was very town.

On the other hand, he was scum in TLI. Tom and I seemed to have caught him early on with good ol' scumhunting and gambits (respectively), and yet we both let off on him because (speaking for myself, but I assume also Tom) because his logic connected all the dots and he made decent points under pressure. Tom and I were both town, and Rockin vastly outlived us, dying only when his town-alligned lover did.

I'd say Marshy nailed Rockin best of anyone. I'm not really sure what his issues are, but they really aren't what jf said, in my opinion.

 

[DtJ Jungle]

i can use examples too EE

just not right now.

 

[Evil Eye]

Geez, where your law at now, J-Scott? Huh?

You're making a case. Burden of proof is on you -- prove this is Rockin's fault beyond a reasonable doubt.

I'm disagreeing. I need only create a reasonable doubt to invalidate an umbrella statement about a playstyle, which must be right in all instances to work.



When batman starts again I'mma kick yo *** soooo gooooood buddeh

 

[#HBC | Mac]

and f.y.i i'm f-l-y, and for those who can't spell, i'm a pretty swell guy.

i want to see EE play a game where he has an 150 word limit on all his posts.

 

[Evil Eye]

You'd have to invent a new number for the number of posts I'd make back to back.

 

[DtJ Jungle]

rockin likes men


there.

 

[Evil Eye]

Now that's an argument the jury will always side with.

 

[Tom]

evil eye is right. rockin is hard to pin down because he seems similarly confusing and slightly helpful / slightly unhelpful both as town and scum. in TLI he did a very good job of both immediately attracting our attention and skirting away from the lynch until endgame.

 

[DtJ Jungle]

I don't remember TLI too well (as i try not to) but didn't most the attention turnt o me after i made my whack *** stupid claim, which was given to me by Rockin/scumteam of whoever?

 

[Omis]

Omis was in the scum team. A very good scumteam is was. Would'a won if not for lovers.

 

[Nicholas1024]

Heh, pwned.

 

[Cacti]

Anything for meeee?

(other then my terrible lurking at times)

 

[DtJ Jungle]

changed to "critique playstyle above you" because half of yall are just saying "ooh ooh do me" and its getting annoying to read. if people want to critique others whove posted then they can feel freer

here you go!

 

[Kirbyoshi]

Omis was in the scum team. A very good scumteam is was. Would'a won if not for lovers.

Why do certain Mafia players like to talk about themselves in the third person? Kirb would never do that.

 

[KevinM]

@Cacti: No offense man but I have nothing to say about you because you literally do nothing but claim your PR and ride till endgame coasting.

 

[Kirbyoshi]

Well Kevin, isn't that a critique of Cacti's play?

 

[KevinM]

I guess haha.
Ten Haha's

 

[Xiivi]

Kevin plays very good, however his playstyle gives people a good excuse to not listen to him which is easy for scum to hide behind and discredit him sometimes. Follow him if he seems to agree with your line of thinking.

Also Kevin should never replace into a game. Do not let Kevin sign up as a replacement for your game; Kevin & I discussed how it's a bad thing once.

 

[KevinM]

Not even if its five minutes in. Cause i won't like it as much.

lolol

 

[Tom]

i want to see EE play a game where he has an 150 word limit on all his posts.

i also want to see this! and if he didnt try to get around it, i think it would be stellar!

 

[KevinM]

Tom would be a lot better if he didn't go holywtf inactive at least once per game

 

[Tom]

yea ...

 

[KevinM]

Aww mann why you gotta go and seem like ya took it so personal

 

[Tom]

Macman: did you get hit on the head recently or something? I can't decide if you're over rated.

 

[Kirby King]

I thought this thread was for constructive criticism?

Tom for all your preaching about not making personal attacks in these games you seem to make things personal a lot. Or at least make them sound that way.

 

[#HBC | Mac]

i don't have a response to that

 

[Tom]

I thought this thread was for constructive criticism?

Tom for all your preaching about not making personal attacks in these games you seem to make things personal a lot. Or at least make them sound that way.

You're right about that; it really bothers me when people make personal attacks in games. And I get heated in games but I think I only respond in turn when someone does it to me - both KevinM and Macman have abused that in games before and tried to make me mad on purpose to see my reaction. I guess I have a hard time leading by example sometimes, but this isn't in a game, so that's my cop out for this call out. To be constructive, I would ask if Macman is having a hard time playing multiple games at once, and let him know that his play-style has become increasingly more frustrating without getting any more effective. I know I'm not the only person who feels this way.

 

[#HBC | Mac]

maybe I am stretchin myself too thin

 

[KevinM]

Yeah whatever Tom, I'mma just ignore you .

 

[#HBC | Ryker]

Back on topic. I hate Kevin, completely and totally, but I can't help but like him. Can someone explain to me why he does what he does?

 

[DtJ Jungle]

cuz he's kevin

 

[KevinM]

Back on topic. I hate Kevin, completely and totally, but I can't help but like him. Can someone explain to me why he does what he does?

Chill u wicha boi <3.

 

[Nicholas1024]

Back on topic. I hate Kevin, completely and totally, but I can't help but like him. Can someone explain to me why he does what he does?

Let me give you a hint. When someone throws out a vote without reasoning, unless the reason is obvious, they're probably fishing for reactions (or a newbie trying to emulate the good players that do so). As for how they read those reactions... I'm still figuring that one out. Besides, that's the classified part.

 

[KevinM]

I'd tell you but then I'd have to modkill you

 

[Steel]

ya man u know how he balls