BoomFrog
Smash Lord
- Joined
- Mar 23, 2020
- Messages
- 1,493
I'm going to try and take a fresh look at this to check myself.
Reads ignoring teams:
FrozenFlame - Frozen is trying crazy hard to actually dissect the game here. This is a far cry from VanillaMafia scum!Frozen who just coasted by and struggled to keeps his reads constant from Day to Day. Sorry FF I don't think you are this good as scum. If FF is scum I'm willing to lose the game here.
Vicarin - If Vic is scum then he got the fake claim of Vanillizer+protector and decided to lean into it hard, including giving up a kill on purpose and committing to bring in endgame with a confirmed townie. Possible, but unlikely. His participation had been low which isn't great. The thoughts about the investigations makes sense from someone sincerely thinking about Fonti's claim. Although as scum maybe he still didn't know which BP was safe to shoot. He did offer his scum reads D3 without pressure which he gets turnout points for. Overall, unlikely to be scum.
Toyzab - Hasn't read back which is understandable as their were very kind in the first place to replace in, in our time of need. I know Sabrar well and his early playful attitude was townie, scum!Sabrar is generally more reserved. UP's thoughts were town motivated as well, especially the "lists are all the same" thing. Trisscar has been very reserved and very against committing to a read. She's very unbothered by being the building wagon, which is townie. The omgus on FF despite knowing it will look bad is townie too. I don't like her actions, but her tone is very idgaf, which feels town. I'm leaning town, but definitely stays in the PoE.
Red Ryu - Finally doing some real scum hunting today. I like the questions he is asking and followed up. Doing half a vote analysis and then never drawing conclusions D2 gets some scummy points. Doubled up power is weird, but IC and Masons is doubled up and jailer+medic is doubled up so maybe it's a theme. If he hadn't shot Bessie I'd be considering him seriously as a teammate. I'm starting to think I should be anyway. #HBC | FrozeηFlame Does Red like to bus?
Fontisian - I don't think I need to repeat myself here.
Overall analysis:
FF is out of consideration for me. Fonti is not aligned with Triss. Red+Vic is too many conspiracy theories put together. That leaves:
Fonti-Red
Fonti-Vic
Triss-Red
Triss-Vic
I'll have to come back to this tomorrow if I have time and see if I can find evidence for it against those four teams. Unfortunately, I think this is all you guys are getting because I will be very busy tomorrow so will probably be barely keeping up with the thread. I still strongly prefer Fonti over Trisscar.
Reads ignoring teams:
FrozenFlame - Frozen is trying crazy hard to actually dissect the game here. This is a far cry from VanillaMafia scum!Frozen who just coasted by and struggled to keeps his reads constant from Day to Day. Sorry FF I don't think you are this good as scum. If FF is scum I'm willing to lose the game here.
Vicarin - If Vic is scum then he got the fake claim of Vanillizer+protector and decided to lean into it hard, including giving up a kill on purpose and committing to bring in endgame with a confirmed townie. Possible, but unlikely. His participation had been low which isn't great. The thoughts about the investigations makes sense from someone sincerely thinking about Fonti's claim. Although as scum maybe he still didn't know which BP was safe to shoot. He did offer his scum reads D3 without pressure which he gets turnout points for. Overall, unlikely to be scum.
Toyzab - Hasn't read back which is understandable as their were very kind in the first place to replace in, in our time of need. I know Sabrar well and his early playful attitude was townie, scum!Sabrar is generally more reserved. UP's thoughts were town motivated as well, especially the "lists are all the same" thing. Trisscar has been very reserved and very against committing to a read. She's very unbothered by being the building wagon, which is townie. The omgus on FF despite knowing it will look bad is townie too. I don't like her actions, but her tone is very idgaf, which feels town. I'm leaning town, but definitely stays in the PoE.
Red Ryu - Finally doing some real scum hunting today. I like the questions he is asking and followed up. Doing half a vote analysis and then never drawing conclusions D2 gets some scummy points. Doubled up power is weird, but IC and Masons is doubled up and jailer+medic is doubled up so maybe it's a theme. If he hadn't shot Bessie I'd be considering him seriously as a teammate. I'm starting to think I should be anyway. #HBC | FrozeηFlame Does Red like to bus?
Fontisian - I don't think I need to repeat myself here.
Overall analysis:
FF is out of consideration for me. Fonti is not aligned with Triss. Red+Vic is too many conspiracy theories put together. That leaves:
Fonti-Red
Fonti-Vic
Triss-Red
Triss-Vic
I'll have to come back to this tomorrow if I have time and see if I can find evidence for it against those four teams. Unfortunately, I think this is all you guys are getting because I will be very busy tomorrow so will probably be barely keeping up with the thread. I still strongly prefer Fonti over Trisscar.