• Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!

    You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!

Awkward Moments Mafia - Game over! Scum wins! Will a SD game ever see a town victory?

#HBC | Dancer

The nicest of the damned.
Joined
Feb 22, 2009
Messages
1,390
Location
Orlando, Fl
Vote Count

1. Red Ryu
2. th3kuzinator
3. Fynal
4. Acrostic
7. Kantrip
8. FragMental (1) - Acrostic
9. Gova
10. Armor (2) - Asdioh, Kantrip
11. Asdioh

Not voting: Red Ryu, th3kuzinator, Fynal, Fragmental, Gova, Armor

With 9 alive it takes 5 to lynch.
 

Fynal

Smash Journeyman
Joined
May 6, 2010
Messages
240
sup

sorry things have been really hectic for me, i've got a free period today i'll post then

IIRC my read on armor was null-scum. i'll figure it out when i've got free
 

Fynal

Smash Journeyman
Joined
May 6, 2010
Messages
240
i love days like this, where we do nothing in WWW class

959 has point. isoing Armor now
 

Fynal

Smash Journeyman
Joined
May 6, 2010
Messages
240
FoS-because-vote-would-put-him-at-L_1: Armor

look at this garbage

623- he doesn't like the extension

867/623- he throws out names with no follow-up all over

902,921- lots of promises of content later, no content, despite approaching deadline

628/631/642- is good with TTK lynch on basis that ryker (DESPITE EVIDENCE TO THE CONTRARY) will produce a good case later

you know what i see here? scum who'se good with any lynch. he didn't want an extension yesterday despite having no-one he really wanted to lynch. He never pushes ryker, instead sort of vaguely prods in TTK's direction without committing (685,867), despite not giving any reason for TTK lynch but having a reason (867) to go after ryker.

there is nowhere in this game where he actually cares who we lynch, he starts out raging at inactives and then later turns to vaguely saying "ok erm im ok with these lynches i guess but i won't actually go for em"

i don't have time to link all his posts, just search this thread for his posts and open em all in order in new tabs to check my cites, thats what i do
 

#HBC | Acrostic

♖♘♗♔♕♗♘♖
Joined
Jan 31, 2010
Messages
2,452
I'm assuming that no one noticed TheThirdKoopa's soft claim on post #579 in which he states:

TheThirdKoopa said:
A Daycop and a Cop is unlikely. Actually, Daycop (Assuming it's sane) is a pretty powerful role to begin with unless Scum has at least something to mess with it. I'm having a hard time buying this or at least a sane Daycop until further notice. And the fact that Frag didn't receive any PM of sorts is also suspicious (as if a daycop needed to be more confirmable)
Fragmental directly addresses the quotation, "You think it's suspicious huh? ... Seems like I'm not the only one who noticed it. Haha." At this point Ryker proceeds to comment on what people have stated to ultimately conclude that TheThirdKoopa is the best lynch to use for the day. I'm sort of hard pressed to believe that Ryker would not pay attention to the reactions from his own gambit/reaction test. I've been skipping around a lot, however Fragmental really needs to explain what s/he noticed. Because I would expect more from Ryker and I assume that if Fragmental did notice what I found on my re-read, then I am curious why s/he didn't speak up and stop TheThirdKoopa from being lynched.
 

#HBC | Acrostic

♖♘♗♔♕♗♘♖
Joined
Jan 31, 2010
Messages
2,452
I'm assuming that no one noticed TheThirdKoopa's soft claim on post #579 in which he states:



Fragmental directly addresses the quotation, "You think it's suspicious huh? ... Seems like I'm not the only one who noticed it. Haha." At this point Ryker proceeds to comment on what people have stated to ultimately conclude that TheThirdKoopa is the best lynch to use for the day. I'm sort of hard pressed to believe that Ryker would not pay attention to the reactions from his own gambit/reaction test. I've been skipping around a lot, however Fragmental really needs to explain what s/he noticed. Because I would expect more from Ryker and I assume that if Fragmental did notice what I found on my re-read, then I am curious why s/he didn't speak up and stop TheThirdKoopa from being lynched.
@RedRyu: Please respond to this.
 

