Lmao. Then pass those thoughts over here. Let's hear em.
Or if there's nothing you want to share, any questions you want tossed my way? This inactivity is killing me.
-
Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!
You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!
Whose Mafia Is it Anyway - Game Over!
- Thread starter giraffelasergun
- Start date
Or if there's nothing you want to share, any questions you want tossed my way? This inactivity is killing me.
The first one is whatever. I also think we've hit one because I still think Soup is a scumbag.@#HBC | marshy
What are your thoughts on Gorf now? regarding your 345
Hey#HBC | Ryker , what do you make of these 2 posts by marshy?
1035
1059
The second one is more of the wishy-washy nature of "should I vote Soup, should I not vote Soup" that characterized Marshy during EoD. If Soup flips town, I really don't like the way Marshy's EoD looks.
There is such a world of difference between Soup and Orange's tone, direction, and actions. Come on.Lore is self serving attitude a scum tell?
Orange was town and at the end he was asking for your lynch despite thinking you were town.
Neither has entered the range I would kill. If you want to know which one I find worse, wait for about 48 hours so I can see how they approach this day phase.
I don't hate the way that either of them approached the end of the day yesterday. I disagree with them about the way Soup looks, but I would much rather fry FF for that than either of them. They sit somewhere near the middle of my list.
Okay, time to remind people why Soup needs to die.
Fair, that's about where I'm sitting too, especially on Gorf. With Tom I'm curious about what his answer will be to my question. Thanks for the answer.
God Soup has posted just so much JUNK
I also hate that his name is intentionally difficult to tag and iso
Isn't that the same with every HBC member?
His "s" isn't an s. It's a special character.
Fair
#HBC | Gorf
toastin walrus since 4/20 maaaan
lore if you were to describe your own method of scumhunting in a vacuum, how do you find scum?
Typically by asking questions, getting hard stances down from people, and committing hard to lynches until I'm shown decent evidence they aren't the lynch. I'd rather tunnel a bit and see how people perform under focused pressure rather than half ass it.
But I've had it shown repeatedly to me that the tunneling is just plain ****ing bad, so I'm trying to work on it.
Hang Soup
Soup has 5 pages of posts which exhibit multiple stretches of complete **** where he memes for a time. I'm not gonna bury you in quotes, but if your memory is so short that you take issue with what I claim he's done, then you can come and ask me and I'll fetch them. So first, I'm going to lay some groundwork.
We do not trust AtE from Soup. We do not read tone from Soup. We do not play that game because he has utilized these things before. This is the slot who faked an outburst and replaced out of a game in order to get a town read for the guy who replaced into his slot. Soup has a HISTORY of this **** and his play is scummy as balls and doesn't line up with a frustrated townie.
1.) Hammer vote.
His first issue is his Ryker "hammer." This post was shortly after the hammer.
The thing is, it doesn't matter. Setting me to L-1 that early when players could roll in and hammer is a ****ing terrible look. It was a joke, regardless of alignment, but it was a terrible vote if town and a very convenient way to put a townie at L-1 where a quickhammer could accidentally occur as scum. **** all the "IT WAS ONLY JOKE" garbage because it does look awful. This is what originally got me onto Soup, but it's not what I want him dead.
2.) Immediate Post Claim Behavior
For the next few hours, Soup does nothing I like. He unvotes Lore saying "I may be wrong on Lore." He calls Spak town on tone. He says the Pythag push is really good (it's not and
#HBC | Gorf
has talked about it more than me) and votes him. He continues to snap at people who dislike him. He responds with phoned in answers (Like him answering a question about reads from Ranmaru with the fact that he and Kary are unaligned). He unvotes Lore saying "I may be wrong on Lore." Nothing he does here takes effort. He, in fact, phones in multiple reasons why he doesn't want to give any effort at this point. It's mostly reactive and Soup stays like that, which brings me into my third point.
3.) Extended Post Claim Behavior And What I Perceive As The Motivation
I think Soup blew up. I don't think that was faked. However, I think he's a scumbag who exploded. The reason he was so reactionary and awful immediately following his claim is because he didn't want to put in the effort if he was going to get CC'd. He just wanted someone to out themselves and then hit the bricks (which, now that I think about it, means there's probably a roleblocker if Soup is scum). That's why, until we'd heard from most of the cast and there was a relaxation of the pressure on Soup, we never got the read list. Too much work if he was just gonna die, but then he woke up and went "huh, I'm still breathing, maybe I can get out of this."
