1 Thread for discussion all match-up isn't good. No one will have an overview of the current match-up.
Just use this as a the main page with a chart and links to the different match-up discussion threads. If every match-up gets it own thread many things will be much more easy and we can use each thread later to rediscuss them.
Why we always start with the top tiers which were discussed so many times? Shouldn't we start with the match-up which weren't discussed in a long time like Rob or other Mid tiers?
At a certain point many smasher will lose their impulse to post in a discussion and we could just discuss the same match-up like in the other match-up discussion periods.
Here is a list of all characters sorted in their perticular ranking and if there is a match-up thread/summary form them:
Character|08/09|10
Metaknight|x|x
Snake|x|x
Diddy Kong|x|x
Wario|x|x
Marth|o|x
Ice Climbers|o|x
Olimar|o|o
Pikachu|o|x
King Dedede|x|o
Mr. Game & Watch|x|o
Lucario|o|x
Zero Suit Samus|x|o
Toon Link|x|o
Kirby|o|o
Fox|o|x
R.O.B.|o|o
Pit|x|o
Peach|x|o
Donkey Kong|x|o
Luigi|x|o
Wolf|x|o
Sonic|x|o
Ike|x|o
Sheik|x|o
Ness|o|o
Pokémon Trainer|x|o
Yoshi|x|o
Lucas|x|o
Mario|x|o
Bowser|x|o
Captain Falcon|o|o
Samus|x|o
Jigglypuff|o|o
Link|o|o
Zelda|o|x
Ganondorf|o|o
This list definitely points out that we're discussion the same match-up over and over again but many match-ups weren't discussed anytime, so we should focus on omitted match-ups.
I think we should start with Olimar, Kirby, Rob, Ness, CF, Jiggs, Link, Ganon because they weren't discussed at all. And then continue with Kind DDD, G&W, ZSS, Tink, Pit, Peach, Dk, Luigi, Wolf, Sonic, Ike, Sheik, PkmnTrainer, Yoshi, Lucas, Mario, Bowser, Samus because these are the most outdated.
Edit: If this thread isn't going to work, I will put up a match-up thread by myself with a better structure and some graphics.