uPick Mafia Ultimate ⭐ Game over! Did the game contain more than a single legal character by the end of its life cycle? Or is it no items, Hades only?

[#HBC | Kary]

As Maven said yesterDay, I've been playing pretty dumb, so with a now limited lynch pool, I see no reason to continue to defend myself. Unless someone wants to argue for FE or Bard, then take me away.

At most, I'd like the Town to vote if I should cut Opo's head or not before I die.

Please pull yourself together. Vote for one of Fire or Bardull. We've already had one mislynch because Maven thought he knew better than town as a whole.

 

[BarDulL]

Opossum

Why limit the lynch pool to just us three? The nomination feels scum-sided since it limits Town's options for the lynch. What if a cop (or in this case, s2n's target) had a result that we could use to lynch the true scum?

 

[BarDulL]

To be clear: I haven't decided whether or not Opossum should be gutted. Just getting a feel for the decision being made here.

 

[Deleted member]

Tbh, I agree with Opo in that Bard and FE are good options to look into but I'd say the best one to go with for now would be...
Vote: Bard

Also, current "Kill the 'possum?" votecount:
Yes: 1(Opo for choosing that damn role)
No: 1(Doop)

 

[Opossum]

Opossum

Why limit the lynch pool to just us three? The nomination feels scum-sided since it limits Town's options for the lynch. What if a cop (or in this case, s2n's target) had a result that we could use to lynch the true scum?

Because you three seemed to be the ones most people found suspicious, really. There's some risk with the role, yes, but the purpose is to prevent last minute mislynches by narrowing the scope. It just relies on the user using it at the right time and on the right targets, is all.

If we tunnel votes into just three oft-suspected people, we limit the scope to a smaller pool where we're more likely to take out scum, provided the town has been making the right calls. At worst, it's a mislynch, which could have easily happened regardless.

 

[#HBC | Kary]

Vote: Bardull

 

[#HBC | Kary]

I fully expect for Pokechu to arrive with a bingo. Let's hope so. See y'all after the sun comes up.

 

[BarDulL]

Can't tell if Opo claimed in response to allegedly being forced by Shish (time frame was roughly 2 or so minutes between their posts), but I'm inclined to think that this is the worst Town ability ever and should never be used in a game again if it's legit.

Anyway, my defense: I have no reason as scum to kill S2n. Given that myself and S2n were working towards gutting Kary, there's very little reason for my alleged scum squad to off him unless Kary and I are magically scummates and we've been distancing each other this entire time. Where's the M.O. here?

That said, I'm of the opinion that Kary needs to die. If I die toDay, I hope you all death sheep myself, Vult, and S2n, and lynch that slot without restraint.

 

[#HBC | Kary]

lmao. killing sold makes me look bad. not rocket science.

i'm of the opinion oppo should full claim since we're playing he has forced our hand.

 

[Fire Emblemier]

That's fair enough.
Since you're in the spotlight today, I would like to see your thoughts on the other two potential lynches. Can you do that in the next 24 hours?

Yeah
Bardull is leaning in the middle. Some of the town cred is for reasons relating to my role that I don't feel like fully explaining yet. Mostly due to his invulnerability to certain stuff.

Shish seems to have powerful abilities that would fit in either alignments hands, though I believe he even mentioned being 3rd party, right?
I honestly need to look back at more of their posts to form a better opinion

 

[Dooplissity]

opo's power is a weird gladiator variant, sure, but gladiator is not a terribly bad power, I saw a game won a few months ago due to a good town gladiate.

also vote: shish

why would we let him live another phase??

 

[Fire Emblemier]

lmao. killing sold makes me look bad. not rocket science.

i'm of the opinion oppo should full claim since we're playing he has forced our hand.

Also I'm a little on the fence on your poison remark from earlier as this is 2nd time you mentioned it and both times on Bard.

 

[BarDulL]

Yes, Kary. I killed off one of my few allies solely to incriminate you when I had Maven, yourself, and Pokechu eyeballing me like fresh brisket. I like that you immediately came to this unlikely conclusion to cover your own tush.

Kary’s behavior is unnecessarily condescending and forceful because she is trying to retain positioning as a town leader, and anyone that has opposed Kary thus far has ended up a dead goose (Vult, S2n, perhaps me). Do the math.

 

[Dooplissity]

lmao. killing sold makes me look bad. not rocket science.

i'm of the opinion oppo should full claim since we're playing he has forced our hand.

no, this is an awful idea. what possible benefit does this give us?

 

[Deleted member]

opo's power is a weird gladiator variant, sure, but gladiator is not a terribly bad power, I saw a game won a few months ago due to a good town gladiate.

also vote: shish

why would we let him live another phase??

