Will you press the button?

[Wario Wario Wario]

Basically give a good gaming related criteria, doesn't have to be Smash, but also add a negative consequence, and the next poster gives a yes or no answer, along with reasoning if they desire, and give another criteria with a positive and negative consequence, for example:

"Waluigi gets in, but Ridley is cut"

"No, Waluigi is a stinky poopoo peepee head

Your most wanted gets in, but your previous most wanted who got in gets cut"

So on. I'll start:

Crash Bandicoot gets in, but Banjo is cut.

 

[Hollywoodrok12]

No. As good as Crash would be, Banjo needs this way more than he does.

The Fire Emblem characters in Smash are all cut, but are replaced with the Fire Emblem characters playable in Dragalia Lost (so Roy, Ike, Robin, Lucina, Corrin & Byleth are replaced with Alfonse, Fjorm, Veronica, Sharena, Peony, & (Young) Tiki. Marth and Chrom stay.)

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Yes. While it'd still be overrepped, at least there'd be less swords.

every clone will be decloned into a fully independent character - EXCEPT Ganondorf.

 

[Hollywoodrok12]

If it takes away from the amount of newcomers that get in like how Everyone is Here did, no. Otherwise, yes.

Your all-time most wanted is somewhere in FP2, but so is your all-time least wanted.

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Yes. Shadow is fine if I get my boy Muddy.

Beat from Jet Set Radio is a newcomer, but as a bonus fighter with no music.

 

[StrangeKitten]

Yes. The lack of music is lamentable for sure, but I wouldn't pass up such a cool character

Your most wanted gets in, but they have a mechanic where they randomly take 40% damage per stock

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Depends on how common it is, if every single stock then no, but if it's every now and then yes.

The Pikmin vocal songs come back, but on the second loop they turn into voice crack meme covers for the rest of the match.

 

[Perkilator]

Depends on how common it is, if every single stock then no, but if it's every now and then yes.

The Pikmin vocal songs come back, but on the second loop they turn into voice crack meme covers for the rest of the match.

HAHAHA no.

Waluigi gets in, but so does Lyn.

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Yes. FE reps are, unfortunately, an inevitability at this point.

We get more Sonic characters, but they take up the entirety of Fighters Pass 2.

 

[Perkilator]

Yes. FE reps are, unfortunately, an inevitability at this point.

We get more Sonic characters, but they take up the entirety of Fighters Pass 2.

No.

We get 10 fighters for Vol. 2 instead of 6, but Byleth and Min Min switch passes.

 

[Hollywoodrok12]

No.

We get 10 fighters for Vol. 2 instead of 6, but Byleth and Min Min switch passes.

Yes. They were both huge disappointments for me, so I don’t care. 4 more fighters means 4 more chances for us to get what would be (in my eyes, at least), a good DLC pick that isn’t Banjo.

The rest of FP2 is all your least wanteds, but every fighter pick in the next game is someone you want (if you run out of most wanteds, it’s other characters you really like)

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

No.

Your favourite obscure one-instalment game gets a sequel, but it sells worse than the first game did.

 

[Perkilator]

No.

Your favourite obscure one-instalment game gets a sequel, but it sells worse than the first game did.

Not on my life.

COVID-19 is wiped from existence and the forced lockdown never happens, but it's the ONLY major thing from 2020 that gets wiped.

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Yes. There is literally no downside to this.

There is a Sony rep, but they only get in because the Switch is Nintendo's last console and their first game for a former competitor's console is a PS-exclusive port of Ultimate with extra content.

 

[Perkilator]

Yes. There is literally no downside to this.

There is a Sony rep, but they only get in because the Switch is Nintendo's last console and their first game for a former competitor's console is a PS-exclusive port of Ultimate with extra content.

Mmmm, maybe just a tap so I can see what it'll look like as a vision.

Ultimate's rereleased and has all the DLC, Coin Battles, Brawl-style target test, and trailers to view in Movies at your leisure. But the starting roster is all of Smash 64's roster and Ultimate's base game non-Echo newcomers (and Piranha Plant), meaning you have to unlock every other character.

 

[Hollywoodrok12]

Mmmm, maybe just a tap so I can see what it'll look like as a vision.

Ultimate's rereleased and has all the DLC, Coin Battles, Brawl-style target test, and trailers to view in Movies at your leisure. But the starting roster is all of Smash 64's roster and Ultimate's base game non-Echo newcomers (and Piranha Plant), meaning you have to unlock every other character.

are there new fighters for said rerelease? If so, yes. If not, reluctant yes.

all Pokemon are brought back to the mainline games for good, but Smash’s roster next game is less than half as large as Ultimate, including newcomers.

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

No. 50 out of 80 is worse than 200 out of 800

Every single Sonic game, past and future, will become good, but they'll all have no soundtrack

 

[Perkilator]

No. 50 out of 80 is worse than 200 out of 800

Every single Sonic game, past and future, will become good, but they'll all have no soundtrack

No. You might as well make them novel adaptations.

Sonic gets a rework, but it makes him mid to low tier.

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Yes. Low tiers are the most fun to watch IMO.

Your most wanted gets in FP2, but the rest of FP2 are all from the same genre (for example: if your most wanted is Waluigi, all other newcomers are from sports games)

 

[Perkilator]

Yes. Low tiers are the most fun to watch IMO.

Your most wanted gets in FP2, but the rest of FP2 are all from the same genre (for example: if your most wanted is Waluigi, all other newcomers are from sports games)

YES. SCREW THE RULES. Sora's my most wanted, so I don't mind more JRPG characters at all.

