Create the Smash Roster, but 100% bias!

[Perkilator]

Updating mine again

Spoiler: 64 (original 12)

• 1. Mario
• 2. Donkey Kong
• 3. Link
• 4. Samus
• 5. Yoshi
• 6. Kirby
• 7. Fox
• 8. Pikachu
• 9. Luigi
• 10. Ness
• 11. Captain Falcon
• 12. Meowth

Spoiler: Melee with another year of development

• 13. Peach
• 14. Bowser
• 15. Ice Climbers
• 16. Sheik
• 17. Zelda
• 18. Scizor
• 19. Wario
• 20. Diddy Kong
• 21. Ayumi Tachibana
• 22. Marth
• 23. Mewtwo
• 24. Mr. Game & Watch
• 25. Young Link
• 26. Ganondorf
• 27. Falco
• 28. Roy

Spoiler: Brawl

• 29. Meta Knight
• 30. Pit
• 31. Zero Suit Samus
• 32. Snake
• 33. Ike
• 34-36. Pokémon Trainer
  • Squirtle
  • Ivysaur
  • Charizard
• 37. Lucas
• 38. Sonic
• 39. King Dedede
• 40. Olimar
• 41. Lucario
• 42. DeMille
• 43. R.O.B.
• 44. Wolf

Spoiler: Sm4sh

Base game

• 45. Villager
• 46. Mega Man
• 47. Wii Fit Trainer
• 48. Rosalina & Luma
• 49. Little Mac
• 50. Greninja
• 51-53. Mii Fighters
  • Brawler
  • Swordfighter
  • Gunner
• 54. Palutena
• 55. PAC-MAN
• 56. Robin
• 57. Shulk
• 58. Bowser Jr. / Koopalings
• 59. Duck Hunt

DLC

• 60. Rayman
• 61. Ryu
• 62. Cloud
• 63. Azura
• 64. Bayonetta

Spoiler: Base Ultimate with another year of development

• 65. Inkling
• 66. Simon Belmont
• 67. Ridley
• 68. King K. Rool
• 69. Incineroar
• 70. Bandana Waddle Dee
• 71. Min Min
• 72. Isabelle
• 73-74. Pyra / Mythra
• 75. Banjo & Kazooie

Spoiler: Echo Fighters

• 4ε. Dark Samus
• 13ε. Daisy
• 22ε. Lucina
• 28ε. Chrom
• 30ε. Dark Pit
• 40ε. Alph
• 56ε. Celica
• 61ε. Ken
• 66ε. Richter Belmont

Spoiler: Fighters Pass

Vol. 1

• 76. Joker
• 77. Hero
• 78. Crash Bandicoot
• 79. Estelle Bright
• 80. Terry Bogard
• 81. Dragonborn

Vol. 2

• 82. Dr. Eggman
• 83. Steve
• 84. Sephiroth
• 85. Ring Fit Trainee
• 86. Kazuya
• 87. Sora

 

[Venus of the Desert Bloom]

All the rosters reek of bias.

 

[kylexv]

Resurrecting my account after over a year just to post in this random thread lol.

Although the point of this thread is to fall completely into bias, I'm still going to base my picks on the resources the dev team had at the time (that is, I'm not replacing a clone with a non-clone, etc.).

Spoiler: Smash 64

I'd honestly keep the Original 12 exactly the same, so:

1. Mario
2. DK
3. Link
4. Samus
5. Yoshi
6. Kirby
7. Fox
8. Pikachu
9. Luigi
10. Ness
11. Captain Falcon
12. Jigglypuff

Spoiler: Melee

Not many changes here:
13. Peach
14. Bowser
15. King Dedede (replacing Icies)
16. Sheik
17. Zelda
18. Dr. Mario
19. Pichu
20. Falco
21. Marth
22. Young Link
23. Ganondorf
24. Mewtwo
25. Roy
26. Mr. Game and Watch

Spoiler: Brawl

Here is where we get into some more substantial changes:
27. Meta Knight
28. Pit
29. Zero Suit Samus
30. Wario
31. Snake
32. Ike
33. Charizard (solo, Squirtle and Ivysaur are cut)
34. Diddy Kong
35. Lucas
36. Sonic
37. Olimar
38. Ridley
39. Isaac
40. Lucario
41. R.O.B.
42. Toon Link
43. Wolf

