A mediocre design with bad teeth is all I ever saw, honestly. Cause really, that and the gloves were the only thing truly wrong with it. I don't see any need for perfection whatsoever and don't consider that a criteria to have a serviceable movie either. They need to look good in motion(which Sonic does just fine). I don't have a perfection complex when it comes to what media I watch. I just want to enjoy something. And so far, the movie looks very enjoyable to me.
That says absolutely nothing. The screenstills are rather dumb at portraying the point since he's supposed to be in motion. Hell, the Nike shoes look actually good in that shot like they don't have shoelaces(which was one of the few valid points). In fact, that's a screenstill that doesn't look awful anyway. Ironically so in this scenario.
If people aren't willing to explain the problem, it's not worth listening to.
Half of what you said weren't even valid points. Who gives a **** about the blue arms? They're a normal thing for him and have been for ages. That's just pointless nostalgia that does not matter. It's one of the non-valid criticisms that's been around for ages. All the more reason it should be kept because it doesn't legitimately matter. The uncanny valley looks looks the exact same as everything in Detective Pikachu to me, so I don't see why that should matter. And I honestly have seen the designs and many of them are offputting to me, really. He's not his exact proportions, but still flows fine in motion, so it's not all that important(besides, he's not always chubby/smaller in the games, and a bit more lankier sometimes. Still the same character). The shoes aren't ****ty either. They're fine. The teeth are the only valid point you even listed right there. Now if you mean using a pair that doesn't have laces, that's a good point. It being a brand name? And? You really think they're going to do a Sonic movie and not use a brand name for a pair of shoes? That's just basic business practice. Sonic also had brand-name shoes in Adventure 2 to show off the new grinding mechanic, the SOAP shoes. It's happened before. Unless you're saying every shoe change in the games are bad too, then it's not honestly bad here.
(That said, I don't have time to reply much anymore beyond this. I have like zero days off and am severely overworked. I'm still going to call out bad points when they come up, and I stand entirely that there are few legitimate points against the Sonic movie that has come up. And with barely 3 points against Sonic's design(lack of gloves, shoelaces, bad teeth) that make a lot of sense to change, I'll probably just have to repeat them over and over again. Though the one thing that'll be pleasing is if they just change these 3 things and leave everything else be. A passable design is all that's actually needed to make a movie. No reason to throw it on a high pedestal, after all. No movie should ever be thrown that high either. No matter what. There's always a reason behind these designs and developments, after all. And so far, I actually expected a very bad design. I got a mediocre one, and that's with the teeth included. So I'm still quite happy they pulled off something passable as is).