Also, FLUDD is not an addition
Okay, so now were going to go off to Neverland with everyone else who's dreaming in their own world, right?
You might as well say that the sky isn't blue before making an opening statement like that, just so I KNOW you're insane.
since the only Melee starters still unconfirmed are Ness, Captain Falcon, and Sheik, I can infer that it's probably not being done for anticipation.
How would that NOT be for anticipation?
silence is generally incriminating, we can try to apply logic to figure out what we don't know.
That depends on the perspective.
You provided facts, yes, but the only ones that actually support your argument are the facts that a Sheik design has been submitted and that Farore's wind is part of Zelda's moveset. Everything else was also speculation.
This is the EXACT same thing with the Shiek is OUT argument.
You people keep pretending there's evidence supporting the argument... THERE IS NOT. You people keep making stuff up and using it to support an argument that doesn't exist!! Arguments that I think are lame:
-Keeping Zelda's moves secret. This can mean either a return or an exclusion. Nothing that great.
-The continuity issue is NOT an issue. REALLY. Brawl's Zelda is not just "TP Zelda", nor is Link just TP Link. They are representations of the characters through the years. Anything can happen provided it's in tune with any of the games. TP Contains Shiekah literature, buildings, character, and clothing worn by ZELDA herself. The tradition is still active. Moreover, Link's earrings are part of a Shiekah tradition.
-Shiek is NOT insignificant - NOBODY, in the entire god **** HISTORY of OoT's EXISTENCE has said anything like that, on any site, from any person, in any piece of literature I've ever seen, UNTIL the "Will Shiek return?" topics started. In addition, to claim something as outrageous as this, makes you look like a moron.
-Zelda sucks on her own. No, she is still her own character even with a Shiek transformation, go play with her, go have fun, her lack of a down b doesn't mean they they should remove such a cool transformation mechanic.
There is nothing to support either side of the argument anyways, as far as I'm concerned. Those are jsut a few points I thought of at the moment. I'm not trying to disprove anything, but in all honesty I think those points are pretty accurate and should be considered by everyone when making their claims.
The BEST evidence we have if you ask me is the fact that Zelda tuned into Shiek in Melee. As a sequel, it is reasonable to assume that they'll keep this and build on it in Brawl as in basically EVERY other character in a sequel (ala 64 ---> Melee), but YOU NEVER KNOW. All I'm saying is that to me, that's really the only thing anyone should be building their argument on. Not random ideas, not questionable interviews, not personal agitaions, just what we've been GIVEN, what we've SEEN, and what has been TESTED and PROVEN based on an established formula.