• Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!

    You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!

Create the Smash Roster, but 100% bias!

Perkilator

Smash Legend
Writing Team
Joined
Apr 8, 2018
Messages
11,254
Location
The perpetual trash fire known as Planet Earth(tm)
Updating mine again
  • 1. Mario
  • 2. Donkey Kong
  • 3. Link
  • 4. Samus
  • 5. Yoshi
  • 6. Kirby
  • 7. Fox
  • 8. Pikachu
  • 9. Luigi
  • 10. Ness
  • 11. Captain Falcon
  • 12. Meowth
  • 13. Peach
  • 14. Bowser
  • 15. Ice Climbers
  • 16. Sheik
  • 17. Zelda
  • 18. Scizor
  • 19. Wario
  • 20. Diddy Kong
  • 21. Ayumi Tachibana
  • 22. Marth
  • 23. Mewtwo
  • 24. Mr. Game & Watch
  • 25. Young Link
  • 26. Ganondorf
  • 27. Falco
  • 28. Roy
  • 29. Meta Knight
  • 30. Pit
  • 31. Zero Suit Samus
  • 32. Snake
  • 33. Ike
  • 34-36. Pokémon Trainer
    • Squirtle
    • Ivysaur
    • Charizard
  • 37. Lucas
  • 38. Sonic
  • 39. King Dedede
  • 40. Olimar
  • 41. Lucario
  • 42. DeMille
  • 43. R.O.B.
  • 44. Wolf
Base game
  • 45. Villager
  • 46. Mega Man
  • 47. Wii Fit Trainer
  • 48. Rosalina & Luma
  • 49. Little Mac
  • 50. Greninja
  • 51-53. Mii Fighters
    • Brawler
    • Swordfighter
    • Gunner
  • 54. Palutena
  • 55. PAC-MAN
  • 56. Robin
  • 57. Shulk
  • 58. Bowser Jr. / Koopalings
  • 59. Duck Hunt
DLC
  • 60. Rayman
  • 61. Ryu
  • 62. Cloud
  • 63. Azura
  • 64. Bayonetta
  • 65. Inkling
  • 66. Simon Belmont
  • 67. Ridley
  • 68. King K. Rool
  • 69. Incineroar
  • 70. Bandana Waddle Dee
  • 71. Min Min
  • 72. Isabelle
  • 73-74. Pyra / Mythra
  • 75. Banjo & Kazooie
  • 4ε. Dark Samus
  • 13ε. Daisy
  • 22ε. Lucina
  • 28ε. Chrom
  • 30ε. Dark Pit
  • 40ε. Alph
  • 56ε. Celica
  • 61ε. Ken
  • 66ε. Richter Belmont
Vol. 1
  • 76. Joker
  • 77. Hero
  • 78. Crash Bandicoot
  • 79. Estelle Bright
  • 80. Terry Bogard
  • 81. Dragonborn
Vol. 2
  • 82. Dr. Eggman
  • 83. Steve
  • 84. Sephiroth
  • 85. Ring Fit Trainee
  • 86. Kazuya
  • 87. Sora
 

kylexv

Smash Master
Joined
Jan 27, 2014
Messages
3,312
Location
On this Planet
Resurrecting my account after over a year just to post in this random thread lol.

Although the point of this thread is to fall completely into bias, I'm still going to base my picks on the resources the dev team had at the time (that is, I'm not replacing a clone with a non-clone, etc.).

I'd honestly keep the Original 12 exactly the same, so:

1. Mario
2. DK
3. Link
4. Samus
5. Yoshi
6. Kirby
7. Fox
8. Pikachu
9. Luigi
10. Ness
11. Captain Falcon
12. Jigglypuff

Not many changes here:
13. Peach
14. Bowser
15. King Dedede (replacing Icies)
16. Sheik
17. Zelda
18. Dr. Mario
19. Pichu
20. Falco
21. Marth
22. Young Link
23. Ganondorf
24. Mewtwo
25. Roy
26. Mr. Game and Watch

Here is where we get into some more substantial changes:
27. Meta Knight
28. Pit
29. Zero Suit Samus
30. Wario
31. Snake
32. Ike
33. Charizard (solo, Squirtle and Ivysaur are cut)
34. Diddy Kong
35. Lucas
36. Sonic
37. Olimar
38. Ridley
39. Isaac
40. Lucario
41. R.O.B.
42. Toon Link
43. Wolf

The only changes here from the original Brawl roster are the following:
  • Squirtle, Ivysaur, and Ice Climbers are cut
  • Mewtwo, Ridley, and Isaac are added

To be continued...maybe
 

nirvanafan

Smash Champion
Premium
Joined
Oct 14, 2016
Messages
2,729
EDIT - 3/7/23, cleaned up with roster maker

EDIT - 5/24/23, added direct links to roster images since imgur images arent showing on the post.

Red = Unlockable
Luigi & Gooey are echoes

https://imgur.io/wPetsuJ?r

Red = Unlockables
Mach Rider has an Excitebiker skin
Foreman Spike, Wolf, Black Shadow, Mach Rider, Pichu, & Celica join Luigi & Gooey as Echoes
Slippy & ROB 64 are like Ice Climbers
Goron & Zora Link are like Zelda/Sheik

https://imgur.io/nBfVH08?r

Rare buyout did not happen till a couple months after Melee hit its finally territory. HM to Conker who was excluded since bad fur day probably released too close to Melee to be included.

Red = Unlockable
Green = Replacement for cut Rare Chatacters
Mii Team is like a tag team Pokemon Trainer
No new echoes
Sonic & Crash are unlockable but revealed before launch like 3rd parties were in Brawl.

https://imgur.io/Gv17ASl

Red = Unlockable in both versions
Yellow = Unlockable in 3DS version only
Everyone listed after random icon is DLC.

Slippy & ROB 64 & Mii Team are either reworked or exclusive to the Wii U edition. I dont agree woth completely scrapping a fighter due to 3DS limitations.

No new echoes in base roster (although they are split off in there own row now) but the top row of DLC are all echoes instead of adding veterans since all are here except Rare.

https://i.imgur.io/TROlcmz.jpg

Everyone is here (Rare is back)
Everyone after Tora is DLC except the Miis

Starting roster is :ultmario: :ultlink: :ultpikachu: :ultkirby: :ultfox: :ultmarth::ultsamus: & DJ KK

New Echoes are Veronica, Dark Samus, Tails, Coco, Hocotate President, & Octoling

Kasumi Alpha / Alpha 152 are like Pyra / Mythra
Rash & Billy Lee (with Pimple & Jimmy Lee Alt) are another duo fighter like Ice Climbers or Slippy & ROB 64

Tora & Lora are the main Xenoblade reps, Poppi, Jin, & Haze will be in background like Pokemon Trainer and occasionally interact with special attacks, taunts, etc.

https://i.imgur.io/YuIzzrk.jpg
 
Last edited:

StrangeKitten

Smash Lord
Joined
Mar 25, 2020
Messages
1,956
Location
Battle Royal Dome
Tails replaces Piranha Plant. Shadow replaces Byleth. Geno replaces Steve. Eggman replaces Kazuya,

Snorlax, Meowth, Eevee + evolutions (transforming character), Zoroark (Hisuian as echo), Okidogi, Meowscarada, Grovyle, Decidueye, Primarina, Gyarados, Ampharos, Scizor, Heracross, Shuckle, Ariados, Ho-oh, Lugia (Shadow Lugia as an echo), Blaziken, Koraidon, Hawlucha, Ursaluna, Nidoking, Clodsire, Donphan, Tyranitar (Iron Thorns as an echo), Lycanroc-midnight, Cloyster, Articuno, Weavile, Crobat, Toxtricity, Shadow Mewtwo as an echo of Mewtwo, Mew, Gengar, Mimikyu, Typhlosion (Hisuian as an echo), Skeledrige, Roaring Moon, Garchomp, Flygon, Dragonite, Empoleon, Corvinknight, Excadrill, Aggron, Obstagoon, Houndoom, Gardevoir, Grimmsnarl, and Alcremie are all added as playable fighters.

Why yes, I do have just a few favorite Pokemon, why do you ask?
 

Perkilator

Smash Legend
Writing Team
Joined
Apr 8, 2018
Messages
11,254
Location
The perpetual trash fire known as Planet Earth(tm)
All the rosters reek of bias.
That's the idea you mook

Anyways, here's my bajillionth revision
  • 1. Mario
  • 2. Donkey Kong
  • 3. Link
  • 4. Samus
  • 5. Yoshi
  • 6. Kirby
  • 7. Fox
  • 8. Pikachu
  • 9. Luigi
  • 10. Ness
  • 11. Captain Falcon
  • 12. Meowth
  • 13. Peach
  • 14. Bowser
  • 15. Ice Climbers
  • 16. Sheik
  • 17. Zelda
  • 18. Scizor
  • 19. Wario
  • 20. Diddy Kong
  • 21. Ayumi Tachibana
  • 22. Marth
  • 23. Mewtwo
  • 24. Mr. Game & Watch
  • 25. Young Link
  • 26. Ganondorf
  • 27. Falco
  • 28. Roy
  • 29. Meta Knight
  • 30. Pit
  • 31. Zero Suit Samus
  • 32. Snake
  • 33. Ike
  • 34-36. Pokémon Trainer
    • Totodile
    • Grovyle
    • Charizard
  • 37. Lucas
  • 38. Sonic
  • 39. King Dedede
  • 40. Olimar
  • 41. Lucario
  • 42. R.O.B.
  • 43. Toon Link
  • 44. Wolf
Base game
  • 45. Villager
  • 46. Mega Man
  • 47. Wii Fit Trainer
  • 48. Rosalina & Luma
  • 49. Little Mac
  • 50. Greninja
  • 51-53. Mii Fighters
    • Brawler
    • Swordfighter
    • Gunner
  • 54. Palutena
  • 55. PAC-MAN
  • 56. Robin
  • 57. Shulk
  • 58. Bowser Jr. / Koopalings
  • 59. Duck Hunt
DLC
  • 60. Rayman
  • 61. Ryu
  • 62. Cloud
  • 63. Azura
  • 64. Bayonetta
  • 65. Inkling
  • 66. Simon Belmont
  • 67. Ridley
  • 68. King K. Rool
  • 69. Incineroar
  • 70. Rowlet
  • 71. Min Min
  • 72. Isabelle
  • 73-74. Pyra / Mythra
  • 75. Bandana Waddle Dee
  • 4ε. Dark Samus
  • 13ε. Daisy
  • 22ε. Lucina
  • 30ε. Dark Pit
  • 40ε. Alph
  • 56ε. Celica
  • 61ε. Ken
  • 66ε. Richter Belmont
Vol. 1
  • 76. Joker
  • 77. Hero
  • 78. Crash Bandicoot
  • 79. Estelle Bright
  • 80. Terry Bogard
  • 81. Banjo & Kazooie
Vol. 2
  • 82. Euden
  • 83. Dr. Eggman
  • 84. Sephiroth
  • 85. Ring Fit Trainee
  • 86. Kazuya
  • 87. Sora
 

Zinith

Yoshi is Thicc in S P I R I T
Joined
May 13, 2018
Messages
24,782
Location
All around you, awaiting to consume your soul
Switch FC
SW-4624-0132-9722
How many here put my boi in just because of being in the OG 8?

