Bingo Mafia: OVAH! Who won?

[GandhiLaserGun]

"You must post in english" refers to the written language you speak in the thread. Pictures are not written so I don't consider this a breach of the rule. However, words within pictures must be written in English.

"You must not post in code" refers to coded language used to communicate illegal information in the game.

Currently I believe no rules are being broken at this time!

Its pretty clear from Kat's language here that he had to legitimately think out the rules to check whether it was against the rules or not, particularly obvious in the underlined section. Had Kat truly incorporated this restriction into his game somehow, he'd not have to do this

Discuss



/disappears again

 

[Seikend]

Unvote
Vote:J

Nabe being pretty confident that soup is scum but not voting is bleh.

Thought the same GLG but don't want to discuss it. Not so fond of mod speculation.

 

[GandhiLaserGun]

K, in that case I'm down to lynch J on the fact that he's been scummy as a cave troll's hairy ballsack instead

 

[Pink Lemonade]

Oh gosh I like Seik's play all of a sudden. Glad to see support for the idea of Smargscum.
1059 is an ugly switch to Soup that coincides with the first person to really lay a vote on Smarg.

X1, check out the exchange that goes on in 1042 > Bottom of 1045 > 1052, i.e. TDW/Asdioh.

I read this when you originally posted it and I read it again, but I don't see anything significant about this exchange tbh. Seikend had some insight on it that was meh, doesn't change my stance on either player.

TDW should claim so we can avoid taking time on a wagon.

Nabe's random reads confuse me greatly. He wants J, Soup, and now TDW but doesn't have his vote on any of them. And he wants TDW to claim for the heck of it.

Its pretty clear from Kat's language here that he had to legitimately think out the rules to check whether it was against the rules or not, particularly obvious in the underlined section. Had Kat truly incorporated this restriction into his game somehow, he'd not have to do this

Discuss



/disappears again

This is actually a good point brought up about J's posting restriction. Not sure how much to take it into account in reference to J, but I think it is a legit point by GLG.

 

[Asdioh]

I disagree PL, I'd rather just ignore the mod speculation and assume J is lying or telling the truth based on what we know about him, not what the mod said.

Gonna try to reread now while baking pizza. Gonna skim through and note the significant stances taken by each player, and why. Gonna do it like, 10 pages at a time :s

 

[Pink Lemonade]

I disagree PL, I'd rather just ignore the mod speculation and assume J is lying or telling the truth based on what we know about him, not what the mod said.

Gonna try to reread now while baking pizza. Gonna skim through and note the significant stances taken by each player, and why. Gonna do it like, 10 pages at a time :s

That's why I said I'm not sure how to take it in reference to J (aka how much it should be considered usable as an argument against J) but I think that its a legit point for GLG to bring up since they thought it had significance.

 

[Asdioh]

I refuse to tell Smar which head of the hydra is posting. For those who know I request you don't let on. Metaing me or the other half is a bad idea.

GBoy if you're wrong about Smar's alignment I'm calling you scum, problemo?

Yes lol look at Rusty Guillotine. I was so wrong it hurt. But good thing I'm not wrong right?

 

[Asdioh]

so OTHER THAN BECAUSE HE IS, why is KevM town?

KevM, why are you calling out lurkers when you haven't posted any content yet? I'm multitasking and J keeps posting before I can, and it gets knocked off my screen (or he posts while I'm going and looking up the quote).

Me saying you're parroting, saying PL is scummy for what he says but thinking he's dumb town and telling you what I think I want for a first lynch and possible vig kill (really hope there is one in this game)

is giving 100 percent more information then you've given thus far by playing the paraphrase J game.

