Bad Idea Mafia Vol. 3 - Ovah!?

[#HBC | Mac]

omni, why dont you like zen? Because he doesn't think you're obv town?

 

[vanderzant]

So your saying discussing mechanics is a scum tell? I slightly agree if it goes on for a long time >_> its a bit distracting but whats interesting is this




Aren't you doing the same thing? =P

The difference is that I've made it incredibly clear who I think is scummy as well as given my input on mechanics.

Omni the more you continue to let nich slide for inactivity while calling others on it the more I want him dead.

I need to talk to kat but he's been gone for several days now. And sorry for the wrong account, on my iPod again.

 

[#HBC | Gorf]

Only on for a bit so here we go:

@Zen The way that Chuckie, in Halo, was so outspoken, trying to lead the town and scumhunting like a bawss. I saw that same thing RIGHT off the bat try'na get the whole little psuedo vote thing going, try'na get town organized. There are def. other things that I'd have to go back and look for, but the details aren't too important and yea that's that. Also, wrt Tandora: Just because she SAYS that she'll shoot doesn't mean she'll act on it. Hell, there are 5 shooters in the game right now, who says she's not scum try'na blend in the crowd, or just an assassin (yea I know that that'd be stupid for an assassin to do but it's still a possibility). The most hand dirty thing I've seen was her Warning! thingy.

@Kuz don't have time to look back right now but if you ask that question again after my V/LA I'll answer.

@Nix no it doesn't. He didn't do ANYTHING but coast. Do you disagree with that?

 

[Swiss]

Gord if Chuckie was scum he'd have replaced out VS me.

Obv.

 

[#HBC | Gorf]

Lol he's not scum.

Obv.

 

[#HBC | Gorf]

Oh lmfao @NBC maf reference.

Amirite?

 

[Swiss]

MLG Gord, MLG.

 

[Omni]

@Mac: when zen and I are town
I feel like we share the same wavelength
so that's why I'm uncomfortable
with him


@Vander:
nich can die, too. I don't mind
I just like the fact that he thinks I'm town
cuz it's true
but no I like nich's early game play
dont shoot him


I don't want Swiss dead.
Zen can shoot.
Tan can shoot or die.
Mac can die.
Chuckie can live.
Neutral on rest of cast.

 

[Nicholas1024]

@Chuckie
My motivation basically died with the D1 quickshot, and it hasn't really recovered. I know that lurking (for me in particular, I mean) is a scumtell, and I don't really have an excuse except for 0 motivation. Take it as you will.

My offer to shoot was basically a recognition that I'm scummy, and an attempt at preventing the inevitable "OH NOES, NICH'S SCUMMY, QUICKSHOT!". In that regard it's worked pretty well.

Anyway, I think Gord should go on the townie list Omni. The way he's been contributing (and his analysis of my play was spot-on, IMO) when he could just join the however-many lurkers we have strikes me as townie, and I've had no major problem with his reads he posted.

 

[Omni]

sooo let's agree on who can shoot
i want zen or tan to shoot mac
what about u guys

 

[Xivii]

I really want Nich to shoot in any case. Would prefer Kuz shot and Mac would be good as well. I just think Tandora would just be a waste because I think she is town and I'd rather use shooting as a means to clear or out and I just don't think Tan is scum. She has been playing too out there like she usually does. After NBC I realize that's just simply how she plays. Like town reckless tell I suppose. Omni you say we are usually on the same wavelength, but I think I have more experience with Tan and the way she has been playing is town Tanny to me. Why I think Nich should be shooter is because he hasn't necessarilly been scummy in a sense (as he hasn't really done anything) so I don't feel confident as him being the a shot today. But his insistance of shooting is suspicious to me. Tandora did the same thing yesterday and people pretty much ignored her. And I think Scum Nich would feel confident enough to make the same proposal today thinking it would slide by. His reasoning that he knew people would think he was scummy seems odd to me. So yeah I think Nich should shoot. And Kuz or mac shot.

 

[Xivii]

Also find it interesting that Ronike defended Omni against me and now Mac is defending me against Omni.

 

[Xivii]

Chuckie is town. And Swiss can be town too I guess.

 

[#HBC | Gorf]

i want zen or tan to shoot mac
what about u guys

Either one shooting is fine with me. I'd rather Tan shoot, but still, I'll be happy either way. But... methinks we should shoot nix > mac.

 

[Nix2100]

Im ok with Tan shooting...not sure who i would want shot though outside of Swiss >_> but thats a argument i won't win.

And chibo is always scummy -_- even i want to lynch him in all the games i was with him =p stop hating on me cause of it.

 

[Chuckie]

I really want to call Nich and have him shoot. I'd probably be fine with Tan shooting but Nich has more of a question mark over him from me.

I can agree with Mac dieing. Kuz as well.

I like nix. I like gord now (forgot he replaced mentos). I'd like to think zen/omni are town but they still worry me slightly.