Kantrip

Kantplay
Joined
Jul 11, 2010
Messages
10,188
Location
B.C. Canada
I have no idea how to read PR play. I'd assume it would look more cautious. I didn't read TTK as a PR, though :(

In retrospect, we should have stayed with the Ryker lynch.

@RR, I believe I've shared my thoughts on Armor.

:phone:
 

FragMental

Smash Rookie
Joined
Sep 13, 2011
Messages
0
Location
The Fridge
I'm assuming that no one noticed TheThirdKoopa's soft claim
That wasn't necessarily a softclaim. TK would say that regardless from his own reasoning, though I suppose you could take it as one.

Fragmental directly addresses the quotation, "You think it's suspicious huh? ... Seems like I'm not the only one who noticed it. Haha." At this point Ryker proceeds to comment on what people have stated to ultimately conclude that TheThirdKoopa is the best lynch to use for the day. I'm sort of hard pressed to believe that Ryker would not pay attention to the reactions from his own gambit/reaction test. I've been skipping around a lot, however Fragmental really needs to explain what s/he noticed. Because I would expect more from Ryker and I assume that if Fragmental did notice what I found on my re-read, then I am curious why s/he didn't speak up and stop TheThirdKoopa from being lynched.
I was commenting on the fact Ryker tried to pull a gambit, of course.

And as for that? I was simply busy. You can note my absence after the whole ordeal of Ryker's seemingly superfluous gambit. I would have spoken up on his behalf had I known he was actually being pursued. From what I can recall, while TK was in the limelight, he was sharing it with Ryker and Gova.

I'm okay with an Armor lynch, he has brought nothing of substance to the table even when he said he would earlier and even when I (and presumably others?) wanted more out of him.
 

#HBC | Red Ryu

Red Fox Warrior
Joined
Jun 15, 2008
Messages
27,486
Location
Milwaukee, Wisconsin
NNID
RedRyu_Smash
3DS FC
0344-9312-3352
@RedRyu: Please respond to this.
How am I suppose to answer this?

Ryker did it to save his own skin, I'm almost 100% sure of this. I have no clue why the hell he did this as a VT. I have no clue what he was looking for in particular.

Best I can say is he was trying to get reads on specific people.

I have no idea how to read PR play. I'd assume it would look more cautious. I didn't read TTK as a PR, though :(

In retrospect, we should have stayed with the Ryker lynch.

@RR, I believe I've shared my thoughts on Armor.

:phone:
You good in the Armor read area. Others need to share it.

At this point I'm here for Ryker and well gotta deal.

I was commenting on the fact Ryker tried to pull a gambit, of course.

And as for that? I was simply busy. You can note my absence after the whole ordeal of Ryker's seemingly superfluous gambit. I would have spoken up on his behalf had I known he was actually being pursued. From what I can recall, while TK was in the limelight, he was sharing it with Ryker and Gova.

I'm okay with an Armor lynch, he has brought nothing of substance to the table even when he said he would earlier and even when I (and presumably others?) wanted more out of him.
Ok, so where do you stand for lynches today?
 

#HBC | Acrostic

♖♘♗♔♕♗♘♖
Joined
Jan 31, 2010
Messages
2,452
That wasn't necessarily a softclaim. TK would say that regardless from his own reasoning, though I suppose you could take it as one.
I don't understand why anyone would jump to the assumption that there is a cop in a closed setup when there could be trackers, watchers, and a bevy of other roles to replace the traditional cop role ESPECIALLY with a day cop claim already in play. In addition TK doubting the presence of a day cop claim, however insisting there is another type of cop in the setup strikes me as a pretty strong soft claim.

I don't know TK, but from my point of view knowing him didn't really mean anything seeing as how you weren't able to press a confident read (slight town read IIRC) on his alignment. Usually when I see someone press a relationship, I hope that it will lead to a greater accuracy in reads and help out scum via PoE.

Most of your interaction with TK fmpov was filler and iffy alignment reads. I am not assuming that familiarity = more assurance in reads. But I am curious what to make of your choice to be familiar with him rather than attempt to secure a read on him early on in this game.

