BC Melee Rankings: Late Fall 2012

[Rusty Shacklefurd]

Just waiting on Tiep and Tony's input on the facebook thread or via email.

They told me to tell you they think I'm the best.

Just so you know.

 

[unityole]

I feel the PR should be:

1 Manuel
2 Tony
3 Adam
4 Ryan
5 Tiep
6 Roby

7 - 10 I do not know 100% Because I have not really seen Evan, Gary etc.

maybe keith deserves a top 10, he played well at the smashfest, consistently.
still waiting for this weekend, Tony might have an edge over most players but from your list 3-6 could still be higher up. Note that Ryan came in 2nd at the last tournament just awhile ago, and Adam beat tony in winners final and final at the 2nd smashfest.

and also, even though John said that he doesnt wish to be on the PR list. HE ***** LAST WEEKEND!

 

[xXx-NoobKing-xXx]

maybe keith deserves a top 10, he played well at the smashfest, consistently.
still waiting for this weekend, Tony might have an edge over most players but from your list 3-6 could still be higher up. Note that Ryan came in 2nd at the last tournament just awhile ago, and Adam beat tony in winners final and final at the 2nd smashfest.

and also, even though John said that he doesnt wish to be on the PR list. HE ***** LAST WEEKEND!

Yah, but John has asked specifically not to be put on the list. We gotta respect that. Also, yes, I did beat tony last time we played in tourney. Tony's more consistent though. That'll get you a long way.

 

[dieslow]

he did beat me in tourney last stock med-high%, but i beat him in a $10 MM right after 3-0 with a 3stock and 2stocks, then in crews i 2 stocked him. FOR THE RECORD. adam was playing really, really good in the tourney set o_O


lulz

 

[firexemblemxpryde]

I think Keith deserves a spot there, too. I don't think we're willing to put Gary up there without going to a tournament; neither can we for Kuriko. I'd say

7) Evan
8) Matt
9) Tim
10) Keith

Oh, are we putting crews in consideration now?

*cough* wai 2 luz nub

 

[xXx-NoobKing-xXx]

he did beat me in tourney last stock med-high%, but i beat him in a $10 MM right after 3-0 with a 3stock and 2stocks, then in crews i 2 stocked him. FOR THE RECORD. adam was TRYING really, really HARD in the tourney set o_O


lulz

fix'd. 10 charmanders.

 

[dieslow]

adam: too bad u werent 'trying' in our MM ~_~

 

[unityole]

adam: too bad u werent 'trying' in our MM ~_~

for the records i was trying really hard in dota but still got owned, :/

 

[xXx-NoobKing-xXx]

tony: drugs are bad mmm'kayyyyyy.

My falcon is only good against Falco's and Marth's now I decided :/

EDIT: Someone help me with Falcon/Fox matchup. Need more practice.

 

[dieslow]

no drug johns our MM was RIGHT after the tourney set -_-;

i sent u guys my list.

 

[xXx-NoobKing-xXx]

no drug johns our MM was RIGHT after the tourney set -_-;

i sent u guys my list.

lol, it wasn't drug johns, I was just bein random.

Anyways, thanks for sending us your list tony. Now that we have all four lists we can create a rough draft of the NEW PR for the 4 of us to see. Then we can all review it once more, make any final changes and have it up anytime between now and Sunday hopefully =).

 

[SpaceFalcon]

EDIT: Someone help me with Falcon/Fox matchup. Need more practice.

..........

 

[xXx-NoobKing-xXx]

I do... it's falcons hardest matchup besides sheik.

I wanna be like, DARKRAIN good against fox's. Nothing less.

 

[firexemblemxpryde]

Pretty much a perfect list... almost exactly what I posted in the FB thread.

 

[Dynamism?]

1. Banana Pudding
2. Marble Block Cheese
3. Blackened Snapper
4. Delux Pizza
5. Spaghetti
6. Root Beer
7. Chocolate Chip Mint Ice Cream
8. Tequila
9. Garlic Toast
10. Swiss Cheese Crackers

This list?

 

[dieslow]

my list will most likely change after saturday, so lets say update on Sunday?

 

[Patooty]

i dnt c ur lst yt

 

[AIDS]

my list will most likely change after saturday, so lets say update on Sunday?

If we do this week after week there will never be an up-date.

 

[dieslow]

re-read my post then shuttup

 

[unityole]

re-read my post then shuttup

:o

10 controllers, 1 falcon and a hot mom ( S )

 

[Dynamism?]

Jack, when is it that you're leaving? I will be all depressed...

 

[xXx-NoobKing-xXx]

1-2 Manuel/Tony
3. Adam
4. Ryan
5-6 Tiep/Roby
7. Evan
8. Matt *
9-10 Gary/Tim

An educated estimate of the new PR.