Anyways, a biased roster from my end wouldn't be a asking for much as I don't have much investment in the other non-Mario characters to want to "alter" them. Nevertheless, most of this is just thinking on the spot

64
1. Mario
2. Donkey Kong
3. Link
4. Samus
5. Yoshi
6. Kirby
7. Fox
8. Pikachu
9. Luigi
10. Diddy Kong
11. Wario
12. Charizard

Melee
13. Peach
14. Bowser
15. Zelda
16. Sheik
17. Falco
18. Ridley
19. Toad
20. Marth
21. Ganondorf
22. Captain Falcon
23. Mewtwo
24. King Dedede
25. Dixie Kong
26. Mr. Game & Watch

Brawl
27. Pit
28. Zero Suit Samus
29. Poochy (so it begins)
30. Ice Climbers
31. Sonic
32. Ike
33. Squirtle
34. Skull Kid
35. Simon
36. Mega Man
37. Ness
38. Olimar
39. Meta Knight
40. R.O.B.
41. Bowser Jr.
42. 9-Volt
43. Lucario
44. Vilager

4
45. Chibi-Robo
46. Crash Bandicoot
47. Rosalina
48. Little Mac
49. Chrom
50. Kamek (would be Yoshi)
51-53. Mii Fighters
54. Palutena
55. Pac-Man
56. Shulk
57. King K. Rool
58. Birdo (would be Mario)
59. Duck Hunt
60. Cloud
61. Ryu
62. Snake
63. Leon

Ultimate
64. Inkling
65. Bayonetta
66. Waluigi (would be Mario)
67. Isabelle
68. Lycancroc
69. Tails
70. Piranha Plant
71. Spyro
72. Erdrick (NOT Hero, 'cause **** that)
73. Banjo-Kazooie
74. Terry
75. Inteleon
76. Sora
77. Kazuya
78. Bandana Dee
79. Pyra
80. Mythra
81. Joker
82. Goku Geno

Echoes
5e. Boshi
13e. Daisy
20e. Lucina
27e. Dark Pit
31e. Shadow
35e. Trevor
61e. Ken

:yoshi:
 

nirvanafan

Smash Champion
Premium
Joined
Oct 14, 2016
Messages
2,729
Decided to do stages, will continue to update, may do assists later as well

Peach's Castle (Mushroom Kingdom)Temple of Time (Hyrule)Castle Dedede (Dream Land)Archenean Ship (Archenea Seas)Ayashiro Estate (Myoujin Village)
Mute City III Grid (King Cup)Sector Z (Lylat System)Gruntilda's Lair (Spiral Mountain)Saffron City (Kanto)

Bowser's Castle (Koopa Kingdom)Jungle Hijinxs (Kongo Jungle)25m (Big Ape City)Mach Ride (Course A - Sector 1)Manhole (Flat Zone)Console Floats (Secret)
Clock Town (Termina)Halberd (Dream Land Skies)Tharcia Coliseum (Jugdral)Big Blue II (Queen Cup)Meteo (Lylat System)Pokemon Stadium (Johto)
Jinjo Village (Isle 'O Hags)Ultratech HQ (KI Tourney)Combo Gym (KI Tourney)dataDyne Central (Lucerne Tower)Holotraining (Carrington Institute)

Every 64 stage returns with Battlefield, Final Destination, and Meta Crystal becoming selectable.

Delfino Plaza (Isle Delfino)Luigi's Mansion (Boo Woods)Wario Ware Inc. (Variety Tower)Ordon Village (Ordona Providence)Dragon Roost Island (Great Sea)
Rail Stations (City Trial)Castle Crimea (Tellius)Casino Palace (Emerald Cup)Pleiades Cruiser (Corneria City)Pokemon Stadium 2 (Sinnoh)
Brinstar (Planet Zebes)Nearby Museum (Wild World)Orange Star Base (Cosmo Land)Duck Hunting (Game A - Round ∞)Excitebike (Selection B - Track 4)
Mii Plaza (Mii Channel)Designer Condo (Interior Decorator)Smashroom (Pictochat)Green Hill Zone (South Island)Warp Room (Wumpa Islands)


All Rare Stages and Console Floats are cut, everwhere else returns

Both3DSWii UDLC
Peach's Castle (N64)Temple of Time (N64)Castle Dedede (N64)Mute City III Grid (N64)Archanean Ship (N64)Ayashiro Estate (N64)Console Tussle (M)
Sector Z (N64)Halberd (M)Saffron City (N64)Meta Crystal (N64)Battlefield (N64)Jungle Hijinx (M)Tourney Ring (M - Combo Gym Reskin)
Big Blue II (M)Pokemon Stadium (M)Clock Town (M)Tharcia Coliseum (M)Meteo (M)Mach Ride (M)Wii U - Meta Crystal (N64)
Castle Crimea (B)Green Hill Zone (B)25m (M)Manhole (M)Bowser's Castle (M)Delfino Plaza (B)3DS - Battlefield (N64)
Warp Room (B)Luigi's Mansion (B)Wario Ware Inc. (B)Ordon Village (B)Rail Stations (B)Wii U - Dragon Roost Island (B)
Dragon Roost Island (B)Pleiades Cruiser (B)Casino Palace (B)Pokemon Stadium 2 (B)3DS - Bowser's Castle (M)
Brinstar (B)Orange Star Base (B)Duck Hunt (B)Mii Plaza (B)
Nearby Museum (B)Excitebike (B)Smashroom (B)Designer Condo (B)
Both3DSWii UDLC
Reset Bomb Forest (Overworld)Rainbow Road (Special Cup)Comet Observatory (Star Festival Orbit)Yoshi's Island (Dinosaur Land)Millennial Tower (Kamurocho)
Holloseum (Dome City)Hylia River (Hyrule)Wario Castle (Treasure Square)Skyloft (Hylian Skies)First Destination (Secret)
Impact Site (PNF-404)Prism Tower (Kalos)Quilty Square (Patch Land)Falcon Flyover (Gold Cup)Normandy Dock Bay D24 (Citadel)
Chibi House (Sanderson Home)Activity Feed (Miiverse)Andross's Factory (Macbeth)Outrealm Gate (Ylisse)Astral Chaos (Manji Clan Mission)
Hayabusa Village (Vigoor Outskirts)Pokemon Coliseum (Kalos)Frigate Orpheon (Tallon IV Orbit)
Black Hole (Macro Land)Happy Home Academy (Main Street)
Wuhu Island Flyover (Air-Sports)Balloon Fight (Game A - Phase 2)
Aspen Lake (Wave Race / 1080)Marathon (Tetris)

Base GameFighter Pass 1Fighter Pass 2
Port Mackerel (Turf War)Amusement Park (City Ruins)Durandal (Kukai Foundation?)
Windy (Panther Kingdom)Partenaire (Clashing Worlds)VS. Marathon (Puyo Puyo Tetris)
Cloud Sea Flythrough (Alrest)Blag Alley (Ratship)Unforgettable (DOATEC Museum)
Sheikah Shrine (Monk Trials)Farmland & Home (Mineral Town)Florio Island (Lental Region)
Garreg Mach Monastery (Fodlan)Poem Notebook (Poetry Brainstorming)
Bonus - Console Floats 2 (Secret)Valhalla (Installation 00)
 
Last edited:

UserKev

Smash Champion
Joined
May 10, 2017
Messages
2,683
This is 100% my roster.

  • Mario, Luigi, Bowser, Peach, Wario, Daisy, Bowser Jr. Waluigi, Birdo
  • DK, Diddy Kong, King K. Rool, Dixie Kong, Cranky Kong
  • Link, Toon Link, Ghirahim
  • Samus, Ridley
  • Captain Falcon
  • Ness
  • Yoshi, Kamek
  • Kirby, King Dedede, Waddle Dee
  • Fox, Falco, Wolf
  • Pikachu, Jigglypuff, Sudowoodo, Charizard, Mimikyu
  • Ice Climbers
  • Mr. Game & Watch
  • Marth, Lyn, Ike, Lucina
  • Olimar
  • Pit,
  • Isabelle, Mr. Resetti
  • Wii Fit Trainer
  • Little Mac
  • Shulk
  • Duck Hunt Dog
  • Bayonetta
  • Bomberman
  • Rayman
  • Scorpion
  • Dragonborn
 

Perkilator

Smash Legend
Writing Team
Joined
Apr 8, 2018
Messages
11,254
Location
The perpetual trash fire known as Planet Earth(tm)
Decided to take quite the different approach with mine this time, as it primarily takes into account characters that were considered / scrapped, with hints of self-indulgence. (Italics bolded denotes unlockable characters)