His readlist is trash. Like, super trash. His **** posting when he realized he was slipping to the next phase on that claim reads like gloating. On the whole, I don't see Soup trying to be proactive except for after he's been called out for a lack of initiative.
I hate this slot. I will not stomach this slot. I do not know why others are willing to give it a pass. His explosion is not townie. His hammer vote is not townie. His claim is not townie. His reads are not townie. His **** posting is not townie. He is not a townie.
Lynch him.
Soup has 5 pages of posts which exhibit multiple stretches of complete **** where he memes for a time. I'm not gonna bury you in quotes, but if your memory is so short that you take issue with what I claim he's done, then you can come and ask me and I'll fetch them. So first, I'm going to lay some groundwork.
We do not trust AtE from Soup. We do not read tone from Soup. We do not play that game because he has utilized these things before. This is the slot who faked an outburst and replaced out of a game in order to get a town read for the guy who replaced into his slot. Soup has a HISTORY of this **** and his play is scummy as balls and doesn't line up with a frustrated townie.
1.) Hammer vote.
His first issue is his Ryker "hammer." This post was shortly after the hammer.
This post was a good little while after it when he was catching heat for it. #413 I'd quote it, but it's huge text and bold.
The thing is, it doesn't matter. Setting me to L-1 that early when players could roll in and hammer is a ****ing terrible look. It was a joke, regardless of alignment, but it was a terrible vote if town and a very convenient way to put a townie at L-1 where a quickhammer could accidentally occur as scum. **** all the "IT WAS ONLY JOKE" garbage because it does look awful. This is what originally got me onto Soup, but it's not what I want him dead.
2.) Immediate Post Claim Behavior
There's the claim. It's #421.
For the next few hours, Soup does nothing I like. He unvotes Lore saying "I may be wrong on Lore." He calls Spak town on tone. He says the Pythag push is really good (it's not and
#HBC | Gorf
has talked about it more than me) and votes him. He continues to snap at people who dislike him. He responds with phoned in answers (Like him answering a question about reads from Ranmaru with the fact that he and Kary are unaligned). He unvotes Lore saying "I may be wrong on Lore." Nothing he does here takes effort. He, in fact, phones in multiple reasons why he doesn't want to give any effort at this point. It's mostly reactive and Soup stays like that, which brings me into my third point.3.) Extended Post Claim Behavior And What I Perceive As The Motivation
I think Soup blew up. I don't think that was faked. However, I think he's a scumbag who exploded. The reason he was so reactionary and awful immediately following his claim is because he didn't want to put in the effort if he was going to get CC'd. He just wanted someone to out themselves and then hit the bricks (which, now that I think about it, means there's probably a roleblocker if Soup is scum). That's why, until we'd heard from most of the cast and there was a relaxation of the pressure on Soup, we never got the read list. Too much work if he was just gonna die, but then he woke up and went "huh, I'm still breathing, maybe I can get out of this."
His readlist is trash. Like, super trash. His **** posting when he realized he was slipping to the next phase on that claim reads like gloating. On the whole, I don't see Soup trying to be proactive except for after he's been called out for a lack of initiative.
I hate this slot. I will not stomach this slot. I do not know why others are willing to give it a pass. His explosion is not townie. His hammer vote is not townie. His claim is not townie. His reads are not townie. His **** posting is not townie. He is not a townie.
Lynch him.
Either that or a Scum JOAT who can bypass protection, so they can kill without risking a possible protect.
Anyway, agreed hardcore with your post.
#HBC | ѕoup
The world is not beautiful, therefore it is.
- Joined
- Sep 15, 2010
- Messages
- 6,865
This is honestly an extremely weak case coming from you.Hang Soup
Soup has 5 pages of posts which exhibit multiple stretches of complete **** where he memes for a time. I'm not gonna bury you in quotes, but if your memory is so short that you take issue with what I claim he's done, then you can come and ask me and I'll fetch them. So first, I'm going to lay some groundwork.
We do not trust AtE from Soup. We do not read tone from Soup. We do not play that game because he has utilized these things before. This is the slot who faked an outburst and replaced out of a game in order to get a town read for the guy who replaced into his slot. Soup has a HISTORY of this **** and his play is scummy as balls and doesn't line up with a frustrated townie.
1.) Hammer vote.
His first issue is his Ryker "hammer." This post was shortly after the hammer.
This post was a good little while after it when he was catching heat for it. #413 I'd quote it, but it's huge text and bold.
The thing is, it doesn't matter. Setting me to L-1 that early when players could roll in and hammer is a ****ing terrible look. It was a joke, regardless of alignment, but it was a terrible vote if town and a very convenient way to put a townie at L-1 where a quickhammer could accidentally occur as scum. **** all the "IT WAS ONLY JOKE" garbage because it does look awful. This is what originally got me onto Soup, but it's not what I want him dead.