 

[Xivii]

I am town. Omni is awkwardly meh.

 

[Chuckie]

I'll make a vote count, let's just pick first preferences instead of multiples as I'd rather force people to take a particular stance rather than be fine with whatever.

***

VOTE COUNT

With 10 alive it's freaking LYLO man!!!!

Shooter
Nich (3): Chuckie, Zen, Nich
Tan (4): Nix, Omni, Gord, Tan

To be shot
Mac (2): Chuckie, Omni
Nix (2): Gord, Swiss
Kuz (2): Zen, Tan
Swiss (1): Nix

Feel free to edit it if I've misinterpreted your stance, but I think that's where we're at.

Once the majority or preferably everyone has voted we will have the two top picks claim.

 

[Xivii]

Chuckie, why did you switch from Kuz to Mac? Also that is Vanderzant, yes?

 

[Chuckie]

I'm impartial to either really, but I didn't mind Kuz' last response to me and mac has been worse in terms of lurking. And it's still vand, yes.

 

[Xivii]

So townieeee

 

[Tandora]

Ok, now that we got some activity and a plan, I'll delay my shoot. Good job with the voting system Chuckie.

Let's say we have 72 hours(ish) until deadline. A shoot will occur this Saturday, so let's get opinions, votes, and claims out there people.

 

[Omni]

mac
y u replace in game
and no care

 

[Nix2100]

wtb more votes for shooter/shootee, missing 3 people here -_-

 

[Chuckie]

The sexy half of Chuckie is away until Monday. Inb4swisssaysvandisn'tthesexierhalf.

 

[Swiss]

Saying the sexier half of Chuckie is very much akin to saying the smart one in a class of *******.

 

[#HBC | Mac]

@Chuckie
My motivation basically died with the D1 quickshot, and it hasn't really recovered.

I don't really understand this. It wasn't really a quick shot since it happened quite a bit after the day began.

@omni:I care, but it's hard to have anything to say where there is a major lack of content and discussion happening today. Can't defend myself either since my case revolves around me lurking/being inactive which is a legitimate reason.

The posts on this day have been doing nothing for me. I still echo the same stances I did in my first post. I feel like I haven't seen any decent reasons for wanting anyone killed besides for activity and though I agree with that, it doesn't help me when trying to figure out who is actually scum.

 

[#HBC | Mac]

Also find it interesting that Ronike defended Omni against me and now Mac is defending me against Omni.

how is it interesting?

 

[#HBC | Gorf]

This game's not going anywhere.

I think it'd be best if we just go along with the shootings tomorrow, since, welp, NOTHING'S happening and we need to give this game a pulse.

@th3, Nich and Macman weigh in on who you want shot and @th3, Swiss and Macman weigh in on who you want to shoot.

Is ANYBODY opposed to ending the Day tomorrow, or Saturday the absolute latest?

 

[th3kuzinator]

Nich > Macman
Macman > Swiss

Tandora > all of em

 

[#HBC | Gorf]

Kinda vague wrt shooter and shootee, but

Shooter
Nich (3): Chuckie, Zen, Nich
Tan (5): Nix, Omni, Gord, Tan, th3

To be shot
Mac (2): Chuckie, Omni
Nix (2): Gord, Swiss
Kuz (2): Zen, Tan
Swiss (1): Nix

that watchu mean?

 

[th3kuzinator]

Oh I didn't realize who you wanted shot as well. Tandora shooting Nix or Mac is preferable. Other way around is fine too.

 

[Nicholas1024]

Hm... As far as shooting goes, I'm willing to shoot if it comes to that, but I'd prefer someone else to shoot (simply because it would give us a semi-clear to work with, and reads are hard to come by this game.)

As far as the shot target goes, I'll use PoE.

Omni, Gord, Chuckie, Zen, and Swiss are on the neutral-to-townie list for me, so I think they should live.

That leaves Nix, Tan, th3, and Macman as the people I'm fine with having shot.

 

[Nix2100]

I find myself ok with Tan shooting mac >_>

Im ok with the deadline shot to be saturday, gives the people that seem to not be here at the moment another day to try to get a word in or get some discussions going

....Still want Swiss dead though >_>

Also ^_^ many thanks Zen for changing your avatar from the redhead to a anime character...makes it less distracting

 

[Xivii]

Good with Saturday

@Macman, you replaced Ronike, yes? What are you not getting? It's like a reversed loop and I'm simply taking note of it.

Nix haha np. It's likely temporary though.

If Tandora shoots can we at least shoot Kuz or Mac then.

 

[~ Gheb ~]

A deadline has been set to the last minute Wednesday, March 9th

 

[Omni]

let's just get it over with

 

[#HBC | Gorf]

@Mod Saturday, March 5th, or Wednesday, March 9th? I'm assuming the former, but just reassurance.

 

[~ Gheb ~]

It was actually March 9th ... my apologies.

 

[Nicholas1024]

Agreed with Omni, there's no need to wait for saturday.