It shouls also be noted that in this hypothetical AU:
  1. Budget, technical limitations and time constraints are not an issue
  2. Each game (with the exception of Smash for 3DS / Wii U, because duh) would start out as arcade release before being ported to consoles.
Mario​
Donkey Kong​
Link​
Samus​
Yoshi​
Kirby​
Fox​
Pikachu​
Luigi
Bowser
Marth
Mewtwo
King Dedede
Ness
Captain Falcon
Meowth
1P Game Rivalries
  1. Mario vs. Luigi (no surprise here) on Peach’s Castle
  2. Donkey Kong vs. Bowser (Mario's earliest foes) on Kongo Jungle
  3. Link vs. Marth (swordsmen of legend) on Hyrule Castle
  4. Samus vs. Mewtwo (the latter of which loosely resembles an alien) on Planet Zebes
  5. Yoshi vs. King Dedede (big eaters) on Super Happy Tree
  6. Kirby vs. Ness (the former of which is a space traveler) on Dream Land
  7. Fox vs. Captain Falcon (pilots with animal motifs) on Sector Z
  8. Pikachu vs. Meowth (again, no surprise here) on Saffron City
Unlock matches
  • Luigi: Clear 1P Game as Mario without losing a life
  • Bowser: Clear 1P Game as DK without losing a life
  • Marth: Clear 1P Game as Link without losing a life
  • Mewtwo: Clear 1P Game as Samus without losing a life
  • King Dedede: Clear 1P Game as Yoshi without losing a life
  • Ness: Clear 1P Game as Kirby without losing a life
  • Captain Falcon: Clear 1P Game as Fox without losing a life
  • Meowth: Clear 1P Game as Pikachu without losing a life
Luigi
Mario​
Donkey Kong​
Link​
Samus​
Yoshi​
Wario
Diddy Kong
Kirby​
Fox​
Pikachu​
Bowser​
Ness​
Ganondorf
King Dedede
Captain Falcon​
Peach​
Zelda / Sheik​
Scizor​
Ice Climbers​
Falco
Meowth
Mewtwo
Ayumi Tachibana
Marth
Roy
Mr. Game & Watch
RANDOM​
Mario​
Donkey Kong​
Link​
Samus / Zero Suit Samus​
Kirby​
Fox​
Pikachu​
Marth
Mr. Game & Watch
Luigi
Diddy Kong​
Zelda / Sheik​
Pit​
King Dedede​
Falco
Pokémon Trainer*​
Ike​
DeMille
Bowser​
Yoshi​
Ganondorf
Ice Climbers​
Meta Knight​
Wolf
Lucario
Ness
Snake​
Peach​
Wario​
Tetra
R.O.B.
Olimar​
Captain Falcon
Meowth
Lucas​
Sonic
*Team now consists of Totodile, Grovyle & Charizard
(Orange denotes 3DS exclusives, blue denotes Wii U exclusives; unlockable characters in the 3DS version are characters who hadn't been properly revealed before the Wii U version comes out, meaning those characters will be a starter in the Wii U version)
3DS version
Mario​
Luigi​
Bowser​
Peach​
Rosalina & Luma​
Bowser Jr.
Donkey Kong​
Diddy Kong​
Link​
Zelda​
Sheik​
Ganondorf​
Samus​
Zero Suit Samus​
Yoshi​
Kirby​
King Dedede​
Meta Knight​
Fox​
Falco
Pikachu​
Meowth
Mewtwo​
Scizor​
Lucario​
Greninja​
Marth​
Ike​
Robin
Ness
Captain Falcon​
Wario
Mr. Game & Watch
Pit​
Palutena​
DeMille
Villager​
Little Mac​
Duck Hunt
Takamaru
Dark Pit
Lucina​
Sonic​
Mega Man​
PAC-MAN
Mii Fighters*​

Wii U version
Mario​
Luigi​
Bowser​
Peach​
Rosalina & Luma​
Bowser Jr.​
Donkey Kong​
Diddy Kong​
Link​
Zelda​
Sheik​
Ganondorf​
Tetra
Samus​
Zero Suit Samus​
Yoshi​
Kirby​
King Dedede​
Meta Knight​
Fox​
Falco
Pikachu​
Meowth
Mewtwo​
Scizor​
Lucario​
Greninja​
Marth​
Ike​
Ness
Captain Falcon​
Ice Climbers
Wario
Pit​
Palutena​
Olimar / Alph
Villager​
Wii Fit Trainer
Little Mac​
Shulk
Takamaru​
Lucina​
Sonic​
Mega Man​
PAC-MAN​
Mii Fighters*​
*Still Brawler, Swordfighter and Gunner

Free updates
Tetra (for 3DS)​
Popo / Nana (for 3DS)​
Olimar / Alph (for 3DS)​
Wii Fit Trainer (for 3DS)​
Shulk (for 3DS)​
Robin (for Wii U)​
Mr. Game & Watch (for Wii U)​
DeMille (for Wii U)​
Dark Pit (for Wii U)​
Duck Hunt (for Wii U)​

DLC Fighters Pass
Rayman​
Ryu​
Roy​
Lucas​
Cloud​
Azura​
Bayonetta​

Timeline of reveals
  • E3 2013
    • Veterans
      • Mario
      • Bowser
      • Donkey Kong
      • Link, now sporting his Skyward Sword design
      • Samus, now sporting her Other M design
      • Kirby, now sporting his Return to Dream Land design and a new moveset using more of his Copy Abilities
      • Fox
      • Pikachu
      • Pit, now sporting his Uprising design
      • Ice Climbers (Wii U only)
    • Newcomers
      • Villager
      • Mega Man
      • Wii Fit Trainer (Wii U only)
  • July 2013
    • Olimar / Alph (Wii U only)
  • August 2013
    • Luigi
  • September 2013
    • Peach
    • Tetra
  • October 2013
    • Sonic
  • November 2013
    • Marth
  • December 2013
    • Rosalina & Luma
    • Zelda, now sporting her Link Between Worlds design
  • January 2014
    • King Dedede, now sporting his Return to Dream Land design
    • Lucario
  • February 2014
    • Little Mac & Scizor
    • Diddy Kong
  • April 2014
    • Smash Direct
      • Zero Suit Samus
      • Sheik
      • Yoshi
      • Mewtwo & Greninja
  • May 2014
    • Ike
  • E3 2014
    • Mii Fighters
    • Palutena & Captain Falcon
    • PAC-MAN & Mr. Game & Watch (3DS only)
  • July 2014
    • Lucina, Ganondorf (now sporting his Ocarina of Time design and a new moveset using his sword from Spaceworld 2000 and Phantom Ganon's trident) & Robin (3DS only)
  • August 2014
    • Meta Knight
    • Shulk (Wii U only)
  • September 2014
    • JP launch day (3DS)
  • October 2014
    • US launch day (3DS)
      • Bowser Jr.
      • DeMille (3DS only)
      • Dark Pit (3DS only)
  • November 2014
    • 50-Fact Extravaganza
      • Takamaru
      • All unlockable characters
      • Duck Hunt gameplay on Wii U
      • All 3DS-only characters coming to Wii U in a future update, and vice-versa
      • Rayman (DLC teaser)
    • US launch day (Wii U)
  • December 2014
    • JP launch day (WII U)
  • April 2015
    • Rayman
    • Fighters Pass (7 fighters for $4,99 each, or a pass for all fighters for $29.99)
    • All 3DS-only characters come to Wii U
  • June 2015
    • Ryu
    • Roy
    • Lucas
    • All Wii U-only characters come to 3DS
  • Novmber 2015
    • Cloud
  • March 2016
    • Azura
    • Bayonetta
Base game
64MeleeBrawlfor 3DS / Wii UNewcomersEcho Fighters
  • 1. Mario​
  • 2. Donkey Kong​
  • 3. Link​
  • 4. Samus​
  • 5. Yoshi​
  • 6. Kirby​
  • 7. Fox​
  • 8. Pikachu​
  • 9. Luigi​
  • 10. Bowser​
  • 11. Marth​
  • 12. Mewtwo​
  • 13. King Dedede​
  • 14. Ness​
  • 15. Captain Falcon​
  • 16. Meowth​
  • 17. Peach​
  • 18. Sheik​
  • 19. Zelda​
  • 20. Scizor​
  • 21. Ice Climbers​
  • 22. Wario​
  • 23. Diddy Kong​
  • 24. Ayumi Tachibana​
  • 25. Ganondorf​
  • 26. Falco​
  • 27. Roy​
  • 28. Mr. Game & Watch​
  • 29. Meta Knight​
  • 30. Pit​
  • 31. Zero Suit Samus​
  • 32. Snake​
  • 33. Ike​
  • 34-36. Pokémon Trainer​
    • Totodile​
    • Grovyle​
    • Charizard​
  • 37. Lucas​
  • 38. Sonic​
  • 39. Olimar​
  • 40. Lucario​
  • 41. DeMille​
  • 42. R.O.B.​
  • 43. Tetra​
  • 44. Wolf​
  • 45. Villager​
  • 46. Mega Man​
  • 47. Wii Fit Trainer​
  • 48. Rosalina & Luma​
  • 49. Little Mac​
  • 50. Greninja​
  • 51-53. Mii Fighters​
    • Brawler​
    • Swordfighter​
    • Gunner​
  • 54. Palutena​
  • 55. PAC-MAN​
  • 56. Robin​
  • 57. Shulk​
  • 58. Bowser Jr.​
  • 59. Takamaru​
  • 60. Duck Hunt​
  • 61. Rayman​
  • 62. Ryu​
  • 63. Cloud​
  • 64. Azura​
  • 65. Bayonetta​
  • 66. Inkling​
  • 67. Simon​
  • 68. Alucard​
  • 69. Ridley​
  • 70. King K. Rool​
  • 71-72. Pyra / Mythra​
  • 73. Bandana Waddle Dee​
  • 74. Incineroar​
  • 75. Waluigi​
  • 4ε. Dark Samus​
  • 10ε. Dry Bowser​
  • 11ε. Lucina​
  • 15ε. Black Shadow​
  • 17ε. Daisy​
  • 23ε. Dixie Kong​
  • 27ε. Chrom​
  • 30ε. Dark Pit​
  • 38ε. Shadow​
  • 39ε. Alph​
  • 49ε. Glass Joe​
  • 56ε. Celica​
  • 62ε. Ken​

Fighters Pass
Vol. 1Vol. 2
  • 76. Joker
  • 77. Slime
  • 78. Crash
  • 79. Estelle Bright
  • 80. Terry Bogard
  • 81. Banjo & Kazooie
  • 82. Min Min
  • 83. Dr. Eggman
  • 84. Sephiroth
  • 85. Steve
  • 86. Kazuya
  • 87. Sora

Timeline of reveals
  • March 2018
    • Teaser trailer
    • Inkling
  • E3 2018
    • Everyone is Here!
      • Dry Bowser
      • Black Shadow
      • Daisy
      • Dixie Kong
      • Chrom
      • Shadow
      • Alph
      • Glass Joe
    • Simon & Alucard
  • EVO 2018
    • Ridley
    • Dark Samus & Celica
    • King K. Rool
  • September 2018 Direct
    • Pyra / Mythra
  • December 2018
    • Arcade version is released
  • February 2019 Direct
    • Bandana Waddle Dee
  • E3 2019
    • Ken & Incineroar
    • Waluigi
  • September 2019 Direct
    • Adventure Mode: World of Light
  • December 2019
    • TGA: Joker (teaser)
    • Console version is released
  • March 2020 Mini-Direct
    • Joker (releasing April 2020)
  • April 2020
    • Mr. Sakurai Presents Joker
  • July 2020 Mini-Direct
    • Slime (releasing shortly after the Direct)
    • Mr. Sakurai Presents Slime
    • Crash Bandicoot (releasing October 2020)
  • October 2020
    • Mr. Sakurai Presents Crash Bandicoot
    • Mini-Direct: Estelle Bright (releasing December 2020)
  • December 2020
    • TGA: Terry Bogard (teaser)
    • Mr. Sakurai Presents Estelle Bright
  • February 2021
    • Terry Bogard (releasing March 2021)
  • March 2021
    • Mr. Sakurai Presents Terry Bogard
  • E3 2021
    • Banjo & Kazooie (releasing shortly after)
    • Mr. Sakurai Presents Banjo & Kazooie
  • September 2021 Direct
    • Min Min (releasing shortly after)
    • Mr. Sakurai Presents Min Min
  • TGA 2021
    • Dr. Eggman (releasing shortly after)
    • Mr. Sakurai Presents Dr. Eggman
  • February 2022 Direct
    • Sephiroth (releasing shortly after)
    • Mr. Sakurai Presents Sephiroth
  • June 2022 Mini-Direct
    • Steve (releasing shortly after)
    • Mr. Sakurai Presents Steve
  • September 2022 Direct
    • Kazuya Mishima (releasing shortly after)
    • Mr. Sakurai Presents Kazuya
  • December 2022
    • TGA: Sora (releasing shortly after)
    • Mr. Sakurai Presents Sora
 