You did this last game you were scum in as well :

Not by a mile! This game is just a bit different than the others I've joined in that it allows me certain liberties I cannot take in a normal situation.

so you obviously have some sort of role that isnt vt, then.

just quoting stuff I find noteworthy

 

[Asdioh]

40 ppp, first ten pages:




1. Pink Lemonade - doesn't think Smarg is scum, but thinks Kevin is avoiding Glyph, thinks Glyph is scummy

2. GandhiLaserGun - Smarg scum, J/Glyph possible scum. Seik scum.

3. BSL [replaced by Nabe]

4. Asdioh - 392

5. KevinM - Smarg scum, PL scummy, Aposl scummy, PL dumbtowny, BSL scummy, goes on a rant on page 10 saying Glyph is playing pro-town while Smarg isn't

6. Toasting Dat Walrus - Smarg scummy

7. Seikend - 396 was the most notable thing I could find

8. Smargaret - Aposl scum, Glyph scummy

9. J - Glyph scum, accuses Smarg of parroting, which Kevin then agrees with

10. JTB - Seikend/Asdioh scummates

11. Aposl

12. Soupamario - Seik/Aposl/JTB scum

13. Glyphmoney - J scum, Smarg scum (but more so J after Js response), Kevin town, Aposl towny




That's my overview of the first 10 pages. If I missed any stances, it's because I was trying to do it fairly quickly. I'll do 11-20 next.

 

[Asdioh]

that pizza was really good

I expect some posts soon or else everybody is scum
srsly guys why don't you have activity when I'm actually around

 

[#HBC | ѕoup]

I know that Feel bro.

On phone so lol

 

[#HBC | Nabe]

X1 comes in and doesn't respond to a point I had to requote from the last Day.

Vote: Soup

PL, what do you think of Seik?

 

[#HBC | Nabe]

Kuz head of TDW can answer that too. Or the other one idrc

 

[KevinM]

I really don't like how far behind D1 has put us.

 

[Pink Lemonade]

PL, what do you think of Seik?

Town read on Seikend. I like the way he handled JTB's claim and he didn't rush a lynch, he genuinely seemed concerned at the end of the Day between picking who he thought was scummiest between J and JTB.

 

[Asdioh]

man, I accidentally fall asleep and only a few posts happen during this time?
I'll get to continuing my reread in the morning.

But on the bright side, DKR is finished so I can finally use it as an example of my town play !

Now, part of my townread on Glyph stems from, like I said, him doing something similar to what I did in DKR. Now, in DKR, near the beginning of the game, I persistently said J was scum (turns out he was) with I guess little reasoning. Look at this post by Glyph in that game: http://www.smashboards.com/showpost.php?p=12412378&postcount=1150

Do you see any similarities between what he pointed out me doing in that game, and what he's doing in this game? It's kind of hypocritical if you ask me, but at the same time I'm willing to believe he's town for now.

 

[Toastin Dat Walrus]

@X1 You're straight tunneling J, and it seems like you're reaching big time for a J lynch with your #2001. Instead, how's about you tell me your opinion on Nabe?

Where IS J anyway? @mod if it's outside the 48 hour time period, request J prod.

X1 comes in and doesn't respond to a point I had to requote from the last Day.

Vote: Soup

Gah what is this I don't even... ugh smh...

Kuz head of TDW can answer that too. Or the other one idrc

I, Gord, think he's obvtown. If Kuz thinks any different then lol, but from how we've been talking I seriously doubt that he thinks any different.

 

[GimR]

idc if j posts or not, without him able to type he useless and annoying. Mafia wont silence him again, most likley so we will see whats up if he gets NK. Asidoh, I dont know anymore,i guess I thought soups argument was right, but now he has backed down leaving me with NO idea. Nabe seems shifty, he doesnt explain anything, wich either means hes fishing for reactions, or doesnt care to give his reasoning. A wagon will either force his reasoning out or make him claim his role, at this point we have to be careful about giving mafia everything though. But if we can get more claims we will eventually get a lie. This should lead to a lynch, or at least a narrowing down of lynch suspects IMO. Not for getting more claims right now just saying what positives and negatives it could lead too.

UNVOTE

 

[Aposl]

sorry guys didnt know my brother was on my computer, that was me btw

 

[Aposl]

unvote

just in case

 

[#HBC | ѕoup]

who is god, btw.

