Unintended Consequences Mafia: The Saga Concludes

[Moronik]

what's all this weaksauce we should lynch moronik ****? nah man, tpk or roxy for sure.

roxy how bout you dont try to copy a personal playstyle and make your own?

 

[Purple]

It was sarcasm Moronik, He doesn't post and it's all fine and gravy, while we don't and its lurking.

 

[Fatchu]

I have a tournment tommorrow, and I dont know when I will be able to post until sunday so i am going to go ahead and vote roxy.

 

[Deleted member]

any reasoning Fatchu?

 

[DtJ S2n]

@Roxy, we don't like that KevinM is so quiet, but other than that, he hasn't done anything that looks scummy.

 

[#HBC | ZoZo]

Fairly certain he was saying that he doesn't like a TPK lynch and would rather have us pursue other avenues because he thinks this one is a bad one. Not suggesting that he had other options at the ready. I still think that is a pretty lame move on Mac's part and I disagree and think that TPK is a fine lynch as are Roxy and Fatchu.

In any case

Unvote, Vote: Nich

This one striked me as odd, care to explain your vote?

 

[Purple]

I'm sure it striked out as odd only because it's a different person than TPK and me.

 

[#HBC | ZoZo]

There was no reason included neither. Thanks for your totally useless post, care to add anything I don't know?

 

[#HBC | Ryker]

This one striked me as odd, care to explain your vote?

Just went through the game to dig out quotes and I realized that I was simply quoting the entire Gheb v Nich argument. Much better to sum it up.

Before I get there, look at the first page. Mod vote from Nich instead of something that could possibly be useful.

Then the Gheb v. Nich. Gheb answered every one of his questions and Nich continued on belligerently telling Gheb that he had done no such thing. The annoying Phoenix Wright .GIF post is the dumbest one. Gheb tries, more than once, to drop the subject because he thinks that it's fruitless (as did I at the time) and Nich won't let him.

He goes on to try and steer the conversation back to that argument multiple times later in the game.

However, the reread did show that he continued on to show that he apologized for it and said the more he read the less he liked his own posts and the more he liked Gheb's.

Aside from that, I haven't seen him do much that mattered at all.

I have a list I keep in a Notepad document to help me keep my suspects straight. He was number three after Chibo and Roxy, so I threw a vote to see what happened and then went digging to find more elaboration than the reason I had typed: "Gheb v. Nich"

 

[Purple]

There was no reason included neither. Thanks for your totally useless post, care to add anything I don't know?

You mad ?

 

[#HBC | ZoZo]

You mad ?

You scum ?

 

[~ Gheb ~]

Ryker, I don't remember Scumcholas making garbage cases like that in any other game. It was probably Dumbcholas D1.

 

[#HBC | Ryker]

I haven't completed any games here with him, so I've got nothing with a definite alignment to draw from. It looks scummy to me.

Can I get links to two games where Nich was scum and two where he was town?

 

[DtJ S2n]

Vote: Roxy
Lovely responses. Why shouldn't we lynch you?

 

[Purple]

You scum ?

You scu m?

Sold2, why should we lynch me?

 

[Nicholas1024]

Just went through the game to dig out quotes and I realized that I was simply quoting the entire Gheb v Nich argument. Much better to sum it up.

Before I get there, look at the first page. Mod vote from Nich instead of something that could possibly be useful.

Then the Gheb v. Nich. Gheb answered every one of his questions and Nich continued on belligerently telling Gheb that he had done no such thing. The annoying Phoenix Wright .GIF post is the dumbest one. Gheb tries, more than once, to drop the subject because he thinks that it's fruitless (as did I at the time) and Nich won't let him.

He goes on to try and steer the conversation back to that argument multiple times later in the game.

However, the reread did show that he continued on to show that he apologized for it and said the more he read the less he liked his own posts and the more he liked Gheb's.

Aside from that, I haven't seen him do much that mattered at all.