Because I made cookies?

 

[#HBC | Kary]

Yes, Kary. I killed off one of my few allies solely to incriminate you when I had Maven, yourself, and Pokechu eyeballing me like fresh brisket. I like that you immediately came to this unlikely conclusion to cover your own tush.

Kary’s behavior is unnecessarily condescending and forceful because she is trying to retain positioning as a town leader, and anyone that has opposed Kary thus far has ended up a dead goose (Vult, S2n, perhaps me). Do the math.

Here's my list off the top of my head

not lynching: DtJ, Opossum, Kary, Doop, Pokechu, Kary

*cough*

 

[#HBC | Kary]

no, this is an awful idea. what possible benefit does this give us?

clearing oppo 100% ?

 

[Dooplissity]

clearing oppo 100% ?

how would a fullclaim clear him 100%?

 

[Deleted member]

how would a fullclaim clear him 100%?

Because he claimed he could become (almost) immortal by fulfilling certain requirements and I fail to see how that connects with a Nickelodeok show flavor wise.

 

[BarDulL]

*cough*

Pretty sure he thought your scum read on me was equally ridiculous and you didn’t need that kind of influence in the game. Just because he didn’t have you in his lynch pool towards the end doesn’t suddenly invalidate him as a target from your point of view.

You also ignored pretty much dodged everything else I had to say, not much of a surprise.

 

[#HBC | Kary]

how would a fullclaim clear him 100%?

thoughts:
his role seems broken if mafia.
he claimed something about possibly becoming immune.
he probably doesnt have anything else on top of this.
claiming probably doesnt hurt him if town.
he's really not done much this game except claim.
is there a huge drawback i'm missing?

 

[BarDulL]

I also don’t get why Kary is incessantly phishing for information on claims of they are somehow magically Town.

Like I said, if I die, take Kary down.

Bed time.

 

[#HBC | Kary]

Pretty sure he thought your scum read on me was equally ridiculous and you didn’t need that kind of influence in the game. Just because he didn’t have you in his lynch pool towards the end doesn’t suddenly invalidate him as a target from your point of view.

You also ignored pretty much dodged everything else I had to say, not much of a surprise.

i literally undermined the 1 valid point you had. i'm town. stop tunneling me over nothing.

 

[JTB]

I'm inclined to think that this is the worst Town

hard agree

why isn't shish dead yet and why are you guys talking about claims meaning anything, this is a upick

 

[Dooplissity]

his role seems broken if mafia.

the traditional Gladiator puts the lynch between you and your target, which is why it can be either alignment. this role is totally balance if mafia is he has the restriction of being forced to include at least 1 mafia in the pool

he claimed something about possibly becoming immune.

yes, and?

he probably doesnt have anything else on top of this.

baseless speculation

claiming probably doesnt hurt him if town.

baseless speculation

he's really not done much this game except claim.

so you want him to... claim more... so he can coast on his claim...

is there a huge drawback i'm missing?

many, potentially. you're assuming this game is way simpler than it is.
also perplexingly, you're assuming that somehow, him claiming clears him 100% in a game where the mafia have expressly been provided fakeclaims

editL fixing broken tags, no content changes

 

[Dooplissity]

anyway I'm going to be spending most of tomorrow on flights but I'm pretty much out of **** to say. I'm with JTB on being disappointed at the quality of play here. Shish needs to die.

 

[Dooplissity]

also while we're beating our richards about roles, it's not weird to anyone else that shish is supposedly a town killing role, when we have a dead, flipped town killing role?

all the role speculation and nobody wants to point that out?

 

[Pokechu]

I didn't get Sold's results for the last night, but I got them for the first. I got that Marisa (JTB) targeted him. Phooey :[

one thing I want to comment on though re: bard vs kary

 

[Pokechu]

Yes, Kary. I killed off one of my few allies solely to incriminate you when I had Maven, yourself, and Pokechu eyeballing me like fresh brisket. I like that you immediately came to this unlikely conclusion to cover your own tush.

Kary’s behavior is unnecessarily condescending and forceful because she is trying to retain positioning as a town leader, and anyone that has opposed Kary thus far has ended up a dead goose (Vult, S2n, perhaps me). Do the math.

Pretty sure he thought your scum read on me was equally ridiculous and you didn’t need that kind of influence in the game. Just because he didn’t have you in his lynch pool towards the end doesn’t suddenly invalidate him as a target from your point of view.