2.) Immediate Post Claim Behavior
There's the claim. It's #421.
For the next few hours, Soup does nothing I like. He unvotes Lore saying "I may be wrong on Lore." He calls Spak town on tone. He says the Pythag push is really good (it's not and
3.) Extended Post Claim Behavior And What I Perceive As The Motivation
I think Soup blew up. I don't think that was faked. However, I think he's a scumbag who exploded. The reason he was so reactionary and awful immediately following his claim is because he didn't want to put in the effort if he was going to get CC'd. He just wanted someone to out themselves and then hit the bricks (which, now that I think about it, means there's probably a roleblocker if Soup is scum). That's why, until we'd heard from most of the cast and there was a relaxation of the pressure on Soup, we never got the read list. Too much work if he was just gonna die, but then he woke up and went "huh, I'm still breathing, maybe I can get out of this."
His readlist is trash. Like, super trash. His **** posting when he realized he was slipping to the next phase on that claim reads like gloating. On the whole, I don't see Soup trying to be proactive except for after he's been called out for a lack of initiative.
I hate this slot. I will not stomach this slot. I do not know why others are willing to give it a pass. His explosion is not townie. His hammer vote is not townie. His claim is not townie. His reads are not townie. His **** posting is not townie. He is not a townie.
Lynch him.
And Soup goes in for the massive rebuttal!! I think he won this one!
Everyone press F to pay respect for Ryker's case, dead before it's time.
F
F
Fandangox
Smash Lord
You probably have enough self-awareness to realize your slot is not going to live long. From your PoV, if you townread Lore, why not Oracle him? if you go down first, it could potentially prevent a misslynch.
Fandangox
Smash Lord
Anything you want to say about that specific Pythag post? You did say you wanted to push the slot Day 2 last phase.
Who else would your direction be for today. Aside from Lore and Soup, who else is in your radar?
The more people talk around Soup instead of talking about him, the more people's eyes will glaze over and they will move on to other things they would rather pursue. Please cease. It didn't merit two responses.
#HBC | Gorf
toastin walrus since 4/20 maaaan
can you surface quotes backing this up (including any that dont have to do with the ran answers, kary unaligned and the phoning in of backing off of lore, but also anything outside of that)?
Fandangox
Smash Lord
Marshy atm can stay, I don't see anything that glaringly worrying or worthy of reading into as of his current phase. I'd kill Kevin mostly cause the slot has not said a lot, and their reasoning for still being on Soup yesterday after the game advanced a bit was just the RVS vote.Fandangox What are your current thoughts on Marshy and KevinM? In addition, if you had to pick one to kill (not lynch) which would it be?
Question, why ask me about these 2, specifically?
Fandangox
Smash Lord
#HBC | Gorf
toastin walrus since 4/20 maaaan
i got nothin right now bro. ask me in like 1-2 days if i havent said **** about it
Fandangox
Smash Lord
His Spak and Pythag comments fit that bill. I can dig them up.
You could argue that stronger play from you would have resulted in a stronger case one way or the other.
Case in point with this response, you're not doing much more than saying "you're wrong"
Where is he wrong?
How is he wrong?
Fandangox
Smash Lord
I will make sure to keep pestering you about it.
#HBC | Gorf
toastin walrus since 4/20 maaaan
wow ebwop fixed in quote **** me
#HBC | Gorf
toastin walrus since 4/20 maaaan
swag
Fair, I just found it hilarious how bad Soup's response was. I'm also incredibly bored at work. I'll stop.
Thanks for the answers.
They're two slots that haven't been discussed much, and I want to pin down how people feel about them as the game moves forward. Do you feel null on both, or do you have any leans in a direction?
Fandangox
Smash Lord
I do not only know exactly which game and post are you talking about, I have that Soup post picture framed and bring it to my side every time Im in a game with him.
Look, is not like you I disagree with your case at all, but YOU were one of the first slots after Kary and Gorf to decided to let him and leave and then focused on Orange.
Response to me about asking about backing down on Lore.
"Not all scum are on the wagon." Said everyone about every wagon ever.
Explanation for Spak town read. Excuses to not add more content (there's more of those too).
I can keep going.
I had no idea this happened. It's kinda ****ed up, to put it mildly.
Fandango while you're answering questions: Read on Tom?
Also, any questions for me? I'm leaving work in a bit, but will be able to answer them later depending on how busy I am.