Bingo Mafia: OVAH! Who won?

[#HBC | Nabe]

Glyph or Asdioh, or perhaps Seikend.

directed towards Nabe ofc.

Sorry, what is this in reference to? People who might be scum with TDW, or your current scumreads?

 

[#HBC | ѕoup]

current scumreads, i'm looking at who might be scum with TDW right now.

 

[Aposl]

Nabe there are 5 votes for tdw right now? shouldnt someone unvote so he cant be hammered? or is this the appropriate amount of pressure?

 

[Aposl]

nmnd just saw asidoh unvote

 

[Asdioh]

TDW is typing up a lengthy response?

 

[#HBC | Nabe]

Oh gosh. Asdioh, you hammered when you voted.

 

[DtJ Glyphmoney]

Caught up. We still can't see J flipping scum, but even if he flips town, we're gonna be getting hella connections and shiz from his flip. Me and Kuz talked it over, and we'll be fine switching our vote. I won't be here for the deadline, gonna be at this school chorus performance. And neither will Kuz. So me placing the vote will probz be me keeping the vote there. If I'm here later tonight and I feel it's the best thing to do, I'll put em at L-1.

J == Not scum

.

I think J's claim is legit about not being able to post in words. I mean, if he's gonna get pic/gif restricted, it'd be broken if he can get his point across with text on a jpg. I mean come on wtf.

Nabe seems really angsty about getting a Soup lynch through. I don't really remember a case on Soup to reference anything scummy he's done, and with my read, he's seeming pretty null atm. I can see genuine town intentions from em. It seems to me like an attempt of a ML.

Vote: Nabe

@Nabe if there's a case on Soup you can show me, please do. If not, tell me why I think you're being mad jumpy about getting people on Soup.

Nabe == Scum

Gord chiming in. Sue me if I'm wrong; just got back from school



His reaction to being at L-1? Ya mean his 1045? What in that entirety of that post made you read Asdioh town? All I got from that was straight up deflection. I found Soup's voting to be a noob slip, personally.



Ugh can you get any scummier I mean argh -______-...

*Post directed at Smarg
Smarg == Scum

BSL needs more votes guys he literally isn't doing anything and pulled A TOTALLY TEXTBOOK scum slip.

Vote: BSL

BSL == Scum *note that there are quite a few of these posts in comparison to his other reads.

Oh, and BSL is Nabe now, so that just doubles up.

Responding to prod.

Vote: Asdioh

Showing where I stand on the issue.

Many of J's posts resemble his scum meta, but there is something distinctly different about them this game that I can't quite put my finger on. However, it rings extremely townie with me. I agree with Nabe that both are good candidates if we specifically want to look for connections, but I think Asdioh is looking scummier.

Thats L-2, yeah? Should be fine there.

@Nabe: who consists of the J group and the Smarg group?
@J and Asdioh: top two scumpicks besides one another.
@GLG: After you catch up with Asdioh, re-evaluated read on Seikend. Is his reluctance to take a side on J vs Asdioh simple cautiousness or scum not trying to become to affiliated with a wagon?
@Seikend, remind me of your read on Smarg.

Woooooow. Yeah J/TDW scummates.

Vote: Sqweedle and Pink Lemonade

Either of these are a nice lynch amirite?

Should be reading thread within the next two hours.

Soup/PL == Scum

Lotta pointing fingers at people for being scum, but rarely any follow up (only time I saw it was with Nabe/BSL). Only time he defends someone is J, despite agreeing his play lines up with his scum meta?

If TDW flips scum we are lynching J the day after without deviation, and vice versa.

 

[Asdioh]

Oh gosh. Asdioh, you hammered when you voted.

Are you telling me that someone had a vote on him earlier than that page?

:|

well let's hope he's scum and the mod doesn't look at this thread for a while!

 

[DtJ Glyphmoney]

Unless I'm mistaken, from the most recent votecount where he has no votes on him, there have only been five votes.

 

[#HBC | Nabe]

Never mind, I thought we had 9 players left. He's at L-2 after the unvote.

 

[Asdioh]

Never mind, I thought we had 9 players left. He's at L-2 after the unvote.

>_>

that's what I thought.

 

[#HBC | Nabe]

Glyph, what does TDWscum make you think about your current scumpicks?

 

[#HBC | Nabe]

Same with PL who should really get posting.

 

[Toastin Dat Walrus]

Sweet job @ convincing me Nabe.

