-RedShadow
Smash Ace
Are you driving to Nikefest Jordan?
Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!
You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!
You left yourself off!in case anyone cares heres the ranking i did in 3mins lol
kal
edgar
spike MT
jamal
jose
clay
n the others seem the same to me lol
You said they were used as "a mere reference." Of course, the semantical argument can start, but it's clear your entire argument was "tournament results aren't as important as subjective analysis."This was the point I was disagreeing with. Everything else you said I mostly agree with, however. I did mention that tournament results are used as a reference.
If Spike is obviously better than Jamal, then we're not going to rank Jamal higher because he's entered tournaments. On the other hand, when there's a grey area (Jamal and Spike are close in skill level, and I'd wager Jamal is better), you have nothing to fall back on but tournament results.Though my argument carries over to your Spike vs Jamal example. Obviously Jamal has entered a lot of tournaments and Spike has entered virtually none. I don't care if it isn't fair or not, but I'd still think that Spike is better than Jamal (hypothetically; I used to think Spike>Jamal 1-2 months ago but now I wouldn't be able to make a judgment call). Of course there is gray area. Usually we use tournament results to differentiate between those gray areas, but when there isn't tournament results for Spike, that doesn't mean we automatically give the benefit to the person who goes to tournaments. This is a mentality that a lot of you have: reward those people that enter tournaments. Of course there are various valid reasons to do so, but keep in mind that that shows bias to how you're comparing Spike and Jamal. I wouldn't disagree with ranking Jamal over Spike, but at the same time I wouldn't agree that Jamal is better than Spike at playing the game. Does that make sense?
I wouldn't place myself above Carl either, although the one tournament we faced each other I beat him, but that's not enough justification, or simply beating him in a crew battle.It's difficult to place Rohan above Carl since they're about equal in skill and both have no tournament record.
....... No.yeah justin sucks
<3
I'd be happy to help, but I have a final that I need to study for, but i'll see if i can write up a mini guide pretty soon (Saturday maybe.)Sorry if i'm "off topic" but I have recently been thinking of modding my wii so I can get those neat skins, the usb loader and what not, and I just wanted to ask if anyone could help me do so.
Sounds great.I'd be happy to help, but I have a final that I need to study for, but i'll see if i can write up a mini guide pretty soon (Saturday maybe.)
Definitely worth it if you haven't modded your Wii at all (free games sound good?)
Also, it seems like i'll be in Austin for the summer for anyone who wants someone to play. I'm a bit of a scrub, but at least I'm someone to play~
I'm about to upload a sh**load of vids from that smashfest in my dorm on my YT account and that's one of them. Gotta upload it now that it's been so hyped up. I mean it's just so amazing that this relative unknown, Brown Link, beat MT's jigglypuff, which is at least the 2nd best jiggs in TX.Don't post the one where Rohan beats me! That never happened!
OMG Reqy just posted in our thread! That's almost as awesome as Scar posting in our thread that one time.hiiiiiiiiiiiii