uPick Mafia Ultimate ⭐ Game over! Did the game contain more than a single legal character by the end of its life cycle? Or is it no items, Hades only?

[Deleted member]

#HBC | Nabe Votecount?

I'm very much torn on who to vote for; the options are pretty limited...

Clearly I should be the Prom King

 

[Fire Emblemier]

Hey, sorry for the lack of replies today was at a family christmas party.

Anyways, on the topic of s2n ability there are only 2 likely scenarios that occured. A) The result was sent to mafia and they of course won't say or even fake reply due to it being more likely to backfire on them. Or B) s2n didn't use his ability so he can speak normally.

Honestly, while I think it might be scenario A, there's too much wifom to truly discuss who it could possibly be.

 

[UtopianPoyzin]

Based on the beginning of Day 3, I've decided to cut some slack for Shish, and I'm also fine with Bardull. Would love to get info from Fire Emblemier about why he changed his vote to GLG last night, seems like a strange move to join Shish for that vote, the only person who had a vote for GLG down at the time. I don't think Fire answered this question yet, unless I missed it.

Oh okay then vote shish

I am also troubled by s2ns missing action. I think it suggests it targeted Scum, since that power is too good to not use. That also suggests that he thought that person was town/likely an NK. Probably warrants some general reevaluation on me/jtb. On mobile since flying, can anyone dig up who he town read?

I don't like this post, makes it seem like Doop evaluated himself as a townread, which isn't really a great thing to do, and raises my suspicion levels a bunch for Doop. By asking people to reevaluate you given that you are claiming yourself to be a publicly acknowledged townread puts a bad taste at least in my mouth. Really wish that Opo gave us some more leverage with the lynch; Shish, Bard, and Fire were not particularly my picks if I had the choice tonight.

 

[UtopianPoyzin]

However, innocent until proven guilty, I went back and grabbed DtJ's reads per

On mobile since flying, can anyone dig up who he town read?

Dooplissity 's request. Now, rather than find who he town read, it was easier to just get who he explicitly stated he read as scum. Those people are Maven, Opo, Poyzin, Fire, amd Kary. He called JTB town. That's all I gathered, but if anybody feels the need to search more in depthly, you all may. For the sake of purpose, I'm assuming everybody unstated he called town. Do with that what you want Dooplissity . Awaiting response from Fire before I cast my vote.

 

[BarDulL]

Oh okay then vote shish

I am also troubled by s2ns missing action. I think it suggests it targeted Scum, since that power is too good to not use. That also suggests that he thought that person was town/likely an NK. Probably warrants some general reevaluation on me/jtb. On mobile since flying, can anyone dig up who he town read?

What's your general scum pool and town pool? Who's in the middle? You seem so distracted and haven't contributed much meat this day phase.

I'm slow could you explain how there being no N2 action for Sold makes me look worse? Is it not possible that he didn't act last night so he didn't have to undergo another posting restriction, or no?

I personally would put myself through the posting restriction in order to possibly get a bingo. I'm surprised to hear you imply that you wouldn't.

 

[BarDulL]

Hey, sorry for the lack of replies today was at a family christmas party.

Anyways, on the topic of s2n ability there are only 2 likely scenarios that occured. A) The result was sent to mafia and they of course won't say or even fake reply due to it being more likely to backfire on them. Or B) s2n didn't use his ability so he can speak normally.

Honestly, while I think it might be scenario A, there's too much wifom to truly discuss who it could possibly be.

Give some leans.

 

[UtopianPoyzin]

Hey BarDulL , while you're here, figured I'd ask. My vote is up in the air at this point, so why should my vote not land on you?

Speaking as a fellow goose, of course.

 

[BarDulL]

Hey BarDulL , while you're here, figured I'd ask. My vote is up in the air at this point, so why should my vote not land on you?

Speaking as a fellow goose, of course.

Didn't Maven get a bingo on Shish? Don't make me peck you with my beak.

 

[UtopianPoyzin]

Didn't Maven get a bingo on Shish?

Did I miss something? When/Where/What is this?

 

[UtopianPoyzin]

I’ll just out that I can RB, and I RBd Shishoe last night. I don’t believe he’s immune to it, or any of his role anymore

Found it. Unsure what the "bingo" means, besides that Shish attempted to use his ability and Maven roleblocked it. Probably need some clarification...

 

[BarDulL]

Did I miss something? When/Where/What is this?

This is the post:

I’ll just out that I can RB, and I RBd Shishoe last night. I don’t believe he’s immune to it, or any of his role anymore

 

[BarDulL]

Found it. Unsure what the "bingo" means, besides that Shish attempted to use his ability and Maven roleblocked it. Probably need some clarification...

It means Shish was lying about his ability use.

Shish has since retracted his ability use, but no one seems to trust him at this point.

