Currently at page 22.
Feeling Glyph is town.
Pretty Null on Asdioh. J does produce a case on him, but he hasn't pushed it much, yet. His play has been eh.
Don't like PL's lack of interaction with J at all, besides commenting on how the hydra should post. During Glyph/J they just addressed Glyph and in Asdioh/J they just address Asdioh.
Key point, D1 re-read puts Glyph as town.
Glyph/J Exchange
+ Points for Glyph - Didn't leap to J scum immediately like I thought just based on the RVS post. Slowly worked up to J scum based on J's posts
- Points for PL -
http://www.smashboards.com/showpost.php?p=12450916&postcount=261 Suggesting we lynch Glyph because he hasn't re-explained himself, minimal interaction with J, everything directed at Glyph. Don't think they took a stance on J
? For Asdioh -
http://www.smashboards.com/showpost.php?p=12452675&postcount=392 Bunch of well explained neutral stances, unexplained scum stances. Does have J scum though.
Just post this for now.
If the only case against Glyph is based on early D1 then I'm cool with Glyph town.
Again, D1 read on Glyph is town.
@Glyph I remember you explaining why it was scummy for J.
How did you reach the conclusion the KevinM was town though, if you had never played with him?
@X1 Yeah, I think that's a possibility. It would be unlucky and unlikely, but definitely possible. 1/5 or something?
Do indies ever have RB powers?
Admission that the calling J out on being scum was already discussed and dismissed.
Yeah, I see why I had PL as super town in D4. A lot better than every other day imo.
Glyph's lack of anything in D5 is kinda bleh. I appreciate not feeling anyone is scum but I dont know. Doesn't seem to be doing any work to find scum.
Ignoring set up, Out of Asdioh, PL, RR and Glyph. I'd have Asdioh>Glyph>PL>RR in the townie scale.
Asdioh has generally been pretty good. Stupid gut.
Glyph's early play was good. Not doing anything toDay is bleh, but ah well.
PL is the opposite of Glyph. Scummy early on, looks good now.
RR is Null for me.
@RR Is PL the only scumpick you have? Who else is possibly scum, and why?
@Aposl Said it before, but repeating it so it's clearer. Scumpicks?
Glyph. Early play (ie, D1). Town. Also heavily implied that Glyph did nothing of notice during D2, 3, and 4.
There's a theme here Seik, you've called me town after not one read through, but TWO. On multiple occasions, even! But once the lynch is down to me and you, then suddenly you find
pages of reasons I'm scummy? There is literally no way you could have read all of those posts, thought they were perfectly fine the first times through, and THEN went back on the THIRD time and realized "oh wait, this is scum!!!"
Your case is all based on things that have been discussed into the ground as well. My play on D1 was
designed to draw a NK. Make a exceptionally distinct connection to ONE player, and go after it hard. I have already said this in the thread, more than happy to pull it up for you.
As for the PR stuff, I call BS. First off, deceivers almost definitely refers to scum, and even if it DOES apply to indies as well, then having pro-town powers is definitely a bonus.
Oh, and I've got a few points about your case I'd like to address.
Let's clear up a couple of things before we start.
Don't consider Glyph clear, that would be dumb.
For starters, a J bus is entirely within reason. J did not want to play.
Literally no way to conclude this from that post unless you heard it directly from J. I'd wager, in a QT.
If this isn't enough, consider the fact that J faked a posting restriction (which essentially stopped him playing for the day) AND replaced out.
Godfather bussing his scummate on D1 is not unheard of.
I hope you're not implying J did not try to play this game hard, because you'd be a bold-faced liar. In no way did he roll over and give up, or even remotely seem to not care. He worked his *** off to not get lynched.
Oh, and since when would I be the godfather? What evidence is there of that being the remaining scum? I could see you pushing that if I had an innocent on me, but I'm literally investigated.