The only changes here from the original Brawl roster are the following:

• Squirtle, Ivysaur, and Ice Climbers are cut
• Mewtwo, Ridley, and Isaac are added

To be continued...maybe

 

[nirvanafan]

EDIT - 3/7/23, cleaned up with roster maker

Spoiler: Smash 64

Red = Unlockable
Luigi & Gooey are echoes

Spoiler: Melee

Red = Unlockables
Mach Rider has an Excitebiker skin
Foreman Spike, Wolf, Black Shadow, Mach Rider, Pichu, & Celica join Luigi & Gooey as Echoes
Slippy & ROB 64 are like Ice Climbers
Goron & Zora Link are like Zelda/Sheik

Rare buyout did not happen till a couple months after Melee hit its finally territory. HM to Conker who was excluded since bad fur day probably released too close to Melee to be included.

Spoiler: Brawl

Red = Unlockable
Green = Replacement for cut Rare Chatacters
Mii Team is like a tag team Pokemon Trainer
No new echoes
Sonic & Crash are unlockable but revealed before launch like 3rd parties were in Brawl.

Spoiler: Smash 4

Red = Unlockable in both versions
Yellow = Unlockable in 3DS version only
Everyone listed after random icon is DLC.

Slippy & ROB 64 & Mii Team are either reworked or exclusive to the Wii U edition. I dont agree woth completely scrapping a fighter due to 3DS limitations.

No new echoes in base roster (although they are split off in there own row now) but the top row of DLC are all echoes instead of adding veterans since all are here except Rare.

Spoiler: Ultimate

Everyone is here (Rare is back)
Everyone after Tora is DLC except the Miis

Starting roster is & DJ KK

New Echoes are Veronica, Dark Samus, Tails, Coco, Hocotate President, & Octoling

Kasumi Alpha / Alpha 152 are like Pyra / Mythra
Rash & Billy Lee (with Pimple & Jimmy Lee Alt) are another duo fighter like Ice Climbers or Slippy & ROB 64

Tora & Lora are the main Xenoblade reps, Poppi, Jin, & Haze will be in background like Pokemon Trainer and occasionally interact with special attacks, taunts, etc.

 

[StrangeKitten]

Tails replaces Piranha Plant. Shadow replaces Byleth. Geno replaces Steve. Eggman replaces Kazuya,

Snorlax, Meowth, Eevee + evolutions (transforming character), Zoroark (Hisuian as echo), Okidogi, Meowscarada, Grovyle, Decidueye, Primarina, Gyarados, Ampharos, Scizor, Heracross, Shuckle, Ariados, Ho-oh, Lugia (Shadow Lugia as an echo), Blaziken, Koraidon, Hawlucha, Ursaluna, Nidoking, Clodsire, Donphan, Tyranitar (Iron Thorns as an echo), Lycanroc-midnight, Cloyster, Articuno, Weavile, Crobat, Toxtricity, Shadow Mewtwo as an echo of Mewtwo, Mew, Gengar, Mimikyu, Typhlosion (Hisuian as an echo), Skeledrige, Roaring Moon, Garchomp, Flygon, Dragonite, Empoleon, Corvinknight, Excadrill, Aggron, Obstagoon, Houndoom, Gardevoir, Grimmsnarl, and Alcremie are all added as playable fighters.

Why yes, I do have just a few favorite Pokemon, why do you ask?

 

[Perkilator]

All the rosters reek of bias.

That's the idea you mook

Anyways, here's my bajillionth revision

Spoiler: 64 (original 12)

• 1. Mario
• 2. Donkey Kong
• 3. Link
• 4. Samus
• 5. Yoshi
• 6. Kirby
• 7. Fox
• 8. Pikachu
• 9. Luigi
• 10. Ness
• 11. Captain Falcon
• 12. Meowth

Spoiler: Melee with another year of development

• 13. Peach
• 14. Bowser
• 15. Ice Climbers
• 16. Sheik
• 17. Zelda
• 18. Scizor
• 19. Wario
• 20. Diddy Kong
• 21. Ayumi Tachibana
• 22. Marth
• 23. Mewtwo
• 24. Mr. Game & Watch
• 25. Young Link
• 26. Ganondorf
• 27. Falco
• 28. Roy

