Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!
You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!
His posts nearing EoD was essentially grabbing onto relevant topics and making idle comments about them with little to no impact. Where you the one who said you feel Pythag is noobtown?
I've heard a lot of debate outside this game lately about scumdar lists. Whether they help scum more (by giving them a guide to play around) or if they help town (by forcing people to put down reads). I assume your comment refers to that debate?
that was gorf
kary was the one to start the soup push and one of the better townies in the game. doubt well get anything from reading into it past that
I mean, if I was shortsighted about Kary based on the pretense of disliking his attitude, then me reading Frozen based only on his attitude means that I should reconsider where I'm looking.
When I'm PR I like to use my abilities as a failsafe, not a confirmation. Maybe it'd be different if I were say, a town cop, but Oracle can help confirm slots I'm less sure on. If I went on Kary on the equilvalent of a scumread, I don't imagine it's all that productive to me or to anyone else saying 'lol i orced my scumread please lynch'
Okay fair enough. And why not Lore? I know you are townreading that slot, but this is literally what most slots let you live another day for.
giraffelasergun
mayb you can kindly edit that into d1 end vc?
Maybe, but considering how I disliked Kary's attitude yet still had him as a strong town read, I think you should definitely reconsider if you're using attitudes to judge things.
He said he didn't want to "follow the hive mind" due to everyone being opposed to him, more or less. Likely salt is the culprit, but frankly I think it was a scum-centric choice.
D1 End Votecount:out rn but any chance someone can put together the dayend votecount?
It was Gorf (who spearheaded the Orange Lynch) but you already knew that.
Why would I oracle someone you guys are talking about lynching. Isn't that a complete waste? It's the same reason why I didn't pick Kary, because the fact remains that I gain nothing oracling slots that have equity to be lynched.
yea that sucks. i dont think pythag being his top scumread has any sort of bearing on my read of pythag. i stand by the case he brought being ****ty. from what i isod alone, id still say slight noobtown aside from the last post he had before he ghosted for a while on like pg 10. but im curious to look more into how he played eod cuz i know he was around.#HBC | Gorf anything to say about the flip? Still thinking Pythag may be town?
is lore still town
i generally think sometimes its beneficial not to give every single read you have if its not important. scumreads are usually always good to give if you feel incentivized to share reads. townreads are important if theyre significant enough for you to share (like spaks on soup and you because they were relevant), but theres benefits to keeping them closed too. i usually think a whole scumdar list is tough unless you just feel like being totally open and letting others question you is a style you dig. but oftentimes the less info for scum about the minutia of your reads the better fmpov
Near the end of the day, you suddenly said that you were beginning to doubt that Soup is scum. However, a (brief) look today didn't show me any posts where you explained this sudden shift. Do you mind explaining it now?
Fandangox
about Spak/Orange that I never replied to, so here it is: Spak/Orange had been an iffy slot since the beginning of the game, where I had a large back and forth with Spak about my hypothetical question. I repeatedly said that I had difficulty reading the slot, including my big Read List post where he was included. To me, he was a viable lynch choice but would have been a much better Vig shot.
#HBC | marshy
#HBC | Ryker
, what do you make of these 2 posts by marshy?
#HBC | Gorf
Yeah Gorf 100% is a slot that I want to see more from before I settle on a read.hes a coinflip ima read into when i get some time. hes done a lot of argument/logical **** that i dont think is past his range as scum. speakin of which
whats your take on frozen?
#HBC | Gorf
Thoughts on Ran?
#HBC | Ryker
Similar deal, but two different players. Tom and Gorf. Opinions on those two slots? Also, which would you kill?
Tom
One thing that people brought up is how Spak gave off Doop vibes from how he went aggro against my hypothetical. However, you did similar (but a lesser amount), yet you got a free pass. In your own words, why do you think this was passed over and ignored?