 

[UtopianPoyzin]

Yeah, but where does the bingo come into play? I'm really tired atm, probably missing the significance. Do we know that Shish tried to kill, or could it have just been a town role?

 

[UtopianPoyzin]

Ohhhh, I gotcha. My mind is moving too slow so I wasn't able to connect the dots. I actually see that, and I don't like that...

Vote: Shish

Thank you for opening my eyes. I shall now begin my peaceful relaxation out on the lake as I go to bed.

 

[UtopianPoyzin]

How do we know that Maven isn't lying though? It wouldn't be out of the question if Maven has an agenda of their own...

 

[BarDulL]

Go to bed.

 

[Dooplissity]

Based on the beginning of Day 3, I've decided to cut some slack for Shish, and I'm also fine with Bardull. Would love to get info from Fire Emblemier about why he changed his vote to GLG last night, seems like a strange move to join Shish for that vote, the only person who had a vote for GLG down at the time. I don't think Fire answered this question yet, unless I missed it.



I don't like this post, makes it seem like Doop evaluated himself as a townread, which isn't really a great thing to do, and raises my suspicion levels a bunch for Doop. By asking people to reevaluate you given that you are claiming yourself to be a publicly acknowledged townread puts a bad taste at least in my mouth. Really wish that Opo gave us some more leverage with the lynch; Shish, Bard, and Fire were not particularly my picks if I had the choice tonight.

I called a spade a spade. Say what you will, but I've been generally townread or at least not scumread. I've also been at the forefront of both the d1 and d2 lynches and posting fairly solid content (biased though I may be).

Vult wasn't obvtown, but he was protown, and he ate the n1 kill. JTB and I both fit that archetype, and it felt disingenuous to just list JTB there, so I put myself down too. I listed myself the same way talking to glg about players more likely to kill vult.

 

[Dooplissity]

What's your general scum pool and town pool? Who's in the middle? You seem so distracted and haven't contributed much meat this day phase.

combination of prepping to travel cross country, travelling 12 hours today, this Day phase starting off really poorly, and shish being the obvious lynch has left me pretty disengaged tbh. I

i wanted to reevaluate reads post shish flip, but that got wacky with d2. Maven and Opo are still town, s2n I thought was town, glg was mild scumlean, shish is still scum. I don't feel strongly enough about anyone else that I think the read will definitely survive shish flip, but I do have two other reads I'm not sure if I feel like sharing ATM, partially because I want to reread iso them to make sure I'm looking at the whole picture. I'll think about whether it makes sense to talk on that toDay later on, it's like 3 am here (also hello, I am near Austin now)

 

[Deleted member]

Didn't Maven get a bingo on Shish? Don't make me peck you with my beak.

I fail to see how that's a bingo at all.

 

[#HBC | Kary]

I fail to see how that's a bingo at all.

Whether or not it is a "bingo" exactly, the fact that you were lying about your ability to kill Oppo, and generally misleading all of us is very incriminating. In the very unlikely event that you are town, it would seem that you have forgotten your win condition.

 

[Deleted member]

Whether or not it is a "bingo" exactly, the fact that you were lying about your ability to kill Oppo, and generally misleading all of us is very incriminating. In the very unlikely event that you are town, it would seem that you have forgotten your win condition.

Nah, I haven't forgotten it at all.

 

[#HBC | Kary]

Nah, I haven't forgotten it at all.

Are you admitting you're scum?

 

[Deleted member]

Are you admitting you're scum?

No, I'm saying ya'll can't understand that Town has reason to lie too.
If Opo was Mafia and they thought I could kill him at any moment, they'd off me.
If Opo was Town, they'd let me live in the hopes I pulled the trigger later.

It's not that complicated.

 

[#HBC | Nabe]

Votecount

Shish (JTB, , Bard, Maven, Doop, Opo, Poyzin)
Bard (Shish, Kary)

 

[#HBC | Kary]

No, I'm saying ya'll can't understand that Town has reason to lie too.
If Opo was Mafia and they thought I could kill him at any moment, they'd off me.
If Opo was Town, they'd let me live in the hopes I pulled the trigger later.

It's not that complicated.

Except you literally said earlier that you thought you were roleblocked by mafia:

I was going through with this because I thought it was a Mafia Roleblocker who hit me.

And if that was correct, Mafia would already know you were lying, so there was no point in trying to gauge their reaction. Yet you did it, and now, here we are.

 

[JTB]

BarDulL or #HBC | Kary , since you have two been around a while, who are the newer players in this game or ones with not a lot of experience? I'll talk more about why I want to know probably toMorrow, but it's something I want to look into based on the shish flip

 

[Pokechu]

I personally would put myself through the posting restriction in order to possibly get a bingo. I'm surprised to hear you imply that you wouldn't.