Spoiler: Brawl

• 29. Meta Knight
• 30. Pit
• 31. Zero Suit Samus
• 32. Snake
• 33. Ike
• 34-36. Pokémon Trainer
  • Totodile
  • Grovyle
  • Charizard
• 37. Lucas
• 38. Sonic
• 39. King Dedede
• 40. Olimar
• 41. Lucario
• 42. R.O.B.
• 43. Toon Link
• 44. Wolf

Spoiler: Sm4sh

Base game

• 45. Villager
• 46. Mega Man
• 47. Wii Fit Trainer
• 48. Rosalina & Luma
• 49. Little Mac
• 50. Greninja
• 51-53. Mii Fighters
  • Brawler
  • Swordfighter
  • Gunner
• 54. Palutena
• 55. PAC-MAN
• 56. Robin
• 57. Shulk
• 58. Bowser Jr. / Koopalings
• 59. Duck Hunt

DLC

• 60. Rayman
• 61. Ryu
• 62. Cloud
• 63. Azura
• 64. Bayonetta

Spoiler: Base Ultimate with another year of development

• 65. Inkling
• 66. Simon Belmont
• 67. Ridley
• 68. King K. Rool
• 69. Incineroar
• 70. Rowlet
• 71. Min Min
• 72. Isabelle
• 73-74. Pyra / Mythra
• 75. Bandana Waddle Dee

Spoiler: Echo Fighters

• 4ε. Dark Samus
• 13ε. Daisy
• 22ε. Lucina
• 30ε. Dark Pit
• 40ε. Alph
• 56ε. Celica
• 61ε. Ken
• 66ε. Richter Belmont

Spoiler: Fighters Pass

Vol. 1

• 76. Joker
• 77. Hero
• 78. Crash Bandicoot
• 79. Estelle Bright
• 80. Terry Bogard
• 81. Banjo & Kazooie

Vol. 2

• 82. Euden
• 83. Dr. Eggman
• 84. Sephiroth
• 85. Ring Fit Trainee
• 86. Kazuya
• 87. Sora

 

[Zinith]

How many here put my boi in just because of being in the OG 8?

Anyways, a biased roster from my end wouldn't be a asking for much as I don't have much investment in the other non-Mario characters to want to "alter" them. Nevertheless, most of this is just thinking on the spot

64
1. Mario
2. Donkey Kong
3. Link
4. Samus
5. Yoshi
6. Kirby
7. Fox
8. Pikachu
9. Luigi
10. Diddy Kong
11. Wario
12. Charizard

Melee
13. Peach
14. Bowser
15. Zelda
16. Sheik
17. Falco
18. Ridley
19. Toad
20. Marth
21. Ganondorf
22. Captain Falcon
23. Mewtwo
24. King Dedede
25. Dixie Kong
26. Mr. Game & Watch

Brawl
27. Pit
28. Zero Suit Samus
29. Poochy (so it begins)
30. Ice Climbers
31. Sonic
32. Ike
33. Squirtle
34. Skull Kid
35. Simon
36. Mega Man
37. Ness
38. Olimar
39. Meta Knight
40. R.O.B.
41. Bowser Jr.
42. 9-Volt
43. Lucario
44. Vilager

4
45. Chibi-Robo
46. Crash Bandicoot
47. Rosalina
48. Little Mac
49. Chrom
50. Kamek (would be Yoshi)
51-53. Mii Fighters
54. Palutena
55. Pac-Man
56. Shulk
57. King K. Rool
58. Birdo (would be Mario)
59. Duck Hunt
60. Cloud
61. Ryu
62. Snake
63. Leon

Ultimate
64. Inkling
65. Bayonetta
66. Waluigi (would be Mario)
67. Isabelle
68. Lycancroc
69. Tails
70. Piranha Plant
71. Spyro
72. Erdrick (NOT Hero, 'cause **** that)
73. Banjo-Kazooie
74. Terry
75. Inteleon
76. Sora
77. Kazuya
78. Bandana Dee
79. Pyra
80. Mythra
81. Joker
82. Goku Geno

Echoes
5e. Boshi
13e. Daisy
20e. Lucina
27e. Dark Pit
31e. Shadow
35e. Trevor
61e. Ken