Last edited:

Perkilator

Smash Legend
Writing Team
Joined
Apr 8, 2018
Messages
11,254
Location
The perpetual trash fire known as Planet Earth(tm)
Decided to take quite the different approach with mine this time, as it primarily takes into account characters that were considered / scrapped, with hints of self-indulgence. (Italics bolded denotes unlockable characters)

It shouls also be noted that in this hypothetical AU:
  1. Budget, technical limitations and time constraints are not an issue
  2. Each game (with the exception of Smash for 3DS / Wii U, because duh) would start out as arcade release before being ported to consoles.
Mario​
Donkey Kong​
Link​
Samus​
Yoshi​
Kirby​
Fox​
Pikachu​
Luigi
Bowser
Marth
Mewtwo
King Dedede
Ness
Captain Falcon
Meowth
1P Game Rivalries
  1. Mario vs. Luigi (no surprise here) on Peach’s Castle
  2. Donkey Kong vs. Bowser (Mario's earliest foes) on Kongo Jungle
  3. Link vs. Marth (swordsmen of legend) on Hyrule Castle
  4. Samus vs. Mewtwo (the latter of which loosely resembles an alien) on Planet Zebes
  5. Yoshi vs. King Dedede (big eaters) on Super Happy Tree
  6. Kirby vs. Ness (the former of which is a space traveler) on Dream Land
  7. Fox vs. Captain Falcon (pilots with animal motifs) on Sector Z
  8. Pikachu vs. Meowth (again, no surprise here) on Saffron City
Unlock matches
  • Luigi: Clear 1P Game as Mario without losing a life
  • Bowser: Clear 1P Game as DK without losing a life
  • Marth: Clear 1P Game as Link without losing a life
  • Mewtwo: Clear 1P Game as Samus without losing a life
  • King Dedede: Clear 1P Game as Yoshi without losing a life
  • Ness: Clear 1P Game as Kirby without losing a life
  • Captain Falcon: Clear 1P Game as Fox without losing a life
  • Meowth: Clear 1P Game as Pikachu without losing a life
Luigi
Mario​
Donkey Kong​
Link​
Samus​
Yoshi​
Wario
Diddy Kong
Kirby​
Fox​
Pikachu​
Bowser​
Ness​
Ganondorf
King Dedede
Captain Falcon​
Peach​
Zelda / Sheik​
Scizor​
Ice Climbers​
Falco
Meowth
Mewtwo
Ayumi Tachibana
Marth
Roy
Mr. Game & Watch
RANDOM​
Mario​
Donkey Kong​
Link​
Samus / Zero Suit Samus​
Kirby​
Fox​
Pikachu​
Marth
Mr. Game & Watch
Luigi
Diddy Kong​
Zelda / Sheik​
Pit​
King Dedede​
Falco
Pokémon Trainer*​
Ike​
DeMille
Bowser​
Yoshi​
Ganondorf
Ice Climbers​
Meta Knight​
Wolf
Lucario
Ness
Snake​
Peach​
Wario​
Tetra
R.O.B.
Olimar​
Captain Falcon
Meowth
Lucas​
Sonic
*Team now consists of Totodile, Grovyle & Charizard
(Orange denotes 3DS exclusives, blue denotes Wii U exclusives; unlockable characters in the 3DS version are characters who hadn't been properly revealed before the Wii U version comes out, meaning those characters will be a starter in the Wii U version)
3DS version
Mario​
Luigi​
Bowser​
Peach​
Rosalina & Luma​
Bowser Jr.
Donkey Kong​
Diddy Kong​
Link​
Zelda​
Sheik​
Ganondorf​
Samus​
Zero Suit Samus​
Yoshi​
Kirby​
King Dedede​
Meta Knight​
Fox​
Falco
Pikachu​
Meowth
Mewtwo​
Scizor​
Lucario​
Greninja​
Marth​
Ike​
Robin
Ness
Captain Falcon​
Wario
Mr. Game & Watch
Pit​
Palutena​
DeMille
Villager​
Little Mac​
Duck Hunt
Takamaru
Dark Pit
Lucina​
Sonic​
Mega Man​
PAC-MAN
Mii Fighters*​

Wii U version
Mario​
Luigi​
Bowser​
Peach​
Rosalina & Luma​
Bowser Jr.​
Donkey Kong​
Diddy Kong​
Link​
Zelda​
Sheik​
Ganondorf​
Tetra
Samus​
Zero Suit Samus​
Yoshi​
Kirby​
King Dedede​
Meta Knight​
Fox​
Falco
Pikachu​
Meowth
Mewtwo​
Scizor​
Lucario​
Greninja​
Marth​
Ike​
Ness
Captain Falcon​
Ice Climbers
Wario
Pit​
Palutena​
Olimar / Alph
Villager​
Wii Fit Trainer
Little Mac​
Shulk
Takamaru​
Lucina​
Sonic​
Mega Man​
PAC-MAN​
Mii Fighters*​
*Still Brawler, Swordfighter and Gunner

Free updates
Tetra (for 3DS)​
Popo / Nana (for 3DS)​
Olimar / Alph (for 3DS)​
Wii Fit Trainer (for 3DS)​
Shulk (for 3DS)​
Robin (for Wii U)​
Mr. Game & Watch (for Wii U)​
DeMille (for Wii U)​
Dark Pit (for Wii U)​
Duck Hunt (for Wii U)​

DLC Fighters Pass
Rayman​
Ryu​
Roy​
Lucas​
Cloud​
Azura​
Bayonetta​

Timeline of reveals
  • E3 2013
    • Veterans
      • Mario
      • Bowser
      • Donkey Kong
      • Link, now sporting his Skyward Sword design
      • Samus, now sporting her Other M design
      • Kirby, now sporting his Return to Dream Land design and a new moveset using more of his Copy Abilities
      • Fox
      • Pikachu
      • Pit, now sporting his Uprising design
      • Ice Climbers (Wii U only)
    • Newcomers
      • Villager
      • Mega Man
      • Wii Fit Trainer (Wii U only)
  • July 2013
    • Olimar / Alph (Wii U only)
  • August 2013
    • Luigi
  • September 2013
    • Peach
    • Tetra
  • October 2013
    • Sonic
  • November 2013
    • Marth
  • December 2013
    • Rosalina & Luma
    • Zelda, now sporting her Link Between Worlds design
  • January 2014
    • King Dedede, now sporting his Return to Dream Land design
    • Lucario
  • February 2014
    • Little Mac & Scizor
    • Diddy Kong
  • April 2014
    • Smash Direct
      • Zero Suit Samus
      • Sheik
      • Yoshi
      • Mewtwo & Greninja
  • May 2014
    • Ike
  • E3 2014
    • Mii Fighters
    • Palutena & Captain Falcon
    • PAC-MAN & Mr. Game & Watch (3DS only)
  • July 2014
    • Lucina, Ganondorf (now sporting his Ocarina of Time design and a new moveset using his sword from Spaceworld 2000 and Phantom Ganon's trident) & Robin (3DS only)
  • August 2014
    • Meta Knight
    • Shulk (Wii U only)
  • September 2014
    • JP launch day (3DS)
  • October 2014
    • US launch day (3DS)
      • Bowser Jr.
      • DeMille (3DS only)
      • Dark Pit (3DS only)
  • November 2014
    • 50-Fact Extravaganza
      • Takamaru
      • All unlockable characters
      • Duck Hunt gameplay on Wii U
      • All 3DS-only characters coming to Wii U in a future update, and vice-versa
      • Rayman (DLC teaser)
    • US launch day (Wii U)
  • December 2014
    • JP launch day (WII U)
  • April 2015
    • Rayman
    • Fighters Pass (7 fighters for $4,99 each, or a pass for all fighters for $29.99)
    • All 3DS-only characters come to Wii U
  • June 2015
    • Ryu
    • Roy
    • Lucas
    • All Wii U-only characters come to 3DS
  • Novmber 2015
    • Cloud
  • March 2016
    • Azura
    • Bayonetta
Base game
64MeleeBrawlfor 3DS / Wii UNewcomersEcho Fighters
  • 1. Mario​
  • 2. Donkey Kong​
  • 3. Link​
  • 4. Samus​
  • 5. Yoshi​
  • 6. Kirby​
  • 7. Fox​
  • 8. Pikachu​
  • 9. Luigi​
  • 10. Bowser​
  • 11. Marth​
  • 12. Mewtwo​
  • 13. King Dedede​
  • 14. Ness​
  • 15. Captain Falcon​
  • 16. Meowth​
  • 17. Peach​
  • 18. Sheik​
  • 19. Zelda​
  • 20. Scizor​
  • 21. Ice Climbers​
  • 22. Wario​
  • 23. Diddy Kong​
  • 24. Ayumi Tachibana​
  • 25. Ganondorf​
  • 26. Falco​
  • 27. Roy​
  • 28. Mr. Game & Watch​
  • 29. Meta Knight​
  • 30. Pit​
  • 31. Zero Suit Samus​
  • 32. Snake​
  • 33. Ike​
  • 34-36. Pokémon Trainer​
    • Totodile​
    • Grovyle​
    • Charizard​
  • 37. Lucas​
  • 38. Sonic​
  • 39. Olimar​
  • 40. Lucario​
  • 41. DeMille​
  • 42. R.O.B.​
  • 43. Tetra​
  • 44. Wolf​
  • 45. Villager​
  • 46. Mega Man​
  • 47. Wii Fit Trainer​
  • 48. Rosalina & Luma​
  • 49. Little Mac​
  • 50. Greninja​
  • 51-53. Mii Fighters​
    • Brawler​
    • Swordfighter​
    • Gunner​
  • 54. Palutena​
  • 55. PAC-MAN​
  • 56. Robin​
  • 57. Shulk​
  • 58. Bowser Jr.​
  • 59. Takamaru​
  • 60. Duck Hunt​
  • 61. Rayman​
  • 62. Ryu​
  • 63. Cloud​
  • 64. Azura​
  • 65. Bayonetta​
  • 66. Inkling​
  • 67. Simon​
  • 68. Alucard​
  • 69. Ridley​
  • 70. King K. Rool​
  • 71-72. Pyra / Mythra​
  • 73. Bandana Waddle Dee​
  • 74. Incineroar​
  • 75. Waluigi​
  • 4ε. Dark Samus​
  • 10ε. Dry Bowser​
  • 11ε. Lucina​
  • 15ε. Black Shadow​
  • 17ε. Daisy​
  • 23ε. Dixie Kong​
  • 27ε. Chrom​
  • 30ε. Dark Pit​
  • 38ε. Shadow​
  • 39ε. Alph​
  • 49ε. Glass Joe​
  • 56ε. Celica​
  • 62ε. Ken​