FragMental said:
I was commenting on the fact Ryker tried to pull a gambit, of course.
Ryker claimed VT somewhere around Page 12. Then he claimed Day Cop on Page 15. It could have been taken as either a gambit or a scum slip. It really didn't strike me as the sort of, "Aha! Look at what I noticed!" interaction when I was re-reading. Especially when this was touched upon by TK that there was an inconsistency somewhere on 13/14 and Asdioh quoted it indicating that there was attention being placed on it before hand.

Fragmental said:
And as for that? I was simply busy. You can note my absence after the whole ordeal of Ryker's seemingly superfluous gambit. I would have spoken up on his behalf had I known he was actually being pursued. From what I can recall, while TK was in the limelight, he was sharing it with Ryker and Gova.
The tone of this paragraph makes me inclined to think that you believed TK was town. With regards to gambits, I only noticed two when I did my reading. Kooz's initial gambit of having mod confirmed information with regards to a town read and then there was Ryker's day cop gambit. I think that superfluous is an incorrect way of phrasing the gambit as it "outed" the cop in some form and if he wasn't lynched, I have some suspicions that TK would have been night killed. Another assumption I am making based on the tone of this post is that you would have been "okay" with a Ryker/Gova lynch. Which begs to question why you didn't choose to place a vote at the end of D1 for either Ryker or Gova and withheld your vote.

If you are town then it is highly likely that you will make it to mylo/lylo for being negligent and unreliable. Will you also be a non-entity when it comes to such a situation as it did D1?

FragMental said:
I'm okay with an Armor lynch, he has brought nothing of substance to the table even when he said he would earlier and even when I (and presumably others?) wanted more out of him.
He's a policy lynch then fypov. I.E. we're lynching him because he's been inactive and not responding as frequently as we would like.
 

#HBC | Acrostic

♖♘♗♔♕♗♘♖
Joined
Jan 31, 2010
Messages
2,452
Hey guys I have a great idea. Let's policy lynch all the inactives and hope we hit scum. I personally find it unsettling that we're pushing on people that aren't push back. But hey, hopefully he's ***** scum and if he flips town then we can proceed and lynch the next inactive on our list. To be honest, I'm not thrilled by Armor's posts upon my re-read. But I don't like how town is just pushing down the path of least resistance. It bites.

Fynal you seem to have these bursts of activity when it comes to deciding on a player or a strong potential wagon. I will admit that I'm mostly basing this on early game when you composed a case against Soupa that I felt you created without bothering to question/scumhunt Soupa. I get this similar vibe with you voting Armor today and using the same bullet list format when I have seen little interaction between you and Armor when it comes to actual game play. I will admit that I didn't focus on your play in middle-late D1, however you strike me as being jumpish with your reads and I'm not sure how to interpret such behavior at the moment.
 

Fynal

Smash Journeyman
Joined
May 6, 2010
Messages
240
ditto 973, except that i was a lot more interested in the ryker lynch.

asdioh is town, as of quick re-read

fyi armor isn't a policy lynch for me, i legitly think he's scummy based on the iso i intended to do a long time ago and didn't get around to until today

@Acro:
1. fypov = from your point of view?
2. are you interested in RR lynch based on ryker slot scummyness? (i am)
3. do you expect RR to know/understand all of ryker's thinking? (i.e. your 972)

@people: how much info do replacements get from the people they replace?
 

#HBC | Acrostic

♖♘♗♔♕♗♘♖
Joined
Jan 31, 2010
Messages
2,452
How am I suppose to answer this? Ryker did it to save his own skin, I'm almost 100% sure of this. I have no clue why the hell he did this as a VT. I have no clue what he was looking for in particular. Best I can say is he was trying to get reads on specific people.
This is the part that kills me. It was Ryker's own gambit. Perhaps I'm being egocentric or putting too much stock in Ryker, but honestly I would EXPECT Ryker of all people with respect to his OWN gambit to see the cop "soft claim". The fact that he didn't comment on it, didn't react to it, or didn't take it into account when he voted bothers me. Honestly. Kooz was even pushing early game that Ryker would attempt to do something to deter the lynch away from him and then Kooz pushes off his wagon. Idek.
 

