I mean, even looking at the MUs he loses (and slightly, mind), how many of them are relevant? Cloud, Rosa, Sheik, ZSS, Mewtwo, Falcon.I'm no expert on Lucario, but whenever I look at a Lucario MU chart I see a high-mid tier character at best. It's possible Lucario players are too pessimistic, but which relevant MUs does he win that makes him top tier? Do you think be beats Diddy Kong? Here is Tsu's latest MU chart: https://twitter.com/tkmtbs/status/931995376738975744
According to Tsu, Lucario loses -2 to Fox, and -1 to Wario, Zero Suit Samus, Ness, Cloud, Rosalina, Sheik, Bowser, Corrin, Mewtwo, Captain Falcon, Lucas, and Mr. Game & Watch. He goes even with some relevant characters, such as Marth/Lucina, Mario, Diddy Kong, Bayonetta, Ryu, and Sonic. While he does beat 19 (20 if you count Dark Pit) characters, only Pikachu is high tier, and none of them are top tiers. Some notable wins (+1): Donkey Kong (huh), Mega Man, Villager, Pikachu, Luigi.
That... Is not the MU chart of a top tier character. It is not the MU chart of a high tier character either, in my opinion. A skilled Lucario can win any MU (though Fox is very hard, apparently), but that doesn't make him top tier/high tier. If that were the case, then Pit should have been much higher on the tier list (though Pit probably has more -2 MUs than Lucario does).
Like Mario, we're left with three reasonable options:
#1: Lucario isn't top/high tier.
#2: Lucario's MU chart is better than Tsu thinks.
#3: Lucario does lose those MUs, but is still top/high tier.
Again, I find #3 highly questionable, which leaves #1 and #2. Is Tsu wrong? If so, then Lucario might be high tier (probably not top tier though, unless Tsu is very wrong). If not, then Lucario should drop. I think Lucario should drop and that he's a bit overrated (it should be noted that ESAM put Lucario in mid tier in his latest tier list).
Of those, we've seen Lucario beat most of them in tournament, multiple times (hi Sheik). Falcon and ZSS are the only two real roadblocks (and I'm not quite sure about Cloud - need to see Tsu vs Tweek going Cloud).
So if we're looking at how his MU spread holds up against the type of bracket you'd see at an S-tier, you'll see Lucario is quite capable of making top 8, and consistently. Very few mid-tiers can say that much.
Beyond that, Lucario's fundamental ability makes all of his -1s volatile. Fox is a -2 because he's in many ways immune to that volatility. He abuses Lucario's frame data, makes him wary of using his top tier projectile, can kill him when he has aura and when he doesn't rather easily, abuses his recovery, prevents him from landing, etc.
Most of his -1s are actually pretty subject to the volatility of aura. That makes them distinctly more winnable for him that most other characters' -1 MUs.
Tl;dr: Lucario's spread has only one, relatively uncommon hard counter. He goes even against most of the best/common characters in the game, and for the instances he doesn't, the volatility of aura allows him a stronger chance than a traditional -1 would show.
Personally, I wouldn't just count "losing MUs" - how bad those MUs are is more important. For example, Leo's Marth MU chart has 10 losing MUs.