i own Rudy. It's pretty good. Along with my elite other 350+ movies (Ask Aesir and Spawn for evidence...)
Also-That tier list is pretty accurate except I really think ROB is much more broken than DDD, GAW, and Falco. Rob is like the Melee Peach. (You have to KILL him to Kill him) Robs nair and bair are extremely broken (dont even bother SGing either attack), hes probably one of the hardest characters to approach, hes camps EXTREMELY well, he reflects projectiles, he has supported DI with his bair, he has one of the best recoveries, he has a strong spike, an angled Fsmash, one of the quickest attacks in the game, (his dsmash) is EXCELLENT out of shield, and has plenty of solid kill moves.
GAW is excellent against ROB but he has more struggling matchupss than ROB does in my opinion.
Other than that, the list is pretty accurate.
PS-Marths Fsmash is BROOKKEEENNN in Melee