Fynal

Smash Journeyman
Joined
May 6, 2010
Messages
240
@Acro: i distinctly remember making a case on soup, then asking him a lot of things and eventually deciding he was town. also i was pushing for ryker lynch for a long time when other people weren't
 

Fynal

Smash Journeyman
Joined
May 6, 2010
Messages
240
have class in 2 mins

@Everyone: thoughts scum-Armor, wrt my 966. sorry its kinda disorganized, i didn't have much time when i wrote it
 

Asdioh

Not Asidoh
Joined
Jun 23, 2008
Messages
16,200
Location
OH
When Asdioh doesn't die toNight he's scum :troll:
"when"

:glare:

sup

sorry things have been really hectic for me, i've got a free period today i'll post then

IIRC my read on armor was null-scum. i'll figure it out when i've got free
it's ok because you're town :3

Requesting deadline extension
you only get one per game, which was used D1

I'm assuming that no one noticed TheThirdKoopa's soft claim on post #579 in which he states:
This is a good catch, and I definitely don't remember this. If I did read that post, I definitely should have caught on to his automatic assumption that there was a regular cop >_<

fyi armor isn't a policy lynch for me, i legitly think he's scummy based on the iso i intended to do a long time ago and didn't get around to until today
This. I'm not voting Armor on policy, I'm voting him because based on my reread, he was pretty much the most stanceless and scummiest player I saw. I would be fine with either his or RR's lynch.


I'm liking Acrostic. (he replaced July, right?)
 

Kantrip

Kantplay
Joined
Jul 11, 2010
Messages
10,188
Location
B.C. Canada
I agree with you about Acrostic. I like his play coming into the game.

This is the part that kills me. It was Ryker's own gambit. Perhaps I'm being egocentric or putting too much stock in Ryker, but honestly I would EXPECT Ryker of all people with respect to his OWN gambit to see the cop "soft claim". The fact that he didn't comment on it, didn't react to it, or didn't take it into account when he voted bothers me. Honestly. Kooz was even pushing early game that Ryker would attempt to do something to deter the lynch away from him and then Kooz pushes off his wagon. Idek.
This is a good point. I hadn't thought of it this way, but thinking about it: it doesn't sit right with me that Ryker would use such a gambit ONLY to save his hide, knowing that he could potentially end up switching the wagon to a mis-lynch on a PR.

Oh, look what happened.

RR not knowing full reasoning and being unable to answer much in the way of Ryker's intentions is an inconvenience. For us, at least. I'm sure it's pretty damn convenient for Ryker not to have to scramble for an explanation.

Then there's the fact that he didn't even use his gambit for any reads (at least, none that he shared), which you covered.

My question for everyone, now is: Do you think Ryker put as much effort as he did into getting the wagon off of him and onto someone else as a "Vanilla Townie"? Was it warranted? Considering we ended up lynching our cop, instead....
 

Fynal

Smash Journeyman
Joined
May 6, 2010
Messages
240
so apparently i'm leaving for ohio at 4 pm tomorrow -_____________-
hopefully i'll have some internet access at least


ryker's gambit = scum fishing for cop to lynch? lets be honest, that TTK lynch came out of freaking nowhere for ryker, he said himself he had no reasons

down for lynching ryker(RR) or armor anytime now

vote: RR

i'm pretty even on which i want atm, voting RR as to have a vote and not have armor at L-1
 

Kantrip

Kantplay
Joined
Jul 11, 2010
Messages
10,188
Location
B.C. Canada
I agree Fynal, that's what I'm seeing too.

WHY on EARTH would someone want to out potential PR's when they could try to actually USE their slot. You'd expect Ryker to do something about his gambit if he's gonna' try so hard just to stay alive (as a claimed vanilla).

I could go for either lynch.

A Red Ruy lynch would provide more in terms of connections to other players, as Armor's activity has been sparse. I'd suggest copping him, but... :glare:
 

Armor

Smash Rookie
Joined
Jul 21, 2011
Messages
4
What happened to this? :glare:
Was going to post, then didn't want to. My motivation to play this has diminished with the amount of content, I'd be okay with my own lynch, but that'd be a **** move to my faction.
there is nowhere in this game where he actually cares who we lynch, he starts out raging at inactives and then later turns to vaguely saying "ok erm im ok with these lynches i guess but i won't actually go for em"
I do care who we lynch. If I didn't, wouldn't my vote have been on TTK, who was inactive, after expressing my dislike for inactives early on? I held back. I told myself there was no reasoning to indicate that he was scum.