I have a list I keep in a Notepad document to help me keep my suspects straight. He was number three after Chibo and Roxy, so I threw a vote to see what happened and then went digging to find more elaboration than the reason I had typed: "Gheb v. Nich"

Ryker...
If you found me so suspicious, and thought my argument was so bad, why did you not say so at the time? I looked back through the thread, and you never offered an opinion on the matter, even when you said you'd reread and catch up. Also, you said just a few pages ago,

Good with TPK and Fatchu.

Also, if Roxy is higher on your scumlist than I am, why are you targeting me with your vote? Your behavior is inconsistent, so explain yourself. Also, bring out the old me v.s. Gheb argument, and point out where I'm wrong rather than just throwing around blanket statements.

 

[Nicholas1024]

I haven't completed any games here with him, so I've got nothing with a definite alignment to draw from. It looks scummy to me.

Can I get links to two games where Nich was scum and two where he was town?

Scum:
Wonderland mafia, Getting schooled mafia

Town:
Unintended consequences mafia, scum wars, spidey mafia.

 

[#HBC | Ryker]

Ryker...
If you found me so suspicious, and thought my argument was so bad, why did you not say so at the time? I looked back through the thread, and you never offered an opinion on the matter, even when you said you'd reread and catch up. Also, you said just a few pages ago,

I did, but I thought we had more prominent suspects at the time.

Also, if Roxy is higher on your scumlist than I am, why are you targeting me with your vote? Your behavior is inconsistent, so explain yourself. Also, bring out the old me v.s. Gheb argument, and point out where I'm wrong rather than just throwing around blanket statements.

Because Roxy is well enough covered and no one is talking about you.

What is inconsistent?

Alright, I'll get the quotes when I'm done brawling.

Thanks for the links.

 

[Kirby King]

Day 2 Vote Count (Lynch 1)
Roxy (5): Gheb_01, Xonar, Nicholas1024, Fatchu, Sold2
The Paprika Killer (3): Roxy, Scamp, Moronik
Fatchu (1): The Paprika Killer
Nicholas1024 (1): Ryker

Not voting: Macman, KevinM, Virgilijus, Evil Eye

It takes 8 out of 14 votes to lynch.

The Day 2 deadline is Saturday, March 27 at 11:59:59 PM ET.

 

[Nicholas1024]

I did, but I thought we had more prominent suspects at the time.

Then quote that post, because I never found one when going back through the thread.

Because Roxy is well enough covered and no one is talking about you.

What is inconsistent?

Alright, I'll get the quotes when I'm done brawling.

Thanks for the links.

Your suspect list is inconsistent. Just a few pages ago you were happy with TPK and Fatchu, and now you've flip-flopped to me and Roxy.

 

[#HBC | Ryker]

Obviously, my list wasn't current. That's what I've been rending to.

 

[Purple]

Woah, don't you guys dare start metagaming on us.

 

[~ Gheb ~]

Woah, don't you guy dare start being useful on us.

 

[Purple]

Gheb, isn't it unfair if a person has an unfair disadvantage in another game that literally has no relevence?

 

[Purple]

"hey guys, i think this Bob Murphy's a murderer, let's go into another world where Bob Murphy also lives and see if he was a murderer there"

oh yeah, you can't do that in real life.

Metagaming is cheating in my opinion, no matter how helpful it is, i don't approve.

 

[Purple]

Oh, and I've never played Dgames before, so this isn't some way to stop you guys from finding "oh so direly painful evidence that will show me to be scum" it's just me voicing my opinion Out of context

 

[Moronik]

i reread and id def rather go paprika over roxy. im annoyed that mac and virg are leaning town but dont do anything to save him

speaking of macman who are these other options youd like to go?

ee should still vote his next suspect. if that doesnt work id like him to fos instead

dont like fatchu and am willing to switch to him. i think paprika killer can still go

I voted for Moronik to see if we got two votes since there are two lynches.

We don't. If we did then I would have had two votes on Moronik or one on Moronik and one on Macman.

pretty sure youre doing it wrong.......

 

[Purple]

EE can't vote at all, it won't work.

 

[Virgilijus]

i reread and id def rather go paprika over roxy. im annoyed that mac and virg are leaning town but dont do anything to save him

I think scum is loading up on either him or Roxy, but am unsure as to which. I'm a bit stymied about it.