Unvote

Vote: Soupamario

First of all guys, if you hadn't noticed, Nabe pulled a very wise gambit. Think of how me and his interactions have been so far toDay. He subtly points his fingers at J and Soup, calling them scum. I start to think that it's coming off really bad, and place my vote. He then continues with his notion of calling Soup scum. Then, without too much, if any at all, pointing at me as scum through the whole Day, he comes up with a cop claim and a guilty on me. But not just any cop claim. He asks his "town bro" Soup to get in on the wagon. Soup then kinda subtly says that he doesn't know if he should. Coupl'a votes pile on, and bang, so does his.

First of all, if he was really a cop with a guilty report on me, he'd have tried to make more of an effort to get me lynched from the beginning of the Day without quite outing himself as the cop. Take note of Royal Mafia Sleepover, where Overswarm was cop with a guilty on Gheb. The ONLY thing that Overswarm did said Day with that guilty was tunnel Gheb. Hard. It was a good cop technique, up until he made himself too obvious. Cops should always try to find sufficent evidence against their scum investigation before outing themselves. That way... they can still cop around! Nabe didn't do this. What does this mean? It was a gambit. And one that worked, at that.

Second of all, maybe my weakest observation, is mod speculation. It's quite broken in mafia to have a doctor and a sane cop in the same game, because then the game can easily turn into follow the cop. Uninformed sanity? Possibly, and quite understandable. Either that, or Kat really DID put a sane cop and doc in the same game and I'm an uninformed miller. But it sounds more reasonable that Nabe pulled a sweet gambit.

Third of all, I wanna take a look back at Soupamario's adding to my wagon. Back in Villains mafia, I was scum, and was attacked HARD for my inability to do anything without being wishy washy. The same type of play happened in Sonic mafia, but I was a noob and not accounted for. The way his approach to the wagon occoured just screams scum to me.

Thanks for finally convincing me, Nabe.

 

[#HBC | ѕoup]

TDW, i thought you didn't see me as scum.

 

[#HBC | Nabe]

The plot thickens.
Please clarify, TDW. Is the gambit that I'm VT faking cop, or cop faking a guilty?

 

[DtJ Glyphmoney]

Nabe: It makes me think we really really need to lynch J.

TDW: So you're saying both Soup and Nabe are both scum? Or that Nabe is town and faking cop?

 

[Toastin Dat Walrus]

@Nabe I'm saying VT gambiting cop w/ a guilty.

@Glyph Soup is scum. Nabe is town faking cop, and did the perfect thing to convince me of Soup scum.

@Soup I didn't.

 

[#HBC | Nabe]

Glyph, who are your scumreads aside from J? Seems to have slipped my mind.

 

[#HBC | Nabe]

TDW, if you had to name one person who you think is town to you right now, particularly after the first Day and Night, who would that be?

 

[#HBC | Nabe]

Asdioh, keep posting.

 

[Toastin Dat Walrus]

Aside from you?

 

[DtJ Glyphmoney]

Currently J/TDW/Soup

 

[Pink Lemonade]

PL, Glyph: It's good to see that you've joined the party. Can TDW be scum with your current scumpicks? Let's all elaborate on our scumpicks, in fact.

Well, you were my strongest scum pick so I have some rethinking to do. My other scum reads were Asdioh and I was leaning scum on GLG.

TDW has a very clear connection to J so I would consider J scum; I would throw KevinM in to be looked at because I don't remember them addressing each other much at all. Aposl and GLG who are null to me right now are still possibilities. Immediate scum reads based off what I remember of his connections.

Anyway, a guilty on Kuz? Last time I ignored that, I ended up regretting it

Lol truth.

On a related note, I feel better about Asdioh from his recent responses and from a little bit of meta I've gained on him, willing to let my suspicions of him go for now if TDW really is scum.

 

[#HBC | Nabe]

Currently J/TDW/Soup

But prior to now, lol.

@TDW: Aside from me, yes. Who's someone you came into D2 with a town read on?

 

[#HBC | ѕoup]

Currently J/TDW/Soup

that's the best scumlist i've ever seen, throw in a suspected mafia, a guilty, and then me.

wonderful, you really do scumhunt good.

 

[#HBC | Nabe]

Soup, what do you think of what TDW said? He seems convinced that you're scum.

 

[#HBC | ѕoup]

personally, i could care less, everyone likes calling me scum, but never back it up, i'm actually happy TDW stated at least something, but it seems like a hesitant vote.