RR/Ryker stuff... Ryker was trying to save his butt, no question. I'd totally think that's all there was to it, but ryker wouldn't move the lynch to just anyone, would he...?
O_O
Would he?
Vote: RR
 

#HBC | Dancer

The nicest of the damned.
Joined
Feb 22, 2009
Messages
1,390
Location
Orlando, Fl
Armor has posted, but he should of been prodded earlier, I just didn't. So now he has the same status of having an extra prod, basically.
 

#HBC | Red Ryu

Red Fox Warrior
Joined
Jun 15, 2008
Messages
27,486
Location
Milwaukee, Wisconsin
NNID
RedRyu_Smash
3DS FC
0344-9312-3352
FoS-because-vote-would-put-him-at-L_1: Armor

look at this garbage

623- he doesn't like the extension

867/623- he throws out names with no follow-up all over

902,921- lots of promises of content later, no content, despite approaching deadline

628/631/642- is good with TTK lynch on basis that ryker (DESPITE EVIDENCE TO THE CONTRARY) will produce a good case later

you know what i see here? scum who'se good with any lynch. he didn't want an extension yesterday despite having no-one he really wanted to lynch. He never pushes ryker, instead sort of vaguely prods in TTK's direction without committing (685,867), despite not giving any reason for TTK lynch but having a reason (867) to go after ryker.

there is nowhere in this game where he actually cares who we lynch, he starts out raging at inactives and then later turns to vaguely saying "ok erm im ok with these lynches i guess but i won't actually go for em"

i don't have time to link all his posts, just search this thread for his posts and open em all in order in new tabs to check my cites, thats what i do
So you bring up some good points on Armor here, but later....

Hey guys I have a great idea. Let's policy lynch all the inactives and hope we hit scum. I personally find it unsettling that we're pushing on people that aren't push back. But hey, hopefully he's ***** scum and if he flips town then we can proceed and lynch the next inactive on our list. To be honest, I'm not thrilled by Armor's posts upon my re-read. But I don't like how town is just pushing down the path of least resistance. It bites.

Fynal you seem to have these bursts of activity when it comes to deciding on a player or a strong potential wagon. I will admit that I'm mostly basing this on early game when you composed a case against Soupa that I felt you created without bothering to question/scumhunt Soupa. I get this similar vibe with you voting Armor today and using the same bullet list format when I have seen little interaction between you and Armor when it comes to actual game play. I will admit that I didn't focus on your play in middle-late D1, however you strike me as being jumpish with your reads and I'm not sure how to interpret such behavior at the moment.
Same things here, and I agree with this to be quite frank.

ditto 973, except that i was a lot more interested in the ryker lynch.

asdioh is town, as of quick re-read

fyi armor isn't a policy lynch for me, i legitly think he's scummy based on the iso i intended to do a long time ago and didn't get around to until today

@Acro:
1. fypov = from your point of view?
2. are you interested in RR lynch based on ryker slot scummyness? (i am)
3. do you expect RR to know/understand all of ryker's thinking? (i.e. your 972)

@people: how much info do replacements get from the people they replace?
I get nothing except anything he would have gotten as a result of his role.

Also you place a great amount of suspicion thinking he is scum, but later...

This is the part that kills me. It was Ryker's own gambit. Perhaps I'm being egocentric or putting too much stock in Ryker, but honestly I would EXPECT Ryker of all people with respect to his OWN gambit to see the cop "soft claim". The fact that he didn't comment on it, didn't react to it, or didn't take it into account when he voted bothers me. Honestly. Kooz was even pushing early game that Ryker would attempt to do something to deter the lynch away from him and then Kooz pushes off his wagon. Idek.
This is really bad WIFOM.

Your expecting Ryker to see something, which he was inactive for a large part of the game and even then he wasn't paying attention to his other lynch he was pushing.

Your assuming he would play perfectly, key thing Ryker doesn't play perfectly. Let's ditch the WIFOM.

so apparently i'm leaving for ohio at 4 pm tomorrow -_____________-
hopefully i'll have some internet access at least


ryker's gambit = scum fishing for cop to lynch? lets be honest, that TTK lynch came out of freaking nowhere for ryker, he said himself he had no reasons

down for lynching ryker(RR) or armor anytime now

vote: RR

i'm pretty even on which i want atm, voting RR as to have a vote and not have armor at L-1
And then you put the vote back on me after your first two posts? What?