I wasn't trying to imply that I wouldn't (I would since I'm always scared of dying LOL), just that I didn't see how him not using it related to me looking worse for it. If he didn't think he'd be killed (which he may have thought after Shish claimed vig yesterDay or after Maven proved his role) then not using the ability makes sense because he'd just be restricting himself for little gain. And based on some players' reactions (like Shish) he might not have wanted to make even more backwards posts because it's unlikely all players would go to the means to un-backwards them (LOL un-backwards, didn't expect to make that word today )

 

[#HBC | Kary]

I wasn't trying to imply that I wouldn't (I would since I'm always scared of dying LOL), just that I didn't see how him not using it related to me looking worse for it.

He picked you Night 1, but apparently not Night 2. Why change? Maybe he didn't change his mind- maybe he picked you again, but you're lying. Pretty obvious deduction.

 

[#HBC | Kary]

BarDulL or #HBC | Kary , since you have two been around a while, who are the newer players in this game or ones with not a lot of experience? I'll talk more about why I want to know probably toMorrow, but it's something I want to look into based on the shish flip

Fire Emblemier is the player who seems to be acting the furthest from what I expect.
I am not really more qualified than you to say who is and isn't experienced/competent in general.

 

[Pokechu]

He picked you Night 1, but apparently not Night 2. Why change? Maybe he didn't change his mind- maybe he picked you again, but you're lying. Pretty obvious deduction.

Oh

That makes sense! Thanks for elaborating

I don't have anything I can say to this in defense. Though I do think that if I was scum and got both, that it would be silly to mention only getting the first Night and not the second. Why not stay quiet about both? But that's just my $0.02

 

[#HBC | Kary]

@Shishœ you came up with a ridiculous lie on Day 2 to try and avoid getting lynched, but at least it wasn't something we could prove wrong. Now Day 3 you come up with something that is obviously unlikely, and then is clearly proved wrong... you don't have a town mindset, your only concern is staying alive. I wish this was majority lynch, so I could hammer you right now. Later.

 

[#HBC | Kary]

I don't have anything I can say to this in defense. Though I do think that if I was scum and got both, that it would be silly to mention only getting the first Night and not the second. Why not stay quiet about both? But that's just my $0.02

Claiming the first one makes you look townie, right?

 

[JTB]

Fire Emblemier is the player who seems to be acting the furthest from what I expect.
I am not really more qualified than you to say who is and isn't experienced/competent in general.

If Shish flips scum, do you think that Fire Emblemier could be their scummate?

I guess I'll bring this up now since there's not much else to discuss until the flip and I understand this is entirely speculation, but if Shish does flip scum, I don't expect Kary or Bard to be scum with him. His play has been very clearly anti-town, especially toDay, and I would expect that someone that was partnered with him and had experience would tell him to do something else in private. I'm glad you bring up Fire Emblemier Kary because that was a slot I was already planning to look into upon a scumShish flip. I haven't read into the slot too much but I recall Stu posting a scum read on them and I remember seeing the slot liking posts in the thread without contributing, which isn't all bad but still gives me pause and reason to look more into it.

 

[#HBC | Kary]

f Shish flips scum, do you think that Fire Emblemier Fire Emblemier could be their scummate?

What if the GLG waggon is the scumteam?

 

[JTB]

Entirely possible, another reason why I was curious about their experience because it just seems too convenient lol

 

[#HBC | Kary]

Entirely possible, another reason why I was curious about their experience because it just seems too convenient lol

You think Maven would turn up at the 11th hour, use his extroardinarily powerful ability and risk outing his entire team just to avoid bussing Shish, and then the next Day turn around and claim a bingo on Shish in order to bus him?

 

[JTB]

Oh no, I considering the people that jumped on the GLG wagon, not maven himself. I think maven is town as I can see the logic behind why he did the double vote thing, even if it was a bad play overall.

 

[Deleted member]

@Shishœ you came up with a ridiculous lie on Day 2 to try and avoid getting lynched, but at least it wasn't something we could prove wrong. Now Day 3 you come up with something that is obviously unlikely, and then is clearly proved wrong... you don't have a town mindset, your only concern is staying alive. I wish this was majority lynch, so I could hammer you right now. Later.

I lied about nothing yesterDay but if you're so hellbent on this then why aren't you voting for me?

 

[#HBC | Kary]

I lied about nothing yesterDay but if you're so hellbent on this then why aren't you voting for me?

Lmao you expect me to believe you somehow have the ability to remove one of the fundamental abilities mafia have? You might as well have said that they are no longer able to Night Kill. It's ridiculous. I'm not voting you because it's unnecessary and you aren't going to die any faster.

 

[#HBC | Kary]

Oh no, I considering the people that jumped on the GLG wagon, not maven himself. I think maven is town as I can see the logic behind why he did the double vote thing, even if it was a bad play overall.

Okay so just Fire and maybe Doops?
How certain are you on Maven town?