 

[#HBC | Nabe]

'kay, cool.

I'm town cop, unconfirmed sanity.
I have a guilty on TDW and I'd like to lynch him.

Vote: TDW
I'm wondering if my town bro Soup will join me in this.

 

[#HBC | ѕoup]

ballsy claim Nabe, too ballsy, might asking me what your play was, or what you were trying to do? or what ARE you trying to do?

 

[#HBC | Nabe]

I got you to prove to me that you were town. It went well.
Get onboard the TDW wagon though, in 10 minutes or so it'll be a good place to be.

 

[#HBC | ѕoup]

had a hunch you were doing some reaction testing, and it somewhat adds up BSL's rolefishing and whatnot, somewhat.

Nabe, what convinced you TDW was scum, or perhaps, what convinced you not to investigate J?

a part of me feels you are being legit about this, but the other part says not sure, just answer some questions for me and lemme reread and ill see if i see what you see, see.

 

[Pink Lemonade]

Unvote
Vote: TDW

That was unexpected, but it explains some of those wishy-washy stances from yesterDay and the shift of focus toDay.

I still think your play was scummy but I don't see any reason why Nabe as scum would want to fake claim under very little pressure just to get TDW killed, so I'm assuming this is legit.

 

[#HBC | Nabe]

I didn't like TDW's interactions with some of my other scumpicks and his play in general.

J on the other hand, I'd have put with JTB, who flipped town. And I was fine with letting the doc/watcher situation move on its own. Didn't expect a silencing or a faking of silencing though.

 

[DtJ Glyphmoney]

vote: TDW

Nabe, why out yourself when the doctor is dead? I'm glad you've got a guilty and all, but now you're just probably going to die tonight...

 

[#HBC | Nabe]

Tired of *****footing around it and far too lazy to actually do work, or pretend to.

 

[#HBC | Nabe]

Soup, your vote is missing the action.

 

[#HBC | Nabe]

PL, Glyph: It's good to see that you've joined the party. Can TDW be scum with your current scumpicks? Let's all elaborate on our scumpicks, in fact.

 

[#HBC | ѕoup]

well nabe, i was thinking about it, and..i suppose, i just have a feeling we're gonna have that **** claim again.

unvote vote TDW

investigate Asdioh for me if this day comes to a close soon.

 

[#HBC | ѕoup]

actaully, Nabe, i have noticed some great buddying between Glyph/Asdioh/ and Seikend.

 

[#HBC | ѕoup]

gonna go re-read though.

 

[DtJ Glyphmoney]

Let me do a quick ISO on TDW to see if anything comes up as far as connections to my scum picks goes.

 

[Asdioh]

I'm town cop

Well I called this from your first posts on D2. I kind of assumed you got a guilty on Soup though, which confused me. I mean, you made it so obvious you had night action proof he was scum, that I figured you should have just claimed cop, instead of posting baseless accusations or whatever @_@ but if you were just looking for reactions I guess it makes sense.

I got you to prove to me that you were town. It went well.
Get onboard the TDW wagon though, in 10 minutes or so it'll be a good place to be.

What exactly did he say that made you think he was town? I don't doubt you or anything, I just want to know.


Anyway, a guilty on Kuz? Last time I ignored that, I ended up regretting it

unvote
Vote: Toastin Dat Walrus

investigate Asdioh for me if this day comes to a close soon.

if he survives the night, sure, I don't mind.

 

[Aposl]

should i hammer tdw? nabe as cop whatdo you think along with the rest of you that voted him

 

[#HBC | Nabe]

Of course not, don't hammer. Lots of Daytime left to go.
Take the time to evaluate your scumreads.

 

[Asdioh]

oh damn he's at L-1 already.

unvote just in case :x

 

[#HBC | ѕoup]

Glyph or Asdioh, or perhaps Seikend.

directed towards Nabe ofc.