Will have a new list soon pplz

 

[Rusty Shacklefurd]

1-2 Manuel/Tony
3. Adam
4. Ryan
5-6 Tiep/Roby
7. Evan
8. Matt *
9-10 Gary/Tim

An educated estimate of the new PR.

Will have a new list soon pplz

What does the star mean and have I ever met Gary or Tim?

 

[Lib3r4t3]

Tim is Daltsy. Guy kinda looks like Bill from Bill and Ted. KIIINDA.

 

[Dynamism?]

:O
Wow Tiep dropped! What happened? He was patient missle **** against Manly last I saw!

Things change...



Who's bill? and YAY finally some Okanagan(ish) rep lol

Btw, I'm training some/an actual main for once and play the game regularly (as of 2 days ago and from now on) so hopefully I'll make 20th or something in 5 years :D

Stoked for MOST2 and CAST4 and SFUJan


JACK STAY HERE!!

 

[Lib3r4t3]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r79EksC6QjA

Bill's the one in the green.

 

[xXx-NoobKing-xXx]

tim is Daltsy

gary is Fox Machine.

 

[AIDS]

I just also want to mention to please review the stats, I know you where not there Adam but I tied manuel in pools on saturday 1-1, I also tied tim 1-1, and on sudnay i played Evan in pools and 2-0'd him. (second match was close though[one stock and two stocked])
I also had 2 very close matches with roby in pools on sunday, and I kept even with him in crews.

Keep this in mind on your update of the PR please.

 

[dieslow]

My new list is..

1st: Me bish
2nd: Manual
3rd: Adam
4th: Ryan
5th: Roby
6th: Tiep
7th: Matt
8th: Meta
9th: Tim
10th: Keith

idk if Tim counts if he doesnt come to anymore SFU's though.

 

[Lib3r4t3]

He's planning on going to Nov 8th and more from what he tells me.

 

[xXx-NoobKing-xXx]

What does the star mean and have I ever met Gary or Tim?

Hopefully he comes with ****!!!

spots 9 and 10 are killing me! We should just change PR to top 5 >.> LOL

 

[Rusty Shacklefurd]

We should just change PR to top 5 >.> LOL

I'd have to agree with that. Not that my oppinion has much weight to it, but srsly, there shouldn't be this many people getting juggled around the bottom two or three slots. 5 man list wouldn't be as precise, but it would be much more simple, accurate, and relevant.

Of course you could always take the arbitrary number route and just go with whatever size list you think can be accurately represented. Who says the list can't be 8 long?

 

[Dynamism?]

I agree with 8, 6 , 7, 20, whatever number is best accurate. But in cases where it's very close between a few yet evident who is next, then go Gary/Tim and Tiep/Roby and Tony/Manly just as it was up there ^^^
Who says they can't be tied?

 

[Rusty Shacklefurd]

The problem is that over the course of each month there's usually about 5 or more people tied for the bottom two slots, and at that point it just doesn't seem like there's any reason to keep a list of ten because the lower slots are constantly tied or fluctuating.

For now you might be in agreement with which two people are tied for the bottom two, but it seems every week everyone changes their mind and shuffles it again. Just cut of the bottom two slots and get it over with.

SIG FIGS, MAN, SIG FIGS

Edit: And hey, if you feel people are aren't being adequately represented, you could just add a side list of The Mediocres featuring Tim, Gary, Kieth, Yakal, Me, Kuriko, and anyone else that's been suggested for the bottom two in the past month. That way EVERYONE GETS A TROPHY!!!

 

[CrackHead]

there should be 10.

 

[xXx-NoobKing-xXx]

there should be 10.

10 charmanders, that is...

 

[Dynamism?]

10 million*

 

[firexemblemxpryde]

Here's what I think. If we give big weighting to the smashfest tournament on Saturday, then:

1 tony
2 manuel
3 adam
4 ryan
5 tiep
6 roby
7 matt
8 evan
9 tim
10 keith

If we don't, but still keep it in mind, from the last bigger tournaments the list is

1 manuel
2 tony
3 adam
4 ryan
5 robyextreme
6 tiep
7 evan
8 matt
9 tim
10 keith

But of course, people are most influenced by what they last saw, despite the circumstance. So expect a list closer to the first.

 

[Dynamism?]

So the real list should be

1. Tony/Manuel
3. Adam
4. Ryan
5. Roby/Tiep
7. Evan/Matt
9. Tim
10. Keith

tada! And the people tied can take the spot ahead in a Bo5 PRM lol

 

[chocolate thunda]

jack is keeping stats for a reason. if you are having trouble with spots 8-10 then you could always revert back to jacks stats to see how the players did against eachother/others. also, in the GTA power rankings for the toronto players, we had an up and comings list so that there was the top 10 along with 3-5 other players that /could/ be on the PR very soon