Youtube Memes Mafia Game Over! Town... WINS :D lolwut end scum win streak B****EZ!!!

[#HBC | Dancer]

Yes, shooting Night 1 was a horrible idea, and probably my worst mistake this game. IIRC, I think I thought I would of been dead by now, so I figured that I might as well of shot. Didn't turned out as planned.

 

[X1-12]

Gheb are you suggest a NL and ask mafia nicely to shoot the SK?

 

[X1-12]

@Sword: did you at any point breadcrumb vig?

 

[#HBC | Dancer]

I did not. I never breadcrumb.

 

[~ Gheb ~]

Gheb are you suggest a NL and ask mafia nicely to shoot the SK?

i dun suggest anything. if i got sumthin' 2 say i say it.

if i thought it 2 b teh best course o' action i woulda said so but idk. just sayin' it in case we lynch town 2day mafia's in teh cornah 2. prolly ain' enuff 2 rely on it but sth 2 keep in teh back of yer mind maybe.

 

[X1-12]

Everyone post your top scumpicks and explain why.

 

[~ Gheb ~]

my scumlist hasnt changed rly. liek, i still think gova's teh play cuz he simply coasted thru teh game whenver scum was in trouble [aka always] n now his mates r dead he dun kno wut 2 do. goin' ahead n say dat its p. much impossible 2 make dat lil input teh way we played teh game so far.

teh main diff. is im unsure nao about sword when i used 2 think he was obvtown earlier im not sure 'bout him nao.

 

[#HBC | Dancer]

Gova
Nabe
KevinM

In that order.

Gheb pretty much summed up the reasoning for suspecting Gova the most. I think he should go toDay.

Nabe I always suspected throughout this game for several different reasons. However, the main reasons for suspecting him now is simply because, besides Gova, I don't think anyone else is mafia. O

KevinM never really helped, at all. He was on correct bandwagons and all but he never did any of the leg work. Swiss pushed hard for KevinM which makes me less suspicious of him.

 

[#HBC | Nabe]

Would really like to hear opinions on 975.

I think that nobody laying claim to that third kill lends a lot of credence to an indy PGO, putting Swords as town. Still unwilling to believe maf/vig/SK, unless Gord was betting on a combo of scum hitting other scum and the JK making good picks. And lol I wouldn't put it past him. But in the end, I think that whether or not Swords is scum depends on the setup, which is one reason that Gova is a better choice.

Gheb is not mafia. Kev is not mafia. X1 is town.

 

[Gova]

@X1:

@Gova:

1. Okay, but I didn't. Sue me. Yes I thought Swiss was scum but he was doing stuff, I didn't want to kill someone who was actually doing stuff. I know that I could of been wrong so I didn't shoot him. GLG on the otherhand was just plain deadweight.
2. Only two Night kills made me think that the indie had no nk. Didn't really think about the possibilty of a doc admititly. Probably my worse mistake this game.
3. SK

1. I will:

@Gheb: You would wether lynch dead weight than one of Swiss or X1? Why? Those two are going to be bothering us this entire game, one of them has to die if you ask me.

Swiss, most of the reasons why I find Kuz to be scummy revolve around flips (specifically yours). Besides, as I stated before you or X1 should pretty much have to go toDay since something like 90% of toDay has been spent discussing which one of you should be lynched.

I highly suggest that either Swiss or X1 go toDay guys, we can't just NOT lynch them after all of the trouble we went through.

I agree with Bed. Why aren't we lynching Swiss or X1? Practicaly the entire Day was spent revovling around those two, why are we all of the sudden flipping around and lynching someone else? Something doesn't feel right about this.

It pretty much has to be one of those two toDay. Still don't know which. Lynching Swiss is probably safer, but I really feel like X1 could be lying. Ehhh . . . *flips a coin*

okay, I think I'm going to have to unvote vote Swiss

In the end, I simply can't see a scum X1 doing this. I hope I'm not mistaken about this.
?