I agree Fynal, that's what I'm seeing too.

WHY on EARTH would someone want to out potential PR's when they could try to actually USE their slot. You'd expect Ryker to do something about his gambit if he's gonna' try so hard just to stay alive (as a claimed vanilla).

I could go for either lynch.

A Red Ruy lynch would provide more in terms of connections to other players, as Armor's activity has been sparse. I'd suggest copping him, but... :glare:
He wasn't trying to out PR's he was trying to save his own hide.

What even gives the impression this was to out PRs?

Was going to post, then didn't want to. My motivation to play this has diminished with the amount of content, I'd be okay with my own lynch, but that'd be a **** move to my faction.

I do care who we lynch. If I didn't, wouldn't my vote have been on TTK, who was inactive, after expressing my dislike for inactives early on? I held back. I told myself there was no reasoning to indicate that he was scum.

RR/Ryker stuff... Ryker was trying to save his butt, no question. I'd totally think that's all there was to it, but ryker wouldn't move the lynch to just anyone, would he...?
O_O
Would he?
Vote: RR
I don't even know what the first two paragraphs mean. It's mostly a back and forth of two ideas that don't make sense together.

The WIFOM at the end is meaningless.
 

Kantrip

Kantplay
Joined
Jul 11, 2010
Messages
10,188
Location
B.C. Canada
I meant that what Ryker was doing had the potential to out PR's. Considering Ryker claimed VT (I'm pretty sure you've also said this is your role), it would certainly harm town if he switched the wagon onto another townie who WASN'T a VT.
 

#HBC | Red Ryu

Red Fox Warrior
Joined
Jun 15, 2008
Messages
27,486
Location
Milwaukee, Wisconsin
NNID
RedRyu_Smash
3DS FC
0344-9312-3352
Except he had no knowledge he was pushing it to a VT. You guys are assuming he did and he catch the crumb.

Yes it had the potential to out PRs, he knew this. It was not his intent.

Also get the idea of him scrambling info out there was a good idea when he was spoiled about the set-up. That would have broken the game in half if he posted with full knowledge of what he knew, I'm assuming the worst.
 

Fynal

Smash Journeyman
Joined
May 6, 2010
Messages
240
ryker was my top scumpick for like the second half of yesterDay. i didn't want to vote him as soon as toDay began because i wanted to get some re-reads in first. which i didn't until yesterday, because derpload of work and IRL stuff

If i'm going to totally ignore ryker's meta, and take him like anyone else, than what he did yesterday was HELLA FREAKING SCUMMY

If i'm going to take who ryker is into account, then it seems really ****ing suspicious that he would gambit being daycop and not notice how people reacted, and then just happen to pick someone who softclaimed cop to be his reasonless target for lynching
 

#HBC | Red Ryu

Red Fox Warrior
Joined
Jun 15, 2008
Messages
27,486
Location
Milwaukee, Wisconsin
NNID
RedRyu_Smash
3DS FC
0344-9312-3352
ryker was my top scumpick for like the second half of yesterDay. i didn't want to vote him as soon as toDay began because i wanted to get some re-reads in first. which i didn't until yesterday, because derpload of work and IRL stuff
Fair enough.

If i'm going to totally ignore ryker's meta, and take him like anyone else, than what he did yesterday was HELLA FREAKING SCUMMY
Why was the Gambit scummy?

Heck before he tried to deflect it, he dropped out of the, "I'm a day cop"

Just because he happened to pick the vanilla cop, doesn't mean the intent was scummy. Define this.

If i'm going to take who ryker is into account, then it seems really ****ing suspicious that he would gambit being daycop and not notice how people reacted, and then just happen to pick someone who softclaimed cop to be his reasonless target for lynching
Stop doing this.

This is not a case. It's really bad WIFOM.

First off, he would have to have prior knowledge that he was picking the cop, key he didn't. Second he would have had to have caught that crumb, also key no one thought it was a crumb until our cop did flip.
 

Fynal

Smash Journeyman
Joined
May 6, 2010
Messages
240
Why was the Gambit scummy?