Waluigi gets in, but characters like Crash are Assist Trophies in his place.

 

[Hollywoodrok12]

Yes. I need 1 victory in Ultimate that wasn't a complete shoe-in, and I'll sacrifice other characters (even my other most wanteds) to do it. Sorry, Crash fans.

Your least wanted gets in, but you become the best player in the world when playing as said least wanted. (only as them. If you switch to someone else, you lose it until you go back to them)

 

[Perkilator]

Yes. I need 1 victory in Ultimate that wasn't a complete shoe-in, and I'll sacrifice other characters (even my other most wanteds) to do it. Sorry, Crash fans.

Your least wanted gets in, but you become the best player in the world when playing as said least wanted. (only as them. If you switch to someone else, you lose it until you go back to them)

Eh, no.

Bandana Dee gets in, but we get a stage based on Pyribbit's boss arena.

 

[Hollywoodrok12]

Eh, no.

Bandana Dee gets in, but we get a stage based on Pyribbit's boss arena.

Yes. Would pick Another Dimension, but it's still a Modern Kirby stage, and Bandana Dee's still using his spear, so it works for me!

You get to pick the FP2 of your dreams with the ability to replace Min Min with someone else if you so desire, but your GSP for every fighter, regardless of whether or not they're in Elite Smash, including your FP2 is set to 1 (the worst possible GSP).

 

[Perkilator]

Yes. Would pick Another Dimension, but it's still a Modern Kirby stage, and Bandana Dee's still using his spear, so it works for me!

You get to pick the FP2 of your dreams with the ability to replace Min Min with someone else if you so desire, but your GSP for every fighter, regardless of whether or not they're in Elite Smash, including your FP2 is set to 1 (the worst possible GSP).

No, because I don't wanna take away from fans of Min Min (especially not to lock an Assist Trophy's playability behind a $6 paywall).

Chrom is replaced with Caeda, but Byleth's other three weapons are taken away from him.

 

[crazybenjamin]

For me, there is literally no upside. No way.
The missing stages return, upgraded to full HD, but 10 random stages already in the game are downgraded to N64-level graphics

 

[Perkilator]

For me, there is literally no upside. No way.
The missing stages return, upgraded to full HD, but 10 random stages already in the game are downgraded to N64-level graphics

Nope.

PAC-MAZE returns, but so does Rumble Falls.

 

[crazybenjamin]

...and this time there's no downside. Yes.
A WOL sequel with cutscenes and platforming is added, but Smashdown and Squad Strike are removed

 

[Perkilator]

...and this time there's no downside. Yes.
A WOL sequel with cutscenes and platforming is added, but Smashdown and Squad Strike are removed

Eh, sure.

Yellow Devil, Metal Face and Dark Emperor are added as Classic Mode bosses, but WoL gets taken out.

 

[crazybenjamin]

No, but a "boss rematch" feature might have sweetened the deal.

Said "boss rematch" feature is added, but you can't rematch regular spirits anymore

 

[Perkilator]

No, but a "boss rematch" feature might have sweetened the deal.

Said "boss rematch" feature is added, but you can't rematch regular spirits anymore

A soul for a soul, I suppose.

Waluigi is revealed at E3 2018, but Ridley is a boss again.

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Yes. Would've saved us from a lot of drama, heh!

Waluigi gets added to Brawl, but only because WarioWare was a Waluigi game instead and as such Waluigi is in before Wario.

 

[Cadillac]

Why not? Sure.

Hornet gets in as a fighter, but she's the only indie character in this pass.

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Yes. Honestly I wasn't even expecting ANY indies!

The next Smash game is your dream Smash game in almost every way, except the character roster.

 

[Perkilator]

Yes. Honestly I wasn't even expecting ANY indies!

The next Smash game is your dream Smash game in almost every way, except the character roster.

Sure, why not?

Boss Spirits can now be re-fought via the Spirit rematch feature, but you have to clear Classic Mode with every non-DLC character after beating WoL.

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

No. Classic mode bad

The next Smash game has 250 different fighters to choose from, but has no single player content except Vs. CPU.

 

[Perkilator]

No. Classic mode bad

The next Smash game has 250 different fighters to choose from, but has no single player content except Vs. CPU.

No. Quality over quantity.

Target Test comes back, but only the DLC characters get unique ones while the base roster has the Brawl-style one where the design changes based on difficulty.

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

No

The next Smash game is a 3D arena fighter spin-off, but the only characters are the original 8, Sonic, Pac-Man, Mewtwo and Bowser

 

[Perkilator]

No

The next Smash game is a 3D arena fighter spin-off, but the only characters are the original 8, Sonic, Pac-Man, Mewtwo and Bowser

No.

Master Chief gets in, but Bubsy is an Assist Trophy where he does nothing but float around, waiting to be hit.

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Yes. Bubsy for Smash!

SSBU gets a full custom character maker, but making actual video game characters is banned for no apparent reason so you can only publish characters of cartoons, anime and memes.

 

[Perkilator]

Yes. Bubsy for Smash!

SSBU gets a full custom character maker, but making actual video game characters is banned for no apparent reason so you can only publish characters of cartoons, anime and memes.

In other words, something I can already do by making a Mii Fighter?


Shadow is Sonic's Echo, but Chrom is replaced with Alm (whoneould feasibly be based on his Fire Emblem Gaiden version).