Fighters Pass
Vol. 1Vol. 2
  • 76. Joker
  • 77. Slime
  • 78. Crash
  • 79. Estelle Bright
  • 80. Terry Bogard
  • 81. Banjo & Kazooie
  • 82. Min Min
  • 83. Dr. Eggman
  • 84. Sephiroth
  • 85. Steve
  • 86. Kazuya
  • 87. Sora

Timeline of reveals
  • March 2018
    • Teaser trailer
    • Inkling
  • E3 2018
    • Everyone is Here!
      • Dry Bowser
      • Black Shadow
      • Daisy
      • Dixie Kong
      • Chrom
      • Shadow
      • Alph
      • Glass Joe
    • Simon & Alucard
  • EVO 2018
    • Ridley
    • Dark Samus & Celica
    • King K. Rool
  • September 2018 Direct
    • Pyra / Mythra
  • December 2018
    • Arcade version is released
  • February 2019 Direct
    • Bandana Waddle Dee
  • E3 2019
    • Ken & Incineroar
    • Waluigi
  • September 2019 Direct
    • Adventure Mode: World of Light
  • December 2019
    • TGA: Joker (teaser)
    • Console version is released
  • March 2020 Mini-Direct
    • Joker (releasing April 2020)
  • April 2020
    • Mr. Sakurai Presents Joker
  • July 2020 Mini-Direct
    • Slime (releasing shortly after the Direct)
    • Mr. Sakurai Presents Slime
    • Crash Bandicoot (releasing October 2020)
  • October 2020
    • Mr. Sakurai Presents Crash Bandicoot
    • Mini-Direct: Estelle Bright (releasing December 2020)
  • December 2020
    • TGA: Terry Bogard (teaser)
    • Mr. Sakurai Presents Estelle Bright
  • February 2021
    • Terry Bogard (releasing March 2021)
  • March 2021
    • Mr. Sakurai Presents Terry Bogard
  • E3 2021
    • Banjo & Kazooie (releasing shortly after)
    • Mr. Sakurai Presents Banjo & Kazooie
  • September 2021 Direct
    • Min Min (releasing shortly after)
    • Mr. Sakurai Presents Min Min
  • TGA 2021
    • Dr. Eggman (releasing shortly after)
    • Mr. Sakurai Presents Dr. Eggman
  • February 2022 Direct
    • Sephiroth (releasing shortly after)
    • Mr. Sakurai Presents Sephiroth
  • June 2022 Mini-Direct
    • Steve (releasing shortly after)
    • Mr. Sakurai Presents Steve
  • September 2022 Direct
    • Kazuya Mishima (releasing shortly after)
    • Mr. Sakurai Presents Kazuya
  • December 2022
    • TGA: Sora (releasing shortly after)
    • Mr. Sakurai Presents Sora
Decided to do this visually using Roster Maker (I tried to do one with Ultimate but it was too big).
64 roster redo.png
Melee roster redo.png
Brawl roster redo.png
3DS roster redo.png
Wii U roster redo.png
Sm4sh DLC redo.png

Mark my words, however; "Everyone is Here" would still happen for Ultimate, and these would be the newcomers:

  • Dark Samus
  • Dry Bowser
  • Black Shadow
  • Daisy
  • Dixie Kong
  • Chrom
  • Shadow the Hedgeog
  • Glass Joe
  • Celica
  • Ken
  • Simon Belmont
  • Alucard
  • Ridley
  • King K. Rool
  • Pyra / Mythra
  • Bandana Waddle Dee
  • Incineroar
  • Waluigi
  • Vol. 1
    • Joker
    • Slime
    • Crash Bandicoot
    • Estelle Bright
    • Terry Bogard
    • Banjo & Kazooie
  • Vol. 2
    • Chun-Li
    • Dr. Eggman
    • Sephiroth
    • Steve
    • Kazuya Mishima
    • Sora
 

Oracle Link

Smash Master
Joined
Oct 9, 2020
Messages
3,743
Location
Germany
Okay so ...
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
Octorok
and Links awekning link!
 
D

Deleted member

Guest
Mario
Luigi
Bowser
Donkey Kong
Link
Zelda
Ganondorf
Pikachu
Mewtwo
Kirby
Dedede
Marth
Samus
Ness
Captain Falcon
Mario
Luigi
Peach
Daisy
Bowser
Bowser Jr.
Donkey Kong
Diddy Kong
Link
Zelda
Ganondorf
Tingle
Pokémon Trainer Red
Pikachu
Mewtwo
Azumarril
Kirby
Dedede
Meta Knight
Marth
Roy
Samus
Ridley
Ness
Banjo-Kazooie
James Bond
Joanna Dark
All the ones from Melee
Wario
K.Rool
Pit
Palutena
Deoxys
Lucario
Rundas
Solid Snake
Bomberman
Simon Belmont
Alucard
Sonic
Dr.Eggman
Geno
Cloud Strife
Isaac Clarke
Mega Man
Pac-Man
Sora
Lucas
Miis
Optimus Prime
Jotaro
all the ones from Brawl and Melee
Waluigi
Duck Hunt Dog
Mach Rider
Wii Fit Trainer
Olimar/Alph
Chrom
Lucina
Robin
Black Shadow
Sephiroth
Greninja
Giovanni
Luke Skywalker/Darth Vader (not sure which one to choose)
Indiana Jones
Kenshiro
Saitama
All the past ones
Guybrush Threepwood
Pauline
Joker from Persona 5
Dragon Quest Heroes
Dragonlord
Alex Kidd
Rundas from Metroid Prime 3
Doomguy
Jonesy
Inkling
Min Min
Steve/Alex
Terry Bogard
Marco from Metal Slug
Kazuya
Fantastic Four
Doctor Doom
Megatron
Superman
Goku


 
Last edited by a moderator:

jamesster445

Smash Lord
Joined
May 7, 2015
Messages
1,160
If Smash 6 has to be some sort of soft reboot here's my biased roster.
  • I limited the roster to about 60, roughly the same amount as Smash 4's final roster.
  • Hot take(?) but I think most of the Smash roster hold up well. Every character is getting some touch ups to an extent. Really everyone should just get a 5th special, a Shield Special specifically. But my focus is adding new faces.
  • Every previously repped series gets to keep at least one character, but no more than 4. (There are 2 exceptions and they are exactly who you think they are)
  • I cut all 3rd parties, this reboot is going back to its roots as a celebration of Nintendo. We can add them back in Smash 7.
  • Subject to change the minute Monolithsoft reveals their new IP.


Alt

  • Mario
  • Luigi
  • Peach
  • Daisy
  • Bowser
  • DK
  • Diddy
  • K Rool
  • Link
  • Zelda
  • Ganondorf
  • Shiek/Impa
  • Samus
  • Ridley
  • Yoshi
  • Kirby
  • Meta-Knight
  • King Dedede
  • Fox
  • Falco
  • Wolf
  • Pikachu
  • Lucario
  • PKMN Trainer (Squirtle, Ivysaur, Charizard)
  • Incineroar
  • Ness
  • Lucas
  • Captain Falcon
  • Ice Climbers
  • Marth
  • Ike
  • Robin
  • G&W
  • Pit
  • Palutena
  • Wario
  • Olimar
  • ROB
  • Villager
  • Isabelle
  • Wii Fit Trainer
  • Lil Mac
  • Shulk
  • Pyra/Mythra
  • Duck Hunt
  • Inkling
  • Min Min
  • Waluigi
  • Dixie Kong
  • EMMI
  • Bandana Dee
  • Meowscarada
  • Alear
  • Noah and Mio
  • Octoling
  • Officer Howard
  • Ring Fit Trainee
  • Andy
  • Euden
  • Foreman Spike
 
Last edited:

