Present a
good argument and I will.
I would like to clear up one thing about the Ridley comment that I forgot to add. Mainly, it can be described by this (poorly spelled) comment.
Dude.. I'm using a ridley skin over Chirzard, and I re-sized him myself, and it looks perfect, so i duno what ur talking about
This one also brings up the re-sizing, especially the melee intro
He has already been downsized in Smash Bros. before (along with many, many other characters). Look at the Melee intro.
Let's look at the melee intro, especially when he is against Samus.
Wings out, he looks a tiny bit larger than Charizard in this picture, give or take a bit. What is the difference between Charizard and a resized Ridley? Removed fire effects? Sound effects? I found this on brawl vault, and it looks like what you guys are talking about. (
http://forums.kc-mm.com/Gallery/BrawlView.php?Number=12295]Link[/url]) If you resize Ridley down to a reasonable size, he becomes the same as Charizard. Give him a size more like his games, and he becomes what he is in the SSE (a really cool boss battle).
Bowser is just too big for Smash.
Olimar is much too small for Smash, they could never add him in.
Waitaminute.
Bowser has been much smaller in many of his titles. Paper Mario (before he grows in size as one of his attacks), every mario kart game, most if not all of the Mario Sports games, and Mario RPG have him smaller. Heck, in the first Super Mario game, Mario and Bowser are almost the same height.
Olimar is irrelevant, as we are talking about larger, non-humanoid characters being downsized to fit, not the flip side. Even though it's confirmed that Olimar is the size of a nickel in his game, he still maintains his relative small size in scale of the rest of the cast.
The debates against my point on Lyn and Goroh are good. I stand by Marth being a good substitute/texture hack seeing we already have Roy added. We might even be able to do sound effects with alternate costumes, so feel free to do it. Also, I agree with red9rd in wanting an Axe/Spear wielding character instead of another swordsman. I don't know enough about F-Zero to understand why Goroh is the best possible choice for a second F-Zero rep. Feel free to inform me.
Dixie is different enough from diddy where she is very possible. the issue is if sakurai decides to add her then the PMBR's hands are tied.
I don't understand the differences between them. It would just seem like an excuse to try out a second version of diddy's moveset. There just doesn't seem to be anything unique about Dixie that translates to a moveset change.
--
I would like to finish by saying I really don't really want more clone engine characters (barring Pichu for the same reasons Roy and Mewtwo are in), and that adding characters for the sake of filling the slots seems like a bad idea on the PMBR's behalf. The remaining characters from melee are outright clones, or would be redundant if added (looking at you, young link). Unless they started adding SSB4 characters (or looked at my personal one-entry wishlist for Smash 4), I can't see my self becoming excited for any new additions.