What you say, and what you do don't line up. You said one has to die D1, it didn't happen but come Night you chose to kill GLG over Swiss. If you didn't want to take the huge resposibility of his death why did you keep advocating for his lynch D1 and D2. A death is a death no matter how it happens and responsibility would land on your shoulders if you got him lynched because we know you were pushing for it where-as if you NK'ed him we would have no idea who did it.

2. So at the start of D2, after seeing your kill and the mafia kill, you just automatically arrived at the conclusion that there is an indy with no NK?

 

[X1-12]

As Gova is proving its in the interest of mafia to kill the indy as well

 

[#HBC | Dancer]

1. Again, I thought Swiss was scum, yes. Again though, I admit to the possibility that I could of been wrong about him, so I didn't shoot him. A death caused by lynching and a death caused by shooting are not the same. Lynching is a group effort, which I wanted. Shooting (as a vig) is just an individuals decision. Besides, what are you even trying to get at here? What does it matter that I was on Swiss'es case and didn't shoot him?

2. Yes

@Nabe: I think the possibility of either an uniformed town PGO or indie PGO is possible. Leaning uninformed town PGO in that case. I actually don't think though that the existance of a town vig is impossible with a town PGO. Think of it like this:

10 townies.
3 mafia

1 doc
1 town roleblocker
1 cop
1 vig
1 mediam
1 town PGO
4 VTs
1 mafia goon
1 godfather
1 mafia PR, or maybe another goon?

In which case either mafia or town could be killed off by the PGO. However, by just looking at the numbers, town would be more likely to be killed off by the PGO due to more visiting roles. If this is the set up is correct, then maybe that's suppose to be compensated for the fact that there is an extra townie plus roleblocker and doc?

Anyway we look at this, the set up seems unlikely in one way or another.

 

[#HBC | Dancer]

Oh, just to clarify, even though I think the possibility of an indie PGO, I think it's unlikely. Just want to make that clear.

 

[Gova]

As Gova is proving its in the interest of mafia to kill the indy as well

If you're implying I'm mafia, you are wrong as I am town. I'm just doing what I can before I go.

At this point its likely indy and scum are both 1 man factions with a kill, we should take either of these lynches. I don't blame him for not looking for connections from Swiss though since he's a devious ******.

i have good reason to doubt nabe's claim, will explain after all claims are done

@nabe: theres nothing else to your role is there?

Forgot about this. What is your reason to doubt Nabe's claim?

Everyone post your top scumpicks and explain why.

Sword as stated.

I would put Kev over Nabe now. He said his two lynch picks for today were Gheb and Sword but all of a sudden he's okay with my lynch?


@Swords

Simply put, I think you are lying.

@Nabe

Missed your question earlier about where I would put myself in the claiming order. It wouldn't have mattered to me. I'm town and I would claim when town says it's beneficial to do so.

 

[X1-12]

I thought him saying watson was a post restriction.

 

[#HBC | Nabe]

An uninformed town PGO? Sounds a bit iffy to me.

Okay, looking at flavour. Medium was Johnathon the Zombie, RB was Numa Numa, Doctor was some martial arts thing. There is a certain amount of sense made in the flavour. Scum so far were Star Wars Kid and that finger kid, those make less sense.

If there were a PGO, it would be X1 or maybe Gheb.
X1, any role flavour behind you being a cop?

 

[#HBC | Nabe]

PGO could be Gova too, that video is really bad and could kill some people.

 

[X1-12]

post-restricted unconfirmed sanity cop who is also an uninformed PGO? I think not.

 

[X1-12]

i really suggest we stop talking about setup and flava toDay

 

[X1-12]

Lynch Gova

Sword DON'T SHOOT WHATEVER GOVA FLIPS. Going against this or disagreeing with me on this will result in it being taken as fact that you are not town.

 

[#HBC | Dancer]

Okay, I won't shoot. My only worry is if there is a SK, how would you be able to tell that I didn't shoot?

 

[X1-12]

I'm discarding the possibility of there genuinely being a standard SK, a vig and a mafia kill. Sorry but sold wouldn't ever approve that.