Perkilator

Smash Legend
Writing Team
Joined
Apr 8, 2018
Messages
11,254
Location
The perpetual trash fire known as Planet Earth(tm)
Here’s take #2837565
(Italics bold denotes unlockable characters)
Mario​
Donkey Kong​
Link​
Samus​
Yoshi​
Kirby​
Fox​
Pikachu​
Luigi
Bowser
Marth
Mewtwo
King Dedede
Ness
Captain Falcon
Meowth
Luigi
Wario
Mario​
Donkey Kong​
Link​
Samus​
Yoshi​
Ganondorf
King Dedede
Falco
Meowth
Kirby​
Fox​
Pikachu​
Ness​
Captain Falcon​
Mewtwo
Mr. Game & Watch
Marth
Bowser​
Peach​
Zelda / Sheik​
Scizor​
Ice Climbers​
Roy
Mario​
Donkey Kong​
Link​
Samus / Zero Suit Samus​
Kirby​
Fox​
Pikachu​
Marth
Captain Falcon
Snake​
Luigi
Diddy Kong​
Zelda / Sheik​
Pit​
King Dedede​
Falco
Meowth
Ike​
Isaac
Sonic​
Bowser​
Yoshi​
Ganondorf
Ice Climbers​
Meta Knight​
Wolf
Mewtwo
Ness
DeMille
RANDOM ONE​
Peach​
Wario​
Tetra
Mr. Game & Watch
Olimar​
Pokémon Trainer (Totodile / Grovyle / Charizard)​
Lucario
Lucas​
R.O.B.
RANDOM ALL​
Mario​
Luigi​
Bowser​
Bowser Jr.
Peach​
Rosalina & Luma​
Wario
Yoshi​
Donkey Kong​
Diddy Kong​
Link​
Zelda​
Sheik​
Ganondorf
Tetra​
Ghirahim​
Samus​
Zero Suit Samus​
Kirby​
King Dedede​
Meta Knight​
Bandana Waddle Dee​
Fox​
Falco
Pikachu​
Charizard​
Meowth
Scizor
Lucario​
Greninja​
Marth​
Ike​
Robin​
Ness
Captain Falcon​
Mr. Game & Watch
Pit​
Dark Pit
Palutena​
Olimar​
Isaac​
DeMille
R.O.B.
Villager​
Wii Fit Trainer​
Little Mac​
Shulk​
Sonic​
Mega Man​
PAC-MAN​
Mii Fighter​
RANDOM​
Mewtwo​
Rayman​
Roy​
Lucas​
Ryu​
Cloud​
Takamaru​
Bayonetta​
Duck Hunt​
64MeleeBrawlfor 3DS / Wii UNewcomers
  • 1. Mario
  • 2. Donkey Kong
  • 3. Link
  • 4. Samus
    • 4ε. Dark Samus
  • 5. Yoshi
  • 6. Kirby
  • 7. Fox
  • 8. Pikachu
  • 9. Luigi
  • 10. Bowser
  • 11. Marth
  • 12. Mewtwo
  • 13. King Dedede
  • 14. Ness
  • 15. Captain Falcon
  • 16. Meowth
  • 17. Peach
    • 17ε. Daisy
  • 18. Zelda
  • 19. Sheik
    • 19ε. Yiga
  • 20. Scizor
  • 21. Ice Climbers
  • 22. Wario
  • 23. Ganondorf
  • 24. Falco
  • 25. Roy
    • 25ε. Chrom
  • 26. Mr. Game & Watch
  • 27. Meta Knight
  • 28. Pit
    • 28ε. Dark Pit
  • 29. Zero Suit Samus
  • 30. Olimar
    • 30ε. Alph
  • 31. Snake
  • 32. Ike
  • Pokémon Trainer
    • 33. Totodile
    • 34. Grovyle
    • 35. Charizard
  • 36. Diddy Kong
    • 36ε. Dixie Kong
  • 37. Lucas
  • 38. Sonic
  • 39. Tetra
  • 40. Wolf
  • 41. Lucario
  • 42. Isaac
  • 43. DeMille
  • 44. R.O.B.
  • 45. Villager
  • 46. Mega Man
  • 47. Wii Fit Trainer
  • 48. Rosalina & Luma
  • 49. Bandana Waddle Dee
  • 50. Little Mac
  • 51. Ghirahim
  • 52. Greninja
  • 53. Mii Fighter
  • 54. Palutena
  • 55. PAC-MAN
  • 56. Robin
  • 57. Shulk
  • 58. Bowser Jr.
  • 59. Rayman
  • 60. Ryu
    • 60ε. Ken
  • 61. Cloud
  • 62. Takamaru
  • 63. Bayonetta
  • 64. Duck Hunt
  • 65. Inkling
  • 66. Simon
    • 66ε. Richter
  • 67. Ridley
  • 68. King K. Rool
  • 69. Incineroar
  • 70. Waluigi
  • 71-72. Pyra / Mythra
  • 73. Magolor
  • 74. Min Min
    • 74ε. Ninjara
  • 75. Banjo & Kazooie
Vol. 1Vol. 2
  • 76. Joker
  • 77. Hero
  • 78. Crash Bandicoot
  • 79. Estelle Bright
  • Team NEO GEO
    • 80. Terry Bogard
    • 81. Iori Yagami
    • 82. Nakoruru
  • 83. Steve
  • 84. Chun-Li
  • 85. Dr. Eggman
  • 86. Sephiroth
  • 87. Ring Fit Trainee
  • 88. Shantae
  • 89. Kazuya Mishima
  • 90. Sora
 
Last edited:

Perkilator

Smash Legend
Writing Team
Joined
Apr 8, 2018
Messages
11,254
Location
The perpetual trash fire known as Planet Earth(tm)
Here’s take #2837565

Mario​
Donkey Kong​
Link​
Samus​
Yoshi​
Kirby​
Fox​
Pikachu​
Luigi
Bowser
Marth
Mewtwo
King Dedede
Ness
Captain Falcon
Meowth
Luigi
Wario
Mario​
Donkey Kong​
Link​
Samus​
Yoshi​
Ganondorf
King Dedede
Falco
Meowth
Kirby​
Fox​
Pikachu​
Ness​
Captain Falcon​
Mewtwo
Mr. Game & Watch
Marth
Bowser​
Peach​
Zelda / Sheik​
Scizor​
Ice Climbers​
Roy
Mario​
Donkey Kong​
Link​
Samus / Zero Suit Samus​
Kirby​
Fox​
Pikachu​
Marth
Captain Falcon
Snake​
Luigi
Diddy Kong​
Zelda / Sheik​
Pit​
King Dedede​
Falco
Meowth
Ike​
Isaac
Sonic​
Bowser​
Yoshi​
Ganondorf
Ice Climbers​
Meta Knight​
Wolf
Mewtwo
Ness
DeMille
RANDOM ONE​
Peach​
Wario​
Tetra
Mr. Game & Watch
Olimar​
Pokémon Trainer (Totodile / Grovyle / Charizard)​
Lucario
Lucas​
R.O.B.
RANDOM ALL​
Mario​
Luigi​
Bowser​
Bowser Jr.
Peach​
Rosalina & Luma​
Wario
Yoshi​
Donkey Kong​
Diddy Kong​
Link​
Zelda​
Sheik​
Ganondorf
Tetra​
Ghirahim​
Samus​
Zero Suit Samus​
Kirby​
King Dedede​
Meta Knight​
Bandana Waddle Dee​
Fox​
Falco
Pikachu​
Charizard​
Meowth
Scizor
Lucario​
Greninja​
Marth​
Ike​
Robin​
Ness
Captain Falcon​
Mr. Game & Watch
Pit​
Dark Pit
Palutena​
Olimar​
Isaac​
DeMille
R.O.B.
Villager​
Wii Fit Trainer​
Little Mac​
Shulk​
Sonic​
Mega Man​
PAC-MAN​
Mii Fighter​
RANDOM​
Mewtwo​
Rayman​
Roy​
Lucas​
Ryu​
Cloud​
Takamaru​
Bayonetta​
Duck Hunt​
64MeleeBrawlfor 3DS / Wii UNewcomers
  • 1. Mario
  • 2. Donkey Kong
  • 3. Link
  • 4. Samus
    • 4ε. Dark Samus
  • 5. Yoshi
  • 6. Kirby
  • 7. Fox
  • 8. Pikachu
  • 9. Luigi
  • 10. Bowser
  • 11. Marth
  • 12. Mewtwo
  • 13. King Dedede
  • 14. Ness
  • 15. Captain Falcon
  • 16. Meowth
  • 17. Peach
    • 17ε. Daisy
  • 18. Zelda
  • 19. Sheik
    • 19ε. Yiga
  • 20. Scizor
  • 21. Ice Climbers
  • 22. Wario
  • 23. Ganondorf
  • 24. Falco
  • 25. Roy
    • 25ε. Chrom
  • 26. Mr. Game & Watch
  • 27. Meta Knight
  • 28. Pit
    • 28ε. Dark Pit
  • 29. Zero Suit Samus
  • 30. Olimar
    • 30ε. Alph
  • 31. Snake
  • 32. Ike
  • Pokémon Trainer
    • 33. Totodile
    • 34. Grovyle
    • 35. Charizard
  • 36. Diddy Kong
    • 36ε. Dixie Kong
  • 37. Lucas
  • 38. Sonic
  • 39. Tetra
  • 40. Wolf
  • 41. Lucario
  • 42. Isaac
  • 43. DeMille
  • 44. R.O.B.
  • 45. Villager
  • 46. Mega Man
  • 47. Wii Fit Trainer
  • 48. Rosalina & Luma
  • 49. Bandana Waddle Dee
  • 50. Little Mac
  • 51. Ghirahim
  • 52. Greninja
  • 53. Mii Fighter
  • 54. Palutena
  • 55. PAC-MAN
  • 56. Robin
  • 57. Shulk
  • 58. Bowser Jr.
  • 59. Rayman
  • 60. Ryu
    • 60ε. Ken
  • 61. Cloud
  • 62. Takamaru
  • 63. Bayonetta
  • 64. Duck Hunt
  • 65. Inkling
  • 66. Simon
    • 66ε. Richter
  • 67. Ridley
  • 68. King K. Rool
  • 69. Incineroar
  • 70. Waluigi
  • 71-72. Pyra / Mythra
  • 73. Magolor
  • 74. Min Min
    • 74ε. Ninjara
  • 75. Banjo & Kazooie
Vol. 1Vol. 2
  • 76. Joker
  • 77. Hero
  • 78. Crash Bandicoot
  • 79. Estelle Bright
  • Team NEO GEO
    • 80. Terry Bogard
    • 81. Iori Yagami
    • 82. Nakoruru
  • 83. Steve
  • 84. Chun-Li
  • 85. Dr. Eggman
  • 86. Sephiroth
  • 87. Ring Fit Trainee
  • 88. Shantae
  • 89. Kazuya Mishima
  • 90. Sora
Changed it again if anyone cares.
 

TheLastMaverickHunter

Smash Journeyman
Joined
Apr 23, 2023
Messages
310
Location
Existent
Feel free to dunk on me for this

64
Keep: :mario64::luigi64::dk64::link64::samus64::yoshi64::kirby64::fox64::pikachu64::ness64::falcon64:
Cut: :jigglypuff64: for :warioc:

Melee
Keep: :peachmelee::bowsermelee::zeldamelee::falcomelee::mewtwomelee::marthmelee::roymelee::icsmelee::gawmelee:
Cut: :drmario: for :ultdaisy:, :sheikmelee: for :dedede:, :younglinkmelee: for Hero of Legend, :pichumelee: for :183:

Brawl
Keep: :diddy::metaknight::wolf::charizard::lucario::ike::pit::olimar::rob::snake::sonic:
Cut: :toonlink: for Tetra, :zerosuitsamus: for Knuckles, :squirtle: for :052:, :ivysaur: for Zero, :lucas:for :ultdarksamus:, :wario: for :ultkrool:
Since :dedede: got in early, his newcomer slot is used to declone :ganondorf: (his old moveset is inherited by Black Shadow)

For
Keep: :4bowserjr::4darkpit::4villager::4littlemac::4shulk::4duckhunt::4megaman::4pacman::4ryu::4cloud:
Cut: :rosalina: for Toad, :4greninja: for N & Zoroark, :4robinm: for Groose, :4lucina: for Lyn, :4corrin: for Sceptile, :4palutena: for Travis Touchdown, :4wiifit: for Bandana Dee, :4mii: for Matt/Wii Sports Mii, :4bayonetta: for Rayman

Ultimate
Keep: :ultridley::ultinkling::ultsimon::ultrichter:
Cut: :ultincineroar: for , :ultisabelle: for Tom Nook, :ultchrom: for Galacta Knight, :ultken: for Dixie Kong
Also add: Midbus, Paper Mario and Henry Cooldown since :ultdaisy::ultkrool::ultdarksamus: are already in

Fighters Passes
Keep: :ultbanjokazooie::ult_terry::ultsteve::ultsephiroth::ultsora:
Cut: :ultpiranha: for Anthony Higgs, :ultjoker: for Raiden, :ulthero: for Slime, :ultbyleth: for CJ (San Andreas), :ultminmin for Marina Liteyears, :ultpyra: for Skull Kid, :ultmythra: for Shadow,:ultkazuya: for Sol Badguy
Add (since FP3 is allowed): Isaac, Bill Rizer, Dante, Crash Bandicoot, Waluigi
 
Last edited:

nirvanafan

Smash Champion
Premium
Joined
Oct 14, 2016
Messages
2,729
EDIT - 3/7/23, cleaned up with roster maker

EDIT - 5/24/23, added direct links to roster images since imgur images arent showing on the post.

