I see.No I mean real smash debaters. The jigglypuff boards had two smash debaters, Illinialex, who was logical (sometimes) and Maniclysane who was probably hands down the dumbest poster I have ever witnessed (He's fun to talk to in a chat though).
You aren't looking in the right places, perhaps. Most Smash Debaters are extremely smart posters.
Also, Brawl/Melee=/=IRL.
Just saying.