 

[Toastin Dat Walrus]

Seikend .

 

[#HBC | ѕoup]

did i not have seikend on my scum list?

 

[DtJ Glyphmoney]

Soup i literally explained why i thought you were scum like a page ago.

Nabe i don't remember i'd have to through my posts haha

 

[#HBC | ѕoup]

that's not the point, i never said i cared about me being in there, i care about what your scumlist looks like besides me.

 

[DtJ Glyphmoney]

...so i'm not allowed to think J is scum now? Or believe tdw is his scummate based of posts i've cited and a guilty result?

 

[#HBC | Nabe]

Thoughts on Glyph and PL, TDW?

 

[Toastin Dat Walrus]

Glyph is null leaning scum, but I'm mad inclined to believe that Glyph and J aren't the same alignment. If J flips scum, Glyph is town, and vice versa. And PL is town.

 

[#HBC | ѕoup]

Got other picks though glyph?

 

[#HBC | Nabe]

Asdioh, keep posting.

 

[Asdioh]

I was reading TDWs response, which looked scummy at first but then I was interrupted by TACOS AND RICE.

Now I'm back from eating and I see his calm response to Nabe, and Nabe acknowledging his gambit guess. I don't really know what to think until Nabe clarifies further... but it would probably be best if he didn't. My original guess that Nabe was cop was him wanting me to guess that he was cop?

So basically, I have to side with either TDW or Soup now, right?

(still doing my reskim reread, it's a boring process, only on page 12 lolol)

 

[#HBC | Nabe]

I'd just like to know what you think a TDW scum flip would say about your current scumpicks.

 

[Asdioh]

Sweet job @ convincing me Nabe.

Unvote

Vote: Soupamario

First of all guys, if you hadn't noticed, Nabe pulled a very wise gambit. Think of how me and his interactions have been so far toDay. He subtly points his fingers at J and Soup, calling them scum. I start to think that it's coming off really bad, and place my vote. He then continues with his notion of calling Soup scum. Then, without too much, if any at all, pointing at me as scum through the whole Day, he comes up with a cop claim and a guilty on me. But not just any cop claim. He asks his "town bro" Soup to get in on the wagon. Soup then kinda subtly says that he doesn't know if he should. Coupl'a votes pile on, and bang, so does his.

First of all, if he was really a cop with a guilty report on me, he'd have tried to make more of an effort to get me lynched from the beginning of the Day without quite outing himself as the cop. Take note of Royal Mafia Sleepover, where Overswarm was cop with a guilty on Gheb. The ONLY thing that Overswarm did said Day with that guilty was tunnel Gheb. Hard. It was a good cop technique, up until he made himself too obvious. Cops should always try to find sufficent evidence against their scum investigation before outing themselves. That way... they can still cop around! Nabe didn't do this. What does this mean? It was a gambit. And one that worked, at that.

Second of all, maybe my weakest observation, is mod speculation. It's quite broken in mafia to have a doctor and a sane cop in the same game, because then the game can easily turn into follow the cop. Uninformed sanity? Possibly, and quite understandable. Either that, or Kat really DID put a sane cop and doc in the same game and I'm an uninformed miller. But it sounds more reasonable that Nabe pulled a sweet gambit.

Third of all, I wanna take a look back at Soupamario's adding to my wagon. Back in Villains mafia, I was scum, and was attacked HARD for my inability to do anything without being wishy washy. The same type of play happened in Sonic mafia, but I was a noob and not accounted for. The way his approach to the wagon occoured just screams scum to me.

Thanks for finally convincing me, Nabe.

@the underlined: I was looking over Soups reaction to the claimed guilty and I just don't know what to think of it. I know if I were in Soups position, I would ask wtf made him suddenly convinced I was town, but then again I probably would have asked that regardless of my alignment. Soup just kind of accepted it. Is that scummy? Maybe? He then seemed indecisive about believing Nabes claim, which I wasn't because as I said, I had already guessed he was cop. Now I'm second-guessing myself, but regardless I'm thinking Nabe is town... but idk what that says about TDW/Soup.

The post I quoted should go far in clearing/condemning TDW, though. Casual redirecting to get the attention off himself, or him actually being impressed by Nabes play and convinced Soup is scum?

^inb4 this is pointed out as being wishy washy and/or indecisive.

I'd just like to know what you think a TDW scum flip would say about your current scumpicks.

J scum

Other than that, not sure yet, which is part of the reason I'm doing a reread trying to make connections between everyone.