You also ignored pretty much dodged everything else I had to say, not much of a surprise.

aren't these two posts "unnecessarily condescending and forceful"

 

[Dooplissity]

honestly it feels like everyone is trying to do budget ryker impersonations

 

[JTB]

I can confirm pokechus result is correct

If shish isn't dead by the time I get home tomorrow from out of state, I'm dropping a fat post calling out every single player that is doing stupid **** and if you want to be put on the spot, you will get this lynch done

I'm being serious, there's so much talk about stuff that goes nowhere (role speculation namely, but now we have BarDulL talking about why a sold kill doesn't benefit him as scum????? How long have you been playing mafia????) and half of you need a wake up call so we can get this game on track

If anyone plays hero again and it results in another mislynch, you will get my eternal fury post game

 

[Dooplissity]

slightly better ryker impersonation because you're actually using it to do something productive

 

[Deleted member]

JTB
You're taking this way too seriously and insulting others simply for them not playing the way you want them to.
You keep condemning role speculation when we're literally in a role madness game and it seems like you want to play a more traditional setup when that clearly isn't possible and you're trying to push everyone alongside that same road aswell. All these roles play a big part into the game which means posting restrictions, unbalaced role abilities and gimmick third parties are all part of the game we're trying to play.

 

[Maven89]

I simply thought that Giraffe was a better choice, and when I saw I could get him lynched I took it.

JTB
You're taking this way too seriously and insulting others simply for them not playing the way you want them to.
You keep condemning role speculation when we're literally in a role madness game and it seems like you want to play a more traditional setup when that clearly isn't possible and you're trying to push everyone alongside that same road aswell. All these roles play a big part into the game which means posting restrictions, unbalaced role abilities and gimmick third parties are all part of the game we're trying to play.

What happened to the vig shot you promised

 

[UtopianPoyzin]

Sorry everybody, I couldn't make in into the thread last night; I was at a Christmas party and my phone was dead. Just about to check in and see what I missed.

 

[Deleted member]

I simply thought that Giraffe was a better choice, and when I saw I could get him lynched I took it.



What happened to the vig shot you promised

People need to vote if they want me to kill Opo or not and I'm pretty sure only one person has expressed a direct sentiment so far

 

[JTB]

What's the argument for killing opo and why do you need us to vote on it?

 

[UtopianPoyzin]

Alright, let's go down the list. I was not s2n's target N2. I would like to hear from the 3 lynch candidates if they were or were not s2n's target N2 before we hear from anyone else.

Pokechu
Maven89
UtopianPoyzin
#HBC | Kary
Dooplissity
Hope I didn't miss anyone. Please say if s2n visited you.

Alright, what about anyone else?

1. giraffelasergun
2. Shishœ
3. Moydow
4. Fire Emblemier
5. Pokechu
6. Maven89
7. DtJ S2n
8. Vult Redux
9. UtopianPoyzin
10. BarDulL
11. #HBC | Kary
12. Dooplissity
13. Opossum
14. JTB

We still need to hear from these 7 if they were s2ns target last Night.

I was not the target.

God****ingdamnit I'm this close to pulling the trigger

Two players had post restrictions and our newly dead Townie had an ability that could just out their killer. This is a role madness game, it's kinda hard for us to just ignore all of that.

I'm kind of with Shish on this one when it pertains to discussing roles. This is a game where every single person has ailities that are tailored to their character that they selected, and just ignoring that anybody could potentially scramble the game up beyond what we planned for (i.e. Maven's GLG lynch, Opo's 3 lynch candidates), it would be unwise to push it aside.

BarDulL , are you immune to poison? Asking for a friend.

Come to think of it, poison would fit the "non-standard killing method" I discussed earlier. I had originally Thoth it may have been a weird type of serial killer, but this makes more sense.

Did you poison him?

And also...

Apparently I'm immune to fire, walls, and I'm nude. Poison is too cruel a mistress.

How do fire, walls, and poison apply in the game? I mean, I have immunity to elements as well, but how do they even work? Does anybody have the ability to poison others? And what even is walls? People's roles are becoming more wacky every day. So far I am aware of fire, poison, cold (from someone's earlier post) and walls (?). Is there any more elements I should be aware of? Any clues on what they do?

And also, directed to BarDulL ...

and I'm nude.

What the hell is this supposed to mean? Lmao... sHoW sOmE dEcEnCy AnD pUt SoMe ClOtHeS oN, sMh.

 

[UtopianPoyzin]

And then there was the Opossum grilling in the second half of the messages. I think I'm all caught up on the thread occurences.

 

[Maven89]

People need to vote if they want me to kill Opo or not and I'm pretty sure only one person has expressed a direct sentiment so far

Is that part of your role? What did you do last night?