 

[Purple]

TPK has been defending himself honestly, except for the past page

 

[#HBC | Mac]

still vlaaaa

stop caring about tpk

 

[Scamp]

Man this is getting hard due to general lack of content. Maybe tomorrow I'll start peppering people with questions I want answered (tourney and friend's birthday today) but for right now I can list a few likely suspects.

Nick: Still doesn't ever seem to offer an opinion that's original. He even copied Fatchu's incorrect thought that anyone is seriously considering Moronik at this point. Of course, Ryker and Sold2 are guilty of that as well.

Macman: Self-admitted terrible scum player. Has pretty much offered us nothing. Also the first post of day 2 really makes it look like he's just out for himself.

Xonar: Now that he's broken away from Gheb's shell.....he's broken away from the game entirely.

And let's see where these go.

 

[#HBC | ZoZo]

I honestly don't think there's a lot going on. I called Ryker on his vote which gave us some information, I guess that's advancing the game. But honestly, we just want to lynch lurkers, what is there for me to say?

 

[DtJ S2n]

"hey guys, i think this Bob Murphy's a murderer, let's go into another world where Bob Murphy also lives and see if he was a murderer there"

oh yeah, you can't do that in real life.

Metagaming is cheating in my opinion, no matter how helpful it is, i don't approve.

Well, I'll give you a different example.

"I think Bob Murphy is a murderer. Notice how angry and aggressive he's gotten recently? Normally he's a really calm guy. The only time I've seen him this aggressive before is when he stole from that one store."

You can definitely do it in real life. As for why we should lynch you, as if you don't already know. Not only are you not helping in general, you're distracting from actual scumhunting. Things like "don't start metagaming" and your responses to our questions simply being the same question redirected, or something useless makes it more difficult for us to figure out anything.

Woah, don't you guys dare start metagaming on us.

Who do you mean by "you guys" and "us."

 

[Moronik]

gheb/xonar/nick: why roxy over paprika again?

virg who ARE you willing to lynch?

 

[#HBC | ZoZo]

There is no Roxy over Paprika, I want them both gone. Would be willing to switch to Fatchu too.

Btw guys, why don't we use the first lynch to get dead meat and use the second to get an actual scummy player if possible?

 

[#HBC | ZoZo]

Actually, assuming we go through with the above...

Unvote, Vote: Paprika at least Roxy posts.

 

[Purple]

While i can understand why you would use that as an example, it's invalid.

Your example is basicaly saying

"I think Bob Murphy is mafia, notice how angry and aggressive he's gotten recently? I also saw him this aggressive earlier in this thread when this happened".

That's like catching scumtells from earlier in the same game. Not going into another thread.

Using other games is not only unfair, but illogical.
"he did it here, so that means he's doing it not for the same reason!" People change, and we could lynching the wrong person over some evidence that isn't real.

I might not be helping 'now' persay, i did do my part in who i FoS and why (macman and TPK). As a matter of fact, they're doing the same things they were doing before (being lurkish, not posting anything ; posting fluff with no solid back-up. However since my posts aren't 'Evil Eye' Good, they aren't looked at highly. In fact i'm still being pressured right now. Note how i didn't vote for Chibo yesterday, he gave us specific reasons why he wasn't posting, and a legit FoS with the posts of why he felt that way (even though it was me -_- ). I have a solid way of playing this game, and FoS'ing people. Which apparently some of you haven't noticed.

When i said don't you guys start metagaming on us. I said it out of context. 'You guys' being the people who are trying to metagame and 'us' being the game of mafia as a whole.

 

[Purple]

sorry, i meant to say "he did it here, so that means he's doing it now for the same reason!"

 

[Deleted member]

Actually, assuming we go through with the above...

Unvote, Vote: Paprika at least Roxy posts.

Hm, test week next week and going to the gym today, nope, no reason at all why I shouldn't post.
if we were going by that logic we might as well dump kevin, who did even less today. at least I'm trying.

Roxy and Sold, why the whole "bob murphy" thing? just vote according to how people are doing now.