Red = Unlockable
Luigi & Gooey are echoes

https://imgur.io/wPetsuJ?r

Red = Unlockables
Mach Rider has an Excitebiker skin
Foreman Spike, Wolf, Black Shadow, Mach Rider, Pichu, & Celica join Luigi & Gooey as Echoes
Slippy & ROB 64 are like Ice Climbers
Goron & Zora Link are like Zelda/Sheik

https://imgur.io/nBfVH08?r

Rare buyout did not happen till a couple months after Melee hit its finally territory. HM to Conker who was excluded since bad fur day probably released too close to Melee to be included.

Red = Unlockable
Green = Replacement for cut Rare Chatacters
Mii Team is like a tag team Pokemon Trainer
No new echoes
Sonic & Crash are unlockable but revealed before launch like 3rd parties were in Brawl.

https://imgur.io/Gv17ASl

Red = Unlockable in both versions
Yellow = Unlockable in 3DS version only
Everyone listed after random icon is DLC.

Slippy & ROB 64 & Mii Team are either reworked or exclusive to the Wii U edition. I dont agree woth completely scrapping a fighter due to 3DS limitations.

No new echoes in base roster (although they are split off in there own row now) but the top row of DLC are all echoes instead of adding veterans since all are here except Rare.

https://i.imgur.io/TROlcmz.jpg

Everyone is here (Rare is back)
Everyone after Tora is DLC except the Miis

Starting roster is :ultmario: :ultlink: :ultpikachu: :ultkirby: :ultfox: :ultmarth::ultsamus: & DJ KK

New Echoes are Veronica, Dark Samus, Tails, Coco, Hocotate President, & Octoling

Kasumi Alpha / Alpha 152 are like Pyra / Mythra
Rash & Billy Lee (with Pimple & Jimmy Lee Alt) are another duo fighter like Ice Climbers or Slippy & ROB 64

Tora & Lora are the main Xenoblade reps, Poppi, Jin, & Haze will be in background like Pokemon Trainer and occasionally interact with special attacks, taunts, etc.

https://i.imgur.io/YuIzzrk.jpg
Thought of some changes to my rosters.

Black Knight replaces Micaiah
Decided that were a magic based moveset is cool we did add Zelda in the same game plus Black Knight is just a good opportunity to add an iconic villain from the series.

Robin replaces Tiki
With Micaiah gone it would make sense to add Robin with the mage moveset Micaiah would have had.

Byleth Almost Replaced
Before adding Black Knight i did consider adding Flame Emperor over Byleth but that no longer seems necessary.

Twelve replaces Ruby Heart
I added Ruby Heart since i want someone to rep all Capcom fighting games. I thought of a better idea being Twelve from SF3. Were they have not appeared in a Capcom Vs. game they can canonically shape shift & mimic other fighters. Taking some creative liberties we can have them do this for different characters/moves from various Capcom fighters & series like the Ditto concept i also had. This would represent what i am going for better imo.

Dante replaces Monika
Dante overall replaces Monika. I still want Monika in Smash but realized she may not be as impactiful here with visual novels already being here through Ayumi. I dont think a dedicated horror or indie rep is enough given the potential humble origins or horror elements other series already here may have. Dante is admittedly a stretch for me since ive only played the mediocre at best DMC2 but from what ive seen of other series games & the character himself i am very optimistic he will become a favorite, plus at the very least the series was a pioneer & influenced other games i do really like. Also getting the Dante people wanted over PS Allstars would be great to see the reaction of.

Kiryu replaces Majima
Majima is still my favorite character & I have always liked Kiryu but after playing Kiwami 2 & most of 3 i feel lime ive grown to like Kiryu even more & feel a little weird putting Majima over him. I would also swap his timing with one of the Capcom reps delaying him to an Ultimate Fighter Pass which makes more sense as it would match closer to the franchises explosion in popularity outside Japan (after the international release of 0). Where i have taken risks on the potential of 1st party series, 3rd party is another ballgame & would be weird to have too niche of series considering all other options.

Giga Mac replaces King Hippo (DK Echo)
The moves work either way imo but Giga Macs general stance would be closer to DK plus it kind of gives us the series protag.

Krystal replaces Veronica
Veronica cant be a Micaiah echo if Micaiah missed the roster to begin with. Slippy & ROB 64 are our Ice Climbers like rep but make it in 3DS with ROB 64 now being a floating head working like a mix of Nana & Luma. Decided to not let that concept die & use Krystal as a Slippy echo to keep that playstyle in Ultimate with this new spot (something i almost did initially anyway)

Alph replaces President
This is something ive been back & forth on anyway (with Louie also in the mix).

Hestu replaces Skull Kid
As much as I like Skull Kid the timing (around BotW) always fealt off. Combine that with Goron & Zora Link already repping Majoras Mask & i decided to shop around. Think Hestu would be an interesting choice with the large roll Koroks had in BotW, ties to the iconic Great Deku Tree, & standout design & moveset potential.

Dingodile/Ayane replace Coco/Kasumi Alphas

This was honestly influenced by a post WarioWarioWario made. I always pictured a Coco echo or Cortex to get in after Crash. I do now think Dingodile could be the best 2nd choice. Hes popular, timing is good (around Crash 4), & has fun moveset potential. He isnt the most expected new series fighter but makes a lot of sense making him a great choice imo.

Decided to swap with Ninja Gaiden/Dead or Alive with Ayane being added as a Hayabusa echo with Crash series now getting the 2nd unique fighter from a 3rd party series role.

The Sim replaces Farmer (SoS/HM)
I like both series. IDK, Sims wasnt really on my radar before but do like the idea & is seemingly a much bigger series. We already have EA in with Mass Effect plus i feel like both these fighters would appeal to a similar audience anyway.

Melia replaces Lora
Honestly forgot Xenoblade DE was out as earlier as it was so a rep here could make more sense than a Torna Expansion character. Melia makes sense with Future Connected being a big selling point for DE plus I think she would stand out & be more unique than Shulk (or Lora for that matter)
 
Last edited:

Perkilator

Smash Legend
Writing Team
Joined
Apr 8, 2018
Messages
11,254
Location
The perpetual trash fire known as Planet Earth(tm)
In the spirit of me changing my mind all the time:
Luigi
Mario​
Donkey Kong​
Link​
Samus​
Captain Falcon
Ness
Yoshi​
Kirby​
Fox​
Pikachu​
Jigglypuff
Luigi
Diddy Kong
Mario​
Donkey Kong​
Link​
Samus​
Yoshi​
Ganondorf
King Dedede
Falco
Jigglypuff
Kirby​
Fox​
Pikachu​
Ness​
Captain Falcon​
Meowth
Mewtwo
Marth
Bowser​
Peach​
Zelda / Sheik​
Scizor​
Ice Climbers​
Mr. Game & Watch
Mario​
Donkey Kong​
Link​
Samus / Zero Suit Samus​
Kirby​
Fox​
Pikachu​
Marth
Isaac
Luigi
Diddy Kong​
Zelda / Sheik​
Pit​
King Dedede​
Falco
Pokémon Trainer (Totodile / Grovyle / Charizard)​

Ike​
DeMille
Peach​
Yoshi​
Ganondorf
Ice Climbers​
Meta Knight​
Wolf
Jigglypuff
Ness
Snake​
Bowser​
Wario​
R.O.B.
Mr. Game & Watch
Olimar​
Captain Falcon
Lucario
Lucas​
Sonic​
Mario​
Luigi​
Peach​
Bowser​
Bowser Jr.
Rosalina & Luma​
Donkey Kong​
Diddy Kong​
Yoshi​
Wario
Link​
Zelda​
Sheik​
Ganondorf
Samus​
Zero Suit Samus​
Fox​
Falco
Kirby​
King Dedede​
Meta Knight​
Pikachu​
Charizard​
Meowth
Jigglypuff
Scizor
Lucario​
Greninja​
Ness
Captain Falcon​
Marth​
Ike​
Robin​
Mr. Game & Watch
Pit​
Dark Pit
Palutena​
Olimar​
Isaac
DeMille
R.O.B.
Villager​
Wii Fit Trainer​
Little Mac​
Shulk​
Takamaru
Duck Hunt
Sonic​
Mega Man​
PAC-MAN​
Mii Fighter (Brawler / Swordfighter / Gunner)​
RANDOM​
Bonus FighterWave 1Wave 2Wave 3
Mewtwo​
Lloyd Irving & Rayman​
Ryu & Cloud​
Azura & Bayonetta​
64MeleeBrawlfor 3DS / Wii UNewcomers
  • 1. Mario
  • 2. Donkey Kong
  • 3. Link
  • 4. Samus
    • 4ε. Dark Samus
  • 5. Yoshi
  • 6. Kirby
  • 7. Fox
  • 8. Pikachu
  • 9. Luigi
  • 10. Ness
  • 11. Captain Falcon
  • 12. Jigglypuff
  • 13. Peach
    • 13ε. Daisy
  • 14. Bowser
  • 15. Ice Climbers
  • 16. Sheik
    • 16ε. Yiga
  • 17. Zelda
  • 18. Scizor
  • 19. Diddy Kong
  • 20. Ganondorf
  • 21. King Dedede
  • 22. Falco
  • 23. Meowth
  • 24. Mewtwo
  • 25. Marth
    • 25ε. Celica
  • 26. Mr. Game & Watch
  • 27. Meta Knight
  • 28. Pit
    • 28ε. Dark Pit
  • 29. Zero Suit Samus
  • 30. Wario
  • 31. Snake
  • 32. Ike
  • 33-35. Pokémon Trainer (Totodile / Grovyle / Charizard)
  • 36. Olimar
    • 36ε. Alph
  • 37. Lucas
  • 38. Sonic
  • 39. Wolf
  • 40. Lucario
  • 41. Isaac
  • 42. DeMille
  • 43. R.O.B.
  • 44. Villager
  • 45. Mega Man
    • 45ε. Proto Man
  • 46. Wii Fit Trainer
  • 47. Rosalina & Luma
  • 48. Little Mac
  • 49. Greninja
  • 50-52. Mii Fighter (Brawler / Swordfighter / Gunner)
  • 53. Palutena
  • 54. PAC-MAN
  • 55. Robin
  • 56. Shulk
  • 57. Bowser Jr.
  • 58. Takamaru
  • 59. Duck Hunt
  • 60. Lloyd Irving
  • 61. Rayman
  • 62. Ryu
    • 62ε. Ken
  • 63. Cloud
  • 64. Azura
  • 65. Bayonetta
    • 65ε. Jeanne
  • 66. Inkling
  • 67. Simon
    • 67ε. Richter
  • 68. Ridley
  • 69. King K. Rool
  • 70. Isabelle
  • 71. Incineroar
  • 72. Waluigi
  • 73. Bandana Waddle Dee
  • 74. Skull Kid
  • 75. Banjo & Kazooie
Vol. 1Vol. 2Vol. 3
  • 76. Joker
  • 77. Hero
  • 78. Crash
  • 79. Terry
  • 80. Steve
  • 81. Byleth
  • 82. Ring Fit Trainee
  • 83. Sephiroth
  • 84. Officer Howard
  • 85. Cinderace
  • 86-87. Pyra / Mythra
  • 88. Min Min
  • 89. Kazuya
  • 90. Sora
 
