Pokechu
- My little baby, bless your soul.
I expect you would have won if I hadn't been able to kill JTB, because I would probably want to him lynch him before you, but that's the way it goes. Unfortunately, buddying me to the moon only gets you so far. Re-reading your posts on the last Day, they were all very "hi I'm here! maybe this?" and it seemed clear to me that your heart wasn't in looking for scum, but overall it served you well here. If you had played a little more decisively in Lylo we might be having a different conversation. Well played. ★★★★
Maven89
- I actually convinced myself that you had to use your ability before the end of Day 2 or you would lose it. That was the best explanation I could come to for you upsetting the Shish waggon the way you did. It is fine to kill a few townies in the early game in order to get information and make progress in the game- unless you have some sort of clear on a slot I just can't agree with trying to save someone like that. You probably know all of this and were just pressed on time, but still.
As to my efforts to kill you, I felt that on balance it would be worth getting an extra flip. -- For the record, it didn't occur to me that there could be multiple mafia kills in one night, and on that basis your flip wouldn't have cost us a Day, and I didn't know who I ought to prime next. Your posts read clearly townie to me, but the problem I had was there just wasn't enough of them for me to be confident in that read. I hope in the next game we meet it's with more time and less pressure. ★★★
UtopianPoyzin
- I had a lot of problems figuring out your slot, you were happy to be in the thread and posting, but you weren't really doing anything on your own initiative. I had several questions, not least I was confused by your mention of gasoline, because my role PM doesn't mention this (I asked Nabe in order to clarify things). I was also concerned by you seemingly worrying over how you are perceived by others, myself especially. For your first game, you played admirably. But I felt you did very little to help the town towards the correct conclusion, and I would be interested to see how you approach the game from that mindset.
The way in which you initially mentioned the cold as an element was a mistake on your part, but you might easily get away with it next time. I still don't understand the whole 'joking with my friend' thing, and I still think that my read on you as "wanting to fit in" was a clue to your role as an Indy. But since you decided to choose, from all possible things, a coat hanger as your character, I will concede that there are some aspects of your character I'm yet to understand.
Finally, I will apologize for pressuring and making gambits on you. Maybe a better person than me would go easy on you in your first game. You seem like a pretty cool person, and one to watch in future games. ★★★
Dooplissity
- I feel like your attitude and content was clearly pro-town all the way through the game. But after Day 2 your activity took a downturn, and so I'm left with not a huge amount to say. The only thing I take an issue with is your support for Oppo's claim on Day 3; it was reasonable to give him a pass on Day 1, but I think when he's literally controlling the lynch he deserves greater scrutiny. But anyways, thank you in particular for supporting me in Lylo, I really didn't want to have to argue with Joey and I think your endorsement helped a lot with that. ★★★★
#HBC | Nabe
I don't have any thoughts about your play. As to the setup, I am amazed- I don't believe it. The roles were clever in all cases, as well as being hilarious and downright inspired in some. The way in which you linked the factions' interactions and delicately hang everything together so that it balanced is simply beyond me. I am cautious about lauding praise upon it only because it seems like a trick, like magic. I for one thoroughly enjoyed my role, and this seems to be the consensus among most players, so again, thank you. And as a host, you were very good, clear, reliable and effective. I expect that you put a lot of work into this one, and I hope that you found some enjoyment in it. If there is a future one, I will look forward to it.
고생해 주셔서 정말 감사합니다 ★★★★★