Heck before he tried to deflect it, he dropped out of the, "I'm a day cop"

Just because he happened to pick the vanilla cop, doesn't mean the intent was scummy. Define this.
:facepalm:

did you read anything I posted yesterDay? i didn't say anything about his gambit being scummy. It was other things, like him being a VT who was pushing for any lynch that wasn't his own, with no reasons behind the lynch.

back to classwork...
 

Fynal

Smash Journeyman
Joined
May 6, 2010
Messages
240
Stop doing this.

This is not a case. It's really bad WIFOM.

First off, he would have to have prior knowledge that he was picking the cop, key he didn't. Second he would have had to have caught that crumb, also key no one thought it was a crumb until our cop did flip.
the whole point is that ryker claimed daycop to see if he could find a cop slip/softclaim, then he saw the claim, then he pushed TTK because he saw the claim.

the fact that none of us saw the softclaim doesn't mean that ryker, a player with a lot more experience, didn't see the softclaim

-are you saying that ryker claimed daycop, but didn't look for people's reactions?
-if not, are you saying ryker did look for people's reactions, but missed exactly what he was looking for (despite being a player of his skill), and just happened to get (un)lucky with his random "not me" lynch pick?
 

#HBC | Red Ryu

Red Fox Warrior
Joined
Jun 15, 2008
Messages
27,486
Location
Milwaukee, Wisconsin
NNID
RedRyu_Smash
3DS FC
0344-9312-3352
:facepalm:

did you read anything I posted yesterDay? i didn't say anything about his gambit being scummy. It was other things, like him being a VT who was pushing for any lynch that wasn't his own, with no reasons behind the lynch.

back to classwork...
Your condemning him for being a VT and pushing a lynch that wasn't his own? Excuse me but should I then ask you to push yourself instead of others?

There was a reason, his reason was the other wagon was better than his own.

the whole point is that ryker claimed daycop to see if he could find a cop slip/softclaim, then he saw the claim, then he pushed TTK because he saw the claim.

the fact that none of us saw the softclaim doesn't mean that ryker, a player with a lot more experience, didn't see the softclaim

-are you saying that ryker claimed daycop, but didn't look for people's reactions?
-if not, are you saying ryker did look for people's reactions, but missed exactly what he was looking for (despite being a player of his skill), and just happened to get (un)lucky with his random "not me" lynch pick?
Stop doing this.

There is nothing to suggest this is why he pushed him, there is nothing to suggest he picked up the crumb.

Just because Ryker has a lot more experience doesn't mean crap. Your expecting him to play perfectly, this never ever ever ever happens. Ryker is good, he is not a robot. Ypur playing an awful game of WIFOM where you trying to push a terrible assumption Ryker knew the crumb on sight. Where is this apparent?

I'm saying he didn't look at everyone's reactions, stop appealing to his skill, Ryker is good but he's no where to the level of perfect like your assuming him to me.

And yes, I am saying he got unlucky.
 

Gova

I'm goin' for it!
Joined
Jul 16, 2008
Messages
1,274
Location
Austin, TX
NNID
Takicodos
Sorry Gova, I more meant their posts wrt each other. Like, give me your thoughts on july's read on fm and fm's read on july.
I don't know what their reads are on each other and hence I don't have any thoughts on their reads of each other.

Still haven't read anything, been busy with school.
 

#HBC | Acrostic

♖♘♗♔♕♗♘♖
Joined
Jan 31, 2010
Messages
2,452
I don't really like where this is going tbqh. I had hoped that my reads would be expanded / challenged. Not really taken as a pro v con push by Fynal v RR.

Armor said:
Was going to post, then didn't want to.
Can you explain why you didn't want to post? Lurking is anti-town behavior and admitting to lurk intentionally as a choice makes me inclined to ask why you are choosing to make this game difficult for those of us who do want to play in it.

Armor said:
My motivation to play this has diminished with the amount of content
Can you explain why the addition of content has made you aversive to engaging in further play? If anything activity should inspire you to play, rather than detract from your level of interest.

Armor said:
I'd be okay with my own lynch, but that'd be a **** move to my faction.
... "my faction" ... That is an awfully awkward way of saying you're town...
 
Top Bottom