Last edited:

Johnknight1

Upward and Forward, Positive and Persistent
Joined
Feb 25, 2007
Messages
18,979
Location
Livermore, the Bay repping NorCal Smash!
NNID
Johnknight1
3DS FC
3540-0575-1486
Mario
Luigi
Bowser
Peach
Donkey Kong
Diddy Kong
Link
Samus
Kirby
Fox
Pikachu
Mewtwo

Yoshi
Wario
Diddy Kong
Ganondorf
Young Link
Sheik
King Dedede
Meta Knight
Falco
Charizard
Eevee / Eeveelutions
Ness
Captain Falcon
Marth

Toon Link
Beast Ganon
Zero Suit Samus
Ridley
Lucas
Wolf
Blastoise (replaces Squirtle)
Venusaur (replaces Ivysaur)
Deoxys

Lucario
Ike
Little Mac
Villager
Hero
Snake
Mega Man
Sonic
Cloud

King K. Rool
Zoroark
Greninja
Robin
Mr. Game and Watch
Tom Nook
Shulk
Pit
Isaac
Duck Hunt
Big Boss / Naked Snake (Echo Fighter)
Ryu
Ken Masters (Echo Fighter)
Simon Belmont
Minecraft Steve
Kazuya Mishima
Tetris

Banjo & Kazooie
Dante
Sephiroth
Crono

Remain characters: 1
Dixie Kong (Echo Fighter)
Decidueye

Lucina (Echo Fighter)
Olimar
Rex (with Pyra / Mythra)
Akuma (Echo Fighter)
Jin Kazama (Echo Fighter)
Terry Bogard
Wonder Red
Monster Hunter

Cranky Kong / The Original Donkey Kong
Joker
Crash Bandicoot
Chosen Undead (Dark Souls)
The Dragonborn (Skyrim)

Sora

Urshifu
Kazuma Kiryu
The Sims
Scorpion (Mortal Kombat)
Leon Kennedy
Master Chief
Kratos (God of War)

Jigglypuff
Dr. Mario
Zelda
Pichu
Ice Climbers
Roy
Pichu
ROB
Mii Brawler
Mii Gunner
Mii Swordfighter
Palutena
Bowser Jr.
Rosalina
Bayonetta
Inklings
Isabelle
Incineroar
Piranha Plant
Min Min
Chrom (Echo)
Richter (Echo)
Dark Samus (Echo Fighter)
Daisy (Echo)
Dark Pit (Echo)

Yes my list is OUT THEREEEEE and I don't care lol. Glad we got what we got though.
 

nirvanafan

Smash Champion
Premium
Joined
Oct 14, 2016
Messages
2,729
Will come back & edit this post for later games but heres my take for a biased roster that doesnt worry about legal hurdles (although still avoided 4th parties). Is subject to change as i play more games.

:ultluigi::ultmario::ultlink::ultfox::ultbanjokazooie:Axel Stone
Paper BoyCrash BandicootPete / FarmerNightsPai ChanLau Chan
:ultmario::ultluigi::ultlink::ultyounglink::ultfox::ultwolf::ultbanjokazooie:Joanna DarkElvis
:ultsonic:TailsNightsPai ChanLau ChanAxel StoneBeatRobo & MoboNightmare
/Siegfried
Crash BanicootFake CrashPete / FarmerSara / FarmerPaper BoyRuby HeartEdward Falcon
:ultmario::ultlink:/
Wolf Link*
:ultvillager:Master ChiefCrash Bandicoot:ultsonic:Pai ChanEdward FalconNightmare
/Siegfried
:ultluigi::ulttoonlink::ultolimar::ultbanjokazooie:Axel SteelTailsLau ChanAda WongPrince of All Cosmos
:ultwario::ultike:Ryu HayabusaJoanna DarkPaper BoyNightsBeatThe SimCJ
:ultfox::ultkirby:Pete the FarmerConkerRampage*Axel StoneRobo & MoboZoey PayneRandom
Notes
  • :ultlink: & Wolf Link work like :ultsamus: & :ultzss: did in Brawl
  • Similarly Rampage works like :ultpokemontrainer: with you swapping between all 3 main monsters (George, Lizzie, & Ralph)

Cuts
  • :ultyounglink:
  • :ultwolf:
  • Elvis
  • Fake Crash
  • Sara the Farmer
  • Ruby Heart
:ultmario::ultluigi::ultwario::ultyoshi::ultlink:Wolf Link:ultfox::ultrobin:
:ultkirby::ultvillager::ultolimar::ultbanjokazooie:Joanna DarkConkerMaster Chief
:ultsonic:TailsNightsPai ChanLau ChanAxel StoneBeatKiryu Kazuma:ultbayonetta1:
Crash BandicootAxel SteelPaper BoyGeorge (Solo Rampage)NightmareSiegfriedPrince of All CosmosDevil JinPete the Farmer
Edward FalconAda WongDanteThe SimZoey PayneCommander ShepherdRyu HayabusaZack (DoA)Frogger
DLCRuby HeartFulgoreRaiden (MG)

Cuts
  • :ulttoonlink:
  • :ultike:
  • Robo & Mobo
  • Lizzie
  • Ralph
  • CJ
 
Last edited:

Swaggod7

Smash Rookie
Joined
Aug 27, 2024
Messages
10
Slippi.gg
SWAG#494
Note: Method of unlock is in Brackets, if no brackets are there, they are in the starting roster
64: Replace :jigglypuff64: with :mewtwomelee: and add :bowsermelee:
Melee: Replace :drmario: with Paper Mario, add :warioc: as an unlockable (play adventure with :mariomelee: in under 20 minutes). SEGA allowed :sonic: to be put into the game (have a hi score of 20 in cruel melee like the rumours said).

Brawl: :drmario: debuted here (complete first 10 events) along with :jigglypuff64:, add :4megaman: (Complete 3 Beast carnage event) Remove :pt:

Sm4sh: Add :strongbad: (Complete All Star: Regulars) and Boshi (Complete King/ Battle of the Yoshis)

Ultimate: Add Shadow as an echo to sonic (Play classic as sonic). The DLC is the same
 

DreamyMystX64

Smash Cadet
Premium
Joined
Nov 6, 2021
Messages
45
A possible Smash reboot game roster with an entirely fresh roster (70% first parties + 30% third parties).


Mario:
Mario
Luigi
Peach
Daisy
Spike
Bowser

Mario Spin-offs:
Yoshi
Wario

Donkey Kong:
Donkey Kong
Diddy Kong

Zelda:
Link
Zelda
Ganondorf

Metroid:
Samus
Ridley

Kirby:
Kirby
King Dedede
Waddle Dee
Meta Knight

Star Fox:
Fox

Pokémon:
Pikachu
Eevee

F-Zero:
Captain Falcon

Fire Emblem:
Alear (w/previous FE characters as “Emblems”)
Veyle

Kid Icarus:
Pit

Pikmin:
Lisa (that’s the Pikmin 4 protagonist’s default name)

Animal Crossing:
Isabelle
Tom Nook

Splatoon:
Inkling
Octoling

Famicom Detective Club:
Ayumi

Murasame Castle:
Takamaru

New Nintendo IP

Others:

Mii (Brawler)

Third Parties:
SEGA:
Sonic, Bayonetta
Capcom: Mega Man, Ryu
Namco: Pac-Man, Kazuya, Lloyd
Square: Cloud, Sora
Konami: Bomberman
SNK: Terry
Microsoft: Steve
Ubisoft: Rayman
Activision: Crash
Indies: Shovel Knight
 
Last edited:

SharkLord

Smash Hero
Joined
Jun 20, 2020
Messages
7,546
Location
Pangaea, 250 MYA
I already posted this in the main thread, but it's a slow day and a rather inactive period on the 'boards, so I might as well repost it here
HyperSmashBrosEX.png

I had previously set up an experimental Switch-centric roster, then went back and slowly added more veterans and long-standing old requests, then went and streamlined that concept down further. Here's my personal ideal roster for a late Switch/early Switch 2 Smash game. A hard limit of 60 full fighters, plus ten Echo fighters. Not counting Mario and his countless spinoff series, every represented series was paired down to only four characters max, plus Echo fighters. The roster's meant to be mostly first-party centric, but I still wanted to preserve some degree of third-party presence.

Also of note is that Echo Fighters are meant to have a bit more freedom in their movesets, but are still using the same general framework and mvoeset as their bases. Also, Zelda's meant to be based on Echoes of Wisdom, but there wasn't a non-chibi design to use, and tiny toy Zelda would stick out like a sore thumb. Marina has Pearl assisting her throughout her moveset, so you don't have to ask where Pearl is. And I needed exactly ten Echoes or the roster wouldn't be a perfect rectangle, so I threw in Sylux and Blood Falcon.

Also I genuinely forgot the Miis so let's just pretend there's a detailed character creator off-screen that includes the Miis
 
Top Bottom