 

[#HBC | Nabe]

I agree that Swords shouldn't shoot, but what if someone hits the assumed PGO, making a total of two NKs? How would we know the difference?

 

[KevinM]

How about we lynch Gova and you chuckle****s don't commit a night action?

Easy as that son.

 

[#HBC | Nabe]

lol.
I would rather X1 cops someone, personally. If he lives, we get a report on who's not scum and also who's not a PGO, since he'll have survived.

 

[KevinM]

If Gova flips last scum like we all suspect there is absolutely no reason for him to cop.

 

[#HBC | Nabe]

Since when do we not suspect an indy, what?

 

[Gova]

Except that I won't flip scum, everyone just says I'm suspicious but no one has provided reasoning for it except for Gheb.

 

[KevinM]

Since when do we not suspect an indy, what?

I was under the impression that we all assume Gova will flip the last scum member correct?

We're not indy hunting, we're scum hunting, so if we're lynching that is basically our statement.

I never said there wasn't an indy.

Semantics though

 

[#HBC | Nabe]

Mm. I assumed that by scum you meant anti-town in general.

Anyway, if X1 were to tell us who he targeted toMorrow, then we'd know that player wasn't a PGO, since he'd still be alive. He could probably tell us who he'll be targeting now; tailor is IMO unlikely given that there was already a godfather. Two roles to screw with one cop in a 13-player game is probably a no. Unless he'd like to keep it secret so that scum don't know, which is just as well, up to him.

 

[#HBC | Dancer]

Eh, let us not get hung up on ideas just as their being a PGO. It could be anything at this point.

vote Gova

gova is now at L_2

@Nabe: Who are your scumpicks as of now?

 

[#HBC | Gorf]

6. Gova- (2): Nabe, Sword

3. Gheb_01- (1): KevinM

1. X1-12- (0)

4. KevinM- (0)

8. SwordDancer- (0)

9. Nabe- (0)

With 6 alive, it takes 4 to lynch. Deadline is January 3rd, 3:30 PM Est.

 

[#HBC | Nabe]

X1 is town, GF flip means a cop exists and therefore he is town. Everyone else is fair game to me, but I'm expecting Gova to flip mafia. You're not mafia because of X1's result, and also because a tailor is unlikely as I've said. So if Gova is town, I'd have to choose between Gheb and Kev toMorrow, both of whom seem obv. not mafia at this point. Leaning Kev if that's the case, because he could just be superbussing, while Gheb seems more genuinely town.

 

[X1-12]

Deadline 2 days away

Unless you have anything to post, we are lynching Gova - If you post with nothing new then we will just go ahead and lynch him.

@Nabe: I will stake ££ and my dice that Gheb is town


Night actions: Vig no shoot whatever happens. If gova flips maf I wont investigate. If he flips indy I will investigate Kev, if he flips town I'll either investigate kev or not investigate at all

 

[#HBC | Nabe]

I agree, Gheb seems very genuinely town. At the very least, I think we can assume he is not mafia.

 

[X1-12]

I'm confident he's not indy either. I've played in a game with him as indy and pegged him off meta I've also read part of another game of his where he was a SK and his indy meta seems the same as his mafia meta

 

[HaileyM]

unvote
Vote Gova

If he doesn't flip Maf feel free to clear me.

-KevinM (sorry about that!)

 

[#HBC | Gorf]

6. Gova- (3): Nabe, Sword, KevinM

1. X1-12- (0)

3. Gheb_01- (0):

4. KevinM- (0)

8. SwordDancer- (0)

9. Nabe- (0)

With 6 alive, it takes 4 to lynch. Deadline is January 3rd, 3:30 PM Est.

 

[X1-12]

bro, thats 3 votes not 2

 

[#HBC | Dancer]

Okay, before we lynch, I just want to ask two questions.

@MOD: Just to make sure, you did have to get this set up spproved, right?

@X1: What do you make of Gova voting Swiss last minute?

unvote

I will revote once these questions are answered.